WR Malik Nabers, NYG (1 Viewer)

[dkp993]

Might have been dumb of me but Nabers was falling in our draft and I still took Drake London over him. I'm just going to trust my gut on this but it was likely a very very stupid move by me and half my league mates to pass on him.

I don't think it was stupid. Guys are in the same zip code value wise. Sure, straight up id take Nabers, but I can see the conversation the other way around. Worst thing about this is your gonna box score comparing the two all season and kicking yourself every week Nabers does better. Ha ha

LOL yep that is so true. And it will probably be a roller coaster ride back and forth as the season goes on where I feel very right and very wrong about my pick depending on the week.

Drake has a better offense and QB, Nabers already has a naggin jury

Awww jeez thanks you guys sure know how to cheer me up

Massive mistake. Wrong move and you’re going to regret it for the rest of your life. Are you sure you’ve ever played fantasy football before?




*all this positivity and support felt dirty. This is the internet after all.

 

[Ministry of Pain]

Redraft '25- He's being drafted at the very top end and I don't understand why he isn't dinged a bit for the Giants, Russ, possible lame duck coach, spotty talent around him
There's safer people to put on your roster, availability should also count. He started 13 games as a rookie, I can do the math based on what he produced but I also think teams will account for him more than any other player on that offense which is going to inhibit his ability to be wide open all the time.

This is a 1st round pick that feels like pure gambling and wanting to try and catch the folks who already took JJ and Chase.
High risk, possible high reward but no sure thing. I respect hose who do decide to take him, I just think you might be in here on Sundays complaining more often than you think
Good Luck!

Pretty much everything you say was true last year, or worse, and he still put up numbers. You don't think teams accounted for him last year?

And QB situation was far worse. Russ can still throw the deep ball and knows his only shot is through Nabers. But let’s say he’s washed. Then it’s Jameis.

To both of you that read my post, "I respect those who do decide to take him"
He just won't be on my team at this price.

I don't think anyone is arguing with your decision to have him on your DND list at his current price, anyone can respect that decision, they're just saying your arguments for doing so are flawed. Reverting to "I won't draft him at this price" instead of addressing your flawed arguments is weak sauce.

You say others in his range are safer, I say who? There are real arguments against anyone at this level in the draft, and even the guys who are "can't miss" above MN can easily miss based on a variety of factors.

Hey Jacob, thanks for taking the time to post back
Maybe you're right, maybe I do have a blind spot

170 targets last year, just seems super high for an 11 yds per catch rate
I understand and again respect that others are excited to get him after the big names come off the board
Maybe Nabers is a big name as well, I want to see Year 2 before i go and commit a 1st round pick on him

If his ADP is 12th overall which I just looked it up, not sure how accurate that is, i thought he was going 7th/8th overall
In a 10-team redraft i can see pairing him with another high expectation WR on the turn to try and have an explosive 1-2 punch
I'm not excited about Russ in New York, others seem to think he will do rather well there

I watched most of his games. The numbers are deceiving. The quality of his targets was putrid. His talent jumped off the page at me and any of the 3 QBs currently on the roster are a huge upgrade compared to what he had to play with last year. I doubt he'll see so many targets again, but I'd be willing to bet my left arm his yards per catch will increase dramatically. If you watch the tape, he wins and he wins big on most every route. If he had a competent QB last year, his numbers would look more like Justin Jefferson's rookie year. He's that good, maybe better. We're just scratching the surface with him.

Now, what I will say about him which is my only real red flag. Watching him so closely, he always seemed to be nicked. Between games nursing injuries, questionable tags, looking dinged getting up play after play, whatever. That worries me a bit but I remember another receiver I felt the exact same about for many years until I finally admitted defeat - Mike Evans.

Nabers WAS the offense last year. He was the focus of every D. He beat every coverage, and he beat it bad. He was open in ways that made bad QBs pull the trigger. No small windows. Massive picture windows to throw through. His talent is undeniable. He has the potential to be the #1 WR in the league for the next 5 seasons. I feel this way about very few guys in the NFL. No one in this range is "safe," so give me upside all day every day. Chase, JJ, Nabers, Nico, BTJ and maybe CeeDee.

The way you're talking about Nabers is the way I talk about guys like MHjr, Odunze, Pearsall, etc. These guys need to prove it. Nabers has proven it.

I want to thank Jacob, this was an outstanding post and it has made me rethink Nabers and ALL 2nd Year WRs like Harrison, Coleman, etc...
Yeah why wouldn't Nabers be even better Year 2? He couldn't have peaked his rookie season

And i believe you did watch a lot of him. I post at least 3-4x a year the best thing you can do to evaluate a player is watch them
I didn't watch that many Giants games last year and a lot of you didn't either but Jacob did and I believe him

The eyeball test in actual games, there is no substitute for it
Luckily here in the SP we have fans and posters from just about ALL 32 teams

I might have an opportunity to take him tonight in a redraft, could come down to him or Derrick Henry in the 1st for me, I'm seriously considering taking the plunge
Jax Dart might be the back up which I think would be great in case something fails with Russ. Dart's camp and some of his preseason might be the best news to come out of NY in a while

Thanks JL for taking the time

 

[rockaction]

Redraft '25- He's being drafted at the very top end and I don't understand why he isn't dinged a bit for the Giants, Russ, possible lame duck coach, spotty talent around him
There's safer people to put on your roster, availability should also count. He started 13 games as a rookie, I can do the math based on what he produced but I also think teams will account for him more than any other player on that offense which is going to inhibit his ability to be wide open all the time.

This is a 1st round pick that feels like pure gambling and wanting to try and catch the folks who already took JJ and Chase.
High risk, possible high reward but no sure thing. I respect hose who do decide to take him, I just think you might be in here on Sundays complaining more often than you think
Good Luck!

Pretty much everything you say was true last year, or worse, and he still put up numbers. You don't think teams accounted for him last year?

And QB situation was far worse. Russ can still throw the deep ball and knows his only shot is through Nabers. But let’s say he’s washed. Then it’s Jameis.

To both of you that read my post, "I respect those who do decide to take him"
He just won't be on my team at this price.

I don't think anyone is arguing with your decision to have him on your DND list at his current price, anyone can respect that decision, they're just saying your arguments for doing so are flawed. Reverting to "I won't draft him at this price" instead of addressing your flawed arguments is weak sauce.

You say others in his range are safer, I say who? There are real arguments against anyone at this level in the draft, and even the guys who are "can't miss" above MN can easily miss based on a variety of factors.

