i am leaning toward taking with B.I guess I really like the idea of getting our bishop to h5, and I don't see a good way to do that by taking the queen with the bishop. Let's look a little deeper into taking with the bishop and see what kind of attack we really do get. I'll do that tonight for a bit.If we take with the Rook. (option A)18. Rxd3 bxc6otello said:we would need to play d4 to protect the e pawn and open up for our white bishop.If we intend to play Nd6+ after they play bxc6, it may make sense to take the queen with the Rook, whereas if we took Q with pawn we would have doubled pawns. P makes a good point. How we take the Q should support our attack.Psychopav said:I like taking with the bishop. Taking with the pawn looks like it just bottles up our bishop even more.
Otello, where do you plan to attack after taking with the pawn?
19. Be2
then I think they move their black bishop - Bc5, Bb4, or Bg7
they could also pull their Knight to c5 here
If we take with the Bishop (option B)
18. Bxd3 bxc6
19. O-O or Rf1
Same move options as above. Which position to we like better for an attack?
I think option B has us further along in our attack, yes?
19...Bb4 would be a check, we'd have to move the king or the c pawn.White:
Let's walk through a couple scenarios (hopefully I get the notation correct...).
18. Bxd3, bxc6
19. 0-0, Bc5+
20. Kh1, 0-0
I don't see much for us here. I really like the idea of playing h4 if they castle, but it is much more effective with a Bishop on e2 or h5. I understand the desire to take the queen with the bishop because it gets him into the action, but IMO it is not nearly as powerful as taking with the rook for the following reasons: 1. We block off our rook from the d file, we do not allow ourselves the opportunity to double up our rooks (either on the f or d file), and we don't get our bishop to h5 (which is where I think it belongs).
The other scenario:
18. Rxd3, bxc6
19. Be2, Bb4 (doesn't allow us to castle, but as DB pointed out earlier, that may not be all bad.)
20. Bh5 (or Rf1), 0-0? (I'm not really sure what they do here. I think we have a pretty good attack going. They can't play Bb7 and try to 0-0-0 because we play Bxf7 then. If they 0-0 right now, I like h4. If they don't castle, we can load up pressure on the pawn at f7 by playing both rooks over to the f file.)
I just may be missing something because it appears that most people want to take with the bishop. Let me know how you see that playing out because I am just not seeing a strong attack by taking with the Bishop.
Yes, once again I messed up the notation. Bb4 would result in us playing c3. Bc5 is what I meant above. I changed it.19...Bb4 would be a check, we'd have to move the king or the c pawn.White:
Let's walk through a couple scenarios (hopefully I get the notation correct...).
18. Bxd3, bxc6
19. 0-0, Bc5+
20. Kh1, 0-0
I don't see much for us here. I really like the idea of playing h4 if they castle, but it is much more effective with a Bishop on e2 or h5. I understand the desire to take the queen with the bishop because it gets him into the action, but IMO it is not nearly as powerful as taking with the rook for the following reasons: 1. We block off our rook from the d file, we do not allow ourselves the opportunity to double up our rooks (either on the f or d file), and we don't get our bishop to h5 (which is where I think it belongs).
The other scenario:
18. Rxd3, bxc6
19. Be2, Bb4 (doesn't allow us to castle, but as DB pointed out earlier, that may not be all bad.)
20. Bh5 (or Rf1), 0-0? (I'm not really sure what they do here. I think we have a pretty good attack going. They can't play Bb7 and try to 0-0-0 because we play Bxf7 then. If they 0-0 right now, I like h4. If they don't castle, we can load up pressure on the pawn at f7 by playing both rooks over to the f file.)
I just may be missing something because it appears that most people want to take with the bishop. Let me know how you see that playing out because I am just not seeing a strong attack by taking with the Bishop.
If we take with the bishop and don't castle, we end up here I think:
18.Bxd3 bxc6 19.Rf1 Bb4+ 20.Ke2
Not such a bad position from which to launch an attack (I think?).
