Week 8's coach approval ratings (1 Viewer)

[chris1969]

http://sports.espn.go.com/nfl/sportsnation/ratings990

Not what I was expecting at all from the fans. Romeo tops the list and look at BB's ranking?

 

[ThePittbully]

People love when coaches get bad teams to win. And NO ONE thought the Browns would be where they are right now with the schedule they play. And thats the same reason Marenelli is so high. And Belichick....people love to hate the Pats, what else can I say? Not to mention the guy has no charisma what so ever. An watching an interview with Bill Belichick is like watching paint dry.

 

[Max Power]

Wow Tomlin (45%) and McCarthy(0%) are way too low.

 

[mad sweeney]

It seems that this is supposed to be fans ranking their own team's coach, that's what I got out of the into paragraph at least. So it depends on who's rating who. Using the BB rating, I'd guess it was the team's fans doing the ratings, since it would probably be lower if it were everyone rating him. And if it is hometown fans doing the rating, a 73 for BB is pretty low for a guy coaching the team of the century. Maybe the non FBG Pat fans don't like seeing Brady out there at 31-0.

I have no idea why Tomlin would be so low, unless it's a bunch of running game purists who don't like seeing long bombs to Ward and Holmes unless ARE is throwing them.

 

[stevegamer]

I doubt Belichick is homers only - he's got a TON of votes, of course, looking at week 1 he had a ton then, and he's up from 52% then. Look at his trend line - looks like the Redskins game pissed off some people.

Next: Packers, Bengals, 49ers got a total of 0 votes for the week - I bet there's a glitch with them.

EDIT: Those teams are now fixed.

 

[Max Power]

I think polls like this lose credibility when any fan can say yah or nay on any coach. People will give bad grades out of spite and If you cant watch the games, you shouldnt be allowed to grade the coach.

 

[The Shizzle]

I'd love to see the zip codes where the votes are from.

 

[twitch]

When a coach like Tony Dungy doesnt have atleast a 95% approval rating, I stop taking it seriously. That poll is worthless.

 

[sdsjr3]

Wow Tomlin (45%) and McCarthy(0%) are way too low.

Exactly! What the heck is up with that? Both are doing fantastic. This thing's bogus IMO.

 

[JP]

Sean Payton and Wisenhunt, both at 3-4, are 3rd and 4th overall. That is ridiculous! Why is McCarthy, at 6-1, at 0% rating. He is listed behind Linehan 0-8 and Cameron 0-8. These ratings are so ridiculous I feel silly posting in this thread. I agree with post #5 that there must be a glitch.

 

[fatness]

Joe Gibbs --- 39%

I can believe that.

 

[chris1969]

I don't think that these can be accurate, the list is just way too screwed up.