I get it and wasnt complaining. I just think the 2 subjects are ALMOST a completely different subset of players so having 2 different WW threads makes more sense to me. As long as they are merged I do appreciate when they are labeled dynasty as you did. I appreciate anybody who participates and wouldnt try to disuade anybody from posting. P.S. Sounds like we are in similar redraft leagues because Achane was drafted in my 17 roster spot league and Atwell was gone 2 weeks ago. Teams are aggressive bottom of the roster churners so sometimes you are better off getting the DROPPED players over wasting so much faab money for the flavor of the day hoping to hit it big. cheers.see this is why Dynasty and redraft waiver wires are COMPLETELY different. Dynasty rosters are usually much bigger. I am in a very competitive 12 team redraft league whereby normally 50 % or more of the players suggested on the WW are already rostered. Most of the names you listed Ive barely heard of and would never roster. the only one potential pick up is Parham (Hill is a likely DROP not an add) .... I am in NO WAY complaining about your list. Just saying the 2 WWs are very very different. Id be all for a separate dynasty WW thread and wouldnt like to have to sort through the Dynasty lists to find any potential help for my redraft team. Again not a complaint and I hope your dynasty suggestions help someone. The people redraft people are picking up are likely already rostered in dynasty leagues so our info is of much less use to you all too Im sure.Neither are available in dynasty leagues. Perhaps we should have separate threads for weekly waivers, one for dynasty and one for redraft.Quentin is a sneaky good callJosh Palmer or Quentin Johnson with initial thoughts that Mike Williams is out for season?
I have posted some waiver wire thoughts labeled as dynasty in this weekly waiver wire thread. I think that's fair. I would patron a dynasty waiver wire thread..... however, couldn't these moves just piggyback on the dynasty trades thread?
I know it's not technically a league trade, but aren't we just trading one end-of-bench player with another on the free agent team, sometimes with FAAB included on our side? If that is a disservice to the trade thread, then certainly the dynasty value thread is fair game, right?
Moderators, if you have any recommendations on where dynasty waiver discussion belongs, I'm all ears.
With that said, 24x12 1QB dynasty for week 4:
- someone dropped Cedric Tillman. I want to pounce, but I'm not sure I will have the patience to see it through.
- If Jimmy G doesn't clear concussion protocol, would Aidan O'Connell get a shot or would it be Hoyer?
- Taysom Hill (TE DESIGNATION) with Carr out
- Parham - 2 TD snags, no more Mike Williams
- Hard to get excited about stashing Jeff Wilson on IR, but he's one Mostert injury away from being really interesting in this offense
- picked up Demario Douglas last week. Almost encouraged that he wasn't completely banished by BB from the offense for this game. Another dud from Juju, hoping maybe that the opportunities pick up going forward. It looked like he had his defender beat for a long TD that Mac severely underthrew
- Jordan Mason - I dropped Chandler for Douglas. My rival picked up Chandler, dropping Mason. Interested in Mason as the CMC manager, but feel like it would ultimately be RBBC headed by Mitchell. Watch list.
The guys that I would have to cut to make the move:
- Likely - big drop, he's making it more tempting to pull the plug, but I really want to hold on with the Mark Andrews injury seal broken
- Deuce Vaughn - zero opportunities. I'm holding, but is Dowdle / Vaughn going to be an either/or?
- McLaughlin - not sure if it's wise, but I really want to hold past the point of the Broncos season being dead to see if he gets turned loose. 5 carries is progress but not sure of the context in a 70-20 game.
I play in multiple leagues re-draft and dynasty, I would venture that many posters here are playing in both, or have multiple re-draft leagues where the depth of rostered players varies widely based on league settings. I get your frustration if you're in one 12-team re-draft league that you care about that's 1QB and has "normal" roster sizes. O'Connell, Tillman, Douglas, Likely, Vaughn, McLaughlin aren't going to factor in to your week 4 waiver decisions. If a moderator gives direction not to post dynasty week 4 pickups in this thread, I will happily comply. However, I kind of doubt they're going to attempt to patrol that since making this a re-draft only thread is still going to leave an array of posters with different league sizes and settings that will still result in waiver wire options that are quite varied with player discussions not immediately applicable to every re-draft league.
Achane and Atwell aren't available in any of my re-draft leagues. I get that they are in some and how much faab to spend on them is going to be a pressing decision that some people are deliberating tonight. Not a big deal for me to skim through. Also, there's some shred of information that I can take away from such discussion even if these players already belong to other rosters in my league. Likewise, you might find that week 4 dynasty waiver discussions that don't apply to your league in week 4, might suddenly yield a hot button name that you're able to action in week 8 re-draft after breaking injury news. Making yourself familiar with names down the depth chart that are being discussed in dynasty waivers weeks ahead can only make you a stronger re-draft player in your very competitive 12-team redraft league. Or you can just skim past to the next post that applies to your team in week 4. I'm pretty sure that this thread isn't getting to 37 pages.