BLOCKED_PUNT
Footballguy
I think most people are ranking it on seasons 1-7 and season 8 was a fever dream.Cant believe GOT is gonna finish so high. The other 3 i expected
I think most people are ranking it on seasons 1-7 and season 8 was a fever dream.Cant believe GOT is gonna finish so high. The other 3 i expected
I think you are being generous with 1-7. It was bad before that.I think most people are ranking it on seasons 1-7 and season 8 was a fever dream.Cant believe GOT is gonna finish so high. The other 3 i expected
Shows hit us all differently. GOT is my #1 show. Horrible, horrible, rushed, horrible finale included. Just a wonderful story, great cast, epic character development and just the genre of television I really dig. ImoI think most people are ranking it on seasons 1-7 and season 8 was a fever dream.Cant believe GOT is gonna finish so high. The other 3 i expected
Cant believe GOT is gonna finish so high. The other 3 i expected
Yeah. And it’s not like people who ranked the Simpsons high were taking the seasons after 8 very much into account.I think most people are ranking it on seasons 1-7 and season 8 was a fever dream.Cant believe GOT is gonna finish so high. The other 3 i expected
Not enough widespread exposure. I've never seen it. Don't have HBO5 - The Wire
Crime
Score: 1879
Average Rank: 6.
I was sure this would be number 1. I love this damn show. Even the "down" seasons.5 - The Wire
Crime
Score: 1879
Average Rank: 6.2
Baltimore drug scene, seen through the eyes of drug dealers, and law enforcement.
List Breakdown
![]()
Nick Vermeil 1
Yo Mama 1
titusbramble 1
krista4 1
whoknew 1
Barry2 2
Runkle 2
Chaos34 2
The Gator 2
ilov80s 2
kupcho1 2
landrys hat 3
Tick 3
Sullie 4
Dan Lambskin 4
Hastur 4
simey 5
Dr Octopus 6
shuke 6
AAABatteries 7
Tau37 9
Binky 9
Psychopav 10
Frostillicus 10
Scoresman 10
McBokonon 11
Gally 12
BlackCrowes 15
Maik Jeaunz 34
When did you think it started to get bad?It was bad before that.
Maybe around season 5 or so (for me). If the last few seasons had even been 60% of what the first 4 were, it would have been Top 10 for me, easy. As it is, though, it didn't even make my Top 70.When did you think it started to get bad?It was bad before that.
Memory is a bit hazy, but IMO the drop off started at the end of S4. Some of that is also book issues as well - too many of my favorite characters killed off and the ones I liked were neutered a bit by putting them with uninteresting characters - e.g Tyrion with Dany.When did you think it started to get bad?It was bad before that.
Memory is a bit hazy, but IMO the drop off started at the end of S4.
A lot of shared characters, not sure if Saul going first works in that order. I would watch in order of when made myself.Ok, I have never seen BCS or BB and considering my taste in TV, I know I will like them. Since BCS is a prequel, is it ok to watch it first? I ask because the reason I haven't watched BB is because my wife just couldn't get into it so that makes it harder to power through. I'm hoping maybe she would like BCS if she didn't know it was connected.
Did anyone else rank Luther? I though him and Alice were great together.Idris Elba making two top 10 appearances.
I see the debate on starting either first. Gun to my head id prolly watch Breaking Bad first because it gives interesting context. Wonder if Gilligan has answered this question for fans?A lot of shared characters, not sure if Saul going first works in that order. I would watch in order of when made myself.Ok, I have never seen BCS or BB and considering my taste in TV, I know I will like them. Since BCS is a prequel, is it ok to watch it first? I ask because the reason I haven't watched BB is because my wife just couldn't get into it so that makes it harder to power through. I'm hoping maybe she would like BCS if she didn't know it was connected.
Like I posted in my edit - I agree that it was strong. All those great things happen, but IMO are offset a bit by things like Sand Snakes, Ramsay, and having less interesting characters because great others went bye-bye. There is nothing remotely as bad as the Sand Snakes in the first 4 seasons. Still very good TV, but not epic, must-see TV like the first 4.Memory is a bit hazy, but IMO the drop off started at the end of S4.
Game of Thrones Spoilers
Season 5 had the Cersei walk of shame. Drogon saving Dany in the arena from the Son of the Harpy. Epic. Brienne killing Stannis. Tyrion and Dany meeting. Nightswatch kill Jon!!! Obviously not the best season but strong. Imo
The Sand Snakes characters were really bad. Ha haLike I posted in my edit - I agree that it was strong. All those great things happen, but IMO are offset a bit by things like Sand Snakes, Ramsay, and having less interesting characters because great others went bye-bye. There is nothing remotely as bad as the Sand Snakes in the first 4 seasons. Still very good TV, but not epic, must-see TV like the first 4.Memory is a bit hazy, but IMO the drop off started at the end of S4.