Hey Jacob, thanks for taking the time to post back
Maybe you're right, maybe I do have a blind spot

170 targets last year, just seems super high for an 11 yds per catch rate
I understand and again respect that others are excited to get him after the big names come off the board
Maybe Nabers is a big name as well, I want to see Year 2 before i go and commit a 1st round pick on him

If his ADP is 12th overall which I just looked it up, not sure how accurate that is, i thought he was going 7th/8th overall
In a 10-team redraft i can see pairing him with another high expectation WR on the turn to try and have an explosive 1-2 punch
I'm not excited about Russ in New York, others seem to think he will do rather well there

I watched most of his games. The numbers are deceiving. The quality of his targets was putrid. His talent jumped off the page at me and any of the 3 QBs currently on the roster are a huge upgrade compared to what he had to play with last year. I doubt he'll see so many targets again, but I'd be willing to bet my left arm his yards per catch will increase dramatically. If you watch the tape, he wins and he wins big on most every route. If he had a competent QB last year, his numbers would look more like Justin Jefferson's rookie year. He's that good, maybe better. We're just scratching the surface with him.

Now, what I will say about him which is my only real red flag. Watching him so closely, he always seemed to be nicked. Between games nursing injuries, questionable tags, looking dinged getting up play after play, whatever. That worries me a bit but I remember another receiver I felt the exact same about for many years until I finally admitted defeat - Mike Evans.

Nabers WAS the offense last year. He was the focus of every D. He beat every coverage, and he beat it bad. He was open in ways that made bad QBs pull the trigger. No small windows. Massive picture windows to throw through. His talent is undeniable. He has the potential to be the #1 WR in the league for the next 5 seasons. I feel this way about very few guys in the NFL. No one in this range is "safe," so give me upside all day every day. Chase, JJ, Nabers, Nico, BTJ and maybe CeeDee.

The way you're talking about Nabers is the way I talk about guys like MHjr, Odunze, Pearsall, etc. These guys need to prove it. Nabers has proven it.

I want to thank Jacob, this was an outstanding post and it has made me rethink Nabers and ALL 2nd Year WRs like Harrison, Coleman, etc...
Yeah why wouldn't Nabers be even better Year 2? He couldn't have peaked his rookie season

And i believe you did watch a lot of him. I post at least 3-4x a year the best thing you can do to evaluate a player is watch them
I didn't watch that many Giants games last year and a lot of you didn't either but Jacob did and I believe him

The eyeball test in actual games, there is no substitute for it
Luckily here in the SP we have fans and posters from just about ALL 32 teams

I might have an opportunity to take him tonight in a redraft, could come down to him or Derrick Henry in the 1st for me, I'm seriously considering taking the plunge
Jax Dart might be the back up which I think would be great in case something fails with Russ. Dart's camp and some of his preseason might be the best news to come out of NY in a while

Thanks JL for taking the time

Dude, you’re taking a guy that considered surgery on his toe (likely turf toe). In the first round. There’s a reason he wound up on FBGs list of guys you’re glad other people drafted. Oof.

JL could be closer to God as far as vision goes, but ain’t nothing healing that toe. And I roster him in dynasty so I pay attention. This has no good written all over it.

 

[dkp993]

Redraft '25- He's being drafted at the very top end and I don't understand why he isn't dinged a bit for the Giants, Russ, possible lame duck coach, spotty talent around him
There's safer people to put on your roster, availability should also count. He started 13 games as a rookie, I can do the math based on what he produced but I also think teams will account for him more than any other player on that offense which is going to inhibit his ability to be wide open all the time.

This is a 1st round pick that feels like pure gambling and wanting to try and catch the folks who already took JJ and Chase.
High risk, possible high reward but no sure thing. I respect hose who do decide to take him, I just think you might be in here on Sundays complaining more often than you think
Good Luck!

Pretty much everything you say was true last year, or worse, and he still put up numbers. You don't think teams accounted for him last year?

And QB situation was far worse. Russ can still throw the deep ball and knows his only shot is through Nabers. But let’s say he’s washed. Then it’s Jameis.

To both of you that read my post, "I respect those who do decide to take him"
He just won't be on my team at this price.

I don't think anyone is arguing with your decision to have him on your DND list at his current price, anyone can respect that decision, they're just saying your arguments for doing so are flawed. Reverting to "I won't draft him at this price" instead of addressing your flawed arguments is weak sauce.

You say others in his range are safer, I say who? There are real arguments against anyone at this level in the draft, and even the guys who are "can't miss" above MN can easily miss based on a variety of factors.

Hey Jacob, thanks for taking the time to post back
Maybe you're right, maybe I do have a blind spot

170 targets last year, just seems super high for an 11 yds per catch rate
I understand and again respect that others are excited to get him after the big names come off the board
Maybe Nabers is a big name as well, I want to see Year 2 before i go and commit a 1st round pick on him

If his ADP is 12th overall which I just looked it up, not sure how accurate that is, i thought he was going 7th/8th overall
In a 10-team redraft i can see pairing him with another high expectation WR on the turn to try and have an explosive 1-2 punch
I'm not excited about Russ in New York, others seem to think he will do rather well there

I watched most of his games. The numbers are deceiving. The quality of his targets was putrid. His talent jumped off the page at me and any of the 3 QBs currently on the roster are a huge upgrade compared to what he had to play with last year. I doubt he'll see so many targets again, but I'd be willing to bet my left arm his yards per catch will increase dramatically. If you watch the tape, he wins and he wins big on most every route. If he had a competent QB last year, his numbers would look more like Justin Jefferson's rookie year. He's that good, maybe better. We're just scratching the surface with him.

Now, what I will say about him which is my only real red flag. Watching him so closely, he always seemed to be nicked. Between games nursing injuries, questionable tags, looking dinged getting up play after play, whatever. That worries me a bit but I remember another receiver I felt the exact same about for many years until I finally admitted defeat - Mike Evans.

Nabers WAS the offense last year. He was the focus of every D. He beat every coverage, and he beat it bad. He was open in ways that made bad QBs pull the trigger. No small windows. Massive picture windows to throw through. His talent is undeniable. He has the potential to be the #1 WR in the league for the next 5 seasons. I feel this way about very few guys in the NFL. No one in this range is "safe," so give me upside all day every day. Chase, JJ, Nabers, Nico, BTJ and maybe CeeDee.

The way you're talking about Nabers is the way I talk about guys like MHjr, Odunze, Pearsall, etc. These guys need to prove it. Nabers has proven it.

I want to thank Jacob, this was an outstanding post and it has made me rethink Nabers and ALL 2nd Year WRs like Harrison, Coleman, etc...
Yeah why wouldn't Nabers be even better Year 2? He couldn't have peaked his rookie season

And i believe you did watch a lot of him. I post at least 3-4x a year the best thing you can do to evaluate a player is watch them
I didn't watch that many Giants games last year and a lot of you didn't either but Jacob did and I believe him

The eyeball test in actual games, there is no substitute for it
Luckily here in the SP we have fans and posters from just about ALL 32 teams

I might have an opportunity to take him tonight in a redraft, could come down to him or Derrick Henry in the 1st for me, I'm seriously considering taking the plunge
Jax Dart might be the back up which I think would be great in case something fails with Russ. Dart's camp and some of his preseason might be the best news to come out of NY in a while

Thanks JL for taking the time

Dude, you’re taking a guy that considered surgery on his toe (likely turf toe). In the first round. There’s a reason he wound up on FBGs list of guys you’re glad other people drafted. Oof.

