What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

The Top 300 Greatest TV Shows of All Time: FBG Consensus: 50 Lists received. 2: Seinfeld 1: Breaking Bad (7 Viewers)

After seeing all the praise in this thread, I figured I’d give Psyche a go. I think I had passed on it until now mostly because it aired on cable, so I assumed it would be cheap and lame, like La Femme Nikita or TekWars.

The show was fine, but I don’t understand why the guy has to pretend to be psychic. Why can’t he just be honest about being super observant and having great instincts like Sherlock Holmes? I don’t get the premise.
 

90 - The Mandalorian​

Sci-Fi/Fantasy/Horror
Score: 339
Average Rank: 40.2

The travels of a lone bounty hunter in the outer reaches of the galaxy, far from the authority of the New Republic.

List Breakdown

Maik Jeaunz 11
turnjose7 26
Instinctive 28
Tick 30
Hastur 33
The Gator 39
Psychopav 39
landrys hat 54
gr00vus 55
Dan Lambskin 62
Todem 65
This is the way
Yes it is. Solid production. Solid cast. Solid Star Wars vibe. Might be the best Star Wars spin off for me
 

91 - Planet Earth​

Documentary
Score: 334
Average Rank: 33.9

A documentary series on the wildlife found on Earth. Each episode covers a different habitat: deserts, mountains, deep oceans, shallow seas, forests, caves, polar regions, fresh water, plains and jungles. Narrated by David Attenborough.

List Breakdown

:pickle: Tick 7
:pickle:ilov80s 10
Dr Octopus 29
AAABatteries 34
Frostillicus 40
Binky 42
Tau37 45
Chaos34 47
Don Quixote 51
I just sort of lumped all the planet earth and similar into this ranking.
 

96 - Looney Tunes/Bugs Bunny​

Animated
Score: 316
Average Rank: 31.5

Cartoons featuring Bugs Bunny/Porky Pig, etc.

List Breakdown

:pickle: :pickle: Rand al Thor 1
zamboni 12
Hastur 13
Atomic Punk 15
Dan Lambskin 23
Runkle 61
Pip's Invitation 63
AAABatteries 64
Still watch it on Saturday mornings(channel MeTV from 9am - 10am)
For those with the Twitch app, there is a station that runs them during the week.
Own all volumes of the original Looney Tunes and Merry Melodies unedited.…..still love em to this day.
 
I mean, I had Supernatural at 3 and it BARELY cracked the top 300. It just feels so weird given that I guarantee you
The Boys
is top 20 and they feel so similar tone wise to me but that might be because they are both Kripke things. Even that is starting to go downhill though.

Did you guys just not watch it or something?
Only you and I apparently watched Supernatural.
 
After seeing all the praise in this thread, I figured I’d give Psyche a go. I think I had passed on it until now mostly because it aired on cable, so I assumed it would be cheap and lame, like La Femme Nikita or TekWars.

The show was fine, but I don’t understand why the guy has to pretend to be psychic. Why can’t he just be honest about being super observant and having great instincts like Sherlock Holmes? I don’t get the premise.
I had only seen the pilot episode when this list started.
Thought Anne Dudek was great. Surprised she was written out cause test audiences didnt like her. Idiots.
Only watched the third overall episode to date since
I will give it until the end of season one as right now the characters are only 2D.

Loved The Mentalist and Medium as similar shows
 
I could just never commit to a new watch of any of these now. That is a lot of seasons and most were 22 episode seasons. I would rather rewatch one I know I love or take the risk on a show like Severence is new or another that only has 8-10 episode seasons.
No one is expecting you to watch all 327 episodes of Supernatural or any show but I guess my stance is if you like it why wouldn't you? We are just likely very different people and I get tired of watching the same shows over and over again. Yeah, I'll watch a rerun once in a while but most of the time I try to find something new.
 