Game of Thrones Spoilers
Season 5 had the Cersei walk of shame. Drogon saving Dany in the arena from the Son of the Harpy. Epic. Brienne killing Stannis. Tyrion and Dany meeting. Nightswatch kill Jon!!! Obviously not the best season but strong. Imo
David Simon also wrote the book that Homicide: Life on the Streets was based on. I really liked The Wire, but I think I liked Homicide better.David Simon was a Baltimore journalist.I don't think any journalists are main characters on the Wire - sort of in the last season, I guess.I've never had any interest in watching The Wire. I had HBO when it was on, and would see the promos when I would watch Six Feet Under. Based on those promos, I had zero interest in checking it out. I'm also averse toward shows/movies where journalists are main characters, because I am one and Hollywood almost always gets the profession "wrong".
I have seen lots of Would I lie to you and its great, but its been running a long time and ive missed well more than half the episodes so couldnt include it, same with 8 out of 10 cats. But 8 out of 10 cats does countdown, seen every episodeWould I Lie To You (#69) and QI (#64): Two great British "panel shows" where improv comedians play within the structure of a game show. WILTY is just laugh-out-loud funny as a comic must read a statement about themselves, and the others must guess whether it's true or not. Can Bob Mortimer rip an apple in half with his bare hands? Did Kevin Bridges once accidentally buy a horse in Bulgaria? Did Claudia Winkleman take her turtle to a pet psychologist because he seemed depressed and stopped scampering around like he used to? Meanwhile, QI is a quick take on all the things you thought you knew but actually don't, or, things you didn't know but really are quite interesting. It explores knowledge in a roundabout way that'll make you laugh until you've got tears in your eyes.
Would I Lie To You (#69) and QI (#64): Two great British "panel shows" where improv comedians play within the structure of a game show. WILTY is just laugh-out-loud funny as a comic must read a statement about themselves, and the others must guess whether it's true or not. Can Bob Mortimer rip an apple in half with his bare hands? Did Kevin Bridges once accidentally buy a horse in Bulgaria? Did Claudia Winkleman take her turtle to a pet psychologist because he seemed depressed and stopped scampering around like he used to? Meanwhile, QI is a quick take on all the things you thought you knew but actually don't, or, things you didn't know but really are quite interesting. It explores knowledge in a roundabout way that'll make you laugh until you've got tears in your eyes.
Did Claudia Winkleman take her turtle to a pet psychologist because he seemed depressed and stopped scampering around like he used to? - i think this was a Lie.
5 - The Wire
Crime
Score: 1879
Average Rank: 6.2
Baltimore drug scene, seen through the eyes of drug dealers, and law enforcement.
List Breakdown
![]()
Nick Vermeil 1
Yo Mama 1
titusbramble 1
krista4 1
whoknew 1
Barry2 2
Runkle 2
Chaos34 2
The Gator 2
ilov80s 2
kupcho1 2
landrys hat 3
Tick 3
Sullie 4
Dan Lambskin 4
Hastur 4
simey 5
Dr Octopus 6
shuke 6
AAABatteries 7
Tau37 9
Binky 9
Psychopav 10
Frostillicus 10
Scoresman 10
McBokonon 11
Gally 12
BlackCrowes 15
Maik Jeaunz 34
I'm on team release date in almost every situation.A lot of shared characters, not sure if Saul going first works in that order. I would watch in order of when made myself.Ok, I have never seen BCS or BB and considering my taste in TV, I know I will like them. Since BCS is a prequel, is it ok to watch it first? I ask because the reason I haven't watched BB is because my wife just couldn't get into it so that makes it harder to power through. I'm hoping maybe she would like BCS if she didn't know it was connected.
Agreed. Any of the remaining 4 can be #1.5 - The Wire
Crime
Score: 1879
Average Rank: 6.2
Baltimore drug scene, seen through the eyes of drug dealers, and law enforcement.
List Breakdown
![]()
Nick Vermeil 1
Yo Mama 1
titusbramble 1
krista4 1
whoknew 1
Barry2 2
Runkle 2
Chaos34 2
The Gator 2
ilov80s 2
kupcho1 2
landrys hat 3
Tick 3
Sullie 4
Dan Lambskin 4
Hastur 4
simey 5
Dr Octopus 6
shuke 6
AAABatteries 7
Tau37 9
Binky 9
Psychopav 10
Frostillicus 10
Scoresman 10
McBokonon 11
Gally 12
BlackCrowes 15
Maik Jeaunz 34
I'm quite surprised. I would have bet a good amount this would be #1.
