What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

What is the worst dynasty trade you have been offered? (3 Viewers)

Birdie048 said:
smbkrypt24 said:
Couldn’t find this thread so appreciate the bump:

Give: 1.03, 1.10, Metchie, Fant
Receive: Mac Jones, K. Pickett, 2.11

1 QB league.
Click to expand...
What medication were they on at the time this offer was proposed? They might want to check the dosage again cause that’s just plain bad!!
I mean I can see Pickett & 2.11 for 1.10 & Metchie but the 1.03 has no place in this deal
Click to expand...
Really not sure. I asked them if they forgot a player to include in the deal, but never got a reply
 
smbkrypt24 said:
Birdie048 said:
smbkrypt24 said:
Couldn’t find this thread so appreciate the bump:

Give: 1.03, 1.10, Metchie, Fant
Receive: Mac Jones, K. Pickett, 2.11

1 QB league.
Click to expand...
What medication were they on at the time this offer was proposed? They might want to check the dosage again cause that’s just plain bad!!
I mean I can see Pickett & 2.11 for 1.10 & Metchie but the 1.03 has no place in this deal
Click to expand...
Really not sure. I asked them if they forgot a player to include in the deal, but never got a reply
Click to expand...
I love that response. Subtle. I'm totally gonna use that line. :lol:
 
Hot Sauce Guy said:
smbkrypt24 said:
Birdie048 said:
smbkrypt24 said:
Couldn’t find this thread so appreciate the bump:

Give: 1.03, 1.10, Metchie, Fant
Receive: Mac Jones, K. Pickett, 2.11

1 QB league.
Click to expand...
What medication were they on at the time this offer was proposed? They might want to check the dosage again cause that’s just plain bad!!
I mean I can see Pickett & 2.11 for 1.10 & Metchie but the 1.03 has no place in this deal
Click to expand...
Really not sure. I asked them if they forgot a player to include in the deal, but never got a reply
Click to expand...
I love that response. Subtle. I'm totally gonna use that line. :lol:
Click to expand...
Agreed. I was gonna reply exactly the same thing :laugh: great line!
 
wlwiles said:
Me talking to a leaguemate: anybody you're looking to maybe flip for a pick? Looks like you'll have some tough cuts to make...
Him: yeah I'd love to sell Mixon, I can't seem to give him away...
Me: Oh cool, I'd be interested in him for the right price. I've got a bit of WR depth and it looks like you could use some there. How about my 2.04 plus another player? take a look at my roster and...
Him: Oh dude hell no, I turned down the 1.06 for him last year so no way I could sell him for less than that now.
Me: :blankstare as I realize I fell in the trap again:
Click to expand...
So which of the bold is correct? It can't be both....hahaha

You either can't give him away or you won't take a 1.06. Opposite ends of the spectrum. hahaha
 
Gally said:
wlwiles said:
Me talking to a leaguemate: anybody you're looking to maybe flip for a pick? Looks like you'll have some tough cuts to make...
Him: yeah I'd love to sell Mixon, I can't seem to give him away...
Me: Oh cool, I'd be interested in him for the right price. I've got a bit of WR depth and it looks like you could use some there. How about my 2.04 plus another player? take a look at my roster and...
Him: Oh dude hell no, I turned down the 1.06 for him last year so no way I could sell him for less than that now.
Me: :blankstare as I realize I fell in the trap again:
Click to expand...
So which of the bold is correct? It can't be both....hahaha

You either can't give him away or you won't take a 1.06. Opposite ends of the spectrum. hahaha
Click to expand...
hence my "you gotta be kidding me" stare at the end of the conversation. "Can't give him away" = "can't find anyone stupid enough to overpay" apparently.