I could just never commit to a new watch of any of these now. That is a lot of seasons and most were 22 episode seasons. I would rather rewatch one I know I love or take the risk on a show like Severence is new or another that only has 8-10 episode seasons.
No one is expecting you to watch all 327 episodes of Supernatural or any show but I guess my stance is if you like it why wouldn't you? We are just likely very different people and I get tired of watching the same shows over and over again. Yeah, I'll watch a rerun once in a while but most of the time I try to find something new.
I don't binge a lot of tv in general - mostly due to shows dipping and me never finishing what I start. Both of those are less likely to happen if I start a show that 30 episodes vs. 327.
 
Why can’t he just be honest about being super observant and having great instincts like Sherlock Holmes? I don’t get the premise.
mostly because it's not as funny that way and plot. The biggest difference is that Holmes was already a member of Scotland Yard (I guess, never read a Holmes novel) while Shawn was not (a member of the SBPD) and HE was being accused of having too much information. I can't remember if he tried to plead with the police that he solved the crime by being super observant and having great instincts and they/more Lassie than her just didn't buy it so he claimed the psychic thing or if he just went straight to that. Also the police chief threatened to prosecute if they ever found out the psycic thing was fake.

It's mostly the funny thing though.
 
I could just never commit to a new watch of any of these now. That is a lot of seasons and most were 22 episode seasons. I would rather rewatch one I know I love or take the risk on a show like Severence is new or another that only has 8-10 episode seasons.
No one is expecting you to watch all 327 episodes of Supernatural or any show but I guess my stance is if you like it why wouldn't you? We are just likely very different people and I get tired of watching the same shows over and over again. Yeah, I'll watch a rerun once in a while but most of the time I try to find something new.
I don't binge a lot of tv in general - mostly due to shows dipping and me never finishing what I start. Both of those are less likely to happen if I start a show that 30 episodes vs. 327.
I think you should give it a try but I can't force you. I thought it might be up you guys alley since they play alot of 80's music.
 
I mean, I had Supernatural at 3 and it BARELY cracked the top 300. It just feels so weird given that I guarantee you
The Boys
is top 20 and they feel so similar tone wise to me but that might be because they are both Kripke things. Even that is starting to go downhill though.

Did you guys just not watch it or something?
Only you and I apparently watched Supernatural.
The only time I ever watched any Supernatural was during basketball seasons - when NBA games / Inside the NBA was the last thing I’d watch at night and Supernatural was on in the mornings when I’d turn the TV back on.
 
I could just never commit to a new watch of any of these now. That is a lot of seasons and most were 22 episode seasons. I would rather rewatch one I know I love or take the risk on a show like Severence is new or another that only has 8-10 episode seasons.
No one is expecting you to watch all 327 episodes of Supernatural or any show but I guess my stance is if you like it why wouldn't you? We are just likely very different people and I get tired of watching the same shows over and over again. Yeah, I'll watch a rerun once in a while but most of the time I try to find something new.
I don't binge a lot of tv in general - mostly due to shows dipping and me never finishing what I start. Both of those are less likely to happen if I start a show that 30 episodes vs. 327.
Plus you listen to a squillion albums/playlists a day. How could you possibly have time to binge TV?
 
I could just never commit to a new watch of any of these now. That is a lot of seasons and most were 22 episode seasons. I would rather rewatch one I know I love or take the risk on a show like Severence is new or another that only has 8-10 episode seasons.
No one is expecting you to watch all 327 episodes of Supernatural or any show but I guess my stance is if you like it why wouldn't you? We are just likely very different people and I get tired of watching the same shows over and over again. Yeah, I'll watch a rerun once in a while but most of the time I try to find something new.
I don't binge a lot of tv in general - mostly due to shows dipping and me never finishing what I start. Both of those are less likely to happen if I start a show that 30 episodes vs. 327.
Plus you listen to a squillion albums/playlists a day. How could you possibly have time to binge TV?
Exactly. That I can do while doing other tasks as well.
 

91 - Planet Earth​

Documentary
Score: 334
Average Rank: 33.9

A documentary series on the wildlife found on Earth. Each episode covers a different habitat: deserts, mountains, deep oceans, shallow seas, forests, caves, polar regions, fresh water, plains and jungles. Narrated by David Attenborough.

