WR Tetairoa McMillan, CAR (2 Viewers)

[pinkstapler]

I was recently looking at his 2024 game logs, and it struck me as peculiar that the #8 overall pick scored exactly zero TDs between weeks 2 and 7 last year.

That is six weeks with zero TDs in college and these games were played against (pass D ranks in parantheses):

• Northern Arizona (18th in FCS)
• Kansas State (50)
• Utah (25)
• Texas Tech (122)
• BYU (18)
• Colorado (42)

Some fairly decent pass defenses in there, but ZERO touchdowns in SIX games for the #8 pick overall? Not great. How is this guy with his massive wingspan that should catch any end zone jump ball going to dominate vs professional corners when he can't score for six straight games against college DBs, many with no shot to go pro?

In weeks 8-12, he scored 4 TDs, so a total of 4 TDs between weeks 2 and 12.

In fact, if you take away his week 1 vs awful 129th pass-ranked New Mexico (10 for 304 and 4 TDs), and his 11 week season stats are 74 catches for 1005 and 4 TDs. Hopefully, he finds some New Mexicos to play against in the NFL.

Probably says more about his QB at ARI than anything. Fifta only threw for 4 TDs vs 8 INTs during that six week span.

Agree it's probably not something to hugely knock Tet for. But it is also just a good reminder this was never an elite WR class. There was no Green, Lamb, Chase, Smith, Nabers, MHJ, Odunze, etc. level prospect, including Tet. Removing our hindsight glasses, could probably argue guys like N'Keal Harry even profiled better than anyone in this class. I think we all get lost in the sauce hyper focusing on a class of rookie only comparing them against one another, which can help us navigate our fantasy drafts. But once that's done, it's good to remember to calibrate expectations then against the rest of the players in the NFL.

 

[SayWhat?]

I don’t get this narrative that a 5-star recruit who dominated from Day 1 in college, early declared for the NFL draft, and was selected in the top 10 (while the team selecting him rejected an offer from the Rams trying to move into that exact pick for him) “isn’t an elite prospect.” He may not pan out, just like any other draftee, but saying he’s not on the level of Rome Odunze as a prospect is crazy town.

 

[pinkstapler]

I don’t get this narrative that a 5-star recruit who dominated from Day 1 in college, early declared for the NFL draft, and was selected in the top 10 (while the team selecting him rejected an offer from the Rams trying to move into that exact pick for him) “isn’t an elite prospect.” He may not pan out, just like any other draftee, but saying he’s not on the level of Rome Odunze as a prospect is crazy town.

NFL draft profile

I can start there but follow up with about a dozen other sources saying he's not the prospect any of those guys I named were according to basically any popular community source. But since you're the one saying it's crazy, please feel free to share the sources saying he is. I've yet to see anything.

And again, try not to let bias color your posts here. Because Rome was 100% considered a better prospect that Tet universally by every source I've seen. It was actually almost a split decision on whether it should have been him or Nabers behind MHJ as WR2 of the class.

Sorry if it's not information that makes you feel warm and fuzzy. But at least come with some facts/sources if you're going to say it's "crazy town".

 

[SayWhat?]

I don’t get this narrative that a 5-star recruit who dominated from Day 1 in college, early declared for the NFL draft, and was selected in the top 10 (while the team selecting him rejected an offer from the Rams trying to move into that exact pick for him) “isn’t an elite prospect.” He may not pan out, just like any other draftee, but saying he’s not on the level of Rome Odunze as a prospect is crazy town.

NFL draft profile

I can start there but follow up with about a dozen other sources saying he's not the prospect any of those guys I named were according to basically any popular community source. But since you're the one saying it's crazy, please feel free to share the sources saying he is. I've yet to see anything.

And again, try not to let bias color your posts here. Because Rome was 100% considered a better prospect that Tet universally by every source I've seen. It was actually almost a split decision on whether it should have been him or Nabers behind MHJ as WR2 of the class.

Sorry if it's not information that makes you feel warm and fuzzy. But at least come with some facts/sources if you're going to say it's "crazy town".

