THIS IS THEIR BEST SONG! - Music Draft - Saturday Night's Alright for iFighting (1 Viewer)

[Pip's Invitation]

And that was the end of the sentence. I said before that, which you edited out:

The Smiths were big in the UK but again, look at the discography to see how well those same releases fared in the US...

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Smiths_discography

This is an awfully pedantic point. Who cares if Midwest housewives never heard of them. Among people who cared about music beyond the top 40, they were important. 

 

[Binky The Doormat]

Honestly if I knew my pick for The Smiths (which I am sorry I made now) would have gotten this reaction I would have gone with my fave from The Partridge Family that I have been saving (and it is an enhanced version!)

WAIT ...WUT.

Did you say the "ENHANCED VERSION"????

Really think you nailed it here.

Though it would be great if you were a bit more gentle with the plebs around here ...OK  

 

[Captain Cranks]

My friend in high school tried to get us into The Smiths because we liked punk, so why not?

He was from Canada. Stupid Canadian friends. Forget Morrissey.

The more you ignore him, the closer he gets.  You're wasting your time.

 

[rockaction]

I'm sure NV will chime in to tell us the The Smiths are his absolutely favourite band, and have been since he was doodling in colouring books, but he's...psst...Canadian.

 

[rockaction]

The more you ignore him, the closer he gets.  You're wasting your time.

I must embrace the Morrissey in order to conquer him? 

 

[squistion]

Your pick was appreciated.  Your inability even to consider other experiences is not.  Music drafts are about discussion and learning.

Bring on Danny and the others!

I am willing to acknowledge other experiences, which I noted with their popularity here in L.A. But the bottom line is, despite being a darling of the indie alt music college crowd, their US fan base was not that big and while people can post their personal anecdotes about how everybody they knew in college loved them, that was simply not reflected in any sales figure of that time. 

 

[krista4]

I am willing to acknowledge other experiences, which I noted with their popularity here in L.A. But the bottom line is, despite being a darling of the indie alt music college crowd, their US fan base was not that big and while people can post their personal anecdotes about how everybody they knew in college loved them, that was simply not reflected in any sales figure of that time. 

No one has disputed this.  So are we good?

 

[rockaction]

I'm just kidding about everything, by the way. I like The Smiths just fine. And I have no opinion on how big they are and would prefer not to get involved with that.

The first time I heard them was on 120 Minutes with "There Is A Light That Never Goes Out" Great song. Great lyrics. I never pursued it further, though, for some reason. Probably because Morrissey was too good looking for my self-esteem.

 

[squistion]

This is an awfully pedantic point. Who cares if Midwest housewives never heard of them. Among people who cared about music beyond the top 40, they were important. 

Yes, popularity reflected in sales and what people say who following radio station airplay of that day for a living is pedantic, I grant you that.

 

[rockaction]

And if a double-decker bus
Crashes into us...

 

[Pip's Invitation]

that was simply not reflected in any sales figure of that time. 

And most of us are saying we don't care about sales figures. That tends not to matter in these threads. None of us are saying your sales figures are wrong. 

 

[Steve Tasker]

I don't know about you guys, but after the last draft and this one, my Youtube algorithm is ####ed.  It's all [redacted pop artists that I drafted in the last draft] and a bunch of god-awful pop music that I'm probably going to take in the back half of this.

 

[rockaction]

I don't know about you guys, but after the last draft and this one, my Youtube algorithm is ####ed.  It's all [redacted pop artists that I drafted in the last draft] and a bunch of god-awful pop music that I'm probably going to take in the back half of this.

Along those lines, my Youtube algorithm is busy trawling this very site and recommends bands I've merely clacked the keyboard about. It's sort of unnerving at times.

 

[squistion]

No one has disputed this.  So are we good?

Yes, they have, they say that actual sales figures or what those who charted radio stations for what songs were actually being played were saying doesn't count - and that I am wrong but have nothing to dispute it with but anecdotal stories of what they and their friends were listening to at the time. 

