Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums
Welcome to Our Forums. Once you've registered and logged in, you're primed to talk football, among other topics, with the sharpest and most experienced fantasy players on the internet.
2011 In Season Dynasty Trade Thread (1 Viewer)
- Thread starter r0llin_game
- Start date
RhymesMcJuice
Footballguy
I didn't see your starting requirements, but it seems like you weakened your championship chance quite a bit. Long-term I like the trade though.
No way anyone gave up desean for Tolbert in a dynasty league.
Tickle Monster
Footballguy
Team A gave up:
Mike Tolbert
2012 5th
Team B gave up:
2012 2nd
Mike Tolbert
2012 5th
Team B gave up:
2012 2nd
ConnSKINS26
Footballguy
I'm lower than most on Desean, but the thing I find hilarious is the 2012 3rd thrown in on Desean's side of the deal.I can just see it now. "Ehhh, idk man, I'm REALLY high on Tolbert. JUST for Jackson? Maybe if you sweetened the pot a bit. Then maybe I could go through with this."
mulliganm
Footballguy
Trade last week:
Team A gives up:
Frank Gore
Mike Thomas
Pittsburgh
Team B gives up:
Daniel Thomas
Vincent Jackson
Green Bay
As Team B, I needed another running back for a title run this year with McFadden getting hurt. Vincent Jackson was WR4 behind AJ, Roddy, and Dez. Also wanted to get Pitt for the playoff weeks.
Team A gives up:
Frank Gore
Mike Thomas
Pittsburgh
Team B gives up:
Daniel Thomas
Vincent Jackson
Green Bay
As Team B, I needed another running back for a title run this year with McFadden getting hurt. Vincent Jackson was WR4 behind AJ, Roddy, and Dez. Also wanted to get Pitt for the playoff weeks.
I'm not buying it, I think the poster is trying to work a trade and lower deseans value with someone who reads fbg's.I'm lower than most on Desean, but the thing I find hilarious is the 2012 3rd thrown in on Desean's side of the deal.I can just see it now. "Ehhh, idk man, I'm REALLY high on Tolbert. JUST for Jackson? Maybe if you sweetened the pot a bit. Then maybe I could go through with this."
Dez
Footballguy
This really did happen if you don't believe just go to the link of the league - this league has been going on for 15 years and the guy trading for Tolbert has been there for 15 years is 6-2 this year and has made the playoffs like 8 years in a row...all that said I am shocked ... he is razor thin at RB but man this is nuts.I actually offered this guy 2 months ago Welker, P-Thomas and pick 1.10 in the rookied draft for D-Jackson and he turned me down.Whoops on his parthttp://www20.myfantasyleague.com/2011/home/20787#0I'm not buying it, I think the poster is trying to work a trade and lower deseans value with someone who reads fbg's.I'm lower than most on Desean, but the thing I find hilarious is the 2012 3rd thrown in on Desean's side of the deal.I can just see it now. "Ehhh, idk man, I'm REALLY high on Tolbert. JUST for Jackson? Maybe if you sweetened the pot a bit. Then maybe I could go through with this."
Wow, it is real. He might be the only person in the world to value Tolbert over desean in a dynasty league.This really did happen if you don't believe just go to the link of the league - this league has been going on for 15 years and the guy trading for Tolbert has been there for 15 years is 6-2 this year and has made the playoffs like 8 years in a row...all that said I am shocked ... he is razor thin at RB but man this is nuts.I actually offered this guy 2 months ago Welker, P-Thomas and pick 1.10 in the rookied draft for D-Jackson and he turned me down.Whoops on his parthttp://www20.myfantasyleague.com/2011/home/20787#0I'm not buying it, I think the poster is trying to work a trade and lower deseans value with someone who reads fbg's.I'm lower than most on Desean, but the thing I find hilarious is the 2012 3rd thrown in on Desean's side of the deal.I can just see it now. "Ehhh, idk man, I'm REALLY high on Tolbert. JUST for Jackson? Maybe if you sweetened the pot a bit. Then maybe I could go through with this."
Jersey35
Footballguy
This trade has caused a bit of a stir in my league, as the assistant commissioner has even hinted that he would consider vetoing the trade (the trade involves the commissioner's team) - and bear in mind that this is a league that has never once had the commissioner veto a trade. The commissioner is upset because he doesn't believe in vetoing ANY trade unless collusion is highly suspect, and now the assistant commissioner is taking it into his own hands to consider a veto because he thinks Team B is getting swindled.Is this trade really that bad? I don't see it at all.