Yes, I am opposed to Bxd3 right now. I'm waiting to be convinced.White - seem to have agreement around Bxd3. Any other views?
I've also been playing around with us taking with Rook & them moving knight on move 19White:
Let's walk through a couple scenarios (hopefully I get the notation correct...).
18. Bxd3, bxc6
19. 0-0, Bc5+
20. Kh1, 0-0
I don't see much for us here. I really like the idea of playing h4 if they castle, but it is much more effective with a Bishop on e2 or h5. I understand the desire to take the queen with the bishop because it gets him into the action, but IMO it is not nearly as powerful as taking with the rook for the following reasons: 1. We block off our rook from the d file, we do not allow ourselves the opportunity to double up our rooks (either on the f or d file), and we don't get our bishop to h5 (which is where I think it belongs).
The other scenario:
18. Rxd3, bxc6
19. Be2, Bc5 (doesn't allow us to castle, but as DB pointed out earlier, that may not be all bad.)
20. Bh5 (or Rf1), 0-0? (I'm not really sure what they do here. I think we have a pretty good attack going. They can't play Bb7 and try to 0-0-0 because we play Bxf7 then. If they 0-0 right now, I like h4. If they don't castle, we can load up pressure on the pawn at f7 by playing both rooks over to the f file.)
I just may be missing something because it appears that most people want to take with the bishop. Let me know how you see that playing out because I am just not seeing a strong attack by taking with the Bishop.
I think this is good for us. Instead of 22. Rf1, I think Bf2 is really good, threatening Rd7. If they don't play Bb7, I think we get the c pawn.I've also been playing around with us taking with Rook & them moving knight on move 1918. Rxd3 bxc6White:
Let's walk through a couple scenarios (hopefully I get the notation correct...).
18. Bxd3, bxc6
19. 0-0, Bc5+
20. Kh1, 0-0
I don't see much for us here. I really like the idea of playing h4 if they castle, but it is much more effective with a Bishop on e2 or h5. I understand the desire to take the queen with the bishop because it gets him into the action, but IMO it is not nearly as powerful as taking with the rook for the following reasons: 1. We block off our rook from the d file, we do not allow ourselves the opportunity to double up our rooks (either on the f or d file), and we don't get our bishop to h5 (which is where I think it belongs).
The other scenario:
18. Rxd3, bxc6
19. Be2, Bc5 (doesn't allow us to castle, but as DB pointed out earlier, that may not be all bad.)
20. Bh5 (or Rf1), 0-0? (I'm not really sure what they do here. I think we have a pretty good attack going. They can't play Bb7 and try to 0-0-0 because we play Bxf7 then. If they 0-0 right now, I like h4. If they don't castle, we can load up pressure on the pawn at f7 by playing both rooks over to the f file.)
I just may be missing something because it appears that most people want to take with the bishop. Let me know how you see that playing out because I am just not seeing a strong attack by taking with the Bishop.
19. Be2 Nc5 - I don't see a good response for us here.
20. Nf6+ Ke7
21. Rd6
Could play out like this, which I like....Bb7
22. Rf1 Bg7
23. Bh5 Bxf6
24. Rxf6
I'm not opposed to taking with the rook & could go either way. They are probably thinking we'll take with the bishop.
Nice! I'm in 3 woodford's right now so don't trust anything I type for the next 12 hours.I'm also about 1 talisker and 4 canadian club and diets in so take that for what it's worth.
DittoI'm in.Let's take with the rook. Consensus?
taking with rook.DittoI'm in.Let's take with the rook. Consensus?
why don't we play 20. Bh6, instead of g5?Black:
Here's an interesting line. It would work better if we could get their rook to c1 without ours on c8 though.
19 ... Rac8
20. Rac1, g5
21. Bg3, h5
22. gxh5, Bh6
We now have the threat of g4 which would win a piece. If we didn't have our rook on c8, this would be pretty cool. But right now they can play:
23. Rxc8, Rxc8
24. Qd3
And they are free. But it just feels like there could be something here getting the bishop to h6 with the double pin.