Reason #147 why I laugh inside everytime someone says "just flip Player X for _____" or "I'll deal Player X later on" like it's just sooooooo easy to make a trade happen, there's too many people like the above that make trading nearly impossible!
 
wlwiles said:
Reason #147 why I laugh inside everytime someone says "just flip Player X for _____" or "I'll deal Player X later on" like it's just sooooooo easy to make a trade happen, there's too many people like the above that make trading nearly impossible!
Click to expand...
Reason #204 is that anytime you inquire about a player their "value" goes up infinitely because someone now wants that guy.........even though the owner with him was going to drop him at the next waiver run anyway.
 
Gally said:
wlwiles said:
Reason #147 why I laugh inside everytime someone says "just flip Player X for _____" or "I'll deal Player X later on" like it's just sooooooo easy to make a trade happen, there's too many people like the above that make trading nearly impossible!
Click to expand...
Reason #204 is that anytime you inquire about a player their "value" goes up infinitely because someone now wants that guy.........even though the owner with him was going to drop him at the next waiver run anyway.
Click to expand...
Reminds me of how any high school football recruit automatically gains an extra star in their rating once they land on Alabama's target list. If Saban's after them then we must have them rated too low!
 
FFPC 1qb, guy just bought the team and sees I need a qb. Not the worst, but dude.........

I give - 1.5, 5.12, 24 2nd
I get - Tua, 3.6, 6.6, 24 4th
 
smbkrypt24 said:
12 team PPR, 1 QB.

Give: J. Jefferson, 1.02, D. Watons, J. Goff
Receive: Mahommes, Stevenson, Purdy
Click to expand...

Is that the same guy who offered you the other awful trade, or are you in a league filled with guys making offers like this? would drive me nuts
 
Willy said:
smbkrypt24 said:
12 team PPR, 1 QB.

Give: J. Jefferson, 1.02, D. Watons, J. Goff
Receive: Mahommes, Stevenson, Purdy
Click to expand...

Is that the same guy who offered you the other awful trade, or are you in a league filled with guys making offers like this? would drive me nuts
Click to expand...
Haha had to scroll to see what I posted earlier. That is 2 different teams in the same league. This most recent one he does every year all year. The older one is first terrible offer from him so I’m giving him a pass
 
I have a few - 16 team SF PPR IDP

Before dealing my 2024 1st for Bateman, and my 2024 2nd 3rd for Mayfield I let it be known I was shopping them for a QB/WR, and then for a QB, respectively.

Offer 1
I give: 2024 1st
I get: Nelson Agholor + KJO
🤢

Offer 2
I give: 2024 1st
I get: Slayton + Agholor

Offer 3
I give 2024 1st
I get: Agholor + Metchie

Offer 4:
I give 2024 1st
I get: Agholor + Renfrow

Offer 5
I give 2024 1st + 2024 2nd
I get: Juju Smith-Schuster (before he signed with NEP, not that it matters)

Offer 6
I give 2024 1st
I get: Amari Cooper

Offer 7
I give: 2024 1st
I get: Tyler Lockett

And my favorite:
I give: Justin Fields,
I get: Tua, Mayfield, Kyle Hamilton
(I have 4 solid safeties already and also HELL no)

These were all mindbogglingly terrible.

That said, the I messaged the dude trying to get Fields and basically told him he was untouchable save for a godfather offer, but I respect the attempt. We struck up a convo and one thing led to another and he dealt me Mayfield for the 2nd/3rd.

The Bateman offer came over as Bateman + 1.07 for Mims, Jordan Davis + 2023 1.01

The 1.01 was a non-starter, but again, while awful, I countered with 2024 1st for Bateman + 2023 3.14, and he countered with Bateman for the ‘24 1st.

So yeah - thanking people for their bad offers and keeping the discussion alive led to 2 pretty solid and needed trades.

But that whole list is laughably bad.
 
Hot Sauce Guy said:
I have a few - 16 team SF PPR IDP

Before dealing my 2024 1st for Bateman, and my 2024 2nd 3rd for Mayfield I let it be known I was shopping them for a QB/WR, and then for a QB, respectively.