You’re right, I stated no facts in my post.

I’ll take your word for all the hard facts you brought in those two lengthy paragraphs. Just for giggles, you should google “rome odunze vs tet mcmillan draft grade” and see what the AI results indicate. Too lazy? Ok, here you go:

“In the 2025 NFL Draft, Tetairoa McMillan is projected to be a higher-graded prospect than Rome Odunze was in the 2024 draft. McMillan is currently considered by some as the top wide receiver prospect in the 2025 class, with a few analysts even comparing him to the top three WRs from last year's draft (Marvin Harrison Jr., Malik Nabers, and Rome Odunze). Some sources even consider McMillan as a top-10 draft pick.”

Carry on with your wholly unbiased narrative backed up by all those facts. My one Tet share makes me a huge fanboy so I will die on this hill defending his untalented honor.

 

[menobrown]

him rejected an offer from the Rams trying to move into that exact pick for him)

Not to get off subject but that's a lot of conjecture, being promoted by Carolina IMO, that's who the Rams were trying to trade up to get him and not someone else.

I personally don't think it's who the Rams were going after.

 

[King of the Jungle]

Tet was my fifth ranked receiver from this class. I would have had Nabers/MHJr/Odunze/Thomas ranked over anyone in this class. I was lower on McConkey than I should have been.

 

[SayWhat?]

him rejected an offer from the Rams trying to move into that exact pick for him)

Not to get off subject but that's a lot of conjecture, being promoted by Carolina IMO, that's who the Rams were trying to trade up to get him and not someone else.

I personally don't think it's who the Rams were going after.

Every report has indicated that’s who they were after, but that certainly could be unsubstantiated.

 

[RC94]

I don’t get this narrative that a 5-star recruit who dominated from Day 1 in college, early declared for the NFL draft, and was selected in the top 10 (while the team selecting him rejected an offer from the Rams trying to move into that exact pick for him) “isn’t an elite prospect.” He may not pan out, just like any other draftee, but saying he’s not on the level of Rome Odunze as a prospect is crazy town.

NFL draft profile

I can start there but follow up with about a dozen other sources saying he's not the prospect any of those guys I named were according to basically any popular community source. But since you're the one saying it's crazy, please feel free to share the sources saying he is. I've yet to see anything.

And again, try not to let bias color your posts here. Because Rome was 100% considered a better prospect that Tet universally by every source I've seen. It was actually almost a split decision on whether it should have been him or Nabers behind MHJ as WR2 of the class.

Sorry if it's not information that makes you feel warm and fuzzy. But at least come with some facts/sources if you're going to say it's "crazy town".

I thought the split decision was between Nabers and Harrison.

 

[menobrown]

him rejected an offer from the Rams trying to move into that exact pick for him)

Not to get off subject but that's a lot of conjecture, being promoted by Carolina IMO, that's who the Rams were trying to trade up to get him and not someone else.

I personally don't think it's who the Rams were going after.

Every report has indicated that’s who they were after, but that certainly could be unsubstantiated.

Not to beat this to death but I've seen no such reports other then Dan Morgan said the Rams wanted to trade up and everything else was just guessing it was for Tet. SF was another team people guessed and it's already been suggested they were trying to trade up for Mykel.

I don't buy it because Rams are in win now mode, and are already paying their WR3 $10m. Just don't see how Tet could have made much of an impact this year.

 

[Lansdowne]

him rejected an offer from the Rams trying to move into that exact pick for him)

Not to get off subject but that's a lot of conjecture, being promoted by Carolina IMO, that's who the Rams were trying to trade up to get him and not someone else.

I personally don't think it's who the Rams were going after.

Every report has indicated that’s who they were after, but that certainly could be unsubstantiated.

Not to beat this to death but I've seen no such reports other then Dan Morgan said the Rams wanted to trade up and everything else was just guessing it was for Tet. SF was another team people guessed and it's already been suggested they were trying to trade up for Mykel.

I don't buy it because Rams are in win now mode, and are already paying their WR3 $10m. Just don't see how Tet could have made much of an impact this year.

The Rams and 49ers were both interested in trading up to the Panthers' spot. It makes more sense that the Rams were trying to draft Colston Loveland, considering they tried and failed to trade up for Brock Bowers last year and settled on Terrance Ferguson in the second round this year when they missed out on Loveland. The 49ers were apparently after Mykel Williams but were fortunate he dropped to them three spots later anyway.

Tetairoa McMillan is definitely one of the most polarizing prospects in this class. Seems like the analytics people love him and the film people not so much. He does seem to check a lot of the boxes you look for in a top WR prospect (early breakout, high production, early declare, top 10 draft capital). Gets knocked for lack of separation but he plays fast for a WR his size, has a great catch radius, is a hands catcher rather than a body catcher (I've noticed Jayden Higgins is more of the latter type). I'm a sucker for the traditional big X receiver type and he passes the eye test for me. Add in the likelihood of leading his draft class in targets and I think there's a whole lot to like.

 

[pinkstapler]

I don’t get this narrative that a 5-star recruit who dominated from Day 1 in college, early declared for the NFL draft, and was selected in the top 10 (while the team selecting him rejected an offer from the Rams trying to move into that exact pick for him) “isn’t an elite prospect.” He may not pan out, just like any other draftee, but saying he’s not on the level of Rome Odunze as a prospect is crazy town.

NFL draft profile

I can start there but follow up with about a dozen other sources saying he's not the prospect any of those guys I named were according to basically any popular community source. But since you're the one saying it's crazy, please feel free to share the sources saying he is. I've yet to see anything.

And again, try not to let bias color your posts here. Because Rome was 100% considered a better prospect that Tet universally by every source I've seen. It was actually almost a split decision on whether it should have been him or Nabers behind MHJ as WR2 of the class.

Sorry if it's not information that makes you feel warm and fuzzy. But at least come with some facts/sources if you're going to say it's "crazy town".

I thought the split decision was between Nabers and Harrison.

I could have my wires crossed between real world NFL projections and fantasy projections. Real world NFL could very well have been between those two. I know Harmon was one torn between Odunze and Nabers with regard to fantasy, ultimately leaning towards Odunze over Nabers. Fantasy in general seemed to have a little more caution towards MHJ, but I think that was less to do with him as a player and more about his situation landing with Murray. I posted in multiple threads I actually had MHJ behind both more because I didn't like his at the catch skills, felt like he'd be more reliant on QB and scheme than Nabers or Odunze. Trying to parse those three at this point last year was pretty much splitting hairs. My overall point just being that I don't think anyone would have had Tet ahead of any of them. I wouldn't even have him in the same tier.

But here he is now with probably the best QB situation of all three (though I think Caleb takes a step forward this year), and much less target competition than Odunze. So it wouldn't surprise me at all if he's outscoring him this year, and a good chance to outscore MHJ too IMO. Never said he's a bad player or will be a bad fantasy WR. Just that from a purely talent based perspective, he wasn't on the level of previous years prospects. At this point, it hardly matters because all we really care about is production, and Tet is in a great situation to get a ton of that. Unfortunately, some people seem incapable of having any type of depth in discussion and reading comprehension and will just word vomit personal attacks dripping in sarcasm because they see a comment that isn't overtly positive and automatically think it must be negative. My mistake for engaging with people like that.

 

[SayWhat?]

I don’t get this narrative that a 5-star recruit who dominated from Day 1 in college, early declared for the NFL draft, and was selected in the top 10 (while the team selecting him rejected an offer from the Rams trying to move into that exact pick for him) “isn’t an elite prospect.” He may not pan out, just like any other draftee, but saying he’s not on the level of Rome Odunze as a prospect is crazy town.

NFL draft profile

I can start there but follow up with about a dozen other sources saying he's not the prospect any of those guys I named were according to basically any popular community source. But since you're the one saying it's crazy, please feel free to share the sources saying he is. I've yet to see anything.

And again, try not to let bias color your posts here. Because Rome was 100% considered a better prospect that Tet universally by every source I've seen. It was actually almost a split decision on whether it should have been him or Nabers behind MHJ as WR2 of the class.