List Breakdown

:pickle: Tick 7
:pickle:ilov80s 10
Dr Octopus 29
AAABatteries 34
Frostillicus 40
Binky 42
Tau37 45
Chaos34 47
Don Quixote 51
I cheated a little here - I included all of the subsequent shows into this as more like seasons of a single show rather than a bunch of individual 6- or 8-episode miniseries, which they technically are. That slow motion shot of the shark tossing the seal was all anyone could talk about for a couple of months there, with good reason. Putting a well-done nature show in such high resolution for the first time took my breath away so many times. The lizard scrambling away from the snakes, the aerial shots of lions after a giraffe, diving in the perfectly clear water-filled caves, the birds flying over the top of the Himalayas, penguins weathering a brutal winter with eggs on their feet, those crazy balls of fish where the birds, seals, and dolphins feed like mad, then a humpback just eats the whole remaining ball, the desperate polar bear failing to eat a walrus and dying for his attempt, the crazy dancing birds... it's been almost 20 years and some of those scenes are just burned into my brain.
 
The Mandalorian is the last show I got hooked on. It's just a blast. I wish they had kept making more seasons instead of switching to a movie.
 
My top 5 favorite Conchords tunes/videos:

5: Think About It
4: Business Time
3: Inner City Pressure
2: Boom!
1: Ladies Of The World - [bonus: official video, on roller skates]

I never watched this show but saw a clip of them doing Business Time in a stand up years ago, and I found it hilarious. The line about the team building exercise t-shirt has stayed with me since.
You should check out t the series then. It's relatively short, and the episodes are only 30 minutes. Plenty more stuff like that in there.
 
After seeing all the praise in this thread, I figured I’d give Psyche a go. I think I had passed on it until now mostly because it aired on cable, so I assumed it would be cheap and lame, like La Femme Nikita or TekWars.

The show was fine, but I don’t understand why the guy has to pretend to be psychic. Why can’t he just be honest about being super observant and having great instincts like Sherlock Holmes? I don’t get the premise.
It's just a plot device and is there for the hijinks that ensue over 9 glorious seasons.

It's closer in spirit to a buddy comedy like Ferris Bueller's Day Off or Harold and Kumar than a true crime solver like Murder She Wrote or Colombo.

It's purely a comedy.
 
Buffy The Vampire Slayer

I've said elsewhere that I place a high premium on TV and movies that give me multiple emotions through the series and episodes. Yes, this show is a bit cheesy - look past that. (or have an edible and laugh even harder at the bad stunt work as Buffy morphs into a ripped 35 year old would a few inches taller than her, it works well for that too). This is a show that still makes me laugh multiple times in an episode on top of the drama and creeps. Yes, it makes me cry in episodes. Prom and the episode The Body come to mind right away. It has actual scares too - Hush is really creepy (and also really funny). Yes, I even like the episode that is a musical.

All that said, what sets it apart is the actors and characters. Like @B Maverick we have had pets named after characters. Giles is probably my favorite character - I love the Britishness and heart that Anthony Stewart Head brought to the character. We had a guinea pig named Giles and my cat that passed a couple years ago was officially named Dr. Rupert Fluffenstein, but Ripper is what I called him. Hannigan as Willow, despite having a voice that makes Tick want to kick a kitten, is another highlight for me. It does fall off a bit after the fanstastic Season 2/Season 3 back to back. A lot of the best characters come and go in those seasons - Oz, Faith, Jenny Calendar, the principals, Kendra to name a few. Still, the back half of the series still features more Willow, more Spike (way better than Angel), and more Anya. It also has some great episodes and ends strong overall.

I will never get tired of watching this show and it is the one I've seen the most (especially seasons 2 and 3). I got to relive the Star Wars stuff with my son which was great, but my daughter has 0 interest in it. I am secretly hoping I can rewatch Buffy yet again with her in a few years. Speaking of S2 and edibles, I am about to hit the great stretch of episodes and the two parter What's My Line? is up tonight. :popcorn:
Also, for its time, the music and bands were fantastic. To me at least.
 
