Seen the tweet tooSchefter reporting
Yes. Poor guy can't have a peaceful offseason.Pray for him and his family.
Reports are the woman was his girlfriend, but who knows.Yes. Poor guy can't have a peaceful offseason.Pray for him and his family.
Shefty saying people close to BMarsh are saying "He'll be ok!"...I'll wait to hear from what he heard from the guy who was next to the other guy.Again, just hope he is ok.@Jay_Glazer Dolphins source told me that team informed by docs that BMarshall is not in imminent danger at this point
I don't know. If he's abducted by aliens later, will he be the same player when he comes back? Could we please stop the baseless speculation - at least for 10 minutes or so.Obviously his health is the number 1 concern here...and I'm glad it looks like he's "ok" from the initial reports. but....looking ahead Im curious. If there are charges filed against him by his girlfriend for domestic violence could he lose a whole year to suspension once he's healthy? or since there is a lock out and no union contract is a suspension unenforceable?
Seemed like a pretty fair question given his prior troubles.I don't know. If he's abducted by aliens later, will he be the same player when he comes back? Could we please stop the baseless speculation - at least for 10 minutes or so.Obviously his health is the number 1 concern here...and I'm glad it looks like he's "ok" from the initial reports. but....looking ahead Im curious. If there are charges filed against him by his girlfriend for domestic violence could he lose a whole year to suspension once he's healthy? or since there is a lock out and no union contract is a suspension unenforceable?
Yeah, it was nothing if not fair.Seemed like a pretty fair question given his prior troubles.I don't know. If he's abducted by aliens later, will he be the same player when he comes back? Could we please stop the baseless speculation - at least for 10 minutes or so.Obviously his health is the number 1 concern here...and I'm glad it looks like he's "ok" from the initial reports. but....looking ahead Im curious. If there are charges filed against him by his girlfriend for domestic violence could he lose a whole year to suspension once he's healthy? or since there is a lock out and no union contract is a suspension unenforceable?
and what??? You want to sit around holding hands signing Kumbia for the next 10 minutes??Look I get it...speculation can get tiresome....and I mentioned that I certainly hope that Marshall is "ok". But bottom line is this guy is always walking on a thin line with the law, with the NFL and with the media. With the current labor situation and with Marshall's history I thought it was a question to ask even if it involved "speculation".I don't know. If he's abducted by aliens later, will he be the same player when he comes back? Could we please stop the baseless speculation - at least for 10 minutes or so.Obviously his health is the number 1 concern here...and I'm glad it looks like he's "ok" from the initial reports. but....looking ahead Im curious. If there are charges filed against him by his girlfriend for domestic violence could he lose a whole year to suspension once he's healthy? or since there is a lock out and no union contract is a suspension unenforceable?
There wasn't anything wrong with your question, especially given the context in which it was given.and what??? You want to sit around holding hands signing Kumbia for the next 10 minutes??Look I get it...speculation can get tiresome....and I mentioned that I certainly hope that Marshall is "ok". But bottom line is this guy is always walking on a thin line with the law, with the NFL and with the media. With the current labor situation and with Marshall's history I thought it was a question to ask even if it involved "speculation".I don't know. If he's abducted by aliens later, will he be the same player when he comes back? Could we please stop the baseless speculation - at least for 10 minutes or so.Obviously his health is the number 1 concern here...and I'm glad it looks like he's "ok" from the initial reports. but....looking ahead Im curious. If there are charges filed against him by his girlfriend for domestic violence could he lose a whole year to suspension once he's healthy? or since there is a lock out and no union contract is a suspension unenforceable?
I agree. When you read that is was Marshall who was stabbed is not surprising at all. Some guys are always in harms ways and Marshall is one of those guys. Every year someting crazy is going on in his life. Pretty sure this will not be the last time we read about Marshall.Hope he has a speedy recovery. The man has lived a very volatile life.
self defense? not saying it was, just saying what would make a wife do it.I keep trying to think what would make a wife take a knife to her husband but can't come up with anything.
She may very well be unstable but hes been arrested before for battery in domestic disputes.Brandon has a checkered past (well documented). But for a woman to stab her husband/boyfriend she eitherA) Feared for her lifeB) Or is seriously a nut barI hope for Brandon's sake it is B so he can cut her loose...and move on. Otherwise he is in some serious trouble with the NFL.But wow....to get stabbed in the stomach....crazy crazy. I have a strong feeling the girl is totally unstable.Yeah I am speculating.