Sorry if it's not information that makes you feel warm and fuzzy. But at least come with some facts/sources if you're going to say it's "crazy town".

You’re right, I stated no facts in my post.

I’ll take your word for all the hard facts you brought in those two lengthy paragraphs. Just for giggles, you should google “rome odunze vs tet mcmillan draft grade” and see what the AI results indicate. Too lazy? Ok, here you go:

“In the 2025 NFL Draft, Tetairoa McMillan is projected to be a higher-graded prospect than Rome Odunze was in the 2024 draft. McMillan is currently considered by some as the top wide receiver prospect in the 2025 class, with a few analysts even comparing him to the top three WRs from last year's draft (Marvin Harrison Jr., Malik Nabers, and Rome Odunze). Some sources even consider McMillan as a top-10 draft pick.”

Carry on with your wholly unbiased narrative backed up by all those facts. My one Tet share makes me a huge fanboy so I will die on this hill defending his untalented honor.

Lol an AI reply is apropos. This entire comment isn't even worth an actual reply. You have the maturity of a 12 year old. Good luck this year.

I'm sorry that the very first google result didn't fit your narrative, AI-generated or otherwise, after you claimed that Rome was 100% considered a better prospect that (sp) Tet universally by every source I've seen.

 

[Marauder]

I don’t get this narrative that a 5-star recruit who dominated from Day 1 in college, early declared for the NFL draft, and was selected in the top 10 (while the team selecting him rejected an offer from the Rams trying to move into that exact pick for him) “isn’t an elite prospect.” He may not pan out, just like any other draftee, but saying he’s not on the level of Rome Odunze as a prospect is crazy town.

NFL draft profile

I can start there but follow up with about a dozen other sources saying he's not the prospect any of those guys I named were according to basically any popular community source. But since you're the one saying it's crazy, please feel free to share the sources saying he is. I've yet to see anything.

And again, try not to let bias color your posts here. Because Rome was 100% considered a better prospect that Tet universally by every source I've seen. It was actually almost a split decision on whether it should have been him or Nabers behind MHJ as WR2 of the class.

Sorry if it's not information that makes you feel warm and fuzzy. But at least come with some facts/sources if you're going to say it's "crazy town".

You’re right, I stated no facts in my post.

I’ll take your word for all the hard facts you brought in those two lengthy paragraphs. Just for giggles, you should google “rome odunze vs tet mcmillan draft grade” and see what the AI results indicate. Too lazy? Ok, here you go:

“In the 2025 NFL Draft, Tetairoa McMillan is projected to be a higher-graded prospect than Rome Odunze was in the 2024 draft. McMillan is currently considered by some as the top wide receiver prospect in the 2025 class, with a few analysts even comparing him to the top three WRs from last year's draft (Marvin Harrison Jr., Malik Nabers, and Rome Odunze). Some sources even consider McMillan as a top-10 draft pick.”

Carry on with your wholly unbiased narrative backed up by all those facts. My one Tet share makes me a huge fanboy so I will die on this hill defending his untalented honor.

Lol an AI reply is apropos. This entire comment isn't even worth an actual reply. You have the maturity of a 12 year old. Good luck this year.

I'm sorry that the very first google result didn't fit your narrative, AI-generated or otherwise, after you claimed that Rome was 100% considered a better prospect that (sp) Tet universally by every source I've seen.

I have no dog in this fight but just for fun, here's what ChatGPT says:

Rome Odunze was the higher-rated draft prospect compared to Tetairoa McMillan.