JL could be closer to God as far as vision goes, but ain’t nothing healing that toe. And I roster him in dynasty so I pay attention. This has no good written all over it.

He’s had the toe since college, . Drafting him with confidence. Dude is a dog and looks special. Don’t see that often.

 

[rockaction]

Redraft '25- He's being drafted at the very top end and I don't understand why he isn't dinged a bit for the Giants, Russ, possible lame duck coach, spotty talent around him
There's safer people to put on your roster, availability should also count. He started 13 games as a rookie, I can do the math based on what he produced but I also think teams will account for him more than any other player on that offense which is going to inhibit his ability to be wide open all the time.

This is a 1st round pick that feels like pure gambling and wanting to try and catch the folks who already took JJ and Chase.
High risk, possible high reward but no sure thing. I respect hose who do decide to take him, I just think you might be in here on Sundays complaining more often than you think
Good Luck!

Pretty much everything you say was true last year, or worse, and he still put up numbers. You don't think teams accounted for him last year?

And QB situation was far worse. Russ can still throw the deep ball and knows his only shot is through Nabers. But let’s say he’s washed. Then it’s Jameis.

To both of you that read my post, "I respect those who do decide to take him"
He just won't be on my team at this price.

I don't think anyone is arguing with your decision to have him on your DND list at his current price, anyone can respect that decision, they're just saying your arguments for doing so are flawed. Reverting to "I won't draft him at this price" instead of addressing your flawed arguments is weak sauce.

You say others in his range are safer, I say who? There are real arguments against anyone at this level in the draft, and even the guys who are "can't miss" above MN can easily miss based on a variety of factors.

Hey Jacob, thanks for taking the time to post back
Maybe you're right, maybe I do have a blind spot

170 targets last year, just seems super high for an 11 yds per catch rate
I understand and again respect that others are excited to get him after the big names come off the board
Maybe Nabers is a big name as well, I want to see Year 2 before i go and commit a 1st round pick on him

If his ADP is 12th overall which I just looked it up, not sure how accurate that is, i thought he was going 7th/8th overall
In a 10-team redraft i can see pairing him with another high expectation WR on the turn to try and have an explosive 1-2 punch
I'm not excited about Russ in New York, others seem to think he will do rather well there

I watched most of his games. The numbers are deceiving. The quality of his targets was putrid. His talent jumped off the page at me and any of the 3 QBs currently on the roster are a huge upgrade compared to what he had to play with last year. I doubt he'll see so many targets again, but I'd be willing to bet my left arm his yards per catch will increase dramatically. If you watch the tape, he wins and he wins big on most every route. If he had a competent QB last year, his numbers would look more like Justin Jefferson's rookie year. He's that good, maybe better. We're just scratching the surface with him.

Now, what I will say about him which is my only real red flag. Watching him so closely, he always seemed to be nicked. Between games nursing injuries, questionable tags, looking dinged getting up play after play, whatever. That worries me a bit but I remember another receiver I felt the exact same about for many years until I finally admitted defeat - Mike Evans.

Nabers WAS the offense last year. He was the focus of every D. He beat every coverage, and he beat it bad. He was open in ways that made bad QBs pull the trigger. No small windows. Massive picture windows to throw through. His talent is undeniable. He has the potential to be the #1 WR in the league for the next 5 seasons. I feel this way about very few guys in the NFL. No one in this range is "safe," so give me upside all day every day. Chase, JJ, Nabers, Nico, BTJ and maybe CeeDee.

The way you're talking about Nabers is the way I talk about guys like MHjr, Odunze, Pearsall, etc. These guys need to prove it. Nabers has proven it.

I want to thank Jacob, this was an outstanding post and it has made me rethink Nabers and ALL 2nd Year WRs like Harrison, Coleman, etc...
Yeah why wouldn't Nabers be even better Year 2? He couldn't have peaked his rookie season

And i believe you did watch a lot of him. I post at least 3-4x a year the best thing you can do to evaluate a player is watch them
I didn't watch that many Giants games last year and a lot of you didn't either but Jacob did and I believe him

The eyeball test in actual games, there is no substitute for it
Luckily here in the SP we have fans and posters from just about ALL 32 teams

I might have an opportunity to take him tonight in a redraft, could come down to him or Derrick Henry in the 1st for me, I'm seriously considering taking the plunge
Jax Dart might be the back up which I think would be great in case something fails with Russ. Dart's camp and some of his preseason might be the best news to come out of NY in a while

Thanks JL for taking the time

Dude, you’re taking a guy that considered surgery on his toe (likely turf toe). In the first round. There’s a reason he wound up on FBGs list of guys you’re glad other people drafted. Oof.

JL could be closer to God as far as vision goes, but ain’t nothing healing that toe. And I roster him in dynasty so I pay attention. This has no good written all over it.

He’s had the toe since college, . Drafting him with confidence. Dude is a dog and looks special. Don’t see that often.

That toe only gets worse. These things progress. Drafting him in the first is a way you potentially get no return on your first. I personally want him to get surgery yesterday. It ruined and ended Deion’s career.

 

[dkp993]

Redraft '25- He's being drafted at the very top end and I don't understand why he isn't dinged a bit for the Giants, Russ, possible lame duck coach, spotty talent around him
There's safer people to put on your roster, availability should also count. He started 13 games as a rookie, I can do the math based on what he produced but I also think teams will account for him more than any other player on that offense which is going to inhibit his ability to be wide open all the time.

This is a 1st round pick that feels like pure gambling and wanting to try and catch the folks who already took JJ and Chase.
High risk, possible high reward but no sure thing. I respect hose who do decide to take him, I just think you might be in here on Sundays complaining more often than you think
Good Luck!

Pretty much everything you say was true last year, or worse, and he still put up numbers. You don't think teams accounted for him last year?

And QB situation was far worse. Russ can still throw the deep ball and knows his only shot is through Nabers. But let’s say he’s washed. Then it’s Jameis.

To both of you that read my post, "I respect those who do decide to take him"
He just won't be on my team at this price.

I don't think anyone is arguing with your decision to have him on your DND list at his current price, anyone can respect that decision, they're just saying your arguments for doing so are flawed. Reverting to "I won't draft him at this price" instead of addressing your flawed arguments is weak sauce.

You say others in his range are safer, I say who? There are real arguments against anyone at this level in the draft, and even the guys who are "can't miss" above MN can easily miss based on a variety of factors.

