Bob Magaw
Footballguy
Has anybody heard the remixed Pepper??
I got it last Friday. Got the big box because...well, I'm a nut. The box is very well done, but I can't help but think I would have been just as happy with the 2 CD set, but I guess some people collect video games, I collect Beatles. Anyway I've gotten through it in the last 6 days.
Packaging is real nice. LOVE the full size album cover that houses all the discs. I had forgotten how much detail was on that cover. Stared at it for hours. People who weren't alive during the LP error have no clue how much better it is to have a large cover. The book is great. Lots of detail. Cool poster and cutouts. It's all stored in a heavy duty box with a 3D cover which is also kind of cool.
As far as the music, I love all the outtakes. Within You Without You is awesome instrumental. I actually love all the instrumentals. The different takes of Strawberry Fields is cool too. Had heard some of it, but not all. I love that they included the mono version of Pepper in the box. That's cool. The Documentary was also well done. Cool that they got George's thoughts before he died. I personally hadn't seen this documentary, but apparently it's been around for awhile. The 5.1 Mixes are a cool thing, but I probably won't listen to them too much.
Which brings us to the real star of the show, the 2017 Remix. For those that don't know, in 1967 Mono was really still the standard. Stereo was in it's infancy. The Beatles weren't even in attendance for the stereo mix, so all the stuff they wanted in was in the mono. If you listen to the two back to back, you will notice several differences between stereo and mono. Different sounds and different effects and even one song in a different key. Most people have only heard the stereo, but the stereo mix was very much of it's time. Vocals mixed to one side in some cases. Weird things moving across the stereo landscape. For sure, a song like A Day In The Life was much better in stereo, but the rockers like Good Morning Good Morning and Sgt Pepper Reprise sounded punchier in mono.
So Giles Martin, son of George Martin decides to go back to the mono tapes and kind of peel back the layers and try and do a more modern stereo mix. Giles said he was looking for "3D Mono." He wanted to have the in your face aspects of the mono with the space that stereo allows for.
IMO, he succeeded. First thing, lots of the mono only sounds you hear are on the new mix. The warbling of John's voice on Lucy In The Sky with Diamonds. The extra crowd noises and Paul's yelling at the end of Sgt Pepper Reprise. She's Leaving Home is sped up here, in the same key as the mono. The transition between Good Morning Good Morning and Sgt Pepper Reprise is also a bit smoother like the mono. Second, everything seems punchier. The raunchiness of the guitars on the opening track jumps out of the speakers. The bass and drums sound very heavy on the entire record. Everything seems to be more audible, yet also raunchier. Third, the moments where the stereo should shine like A Day In The Life are unreal.
So, to wrap up, this mix of Pepper is the one that I will listen to going forward. I would suggest getting it. If this much care will be taken with remixing the Beatles stereo catalogue, I would be all for it. Several albums could use this treatment. Help, Rubber Soul, and Revolver for starters. Maybe the White Album too.
I'll add more thoughts on the sound, differences, content and packaging after spending more time listening/looking, I've listened to everything at least once but haven't read much of the book yet, it is beautiful and fairly substantial.
My overwhelming overall impression, and this includes my favorite Miles Davis and Pink Floyd box sets, is this is instantly one of the best of it's kind in my entire collection.
I would have bought anyway, but was especially looking forward to the newly re-mixed/mastered (I assume most of those who care know the difference) 5.1 surround version by George's son Giles. Probably listened to 3-4 X at least. I thought the rear channels were low/imbalanced, but maybe intended more for understated ambience, OR a system issue? Any feedback on the latter appreciated. I need to spend more time with the new STEREO remix, as well as the multi-track elements in general and mono content specifically.
Today is the 50 Year Anniversary of the release of SPLHCB to the day. The Capitol Records building raised a flag at exactly 9:09 AM (nod to Lennon?) and tonight the building will be bathed in light the color of their four individual "uniforms".
* Thanks again to saintsfans, eternally grateful for and indebted to the 96-97% of my Beatles knowledge which he was the source of.
You reminded me, I would love for my two favorite Beatles albums to get this deluxe, expanded treatment - Rubber Soul and (ESPECIALLY) Revolver.
Last edited by a moderator: