This is going to be a fun thread to bump in a few years.
Which side are you on, G?
I think Tebow has all the tools to be a successful QB in the NFL. Most of which isn't that he's a "winner" in the mold of guys like Vince Young or athletic in the mold of JaMarcus, guys that have been mentioned so far. He has the work ethic and intelligence to be so much more than them in addition to his physical tools. Those physical tools, btw, are extraordinary. His size/speed is ridiculous.Those questioning his accuracy haven't looked at his passing #'s and/or watched him play. The guy can definitely throw the football.
Now, he does have a very slow release. He is not your typical NFL pocket passer. But, that's not because he's failed at it. It's because he hasn't been asked to do it. So, before I label him nothing more than a college gimmick, I'd like to see him, you know, actually take plays while not being primarily in the shotgun and see how he does. Might he fail? Surely. But is it a foregone conclusion like so many are suggesting here? Far from it.
I think some folks are writing him off WAY too early. Oh, and final note. I hate the Gators. This has nothing to do with fandom whatsoever. I grew up in Florida and can't stand them. But Tebow is a legitimate prospect that has the POTENTIAL to do very well in the NFL. I'm not going to say he's a lock for success because he's not. There are things to be concerned about. But I definitely won't be dismissing him outright like most are. And if I had to bet one way or the other, I'd be on the side of him being a legit NFL starting QB vs. not.