Offer 1
I give: 2024 1st
I get: Nelson Agholor + KJO
🤢

Offer 2
I give: 2024 1st
I get: Slayton + Agholor

Offer 3
I give 2024 1st
I get: Agholor + Metchie

Offer 4:
I give 2024 1st
I get: Agholor + Renfrow

Offer 5
I give 2024 1st + 2024 2nd
I get: Juju Smith-Schuster (before he signed with NEP, not that it matters)

Offer 6
I give 2024 1st
I get: Amari Cooper

Offer 7
I give: 2024 1st
I get: Tyler Lockett

And my favorite:
I give: Justin Fields,
I get: Tua, Mayfield, Kyle Hamilton
(I have 4 solid safeties already and also HELL no)

These were all mindbogglingly terrible.

That said, the I messaged the dude trying to get Fields and basically told him he was untouchable save for a godfather offer, but I respect the attempt. We struck up a convo and one thing led to another and he dealt me Mayfield for the 2nd/3rd.

The Bateman offer came over as Bateman + 1.07 for Mims, Jordan Davis + 2023 1.01

The 1.01 was a non-starter, but again, while awful, I countered with 2024 1st for Bateman + 2023 3.14, and he countered with Bateman for the ‘24 1st.

So yeah - thanking people for their bad offers and keeping the discussion alive led to 2 pretty solid and needed trades.

But that whole list is laughably bad.
Click to expand...
No trades with the Agholor manager? Lol. The fact that he thinks Agholor has value (or he thinks you think Agholor has value) is a strong tell that further discussions would be pointless.
 
zaner75 said:
No trades with the Agholor manager? Lol. The fact that he thinks Agholor has value (or he thinks you think Agholor has value) is a strong tell that further discussions would be pointless.
Click to expand...
I opened every one of those offers like “what the…” “**** no”…”oh come on!”
 
Hot Sauce Guy said:
Offer 6
I give 2024 1st
I get: Amari Cooper
Click to expand...

ghostguy123 said:
What's wrong with offer #6?
Click to expand...

I got essentially this offer in an FFPC superflex. (I give my '24 1st for his Cooper, '24 3rd, '24 4th.) I don't know that I would say it's the worst trade I've been offered, but it was pretty much an instant reject for me. Maybe if you have a competing team that needs a starting WR (mine needs more than that to be competitive), it's a consideration. But I don't think he's worth a superflex 1st.
 
phandango said:
I got essentially this offer in an FFPC superflex. (I give my '24 1st for his Cooper, '24 3rd, '24 4th.) I don't know that I would say it's the worst trade I've been offered, but it was pretty much an instant reject for me. Maybe if you have a competing team that needs a starting WR (mine needs more than that to be competitive), it's a consideration. But I don't think he's worth a superflex 1st.
Click to expand...
Agree - it’s not the worst offer. Just a bad offer on a long list of worse ones. And older than I was seeking (I saw it as slightly less bad than the Lockett offer from the same dude)
 
If the completed trades thread had a deal where Cooper was moved for a future 1st, there would be people on both sides of it.
Unless of course the future 1st is predicted to be very high.

I have one league where I'd pay a future 1st for Cooper, but zero chance that guy moves Cooper for a projected playoff 2024 1st.
And as I've said before, every trade you turn down is the same as making the same trade in reverse.
Hence, that owner clearly prefers Cooper to the 2024 1st.
 
ghostguy123 said:
If the completed trades thread had a deal where Cooper was moved for a future 1st, there would be people on both sides of it.
Unless of course the future 1st is predicted to be very high.

I have one league where I'd pay a future 1st for Cooper, but zero chance that guy moves Cooper for a projected playoff 2024 1st.
And as I've said before, every trade you turn down is the same as making the same trade in reverse.
Hence, that owner clearly prefers Cooper to the 2024 1st.
Click to expand...
Personally Cooper leaves a bad dynasty taste in my mouth. Each to their own.
 
ghostguy123 said:
1 QB league.