Hey Jacob, thanks for taking the time to post back
Maybe you're right, maybe I do have a blind spot

170 targets last year, just seems super high for an 11 yds per catch rate
I understand and again respect that others are excited to get him after the big names come off the board
Maybe Nabers is a big name as well, I want to see Year 2 before i go and commit a 1st round pick on him

If his ADP is 12th overall which I just looked it up, not sure how accurate that is, i thought he was going 7th/8th overall
In a 10-team redraft i can see pairing him with another high expectation WR on the turn to try and have an explosive 1-2 punch
I'm not excited about Russ in New York, others seem to think he will do rather well there

I watched most of his games. The numbers are deceiving. The quality of his targets was putrid. His talent jumped off the page at me and any of the 3 QBs currently on the roster are a huge upgrade compared to what he had to play with last year. I doubt he'll see so many targets again, but I'd be willing to bet my left arm his yards per catch will increase dramatically. If you watch the tape, he wins and he wins big on most every route. If he had a competent QB last year, his numbers would look more like Justin Jefferson's rookie year. He's that good, maybe better. We're just scratching the surface with him.

Now, what I will say about him which is my only real red flag. Watching him so closely, he always seemed to be nicked. Between games nursing injuries, questionable tags, looking dinged getting up play after play, whatever. That worries me a bit but I remember another receiver I felt the exact same about for many years until I finally admitted defeat - Mike Evans.

Nabers WAS the offense last year. He was the focus of every D. He beat every coverage, and he beat it bad. He was open in ways that made bad QBs pull the trigger. No small windows. Massive picture windows to throw through. His talent is undeniable. He has the potential to be the #1 WR in the league for the next 5 seasons. I feel this way about very few guys in the NFL. No one in this range is "safe," so give me upside all day every day. Chase, JJ, Nabers, Nico, BTJ and maybe CeeDee.

The way you're talking about Nabers is the way I talk about guys like MHjr, Odunze, Pearsall, etc. These guys need to prove it. Nabers has proven it.

I want to thank Jacob, this was an outstanding post and it has made me rethink Nabers and ALL 2nd Year WRs like Harrison, Coleman, etc...
Yeah why wouldn't Nabers be even better Year 2? He couldn't have peaked his rookie season

And i believe you did watch a lot of him. I post at least 3-4x a year the best thing you can do to evaluate a player is watch them
I didn't watch that many Giants games last year and a lot of you didn't either but Jacob did and I believe him

The eyeball test in actual games, there is no substitute for it
Luckily here in the SP we have fans and posters from just about ALL 32 teams

I might have an opportunity to take him tonight in a redraft, could come down to him or Derrick Henry in the 1st for me, I'm seriously considering taking the plunge
Jax Dart might be the back up which I think would be great in case something fails with Russ. Dart's camp and some of his preseason might be the best news to come out of NY in a while

Thanks JL for taking the time

Dude, you’re taking a guy that considered surgery on his toe (likely turf toe). In the first round. There’s a reason he wound up on FBGs list of guys you’re glad other people drafted. Oof.

JL could be closer to God as far as vision goes, but ain’t nothing healing that toe. And I roster him in dynasty so I pay attention. This has no good written all over it.

He’s had the toe since college, . Drafting him with confidence. Dude is a dog and looks special. Don’t see that often.

That toe only gets worse. These things progress. Drafting him in the first is a way you potentially get no return on your first. I personally want him to get surgery yesterday. It ruined and ended Deion’s career.

That’s just one of the reasons why this game is so fun. We all get to choose what we do. Most of us will be right quite a bit, and be internally tortured when we’re wrong. It’s OK you’re wrong this time.

 

[rockaction]

Redraft '25- He's being drafted at the very top end and I don't understand why he isn't dinged a bit for the Giants, Russ, possible lame duck coach, spotty talent around him
There's safer people to put on your roster, availability should also count. He started 13 games as a rookie, I can do the math based on what he produced but I also think teams will account for him more than any other player on that offense which is going to inhibit his ability to be wide open all the time.

This is a 1st round pick that feels like pure gambling and wanting to try and catch the folks who already took JJ and Chase.
High risk, possible high reward but no sure thing. I respect hose who do decide to take him, I just think you might be in here on Sundays complaining more often than you think
Good Luck!

Pretty much everything you say was true last year, or worse, and he still put up numbers. You don't think teams accounted for him last year?

And QB situation was far worse. Russ can still throw the deep ball and knows his only shot is through Nabers. But let’s say he’s washed. Then it’s Jameis.

To both of you that read my post, "I respect those who do decide to take him"
He just won't be on my team at this price.

I don't think anyone is arguing with your decision to have him on your DND list at his current price, anyone can respect that decision, they're just saying your arguments for doing so are flawed. Reverting to "I won't draft him at this price" instead of addressing your flawed arguments is weak sauce.

You say others in his range are safer, I say who? There are real arguments against anyone at this level in the draft, and even the guys who are "can't miss" above MN can easily miss based on a variety of factors.

Hey Jacob, thanks for taking the time to post back
Maybe you're right, maybe I do have a blind spot

170 targets last year, just seems super high for an 11 yds per catch rate
I understand and again respect that others are excited to get him after the big names come off the board
Maybe Nabers is a big name as well, I want to see Year 2 before i go and commit a 1st round pick on him

If his ADP is 12th overall which I just looked it up, not sure how accurate that is, i thought he was going 7th/8th overall
In a 10-team redraft i can see pairing him with another high expectation WR on the turn to try and have an explosive 1-2 punch
I'm not excited about Russ in New York, others seem to think he will do rather well there

I watched most of his games. The numbers are deceiving. The quality of his targets was putrid. His talent jumped off the page at me and any of the 3 QBs currently on the roster are a huge upgrade compared to what he had to play with last year. I doubt he'll see so many targets again, but I'd be willing to bet my left arm his yards per catch will increase dramatically. If you watch the tape, he wins and he wins big on most every route. If he had a competent QB last year, his numbers would look more like Justin Jefferson's rookie year. He's that good, maybe better. We're just scratching the surface with him.

Now, what I will say about him which is my only real red flag. Watching him so closely, he always seemed to be nicked. Between games nursing injuries, questionable tags, looking dinged getting up play after play, whatever. That worries me a bit but I remember another receiver I felt the exact same about for many years until I finally admitted defeat - Mike Evans.

Nabers WAS the offense last year. He was the focus of every D. He beat every coverage, and he beat it bad. He was open in ways that made bad QBs pull the trigger. No small windows. Massive picture windows to throw through. His talent is undeniable. He has the potential to be the #1 WR in the league for the next 5 seasons. I feel this way about very few guys in the NFL. No one in this range is "safe," so give me upside all day every day. Chase, JJ, Nabers, Nico, BTJ and maybe CeeDee.

The way you're talking about Nabers is the way I talk about guys like MHjr, Odunze, Pearsall, etc. These guys need to prove it. Nabers has proven it.

