I think it is safe to say that if you own Peterson, he will bring your team at least one title. These are the players one tries to obtain...
I've never been in a one round draft before.
I understand the point, and the later rounds are what makes up a strong squad. However, having a player that has the potential of Peterson, gives you more opportunity to make mistakes with those picks. His possible elite production will help negate those mistakes, and over a period of years he will increase your chances of winning a championship tremendously. If you even do an "adequate" job with the rest of your picks, you should bring a title home in the next few years with him in your lineup.
I know what you mean, but there are players like this almost every year. 2 years ago I had LT and I knew that if my receivers had just an average game (and I had quite good receivers - Harrison being one of them) I would win the matchup. Brady probably did that for many owners last year, Priest Holmes a few years back, Alexander in his 28TD season. Its great when that happens, a dominant player having a career season. It's unlikely to happen more than once though.
This is where I may disagree. Players like Faulk, Priest, and most recently, LT, have performed at such a high level, it's like getting 2-player production for the price of one. Those players are very rare, and once you have one, it gives you an absolute advantage over your competition. Like ADP did last year, LT had disappointed his owners in Week 16 for at least 2 consecutive years prior. That's bad luck, it doesn't speak to their overall production potential.Those who avoid ADP do it at their own peril.
Are you disagreeing with me? It seems like we're singing from the same songsheet. The only thing I would say is that they might not be as rare as you think, unless you're limiting it to just RB's.Moss 2007 - best ever WR season
Brady 2007 - best ever QB season
LT 2006 - best ever RB season
Alexander 2005 - best ever RB season (at that time)
Manning 2004 - best ever QB season (at that time)
Priest 2003 - best ever RB season (at that time)
If you had any of those guys in their respective seasons you had would have had a very good chance to dominate your league.