Huh? Simpsons maybe has fallen off a bit in the last little bit but season 8 was in the late 90’s and they had an incredible run well past that.Yeah. And it’s not like people who ranked the Simpsons high were taking the seasons after 8 very much into account.
Ok, I have never seen BCS or BB and considering my taste in TV, I know I will like them. Since BCS is a prequel, is it ok to watch it first? I ask because the reason I haven't watched BB is because my wife just couldn't get into it so that makes it harder to power through. I'm hoping maybe she would like BCS if she didn't know it was connected.
I thought the previews looked terrible and I didn’t hear good things. I’d love for it to be good and watch it.yeah I thought The Offer might make it in this group
Agreed. I don’t think BCS has the same effect with the whole premise if you watch it before BB.Ok, I have never seen BCS or BB and considering my taste in TV, I know I will like them. Since BCS is a prequel, is it ok to watch it first? I ask because the reason I haven't watched BB is because my wife just couldn't get into it so that makes it harder to power through. I'm hoping maybe she would like BCS if she didn't know it was connected.
Watch Breaking Bad first. For sure. BCS is overlaid over the top. It's not a straight "prequel" in that some of the events happen after (and dramatically recharacterize) what happens in BB.
49 The Gong Show
I didn’t think of this as a TV show per se. Otherwise would have been top 30 easy for me. Only the Curly and Shemp iterations though.62 The Three Stooges
I had the gong show as well. So wonderfully goofy.49 The Gong Show
When I said a long while back that I had one show on my list that was almost entirely due to nostalgia, this was the one.
Everything from the Unknown Comic to 2 teenage girls licking popsicles(what a fun scandal that was).I had the gong show as well. So wonderfully goofy.49 The Gong Show
When I said a long while back that I had one show on my list that was almost entirely due to nostalgia, this was the one.
Yep. And Cheryl Lynn. And Chuck Burris with the clapping.Everything from the Unknown Comic to 2 teenage girls licking popsicles(what a fun scandal that was).I had the gong show as well. So wonderfully goofy.49 The Gong Show
When I said a long while back that I had one show on my list that was almost entirely due to nostalgia, this was the one.
3 great shows and one terrible show to go. Intrigued to see the order.
Agreed. Any of the remaining 4 can be #1.5 - The Wire
Crime
Score: 1879
Average Rank: 6.2
Baltimore drug scene, seen through the eyes of drug dealers, and law enforcement.
List Breakdown
![]()
Nick Vermeil 1
Yo Mama 1
titusbramble 1
krista4 1
whoknew 1
Barry2 2
Runkle 2
Chaos34 2
The Gator 2
ilov80s 2
kupcho1 2
landrys hat 3
Tick 3
Sullie 4
Dan Lambskin 4
Hastur 4
simey 5
Dr Octopus 6
shuke 6
AAABatteries 7
Tau37 9
Binky 9
Psychopav 10
Frostillicus 10
Scoresman 10
McBokonon 11
Gally 12
BlackCrowes 15
Maik Jeaunz 34
I'm quite surprised. I would have bet a good amount this would be #1.
It was going to be this for me if I didn’t pick Kirshner. I just remember seeing Kirshner more on live TV rather than Special - the latter more through YouTube clips. Both were great though obviously.32. The Midnight Special. People from the music threads could have guessed this because I am posting random clips from it all the time. The Tonight Show and most other talk shows were mostly rock-free in the '70s, so this was where you could watch the best rock acts of the day perform live. The episode lineups are fascinating as we see the legendary and obscure together.
Was #59 on my list. Did my part.No Herman's Head reveal yet? Suspense is building.
It was #282.Malcolm in the Middle not being here is kind of ??? I thought it might be a shoo in for you Breaking Bad fans.
I had Wings @ 35 and Are you @ 7053. Wings. Fun sitcom about people who work at a small airport in Nantucket. Was created by the same three Cheers writers who also created Fraiser, and had a great cast including Steven Weber, Tony Shaloub and Thomas Haden Church. Some of the Cheers cast members guest starred, playing their Cheers characters.
58. Are You Being Served? British sitcom about department store workers who put up with stuffy bosses and hyper-demanding customers; could be seen on PBS in the '70s, '80s and '90s. Another one of those shows where I just wanted to hang out with these people.
How did the 3 Stooges not make the top 300? That's a ****in travesty!While we wait, here was the rest of my list that didn't make the top 300.
24 Get A Life
37 O.J.: Made in America
40 Shock Theater/Saturday Night Dead
44 Iron Chef America
47 Sharp Objects
49 The Gong Show
50 V (1983)
53 Joe Shmoe Show
54 The OA
55 Small Wonder
56 Black Summer
58 Most Extreme Elimination Challenge
60 The Killing
62 The Three Stooges
67 Monstervision
69 Maniac
70 Talk Soup