I want to thank Jacob, this was an outstanding post and it has made me rethink Nabers and ALL 2nd Year WRs like Harrison, Coleman, etc...
Yeah why wouldn't Nabers be even better Year 2? He couldn't have peaked his rookie season

And i believe you did watch a lot of him. I post at least 3-4x a year the best thing you can do to evaluate a player is watch them
I didn't watch that many Giants games last year and a lot of you didn't either but Jacob did and I believe him

The eyeball test in actual games, there is no substitute for it
Luckily here in the SP we have fans and posters from just about ALL 32 teams

I might have an opportunity to take him tonight in a redraft, could come down to him or Derrick Henry in the 1st for me, I'm seriously considering taking the plunge
Jax Dart might be the back up which I think would be great in case something fails with Russ. Dart's camp and some of his preseason might be the best news to come out of NY in a while

Thanks JL for taking the time

Dude, you’re taking a guy that considered surgery on his toe (likely turf toe). In the first round. There’s a reason he wound up on FBGs list of guys you’re glad other people drafted. Oof.

JL could be closer to God as far as vision goes, but ain’t nothing healing that toe. And I roster him in dynasty so I pay attention. This has no good written all over it.

He’s had the toe since college, . Drafting him with confidence. Dude is a dog and looks special. Don’t see that often.

That toe only gets worse. These things progress. Drafting him in the first is a way you potentially get no return on your first. I personally want him to get surgery yesterday. It ruined and ended Deion’s career.

That’s just one of the reasons why this game is so fun. We all get to choose what we do. Most of us will be right quite a bit, and be internally tortured when we’re wrong. It’s OK you’re wrong this time.

.04

 

[Jacob's Ladder]

Redraft '25- He's being drafted at the very top end and I don't understand why he isn't dinged a bit for the Giants, Russ, possible lame duck coach, spotty talent around him
There's safer people to put on your roster, availability should also count. He started 13 games as a rookie, I can do the math based on what he produced but I also think teams will account for him more than any other player on that offense which is going to inhibit his ability to be wide open all the time.

This is a 1st round pick that feels like pure gambling and wanting to try and catch the folks who already took JJ and Chase.
High risk, possible high reward but no sure thing. I respect hose who do decide to take him, I just think you might be in here on Sundays complaining more often than you think
Good Luck!

Pretty much everything you say was true last year, or worse, and he still put up numbers. You don't think teams accounted for him last year?

And QB situation was far worse. Russ can still throw the deep ball and knows his only shot is through Nabers. But let’s say he’s washed. Then it’s Jameis.

To both of you that read my post, "I respect those who do decide to take him"
He just won't be on my team at this price.

I don't think anyone is arguing with your decision to have him on your DND list at his current price, anyone can respect that decision, they're just saying your arguments for doing so are flawed. Reverting to "I won't draft him at this price" instead of addressing your flawed arguments is weak sauce.

You say others in his range are safer, I say who? There are real arguments against anyone at this level in the draft, and even the guys who are "can't miss" above MN can easily miss based on a variety of factors.

Hey Jacob, thanks for taking the time to post back
Maybe you're right, maybe I do have a blind spot

170 targets last year, just seems super high for an 11 yds per catch rate
I understand and again respect that others are excited to get him after the big names come off the board
Maybe Nabers is a big name as well, I want to see Year 2 before i go and commit a 1st round pick on him

If his ADP is 12th overall which I just looked it up, not sure how accurate that is, i thought he was going 7th/8th overall
In a 10-team redraft i can see pairing him with another high expectation WR on the turn to try and have an explosive 1-2 punch
I'm not excited about Russ in New York, others seem to think he will do rather well there

I watched most of his games. The numbers are deceiving. The quality of his targets was putrid. His talent jumped off the page at me and any of the 3 QBs currently on the roster are a huge upgrade compared to what he had to play with last year. I doubt he'll see so many targets again, but I'd be willing to bet my left arm his yards per catch will increase dramatically. If you watch the tape, he wins and he wins big on most every route. If he had a competent QB last year, his numbers would look more like Justin Jefferson's rookie year. He's that good, maybe better. We're just scratching the surface with him.

Now, what I will say about him which is my only real red flag. Watching him so closely, he always seemed to be nicked. Between games nursing injuries, questionable tags, looking dinged getting up play after play, whatever. That worries me a bit but I remember another receiver I felt the exact same about for many years until I finally admitted defeat - Mike Evans.

Nabers WAS the offense last year. He was the focus of every D. He beat every coverage, and he beat it bad. He was open in ways that made bad QBs pull the trigger. No small windows. Massive picture windows to throw through. His talent is undeniable. He has the potential to be the #1 WR in the league for the next 5 seasons. I feel this way about very few guys in the NFL. No one in this range is "safe," so give me upside all day every day. Chase, JJ, Nabers, Nico, BTJ and maybe CeeDee.

The way you're talking about Nabers is the way I talk about guys like MHjr, Odunze, Pearsall, etc. These guys need to prove it. Nabers has proven it.

I want to thank Jacob, this was an outstanding post and it has made me rethink Nabers and ALL 2nd Year WRs like Harrison, Coleman, etc...
Yeah why wouldn't Nabers be even better Year 2? He couldn't have peaked his rookie season

And i believe you did watch a lot of him. I post at least 3-4x a year the best thing you can do to evaluate a player is watch them
I didn't watch that many Giants games last year and a lot of you didn't either but Jacob did and I believe him

The eyeball test in actual games, there is no substitute for it
Luckily here in the SP we have fans and posters from just about ALL 32 teams

I might have an opportunity to take him tonight in a redraft, could come down to him or Derrick Henry in the 1st for me, I'm seriously considering taking the plunge
Jax Dart might be the back up which I think would be great in case something fails with Russ. Dart's camp and some of his preseason might be the best news to come out of NY in a while

Thanks JL for taking the time

Dude, you’re taking a guy that considered surgery on his toe (likely turf toe). In the first round. There’s a reason he wound up on FBGs list of guys you’re glad other people drafted. Oof.

JL could be closer to God as far as vision goes, but ain’t nothing healing that toe. And I roster him in dynasty so I pay attention. This has no good written all over it.

He’s had the toe since college, . Drafting him with confidence. Dude is a dog and looks special. Don’t see that often.

The way he moves with and without the ball, the toe is a non-issue IMHO. Dude just doesn't like to practice it seems. He's a Ja'Marr Chase clone, but possibly MORE athletic and even more room for growth.

 

[oswizzle]

One wrong step on that toe … it’s gonna be a long season … not the kind of a confidence I’d want in my 1st rounder … he was kind of force fed the ball too and the team was ultra meh

 

[Jacob's Ladder]

As far as Gordon's height, I like tall RBs who know how to use leverage. Marcus Allen was a master at it. I also have no speed concerns. Like many tall guys, their 40 often doesn't correlate with their long speed. King Henry is the poster boy for that dynamic.

I'm not saying Gordon is as fast as Henry (he's not), but he's far from a lumbering big guy. Ollie can pick 'em up and put 'em down...he had plenty of long runs in college.

He did have quite a few big runs/catches, he can move with a runway.