 

[krista4]

I don't know about you guys, but after the last draft and this one, my Youtube algorithm is ####ed.  It's all [redacted pop artists that I drafted in the last draft] and a bunch of god-awful pop music that I'm probably going to take in the back half of this.

4th one on my sidebar.

 

[krista4]

Yes, they have, they say that actual sales figures or what those who charted radio stations for what songs were actually being played were saying doesn't count - and that I am wrong but have nothing to dispute it with but anecdotal stories of what they and their friends were listening to at the time. 

No.  They haven't.

 

[Pip's Invitation]

Along those lines, my Youtube algorithm is busy trawling this very site and recommends bands I've merely clacked the keyboard about. It's sort of unnerving at times.

When I was doing my "listen to songs picked that I wasn't familar with" thing last night, when I would type the artist name into the Youtube search bar, one of the top 3 suggestions was always the name of the song in question, regardless of whether it was one of the artist's popular songs or not. 

 

[Pip's Invitation]

Yes, they have, they say that actual sales figures or what those who charted radio stations for what songs were actually being played were saying doesn't count - and that I am wrong but have nothing to dispute it with but anecdotal stories of what they and their friends were listening to at the time. 

I've never put someone on ignore in the middle of a music draft. I am getting very close to changing that. 

 

[squistion]

No.  They haven't.

Excellent concise rebuttal. I look forward to continuing this discussion with you.

 

[krista4]

Excellent concise rebuttal. I look forward to continuing this discussion with you.

I look forward to your links to where anyone said you were "wrong" or that sales "don't count."

 

[dickey moe]

I'll take an little indie band here, some of you may know... but probably not.

4- Elvis Costello and the Attractions- Alison

so many tunes to take from him/them. I love Trust, and was tempted with my favorite- Strict Time. Then started leaning to What's So Funny about Peace Love and Understanding... but Alison just slays me as a perfect song and perfect encapsulation of EC. every time. 

Good one. 

 

[krista4]

I've never put someone on ignore in the middle of a music draft. I am getting very close to changing that. 

I've had to take a few people off ignore because they ended up in music drafts!    It always felt weird.  But in each case (so far) I wasn't sorry I did and was happy to get to know something about them on a different level.

 

[El Floppo]

I’m just relaying my experience at my high school and my colleges. Obviously others had different experiences.

I was kidding. Of course that's what you were doing.

I'm not going to use the WRONG thing any more. 

 

[rockaction]

When I was doing my "listen to songs picked that I wasn't familar with" thing last night, when I would type the artist name into the Youtube search bar, one of the top 3 suggestions was always the name of the song in question, regardless of whether it was one of the artist's popular songs or not. 

By the way, never got to really comment on your comments. Vampire Weekend is heavily influenced by Paul Simon, especially albums like Graceland, or his more "world music" endeavors. That was actually a knock on the band coming out of Columbia University. That they were preppy but were appropriating black music, much like Simon. In the end, they got a hall pass because they were so darn good, but that criticism was there.

As far as Daft Punk goes, I can see where you'd want to get drunk and do irresponsible things. Pretty grimy.

 

[El Floppo]

yeesh.

and yuck.

 

[TripItUp]

I like the Smiths.  Music snobs also like the Smiths.

Do I think they get too much attention along with a hand full of other music snob bands?  Absolutely.

 

[Ilov80s]

The Smiths were popular but not as popular as other artists. I think we all agree. 

 

[El Floppo]

btw- speaking of messing up algorithms... is anyboyd keeping a running Spotify playlist for this?

 

[El Floppo]

The Smiths were popular but not as popular as other artists. I think we all agree. 

WRONG

 

[rockaction]

I was kidding. Of course that's what you were doing.

I'm not going to use the WRONG thing any more. 

That's so wrong.

 

[squistion]

WAIT ...WUT.

Did you say the "ENHANCED VERSION"????

Really think you nailed it here.