Probably some temporarily. These incidents seem to knock his near term value down until the season starts, he puts up points then its kinda forgotten about.............until the next incident and the cycle starts all over again. It is getting to the point though where you have to wonder long long until his value is hurt permanently cause im still trying to think of a guy who's gotten into this much repeated trouble and finished his career in thr nfl.Now that we know Marshall's going to make a full recovery, let's discuss the most pertinent issue at hand... Has this incident affected Marshall's worth in dynasty? And if so, how much?
Yep, she's been arrested:http://blogs.palmbeachpost.com/thedailydolphin/2011/04/23/reports-dolphins-wr-brandon-marshall-hospitalized-after-stabbing/Has an arrest been made yet? You would think stabbing someone is a bad thing unless there's proof of self defense.
Headline you'll never see upon waking on a Saturday morning. "Peyton Manning stabbed in domestic dispute in ICU"
Maybe she was training to become a knife thrower in the circus. He was just being a supportive husband. What could go wrong?Brandon has a checkered past (well documented). But for a woman to stab her husband/boyfriend she eitherA) Feared for her lifeB) Or is seriously a nut barI hope for Brandon's sake it is B so he can cut her loose...and move on. Otherwise he is in some serious trouble with the NFL.But wow....to get stabbed in the stomach....crazy crazy. I have a strong feeling the girl is totally unstable.Yeah I am speculating.
This was not completely surprising, given Marshall's history. But, it would be a total shocker if the domestic dispute and stabbing involved Manning, Josh Freeman, Matt Ryan, Reggie Wayne, Wes Welker, MJD, Ray Rice, Torry Holt, etc. In fact, I would be floored to read this happening to most guys in the NFL. The fact that it happened to Marshall and I wasn't surprised (nor do I suspect most others were, as well) is indicative of the sort of image Marshall has cultivated throughout his brief career.Headline you'll never see upon waking on a Saturday morning. "Peyton Manning stabbed in domestic dispute in ICU"
Was this the same woman he had problems with while in Denver? If so, I can't believe there wasn't someone in the audience who didn't stand up and give a reason for them not to be married.Marshall's wife arrested, booked on battery Brandon Marshall's wife has been arrested and charged with one count of aggravated battery with a deadly weapon.It appears the early speculation that Marshall's wife, Michi Nogami-Marshall, was behind the stabbing that landed him in the hospital is true. A little more than two years ago, Marshall was arrested and charged with disorderly conduct in Atlanta after allegedly getting into a fight with Nogami-Marshall, then his fiancee, but the charges were dropped the next day. Details of the two's latest incident, such
That is why it is fair to say Marshall's long term dynasty value has suffered. If you could trade him straight up for another player with the same value statistically & age, then it may be wise to pull the trigger. Not now obviously, wait until mid season when his mental fortitude is nothing but an afterthought to most.This was not completely surprising, given Marshall's history. But, it would be a total shocker if the domestic dispute and stabbing involved Manning, Josh Freeman, Matt Ryan, Reggie Wayne, Wes Welker, MJD, Ray Rice, Torry Holt, etc. In fact, I would be floored to read this happening to most guys in the NFL. The fact that it happened to Marshall and I wasn't surprised (nor do I suspect most others were, as well) is indicative of the sort of image Marshall has cultivated throughout his brief career.Headline you'll never see upon waking on a Saturday morning. "Peyton Manning stabbed in domestic dispute in ICU"
Just got the police report, which labels it a "domestic violence" case. Brandon Marshall claims he slipped on a vase. His wife claims self D
Was there a McDonalds wrapper under the vase?From beat writer Omar Kelly:
Just got the police report, which labels it a "domestic violence" case. Brandon Marshall claims he slipped on a vase. His wife claims self D
She was cleaning the knife when his stomach got in the way.Was there a McDonalds wrapper under the vase?From beat writer Omar Kelly:
Just got the police report, which labels it a "domestic violence" case. Brandon Marshall claims he slipped on a vase. His wife claims self D
Marshall is expected to be discharged and will be allowed to go home today.
...
Sources have told the Dolphins Marshall was not violent in response to the stabbing. But ...
The club has questions about how the incident began. Club personnel realize most wives don't just wake up in the morning and stab their husband without provocation. This issue will be important because the NFL's personal conduct policy will come into play.
...
Marshall's domestic violence issues are not new. He was involed in a public incident with his current wife and had no less thant seven incidents with his previous girlfriend Rasheedah Whatley.
Wow, I wonder if he lied in the police report.. If so, and if his wife contends that it was indeed a stabbing in self defense, this is going to be pretty bad for Marshall.From beat writer Omar Kelly:
Just got the police report, which labels it a "domestic violence" case. Brandon Marshall claims he slipped on a vase. His wife claims self D