One wrong step on that toe … it’s gonna be a long season … not the kind of a confidence I’d want in my 1st rounder … he was kind of force fed the ball too and the team was ultra meh

But how bad is the toe problem...really? Have you watched Nabers? Through college? Through 2024 with Jones, Devito and Lock throwing him the ball? You don't move that way with turf toe of any kind. That just ain't reality.

Nabers is the dude. He will outperform 2024 with Wilson or Dart, just give him the ball and watch him do work.

- YouTube

Enjoy the videos and music you love, upload original content, and share it all with friends, family, and the world on YouTube.

www.youtube.com

 

[Jacob's Ladder]

Check out 89's breakdown of Nabers' rookie season. I greatly respect what Smith did on the field and he's an extremely intelligent WR. I love his breakdowns of rookie WRs, they are very insightful and fair. He doesn't get everything right, but he's fun to listen to and better than your average analyst. What I find interesting about the Nabers breakdown is Smith feels like he has room to grow with his route running. I suppose that's true for everyone, but I watched Nabers do work all season long against 1s as the Giants' only real threat on the field. He straight up torched some DBs and defenses designed specifically to stop him and only him. To think he can get even better in that area is downright scary and the NFL has been put on notice. A better potential playmaker than Chase?

- YouTube

Enjoy the videos and music you love, upload original content, and share it all with friends, family, and the world on YouTube.

www.youtube.com

 

[rockaction]

Nobody is arguing this guy’s talent. Everybody is concerned with an injury. I don’t mean to be caustic but you seem to be totally ignoring the reasons why we’re not sold on him. I had him over MHJ in dynasty so that’s what I think of him. It’s. The. Toe.

 

[Runkle]

Didn't want to have to take him, but he fell to me. Guess I'm in for a long season.

 

[dkp993]

Nobody is arguing this guy’s talent. Everybody is concerned with an injury. I don’t mean to be caustic but you seem to be totally ignoring the reasons why we’re not sold on him. I had him over MHJ in dynasty so that’s what I think of him. It’s. The. Toe.

What do I know, I drafted CMC this year (@Hot Sauce Guy) to pair with Nabers (and also got Godwin toward the end of the draft). Must be a glutton for punishment. As the esteemed Ricky Bobby says “if you ain’t first you’re last!”

 

[rockaction]

Nobody is arguing this guy’s talent. Everybody is concerned with an injury. I don’t mean to be caustic but you seem to be totally ignoring the reasons why we’re not sold on him. I had him over MHJ in dynasty so that’s what I think of him. It’s. The. Toe.

What do I know, I drafted CMC this year (@Hot Sauce Guy) to pair with Nabers (and also got Godwin toward the end of the draft). Must be a glutton for punishment. As the esteemed Ricky Bobby says “if you ain’t first you’re last!”

Oh, it’s not really you I’m disagreeing with. I was stating my case (as others have) and it seems Jacob’s Ladder is pointing to how good Nabers is as if that was the sticking point.

I know that. I moved up in a rookie draft to get him. It’s that he’s hurt.

 

[Jacob's Ladder]

We talkin' about the "chronic toe injury" that has caused Malik Nabers to miss exactly 0 games in college? The same "chronic toe injury" that has caused Malik Nabers to miss exactly 0 games in the NFL? The same "chronic toe injury" that was such a concern during pre-draft evaluations that it caused Nabers to fall all the way to #6 overall in the 2024 NFL Draft?

Scared money don't make money.

 

[rockaction]

We talkin' about the "chronic toe injury" that has caused Malik Nabers to miss exactly 0 games in college? The same "chronic toe injury" that has caused Malik Nabers to miss exactly 0 games in the NFL? The same "chronic toe injury" that was such a concern during pre-draft evaluations that it caused Nabers to fall all the way to #6 overall in the 2024 NFL Draft?

Scared money don't make money.

The same one they were worried enough about to seriously discuss surgery?

Yeah, that one.

The agony of the feet: Why turf toe is such a dreaded injury in the NFL

A misunderstood and often dismissed condition, a big toe hyperextension can cause crippling pain with every step, creating mental anguish and fatigue that take a huge toll on an athlete. After decades of occurrences, it's finally being taken seriously.

www.espn.com

 

[Jacob's Ladder]

Yep, that one. Ooooooo, scary, an article about turf toe on ESPN that doesn't even mention Nabers. Great post!

Again, you don't move the way Nabers moves with turf toe. It just doesn't happen. Does he have something going on? Maybe, probably. Is that even the reason he's been sitting out? Who knows. They say it's a back problem. Has his toe problem even been labeled turf toe by anyone inside or the organization or Nabers himself? Nope. It would have come up in the pre-draft medical if he had turf toe and he damn sure wouldn't be moving the way he moves on the Giants hard *** field if he had turf toe. Regardless, this "problem" he is dealing with "since college" has caused him to miss exactly 0 games in his college/NFL career while becoming the 6th overall draft pick and having one of the greatest rookie seasons of all time, despite missing time due to a concussion. Let me repeat that for those keeping track. ZERO games missed due to a toe injury. Nabers called the problem an annoying mosquito, also publicly stated surgery isn't a near term concern. Yawn.

 

[zamboni]

Definitely concerned about Nabers re-aggravating his toe, but I’m concerned about all my players getting hurt. Part of the hobby we adore and despise simultaneously.

 

[Jacob's Ladder]

Definitely concerned about Nabers re-aggravating his toe, but I’m concerned about all my players getting hurt. Part of the hobby we adore and despise simultaneously.

My question remains. When did he "aggravate" it and what impact did it have on his play? If he ever had a turf toe injury, it didn't show up in his play and I don't ever remember it showing up on an injury report.

My problem is everyone except Nabers and the Giants keep calling this turf toe. What if it's a hangnail? An ingrown toenail? A broken toenail? Cracked skin?

 

[rockaction]

Definitely concerned about Nabers re-aggravating his toe, but I’m concerned about all my players getting hurt. Part of the hobby we adore and despise simultaneously.

My question remains. When did he "aggravate" it and what impact did it have on his play? If he ever had a turf toe injury, it didn't show up in his play and I don't ever remember it showing up on an injury report.

My problem is everyone except Nabers and the Giants keep calling this turf toe. What if it's a hangnail? An ingrown toenail? A broken toenail? Cracked skin?

Yeah, you would have a better point if you said he’ll manage it and you’re not too worried, but you’re pretty much denying it’s an injury and at the least that it doesn’t trouble him. But it is an injury and it does trouble him. I think your cavalier dismissal actually serves to prove nothing other than that you’re cavalier. Which is great, but the best that gets you is mascot status and that’s only in Virginia.

 

[Jacob's Ladder]

Definitely concerned about Nabers re-aggravating his toe, but I’m concerned about all my players getting hurt. Part of the hobby we adore and despise simultaneously.