Even without all that ridiculousness, what about playing g5? It gives our knight a nice spot g6.
I agree. Unless someone has another suggestion I say we go ahead and do itWe were talking Be2 here I think.White: they played bxc6
because they can play g5 thenwhy don't we play 20. Bh6, instead of g5?Black:
Here's an interesting line. It would work better if we could get their rook to c1 without ours on c8 though.
19 ... Rac8
20. Rac1, g5
21. Bg3, h5
22. gxh5, Bh6
We now have the threat of g4 which would win a piece. If we didn't have our rook on c8, this would be pretty cool. But right now they can play:
23. Rxc8, Rxc8
24. Qd3
And they are free. But it just feels like there could be something here getting the bishop to h6 with the double pin.
Even without all that ridiculousness, what about playing g5? It gives our knight a nice spot g6.
Agreed.kutta said:I agree. Unless someone has another suggestion I say we go ahead and do itdancingbones said:We were talking Be2 here I think.otello said:White: they played bxc6
when play h4, we take with g pawn?kutta said:Black:
Here's an interesting line. It would work better if we could get their rook to c1 without ours on c8 though.
19 ... Rac8
20. Rac1, g5
21. Bg3, h5
22. gxh5, Bh6
We now have the threat of g4 which would win a piece. If we didn't have our rook on c8, this would be pretty cool. But right now they can play:
23. Rxc8, Rxc8
24. Qd3
And they are free. But it just feels like there could be something here getting the bishop to h6 with the double pin.
Even without all that ridiculousness, what about playing g5? It gives our knight a nice spot g6.
Did you make the move or are you waiting?Agreed.kutta said:I agree. Unless someone has another suggestion I say we go ahead and do itdancingbones said:We were talking Be2 here I think.otello said:White: they played bxc6
I think so. But it gets pretty hairy over therewhen play h4, we take with g pawn?kutta said:Black:
Here's an interesting line. It would work better if we could get their rook to c1 without ours on c8 though.
19 ... Rac8
20. Rac1, g5
21. Bg3, h5
22. gxh5, Bh6
We now have the threat of g4 which would win a piece. If we didn't have our rook on c8, this would be pretty cool. But right now they can play:
23. Rxc8, Rxc8
24. Qd3
And they are free. But it just feels like there could be something here getting the bishop to h6 with the double pin.
Even without all that ridiculousness, what about playing g5? It gives our knight a nice spot g6.
moving nowDid you make the move or are you waiting?Agreed.kutta said:I agree. Unless someone has another suggestion I say we go ahead and do itdancingbones said:We were talking Be2 here I think.otello said:White: they played bxc6
that is my thought as well.I think so. But it gets pretty hairy over there\when play h4, we take with g pawn?kutta said:Black:
Here's an interesting line. It would work better if we could get their rook to c1 without ours on c8 though.
19 ... Rac8
20. Rac1, g5
21. Bg3, h5
22. gxh5, Bh6
We now have the threat of g4 which would win a piece. If we didn't have our rook on c8, this would be pretty cool. But right now they can play:
23. Rxc8, Rxc8
24. Qd3
And they are free. But it just feels like there could be something here getting the bishop to h6 with the double pin.
Even without all that ridiculousness, what about playing g5? It gives our knight a nice spot g6.
I think we should go Rac8 here.kutta said:Black:
Here's an interesting line. It would work better if we could get their rook to c1 without ours on c8 though.
19 ... Rac8
20. Rac1, g5
21. Bg3, h5
22. gxh5, Bh6
We now have the threat of g4 which would win a piece. If we didn't have our rook on c8, this would be pretty cool. But right now they can play:
23. Rxc8, Rxc8
24. Qd3
And they are free. But it just feels like there could be something here getting the bishop to h6 with the double pin.
Even without all that ridiculousness, what about playing g5? It gives our knight a nice spot g6.
still have the option to pursue your idea.I know it's late but I'm good with Rac8 as black.