Me too: good foresight TIS
Exactly
9” Tree planted JUST on your side of that line + Balance in cash as Damages seems fair.
End result should be you getting as close to comparable a tree in that spot (and fully on your land) as possible. If for not other reason than this dude clearly doesn’t want a big tree there and is being shady/manipulative about it.
I see what you did there.
Yeah, part of me doesn't see him starting there either.
But, at the same time, I don't think the guy is dumb and you don't get to his position with his experience without having some smarts and common sense. I would hope by this point he realizes that I've been doing my homework on this matter. He should realize that I've gotten my own appraisal, warned him to leave the tree there until that was done, pushed for a survey, AND happened to find the company he spoke with regarding this tree already, etc. He almost certainly knows the law regarding this given his occupation and, at this point, realize that I probably do too.
If so, he's hopefully smart enough not to start with some ridiculous lowball offer, which $1-2K would be. Unfortunately for him, I've wasted a good bit of time already on this matter trying to get things done in a timely fashion before the tree was gone and I was stuck with a he said/she said type matter. Because of that, I don't plan on a lot of back and forth with him. If he starts reasonably, I'd like to just get it done and end it there. If he starts stupid low, then I'm pushing for the max and will be letting him know I know what I'm entitled to.
The fact of it is, he wouldn't just be on the hook for $15K if I pushed this legally. It could be far, far more if I pushed the replacement value aspect of this which I would be entitled to. I currently have no intention of going there but I will if I need to.