After seeing all the praise in this thread, I figured I’d give Psyche a go. I think I had passed on it until now mostly because it aired on cable, so I assumed it would be cheap and lame, like La Femme Nikita or TekWars.

The show was fine, but I don’t understand why the guy has to pretend to be psychic. Why can’t he just be honest about being super observant and having great instincts like Sherlock Holmes? I don’t get the premise.
I had only seen the pilot episode when this list started.
Thought Anne Dudek was great. Surprised she was written out cause test audiences didnt like her. Idiots.
Only watched the third overall episode to date since
I will give it until the end of season one as right now the characters are only 2D.

Loved The Mentalist and Medium as similar shows
Noted!

To you and others, my rule is to always stick with shows for three episodes before making a call (Pilots are often very different and subsequently crap). So that’s what I told my wife when I was trying to convince her that Resident Alien was worth watching. Later episodes grew on her.

I’ll stick with Psych and hopefully see it all come together the way you guys have.
 
After seeing all the praise in this thread, I figured I’d give Psyche a go. I think I had passed on it until now mostly because it aired on cable, so I assumed it would be cheap and lame, like La Femme Nikita or TekWars.

The show was fine, but I don’t understand why the guy has to pretend to be psychic. Why can’t he just be honest about being super observant and having great instincts like Sherlock Holmes? I don’t get the premise.
I had only seen the pilot episode when this list started.
Thought Anne Dudek was great. Surprised she was written out cause test audiences didnt like her. Idiots.
Only watched the third overall episode to date since
I will give it until the end of season one as right now the characters are only 2D.

Loved The Mentalist and Medium as similar shows
Noted!

To you and others, my rule is to always stick with shows for three episodes before making a call (Pilots are often very different and subsequently crap). So that’s what I told my wife when I was trying to convince her that Resident Alien was worth watching. Later episodes grew on her.

I’ll stick with Psych and hopefully see it all come together the way you guys have.
This is some bull$#^&! Tell that human they must watch!

(you just read that in his voice, didn't you?) lol
 
@landrys hat might be my hero.

I didn't have the balls to rank it #1, but you, sir, are a patriot and a scholar.

ETA: And possibly a warrior-poet, but I'm uncertain as to what exactly that means.

Audre Lorde, who I had to read as a senior in high school. She's a warrior-poet, bro. Make way for intersectionality that she helped create. Yes, that was her.
 

89 - Family Guy​

Animated
Score: 349
Average Rank: 27.4

In a wacky Rhode Island town, a dysfunctional family strive to cope with everyday life as they are thrown from one crazy scenario to another.

List Breakdown

:pickle: titusbramble 6
AAABatteries 14
Atomic Punk 17
Tick 22
Jayrod 23
BLOCKED PUNT 32
John Madden's Lunchbox 46
turnjose7 59
 

88 - The Boys​

Sci-Fi/Fantasy/Horror
Score: 350
Average Rank: 39.2

A group of vigilantes set out to take down corrupt superheroes who abuse their superpowers.

List Breakdown

:pickle: BLOCKED PUNT 4
kupcho1 24
Tick 31
AAABatteries 37
The Gator 38
steelerfan1 40
Chaos34 42
Gally 47
Dan Lambskin 51
Jayrod 58
Yo Mama 59
 
Seeing the Boys get on the board made me realize I completely forgot about a show that would've been top 50 for me - Ash v the Evil Dead. Both were/are completely over the top, but Ash was hilarious. I can't believe I forgot about that one. I do enjoy the Boys, but it's dragging or something these last few seasons. Lost it's way? I don't know, I was a huge fan of the first few seasons, and it is fun to see what they will come up with next to shock you (the self-replicating human centipede orgy was a good one, as was Hughie dressed as the Webweaver in the dungeon...). Ultimately though, for me they could kill any of the characters and I don't think I'd really care. Except for Kimiko, but I don't think she can die.
 

89 - Family Guy​

For awhile I thought there must be something wrong with me because my friends were always talking about how funny Family Guy was. I watched a couple of episodes and didn't even chuckle. Then my feelings were validated in this episode of South Park - South Park takes on Family Guy
For me, I don't like the style of the show. There are a lot of: say something funny, flash to somewhere else to show that funny thing, come back. Don't know why, it's just something that bothered me when I tried watching the show.
 

