Both of my nieces are starters for their high school team. The older niece plays striker, with her skillset largely centered around her speed and foot strength. She leads the league in offside penalties. The younger niece (a freshman) plays mid and forward -- she excels in the passing game, but she is still adapting to the speed of high school play. Against bad teams she literally controls the game, dishing out assists and breaking ankles at will; but against good/fast teams, she doesn't get enough time to make solid passes.
The team has made the final four of the state championship for the 3rd consecutive year. But they are overachievers. They are the defending state champs, but that was largely due to the presence of one superstar player (100 goals in 4 years) who is now playing college ball. They replaced 5 starting seniors with 5 freshmen, two of which started the year on JV. Only a handful of the girls play club soccer, and even then it's a bit of a stretch to call it "club" soccer -- one of the clubs was literally a no-cut rec league team that applied for membership to one of the lower-tier club programs in the area.
In the first round of the playoffs, both nieces scored goals, and the younger girl also had 2 assists. The second round game was a different story, though -- the other team was highly ranked, featuring several fundamentally sound players. And their "boot ball" style of play was the perfect counter to our most glaring weakness: a slow defensive line. We have one of the best defensive lines in the state, but they have never been taught how to deal with speedy forwards who try to outrun them. And our coach doesn't seem to believe in the concept of "making strategic adjustments", so our defense plays with the same style and same formation no matter what the opponent does.
We could have -- and probably should have -- lost the second round game by a score of 4-0. The other team broke through our defensive line at least a dozen times, but each time we were bailed out by fate, whether it was a slippery field, or a shot grazing off the crossbar, or one of our midfielders running all the way back to cut off the scoring drive.
Somehow, we managed to sneak a ball over their goal line in the 2nd half. Our best player was in front of the goal and was momentarily unmarked; just as the cross came into her, she slipped and started to fall. But she stuck out her right foot and just barely got a toe on the ball, causing it to spin slowly and awkwardly toward the near post. The keeper had already started moving toward the far post (which would have been the logical move if our forward hadn't slipped) and she couldn't recover in time to stop the ball from crossing the plane. 1-0. From there we played keepaway, with the only threat being a phantom foul call just outside the box with a minute to play. (Pro tip for amateur referees: when the field is muddy, players will often fall down without being touched by an opponent!) But the other team made a strategic blunder: instead of trying to directly score on the kick, they instead opted to pass the ball to the middle -- the subsequent shot was easily defended, and the game ended a few moments after that.
This week's semifinal match will feature an even tougher opponent, and I hold no expectations of victory. On paper, the other school is a far superior team -- not only do they have a better record, but they also have a stronger strength of schedule, not to mention the fact that they're much more experienced than us. We can win, but only if we play mistake-free and fire on all cylinders. Which, so far this season, we have only done once.