My question remains. When did he "aggravate" it and what impact did it have on his play? If he ever had a turf toe injury, it didn't show up in his play and I don't ever remember it showing up on an injury report.

My problem is everyone except Nabers and the Giants keep calling this turf toe. What if it's a hangnail? An ingrown toenail? A broken toenail? Cracked skin?

Yeah, you would have a better point if you said he’ll manage it and you’re not too worried, but you’re pretty much denying it’s an injury and at the least that it doesn’t trouble him. But it is an injury and it does trouble him. I think your cavalier dismissal actually serves to prove nothing other than that you’re cavalier. Which is great, but the best that gets you is mascot status and that’s only in Virginia.

I've acknowledged he has some sort of injury, and every player who steps on the field for even one play is an injury away from a season or career ender, but no one has provided any sort of real report on the severity or nature of Naber's actual injury. All I can do is watch him and believe what my eyes can see.

I'm still waiting for a link from the team or Nabers camp that states he has turf toe. It would be better if you provided one. Heck, we're even speculating on which toe aren't we? Twitter docs, tv personalities and message board crusaders aside, who in the know has actually said he has turf toe? Heck, I haven't even seen a reputable beat writer say, "sources inside the organization tell me it's turf toe." Admit you're guessing and just running with an unproven and unverified narrative. You should do more research.

 

[oswizzle]

Jacob definitely went all in Nabers… I feel like you drafted him with your first pick in every draft bro… that or you bought up all his rookie Autos and with good season you can hopefully unload them all

 

[Hot Sauce Guy]

Might have been dumb of me but Nabers was falling in our draft and I still took Drake London over him. I'm just going to trust my gut on this but it was likely a very very stupid move by me and half my league mates to pass on him.

I don't think it was stupid. Guys are in the same zip code value wise. Sure, straight up id take Nabers, but I can see the conversation the other way around. Worst thing about this is your gonna box score comparing the two all season and kicking yourself every week Nabers does better. Ha ha

LOL yep that is so true. And it will probably be a roller coaster ride back and forth as the season goes on where I feel very right and very wrong about my pick depending on the week.

Drake has a better offense and QB, Nabers already has a naggin jury

Awww jeez thanks you guys sure know how to cheer me up

I’m a huge London honk and I probably still take Nabers. Probably. Hard to say until I’m OTC His back is reportedly fine, and while the toe that people can’t stop talking about is legit, it hasn’t slowed him down to date. But that said, I do have them relatively in the same tier, so probably not “stupid”, but certainly possible Nabers puts up better numbers. Since it’s a coin flip, go with your gut.

On second thought, if possible I don’t want to have to watch a minute of NYG football this year, so I probably also take London.

Until Dart comes in & lights the league on fire. That’s when ya might regret it.

 

[rockaction]

Until Dart comes in & lights the league on fire. That’s when ya might regret it.

Yeah, dude, I was gonna stop you before you tried to make it home against that cannon Dave Parker has in right. Dart is the screw up the Jets might rue for a long, long time.

 

[Hot Sauce Guy]

Until Dart comes in & lights the league on fire. That’s when ya might regret it.

Yeah, dude, I was gonna stop you before you tried to make it home against that cannon Dave Parker has in right. Dart is the screw up the Jets might rue for a long, long time.

But… but the 3B coach is sending me!

 

[Hot Sauce Guy]

the Jets might rue

Also, and a little off-topic, do people still "rue" things?

When was the last time you shook your fist and said, "you'll rue the day you messed with me!"?

 

[darksideofoz]

the Jets might rue

Also, and a little off-topic, do people still "rue" things?

When was the last time you shook your fist and said, "you'll rue the day you messed with me!"?

I did that to my 7 year old a few weeks ago. He looked at me like he usually does, not understanding but also like he's barely tolerating me.

 

[Hot Sauce Guy]

the Jets might rue

Also, and a little off-topic, do people still "rue" things?

When was the last time you shook your fist and said, "you'll rue the day you messed with me!"?

I did that to my 7 year old a few weeks ago. He looked at me like he usually does, not understanding but also like he's barely tolerating me.

I think it’s only effective if you then twirl your waxed handlebar mustache, and cackle sinisterly.

 

[Jacob's Ladder]

Jacob definitely went all in Nabers… I feel like you drafted him with your first pick in every draft bro… that or you bought up all his rookie Autos and with good season you can hopefully unload them all

I obviously love his talent. Drafting him everywhere? Nah, people are smart enough to ignore false narratives like this one. His value hasn’t fallen enough to create any sort of real value.

The thing that bothers me is a turf toe label and narrative that is 100% unverified and driven my arm chair enthusiasts and twitter docs. This is the worst type of lazy sports analysis and reporting.

TBH, that nasty concussion and multi-week recovery on what initially appeared to be a nothing tackle worries me more than what’s going on with his big toe, pinky toe or naughty toe…

 

[darksideofoz]

Jacob definitely went all in Nabers… I feel like you drafted him with your first pick in every draft bro… that or you bought up all his rookie Autos and with good season you can hopefully unload them all

I obviously love his talent. Drafting him everywhere? Nah, people are smart enough to ignore false narratives like this one. His value hasn’t fallen enough to create any sort of real value.

The thing that bothers me is a turf toe label and narrative that is 100% unverified and driven my arm chair enthusiasts and twitter docs. This is the worst type of lazy sports analysis and reporting.

TBH, that nasty concussion and multi-week recovery on what initially appeared to be a nothing tackle worries me more than what’s going on with his big toe, pinky toe or naughty toe…

Been 100% in step with how you're assessing Nabers toe and general health. And stated as much a few pages back. It hasn't affected his play, at all. He hasn't missed time, at all. Fpr years of "dealing" with...what exactly? A few years down the road when it finally might, everyone will be claiming their fantasy greatness for calling it.

I wish someone could play a game of this little piggy to see which one makes him cry "wee! wee! wee!" all the way home.

 

[rockaction]

Jacob definitely went all in Nabers… I feel like you drafted him with your first pick in every draft bro… that or you bought up all his rookie Autos and with good season you can hopefully unload them all

I obviously love his talent. Drafting him everywhere? Nah, people are smart enough to ignore false narratives like this one. His value hasn’t fallen enough to create any sort of real value.

The thing that bothers me is a turf toe label and narrative that is 100% unverified and driven my arm chair enthusiasts and twitter docs. This is the worst type of lazy sports analysis and reporting.

TBH, that nasty concussion and multi-week recovery on what initially appeared to be a nothing tackle worries me more than what’s going on with his big toe, pinky toe or naughty toe…

Been 100% in step with how you're assessing Nabers toe and general health. And stated as much a few pages back. It hasn't affected his play, at all. He hasn't missed time, at all. Fpr years of "dealing" with...what exactly? A few years down the road when it finally might, everyone will be claiming their fantasy greatness for calling it.

I wish someone could play a game of this little piggy to see which one makes him cry "wee! wee! wee!" all the way home.