88 - The Boys​

Sci-Fi/Fantasy/Horror
Score: 350
Average Rank: 39.2

A group of vigilantes set out to take down corrupt superheroes who abuse their superpowers.

List Breakdown

:pickle: BLOCKED PUNT 4
kupcho1 24
Tick 31
AAABatteries 37
The Gator 38
steelerfan1 40
Chaos34 42
Gally 47
Dan Lambskin 51
Jayrod 58
Yo Mama 59
Such a fun, unique take on the superhero genre that has oversaturated the market. I’d never heard of the graphic novels, so this was a complete surprise for me when I first started watching.
 

89 - Family Guy​

For awhile I thought there must be something wrong with me because my friends were always talking about how funny Family Guy was. I watched a couple of episodes and didn't even chuckle. Then my feelings were validated in this episode of South Park - South Park takes on Family Guy
For me, I don't like the style of the show. There are a lot of: say something funny, flash to somewhere else to show that funny thing, come back. Don't know why, it's just something that bothered me when I tried watching the show.
Yeah I know lots of people who love this (and its spinoffs) and find it hilarious, but I just don’t get it.
 

88 - The Boys​

Sci-Fi/Fantasy/Horror
Score: 350
Average Rank: 39.2

A group of vigilantes set out to take down corrupt superheroes who abuse their superpowers.

List Breakdown

:pickle: BLOCKED PUNT 4
kupcho1 24
Tick 31
AAABatteries 37
The Gator 38
steelerfan1 40
Chaos34 42
Gally 47
Dan Lambskin 51
Jayrod 58
Yo Mama 59
I'm gonna 'blocked punt' this one. Never heard of it.
 

89 - Family Guy​

Animated
Score: 349
Average Rank: 27.4

In a wacky Rhode Island town, a dysfunctional family strive to cope with everyday life as they are thrown from one crazy scenario to another.

List Breakdown

:pickle: titusbramble 6
AAABatteries 14
Atomic Punk 17
Tick 22
Jayrod 23
BLOCKED PUNT 32
John Madden's Lunchbox 46
turnjose7 59
“No” by Consuela.

 

88 - The Boys​

Sci-Fi/Fantasy/Horror
Score: 350
Average Rank: 39.2

A group of vigilantes set out to take down corrupt superheroes who abuse their superpowers.

List Breakdown

:pickle: BLOCKED PUNT 4
kupcho1 24
Tick 31
AAABatteries 37
The Gator 38
steelerfan1 40
Chaos34 42
Gally 47
Dan Lambskin 51
Jayrod 58
Yo Mama 59
I had this in my original 70 but it didn't make the final cut. Really neat concept. I think each season has been worse than the prior though.
 

88 - The Boys​

Sci-Fi/Fantasy/Horror
Score: 350
Average Rank: 39.2

A group of vigilantes set out to take down corrupt superheroes who abuse their superpowers.

List Breakdown

:pickle: BLOCKED PUNT 4
kupcho1 24
Tick 31
AAABatteries 37
The Gator 38
steelerfan1 40
Chaos34 42
Gally 47
Dan Lambskin 51
Jayrod 58
Yo Mama 59
Such a fun, unique take on the superhero genre that has oversaturated the market. I’d never heard of the graphic novels, so this was a complete surprise for me when I first started watching.
I started watching season one and got distracted…..gotta get back to this because I loved all I saw thus far.
 

88 - The Boys​

Sci-Fi/Fantasy/Horror
Score: 350
Average Rank: 39.2

A group of vigilantes set out to take down corrupt superheroes who abuse their superpowers.

