But the reason why I tend to intuitively believe the Democrats here, beyond Trump’s total lack of honesty, is that they’re making arguments that make more sense to me. The Democrats are saying “let’s do everything that needs to be done,” while the .Republicans are trying to be more targeted, and offering some arguments that I consider specious, such as that if you give stimulus money to workers they will become lazy and stop seeking employment. That’s absurd.
Minus the rhetoric, I generally believe that the Republican idea of targeted action is almost always preferable to general action, EXCEPT in the case or emergency. This is an emergency so I favor the Democratic approach.