I give 1.04, 1.09, and 2.09
I get Jalen Hurts

I've made it clear I am in 100% full rebuild, and am looking to trade my players for picks. Hence, awful.
Click to expand...
You should have countered 1.09 and 2.9 for Hurts, then either trade Hurts for a future 1st+ or another young asset. Probably better than what you will get at 1.9 and 2.9.
 
joey said:
eighsse2 said:
JohnnyU said:
Hot Sauce Guy said:
JohnnyU said:
Hot Sauce Guy said:
This one’s gotta be close:

16-team PPR SF TE-P IDP

I get: Pickens, Njoku, 1.14
I give: 1.01

I-
Click to expand...
1.01
Click to expand...
Ya think? 😂
Click to expand...
I forgot this was the worst offer thread. I thought it was the trade thread
Click to expand...
😂 I did that a while back.
Click to expand...
What are you guys talking about?!?! That’s a free Njoku!!!
Click to expand...
I didn’t know he was imprisoned. 🤔
 
Hot Sauce Guy said:
joey said:
eighsse2 said:
JohnnyU said:
Hot Sauce Guy said:
JohnnyU said:
Hot Sauce Guy said:
This one’s gotta be close:

16-team PPR SF TE-P IDP

I get: Pickens, Njoku, 1.14
I give: 1.01

I-
Click to expand...
1.01
Click to expand...
Ya think? 😂
Click to expand...
I forgot this was the worst offer thread. I thought it was the trade thread
Click to expand...
😂 I did that a while back.
Click to expand...
What are you guys talking about?!?! That’s a free Njoku!!!
Click to expand...
I didn’t know he was imprisoned. 🤔
Click to expand...
I thought the mistake by the lake was a prison.
 
JohnnyU said:
ghostguy123 said:
JohnnyU said:
ghostguy123 said:
What's wrong with offer #6?
Click to expand...
Rode hard and put out wet soon to be geezer as far as a dynasty asset?
Click to expand...
Top 10 WR with a good QB for a while. He's 28.
Not a worst offer candidate
Click to expand...
I agree not a worst offer candidate. I think this thread has gotten lax with posts claiming worst offers.
Click to expand...
This thread has become a place for people that love to talk about their teams - getting “not so great” offers and posting them here.
Some of the offers in here aren’t even all that bad really.
 
ghostguy123 said:
If the completed trades thread had a deal where Cooper was moved for a future 1st, there would be people on both sides of it.
Unless of course the future 1st is predicted to be very high.

I have one league where I'd pay a future 1st for Cooper, but zero chance that guy moves Cooper for a projected playoff 2024 1st.
And as I've said before, every trade you turn down is the same as making the same trade in reverse.
Hence, that owner clearly prefers Cooper to the 2024 1st.
Click to expand...
The other owner clearly prefers the 2024 1st to Cooper
 
Dr. Octopus said:
This thread has become a place for people that love to talk about their teams - getting “not so great” offers and posting them here.
Some of the offers in here aren’t even all that bad really.
Click to expand...
The title of the thread leaves little room for people to participate if strictly followed. By definition, everyone should only have one submission, however, many people get many bad offers. Having people post offers they think are bad and see opinions counter to theirs can be constructive to help shape valuations. To only have a thread where everyone agrees is just an echo chamber where people can then feel a (false) sense of superiority about their knowledgeability over others.
I guess if someone doesn't like it, they can choose to not read/participate.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

Ministry of Pain
New Dynasty League and we've had our first trade where people are asking questions
2
Replies
79
Views
795
JohnnyU
JohnnyU
ignatiusjreilly
Have I been starting the wrong BRobinson?
Replies
4
Views
518
ignatiusjreilly
ignatiusjreilly
Terpman22
Do you play fantasy football with your spouse?
Replies
27
Views
584
Saint
Saint

Users who are viewing this thread

Total: 1 (members: 0, guests: 1)
Back
Top