List Breakdown

:pickle: BLOCKED PUNT 4
kupcho1 24
Tick 31
AAABatteries 37
The Gator 38
steelerfan1 40
Chaos34 42
Gally 47
Dan Lambskin 51
Jayrod 58
Yo Mama 59
Such a fun, unique take on the superhero genre that has oversaturated the market. I’d never heard of the graphic novels, so this was a complete surprise for me when I first started watching.
I started watching season one and got distracted…..gotta get back to this because I loved all I saw thus far.
You might not like how the last couple seasons get more overtly political - it caricaturizes both sides, but it’s more in your face.
 

89 - Family Guy​

For awhile I thought there must be something wrong with me because my friends were always talking about how funny Family Guy was. I watched a couple of episodes and didn't even chuckle. Then my feelings were validated in this episode of South Park - South Park takes on Family Guy
I’m not as extreme on this show as you or the South Park guys, but my opinion is closer to yours than to the Family Guy fanatics.
 

88 - The Boys​

Sci-Fi/Fantasy/Horror
Score: 350
Average Rank: 39.2

A group of vigilantes set out to take down corrupt superheroes who abuse their superpowers.

List Breakdown

:pickle: BLOCKED PUNT 4
kupcho1 24
Tick 31
AAABatteries 37
The Gator 38
steelerfan1 40
Chaos34 42
Gally 47
Dan Lambskin 51
Jayrod 58
Yo Mama 59
Hey BLOCKED PUNT: I don’t watch this and have never heard of it.
 
The Boys

Absolutely marvelous show. At least first handful of seasons . Sex. Drugs. Violence. Crazy storyline. Love it. Billy Joel? Hell ya
 

89 - Family Guy​

For awhile I thought there must be something wrong with me because my friends were always talking about how funny Family Guy was. I watched a couple of episodes and didn't even chuckle. Then my feelings were validated in this episode of South Park - South Park takes on Family Guy
For me, I don't like the style of the show. There are a lot of: say something funny, flash to somewhere else to show that funny thing, come back. Don't know why, it's just something that bothered me when I tried watching the show.
Yeah I know lots of people who love this (and its spinoffs) and find it hilarious, but I just don’t get it.
I’ve seen a few episodes but more of a South Park guy. Kind of creeps me out how the dad Peter’s chin looks like a ball sack.
 

89 - Family Guy​

For awhile I thought there must be something wrong with me because my friends were always talking about how funny Family Guy was. I watched a couple of episodes and didn't even chuckle. Then my feelings were validated in this episode of South Park - South Park takes on Family Guy
For me, I don't like the style of the show. There are a lot of: say something funny, flash to somewhere else to show that funny thing, come back. Don't know why, it's just something that bothered me when I tried watching the show.
Yeah I know lots of people who love this (and its spinoffs) and find it hilarious, but I just don’t get it.
I’ve seen a few episodes but more of a South Park guy. Kind of creeps me out how the dad Peter’s chin looks like a ball sack.
:lol:
 

88 - The Boys​

Sci-Fi/Fantasy/Horror
Score: 350
Average Rank: 39.2

A group of vigilantes set out to take down corrupt superheroes who abuse their superpowers.

List Breakdown

:pickle: BLOCKED PUNT 4
kupcho1 24
Tick 31
AAABatteries 37
The Gator 38
steelerfan1 40
Chaos34 42
Gally 47
Dan Lambskin 51
Jayrod 58
Yo Mama 59
I had this in my original 70 but it didn't make the final cut. Really neat concept. I think each season has been worse than the prior though.
That's what kept it off my list. 1st season is :moneybag: but it fell a lot after that
 
88 The Boys - @Instinctive summed up my take perfectly, good start but lost interest

89 Family Guy - watched a lot with my teenage sons, so it holds a special place in my memory

90 The Mandalorian - really enjoyed it but not nearly enough to make my list

92 Daredevil - another good one but didn’t come to mind when compiling. If you combined this with Punisher, Jessica Jones, etc. it likely would have placed in the 50s at least

93 Beavis and Butt-Head - slightly too stupid for my liking

94 WKRP In Cincinnati - incredible lineup with some of the best characters. I was doing the open fake door at co-worker cubicles bit until I retired last year

96 Looney Toons/Bugs Bunny - impossible to omit. I still play a few episodes to warm up before our outdoor movie nights at the cabin
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top