You know, this whole "write about why it's eligible" thing just isn't going to work for me. Two of three lists so far haven't included the information, and I don't like hassling people for it. Also, it's just too complicated for me to look up everyone's picks yet again. Say you have Tool on your list - some are eligible, some are not, and I don't feel like wading through to prove the negative that they're weren't eligible the first two times.
EXECUTIVE DECISION: Vet your own lists carefully, and I am not nixing anything unless it's obvious to me. We'll call that The Sixpence None The Richer rule. If some dork wants to object to your pick when it's posted in the countdown, then we can deal with it at that time. I'll just delete your pick from the list then, with no replacement to be made.