Though it would be great if you were a bit more gentle with the plebs around here ...OK  

Yeah, enhanced and may not have been done so legally, the drums from the original version were erased and then redone to give the song an extra punch.

 

[rockaction]

WRONG

 

[squistion]

The Smiths were popular but not as popular as other artists. I think we all agree. 

Indeed. Probably the least controversial post I have seen since I started this "best song" choice fiasco.

 

[rockaction]

Jeez, Pip, you almost had a Tyreek fumble but it bounced right back up into his arms while he was still moving.

 

[Binky The Doormat]

The more you ignore him, the closer he gets.  You're wasting your time.

 oh no, believe me ...

if he thinks you're interested ...

he'll come rub on ya

 

[El Floppo]

Yes, they have, they say that actual sales figures or what those who charted radio stations for what songs were actually being played were saying doesn't count - and that I am wrong but have nothing to dispute it with but anecdotal stories of what they and their friends were listening to at the time. 

wow. 

I shared my experience and asked what others' experiences were in here. 

take it as crappily as you will and have. 

 

[krista4]

 oh no, believe me ...

if he thinks you're interested ...

he'll come rub on ya

Are we talking about...Morrissey?  

 

[TripItUp]

OK I'll pull the pin

4.24 - Taylor Swift - All Too Well (Ten Minute Version)

As a 40ish year old man, I obviously don't connect with any of Swift's early albums but I was blown away by 1989 which I consider her best album.  As a result, I would go with "Blank Space" as her best.  

I also like Eephus' diverse selections in this draft, that is what I value most when selecting my inner circle of music snob friends. 

 

[rockaction]

Are we talking about...Morrissey?  

I didn't get the original comment and did the best I could with it. I blame Cranks.

I'm kidding about blaming Cranks, by the way. I hope we take it with that laughing tone in mind.

 

[krista4]

I didn't get the original comment and did the best I could with it. I blame Cranks.

I'm kidding about blaming Cranks, by the way. I hope we take it with that laughing tone in mind.

YOU MONSTER.

 

[Steve Tasker]

Can we at least agree that "Girlfriend in a Coma" is one of the most ridiculous song titles ever?

 

[krista4]

Can we at least agree that "Girlfriend in a Coma" is one of the most ridiculous song titles ever?

No, it's serious.

 

[Binky The Doormat]

Are we talking about...Morrissey?  

who? what?

...yes

 

[krista4]

Hey, not Hill on that TD!

 

[rockaction]

Can we at least agree that "Girlfriend in a Coma" is one of the most ridiculous song titles ever?

It was the first song my Canadian friend tried to get me into. "You've never heard 'Girlfriend In A Coma,'" he asked.

That's true.

Hey, Pip or krista4, how does one handle that interrogative within the sentence when it aligns like that?

 

[Steve Tasker]

No, it's serious.

Do you really think this draft will pull through?

 

[rockaction]

Hey, not Hill on that TD!

So funny because when I looked up from my computer, I thought it was Hill.

Apropos of nothing, If Patrick Mahomes had shown up the past four weeks like tonight, I'd be looking at a potential playoff in my main dynasty league. Instead, no dice.

 

[krista4]

So funny because when I looked up from my computer, I thought it was Hill.

Apropos Apricot of nothing, If Patrick Mahomes had shown up the past four weeks like tonight, I'd be looking at a potential playoff in my main dynasty league. Instead, no dice.

Fixed.

 

[Binky The Doormat]

Yes, they have, they say that actual sales figures or what those who charted radio stations for what songs were actually being played were saying doesn't count - and that I am wrong but have nothing to dispute it with but anecdotal stories of what they and their friends were listening to at the time. 

No.  They haven't.

completely unproven.

 

[Red Hat Road]

Side note: @Red Hat Road, who are you?

alias of a name that you most likely wouldn’t recognize anyway (except maybe from the bottom of one of the other drafts).

I’ve never done nearly as much posting as reading.