Rome Odunze – 2024 NFL Draft​

• Draft Position: 9th overall by the Chicago Bears.
• Overall Prospect Rank: Ranked as the No. 3 overall prospect on NFL Network analyst Daniel Jeremiah’s Big Board.
• Scouting Grade: 8.9 (Impact Player — 1st Round)
• Position Rank: WR2 (behind Marvin Harrison Jr.)
• Pro Comparison: Shades of Davante Adams
• College Performance: In 2023, Odunze recorded 92 receptions for 1,640 yards and 13 touchdowns, earning consensus All-American honors. en.wikipedia.org+4profootballnetwork.com+4pff.com+4nfl.comsports.yahoo.com+22bleacherreport.com+22bleacherreport.com+22as.com+4bleacherreport.com+4nypost.com+4

Tetairoa McMillan – 2025 NFL Draft​

• Draft Position: Selected by the Carolina Panthers in the 2025 NFL Draft.
• Overall Prospect Rank: Ranked as the No. 3 overall player and top wide receiver on Pro Football Focus's big board.
• Scouting Grade: 8.4 (Impact Player — 1st Round)
• Position Rank: WR1
• Pro Comparison: Tee Higgins or Mike Evans
• College Performance: In 2024, McMillan had 84 receptions for 1,319 yards and was named a Consensus All-American. pff.comsports.yahoo.com+6bleacherreport.com+6nypost.com+6en.wikipedia.org

Comparison Summary​

Prospect	Draft Year	Overall Rank	Position Rank	Scouting Grade	Draft Position
Rome Odunze	2024	No. 3	WR2	8.9	9th Overall
Tetairoa McMillan	2025	No. 3	WR1	8.4	Panthers' Pick

While both receivers were highly regarded, Odunze was evaluated as a slightly higher prospect, with a superior scouting grade and a top-three overall ranking in his draft class. McMillan, though ranked as the top wide receiver in the 2025 class, had a marginally lower overall scouting grade.pff.com
It's important to note that draft evaluations can vary between years due to the differing strengths of draft classes. Odunze's 2024 class was particularly strong at the wide receiver position, making his high ranking even more noteworthy.

 

[Blue Wave]

I don’t get this narrative that a 5-star recruit who dominated from Day 1 in college, early declared for the NFL draft, and was selected in the top 10 (while the team selecting him rejected an offer from the Rams trying to move into that exact pick for him) “isn’t an elite prospect.” He may not pan out, just like any other draftee, but saying he’s not on the level of Rome Odunze as a prospect is crazy town.

NFL draft profile

I can start there but follow up with about a dozen other sources saying he's not the prospect any of those guys I named were according to basically any popular community source. But since you're the one saying it's crazy, please feel free to share the sources saying he is. I've yet to see anything.

And again, try not to let bias color your posts here. Because Rome was 100% considered a better prospect that Tet universally by every source I've seen. It was actually almost a split decision on whether it should have been him or Nabers behind MHJ as WR2 of the class.

Sorry if it's not information that makes you feel warm and fuzzy. But at least come with some facts/sources if you're going to say it's "crazy town".

You’re right, I stated no facts in my post.

I’ll take your word for all the hard facts you brought in those two lengthy paragraphs. Just for giggles, you should google “rome odunze vs tet mcmillan draft grade” and see what the AI results indicate. Too lazy? Ok, here you go:

“In the 2025 NFL Draft, Tetairoa McMillan is projected to be a higher-graded prospect than Rome Odunze was in the 2024 draft. McMillan is currently considered by some as the top wide receiver prospect in the 2025 class, with a few analysts even comparing him to the top three WRs from last year's draft (Marvin Harrison Jr., Malik Nabers, and Rome Odunze). Some sources even consider McMillan as a top-10 draft pick.”

Carry on with your wholly unbiased narrative backed up by all those facts. My one Tet share makes me a huge fanboy so I will die on this hill defending his untalented honor.

Lol an AI reply is apropos. This entire comment isn't even worth an actual reply. You have the maturity of a 12 year old. Good luck this year.

I'm sorry that the very first google result didn't fit your narrative, AI-generated or otherwise, after you claimed that Rome was 100% considered a better prospect that (sp) Tet universally by every source I've seen.

I have no dog in this fight but just for fun, here's what ChatGPT says:

Rome Odunze was the higher-rated draft prospect compared to Tetairoa McMillan.