Not really. If he misses time this year I'll be right here. It'll be simple. I'll be right. You'll have just name called and been cavalier about a nagging toe injury for which the player has said surgery was discussed but that they were going with maintenance. I think I've both played at a reasonably high level (collegiate) and watched for forty years. Maybe I lack the testicular fortitude you so seek in your endeavors, but I think you're being foolish.

 

[Aznflyer14]

Look like Nabers is taking much more proactive with health particularly with recovery and rehab.

Malik Nabers has had a strong summer, and part of it has been the time he’s spent bonding with Wilson. One story I heard about Wilson setting the tone was the room he rented for recovery and rehab in the team hotel for camp—a room that younger teammates started to gravitate to, with some borrowing from the quarterback’s methods. Nabers was at the top of the list of guys to do that, and it’s shown in how consistent he’s become, as the violent, aggressive, fast style of play he brought into the pros has started to conform to the NFL.

 

[Jacob's Ladder]

Jacob definitely went all in Nabers… I feel like you drafted him with your first pick in every draft bro… that or you bought up all his rookie Autos and with good season you can hopefully unload them all

I obviously love his talent. Drafting him everywhere? Nah, people are smart enough to ignore false narratives like this one. His value hasn’t fallen enough to create any sort of real value.

The thing that bothers me is a turf toe label and narrative that is 100% unverified and driven my arm chair enthusiasts and twitter docs. This is the worst type of lazy sports analysis and reporting.

TBH, that nasty concussion and multi-week recovery on what initially appeared to be a nothing tackle worries me more than what’s going on with his big toe, pinky toe or naughty toe…

Been 100% in step with how you're assessing Nabers toe and general health. And stated as much a few pages back. It hasn't affected his play, at all. He hasn't missed time, at all. Fpr years of "dealing" with...what exactly? A few years down the road when it finally might, everyone will be claiming their fantasy greatness for calling it.

I wish someone could play a game of this little piggy to see which one makes him cry "wee! wee! wee!" all the way home.

Not really. If he misses time this year I'll be right here. It'll be simple. I'll be right. You'll have just name called and been cavalier about a nagging toe injury for which the player has said surgery was discussed but that they were going with maintenance. I think I've both played at a reasonably high level (collegiate) and watched for forty years. Maybe I lack the testicular fortitude you so seek in your endeavors, but I think you're being foolish.

Lighten up Francis. You’re being way too defensive and sensitive.

 

[rockaction]

Jacob definitely went all in Nabers… I feel like you drafted him with your first pick in every draft bro… that or you bought up all his rookie Autos and with good season you can hopefully unload them all

I obviously love his talent. Drafting him everywhere? Nah, people are smart enough to ignore false narratives like this one. His value hasn’t fallen enough to create any sort of real value.

The thing that bothers me is a turf toe label and narrative that is 100% unverified and driven my arm chair enthusiasts and twitter docs. This is the worst type of lazy sports analysis and reporting.

TBH, that nasty concussion and multi-week recovery on what initially appeared to be a nothing tackle worries me more than what’s going on with his big toe, pinky toe or naughty toe…

Been 100% in step with how you're assessing Nabers toe and general health. And stated as much a few pages back. It hasn't affected his play, at all. He hasn't missed time, at all. Fpr years of "dealing" with...what exactly? A few years down the road when it finally might, everyone will be claiming their fantasy greatness for calling it.

I wish someone could play a game of this little piggy to see which one makes him cry "wee! wee! wee!" all the way home.

Not really. If he misses time this year I'll be right here. It'll be simple. I'll be right. You'll have just name called and been cavalier about a nagging toe injury for which the player has said surgery was discussed but that they were going with maintenance. I think I've both played at a reasonably high level (collegiate) and watched for forty years. Maybe I lack the testicular fortitude you so seek in your endeavors, but I think you're being foolish.

Lighten up Francis. You’re being way too defensive and sensitive.

Nah. You're weird. I went back because I remember weird interactions with you and sure enough, there they were. You were dead wrong about some forty time and wouldn't let it go for like two pages. This place is plenty big enough for the both of us. You've gotten personal four times already in this thread. I don't play that. Good day, bro. This argument wasted an hour of my time because I always assume good faith, but this situation didn't deserve it.

 

[steelerfan1]

Dang it! I’m in for the ride. I chased the talent lastnight.

 

[Proteus]

the Jets might rue

Also, and a little off-topic, do people still "rue" things?

When was the last time you shook your fist and said, "you'll rue the day you messed with me!"?

I think the wild popularity of Rue McClanahan across many demographics might have altered the calculus of that usage.

Also...I had no idea this toe was such a potent issue. Don't have any shares yet but this bums me out.

I hereby name that toe...Little Judkins

 

[Payne]

Dang it! I’m in for the ride. I chased the talent lastnight.

I did too.

 

[Faust]

Giants WR Malik Nabers says back injury was 'a minor thing'

 

[Jacob's Ladder]

Not even a questionable tag. Big surprise, right?

 

[dnurk]

Tagging as I have a share this year.

 

[Wigglytuff's Gruff]

Picking 4th in a 16 team standard he somehow made it back to my 2nd pick at 29. Miracle stuff.

Now have him everywhere. Literally every league I do.

 

[Faust]

Jordan Raanan
The Giants will "back down" on WR Malik Nabers at Friday's practice, per coach Brian Daboll. He's dealing with back tightness. Daboll seems confident it's not a big thing.

"He'll be all right," Daboll said. "He'll be all right."

https://x.com/jordanraanan/status/1963989907564544393?s=61

 

[Payne]

Jordan Raanan
The Giants will "back down" on WR Malik Nabers at Friday's practice, per coach Brian Daboll. He's dealing with back tightness. Daboll seems confident it's not a big thing.

"He'll be all right," Daboll said. "He'll be all right."

https://x.com/jordanraanan/status/1963989907564544393?s=61

 

[Uncle Leo]

So much injury drama with this dude. Reminds me of the Odell years.

 

[Jacob's Ladder]

So much injury drama with this dude. Reminds me of the Odell years.

By the time Odell started getting injured he was cooked. Nabers (so far), reminds me of Mike Evans. Always dinged, always questionable, but always at peak performance when the bright lights came on. Nabers still has a lot to prove but so far he’s proven he is a gamer, hates practice, is a tough *** dude or some combination of the 3.

 

[Uncle Leo]

5 catches on 12 targets? Were the others drops or Russ got rushed?

 

[dkp993]

5 catches on 12 targets? Were the others drops or Russ got rushed?

1 drop on a really difficult catch. The others were not close. Wilson never really had any time today. He’s also bad.

 

[Payne]

I know we shouldn't panic after week 1, but I'm certainly concerned. This coaching staff sucks.

 

[ffmail4me]

When the Giants roll out Dart things will improve. Russell may still be able to run out of the pocket, but he is pretty washed as a passer IMO.