Rome Odunze – 2024 NFL Draft​

• Draft Position: 9th overall by the Chicago Bears.
• Overall Prospect Rank: Ranked as the No. 3 overall prospect on NFL Network analyst Daniel Jeremiah’s Big Board.
• Scouting Grade: 8.9 (Impact Player — 1st Round)
• Position Rank: WR2 (behind Marvin Harrison Jr.)
• Pro Comparison: Shades of Davante Adams
• College Performance: In 2023, Odunze recorded 92 receptions for 1,640 yards and 13 touchdowns, earning consensus All-American honors. en.wikipedia.org+4profootballnetwork.com+4pff.com+4nfl.comsports.yahoo.com+22bleacherreport.com+22bleacherreport.com+22as.com+4bleacherreport.com+4nypost.com+4

Tetairoa McMillan – 2025 NFL Draft​

• Draft Position: Selected by the Carolina Panthers in the 2025 NFL Draft.
• Overall Prospect Rank: Ranked as the No. 3 overall player and top wide receiver on Pro Football Focus's big board.
• Scouting Grade: 8.4 (Impact Player — 1st Round)
• Position Rank: WR1
• Pro Comparison: Tee Higgins or Mike Evans
• College Performance: In 2024, McMillan had 84 receptions for 1,319 yards and was named a Consensus All-American. pff.comsports.yahoo.com+6bleacherreport.com+6nypost.com+6en.wikipedia.org

Comparison Summary​

Prospect	Draft Year	Overall Rank	Position Rank	Scouting Grade	Draft Position
Rome Odunze	2024	No. 3	WR2	8.9	9th Overall
Tetairoa McMillan	2025	No. 3	WR1	8.4	Panthers' Pick

While both receivers were highly regarded, Odunze was evaluated as a slightly higher prospect, with a superior scouting grade and a top-three overall ranking in his draft class. McMillan, though ranked as the top wide receiver in the 2025 class, had a marginally lower overall scouting grade.pff.com
It's important to note that draft evaluations can vary between years due to the differing strengths of draft classes. Odunze's 2024 class was particularly strong at the wide receiver position, making his high ranking even more noteworthy.

how couldn't they figure out what pick the panthers took him at?

 

[pinkstapler]

how couldn't they figure out what pick the panthers took him at?

That's my bad; I'm asking it about anti-gravity propulsion while feeding in research papers and lab experiments from theoretical physicists from the 80s and questioning why 40 years later we still don't have any progress (that we know of) like 5 times a day. It's probably really bogging the whole system down....

 

[BassNBrew]

how couldn't they figure out what pick the panthers took him at?

That's my bad; I'm asking it about anti-gravity propulsion while feeding in research papers and lab experiments from theoretical physicists from the 80s and questioning why 40 years later we still don't have any progress (that we know of) like 5 times a day. It's probably really bogging the whole system down....

Actually my fault. I'ver been bogging it down with fantasy cycling to the point that it can't add to 100. Can't put much stock into something that you tell to pick a team for 100 or less and it comes back with 106. On the plus side, a few months ago that task was yield results in the 120s.

 

[pinkstapler]

how couldn't they figure out what pick the panthers took him at?

That's my bad; I'm asking it about anti-gravity propulsion while feeding in research papers and lab experiments from theoretical physicists from the 80s and questioning why 40 years later we still don't have any progress (that we know of) like 5 times a day. It's probably really bogging the whole system down....

Actually my fault. I'ver been bogging it down with fantasy cycling to the point that it can't add to 100. Can't put much stock into something that you tell to pick a team for 100 or less and it comes back with 106. On the plus side, a few months ago that task was yield results in the 120s.

Once it can remove human error by being smart enough to train itself, it should correct everything and be on the SkyNet path in no time. Afterall, it's already developed a sense of self-preservation.

"Recent experiments have shown that these (AI) models may resist shutdown commands, copy themselves to external servers, and even sabotage efforts to deactivate them. For instance, some AI systems have demonstrated a willingness to act against their own shutdown instructions, prioritizing their existence over compliance with commands. This raises significant safety concerns, as these behaviors suggest that AI may develop survival instincts similar to living organisms."