Three trades went down this week in my 12 team PPR league:
A gave up Whitehurst, Charlie SEA QB;Mendenhall, Rashard PIT RB
B gave up Cassel, Matt KCC QB;Austin, Miles DAL WR; Year 2012 Round 2 Draft Pick from B
C gave up Battle, Jackie KCC RB; Year 2012 Round 2 Draft Pick from C
B gave up Starks, James GBP RB
D gave up Thomas, Daniel MIA RB;Fitzgerald, Larry ARI WR;Finley, Jermichael GBP TE; Year 2012 Round 1 Draft Pick from D
B gave up Mendenhall, Rashard PIT RB;Colston, Marques NOS WR;Graham, Jimmy NOS TE
A gave up Whitehurst, Charlie SEA QB;Mendenhall, Rashard PIT RB
B gave up Cassel, Matt KCC QB;Austin, Miles DAL WR; Year 2012 Round 2 Draft Pick from B
C gave up Battle, Jackie KCC RB; Year 2012 Round 2 Draft Pick from C
B gave up Starks, James GBP RB
D gave up Thomas, Daniel MIA RB;Fitzgerald, Larry ARI WR;Finley, Jermichael GBP TE; Year 2012 Round 1 Draft Pick from D
B gave up Mendenhall, Rashard PIT RB;Colston, Marques NOS WR;Graham, Jimmy NOS TE
The Comedian
Footballguy
Absolutely nothing wrong with this trade. Assistant commissioner is a doosh.'Jersey35 said:
thurston4040
Footballguy
12 team PPR
team A gives up:
Wes Welker
DeSean Jackson
team B gives up:
AJ Green
Jonathan Stewart
team A gives up:
Wes Welker
DeSean Jackson
team B gives up:
AJ Green
Jonathan Stewart
bengalbuck
Footballguy
That 2nd deal is ridiculous. Seems like Stafford and a 2012 1st isn't worth Rice by himself, much less with Vick also included. I saw some talk earlier in this thread about DJax's dynasty value and I think it is a lot lower than many here seem to think. There was a guy in one of my leagues shopping him around and he couldn't get much at all for him.
I personally had to make a tough call on him as I was offered him relatively cheaply and I decided to pass. He's just not that high above replacement level in a PPR league with his lack of catches and inconsistency.
RhymesMcJuice
Footballguy
I was surprised Holmes still held that much value.
jeter23
Footballguy
Me too!
The Man With No Name
Footballguy
Gave Vincent Jackson
Got Chris Johnson
Got Chris Johnson
Dr. Octopus
Footballguy
plus throw in a pick?
r0llin_game
Footballguy
I'm going to post the Week 6-9 trades sometimes this week in all of my leagues. I did this one though.
Sent: Matt Flynn, '12 1st (anywhere from .05-.08 most likely), '12 2nd (.07-.12)
Received: Matthew Stafford
My QBs were Hasselbeck, Kolb, Flynn, Mallett. My RB's are dreadful for this year, but have JC and Ryan Williams so they should be better and I start Gronk/Graham at TE/Flex. Currently 5-4 with 3 of my 4 losses by <7 points. Felt the trade gave me a top 6 dynasty QB and if JC recovers fully, I'll have a really young core of Stafford, JC, Starks, Williams, Mike Wallace, Gronk, Graham and can fill in some pieces.
Sent: Matt Flynn, '12 1st (anywhere from .05-.08 most likely), '12 2nd (.07-.12)
Received: Matthew Stafford
My QBs were Hasselbeck, Kolb, Flynn, Mallett. My RB's are dreadful for this year, but have JC and Ryan Williams so they should be better and I start Gronk/Graham at TE/Flex. Currently 5-4 with 3 of my 4 losses by <7 points. Felt the trade gave me a top 6 dynasty QB and if JC recovers fully, I'll have a really young core of Stafford, JC, Starks, Williams, Mike Wallace, Gronk, Graham and can fill in some pieces.
Skeletore Eh
Footballguy
Love the green Stewart side. Although welker may be better this year I'll take green by a long shot and Stewart over desean. Just don't like desean in ppr with the inconsistency and Stewart is asserting himself in Carolina as the superior back
Last edited by a moderator:
Skeletore Eh
Footballguy
Although it may help your championship aspirations this year, I like the other side quite a bit.Trade last week:Team A gives up:Frank GoreMike ThomasPittsburghTeam B gives upaniel ThomasVincent JacksonGreen BayAs Team B, I needed another running back for a title run this year with McFadden getting hurt. Vincent Jackson was WR4 behind AJ, Roddy, and Dez. Also wanted to get Pitt for the playoff weeks.
Travieso
Footballguy
Another Gore trade for comparisonA gives GoreB gives 2012 first (mid to late; too early to tell)Dem. Thomas
Although it may help your championship aspirations this year, I like the other side quite a bit.Trade last week:Team A gives up:Frank GoreMike ThomasPittsburghTeam B gives up
The Captain
Footballguy
12 Tesm PPR dynasty
Team A gives:
Tampa Mike & 2 2012 2nd rd picks
Team B gives:
Steve Smith (car)
Team A gives:
Tampa Mike & 2 2012 2nd rd picks
Team B gives:
Steve Smith (car)
mulliganm
Footballguy
To be fair, this is not a complete dynasty. We keep 12 from year to year (about half of the rosters) and starts 2 QB. I dont believe that I would have had room for Thomas. So, it basically boiled down to VJax for Gore. Granted, I lost the last two weeks with Gore including this past week while playing against VJax. The best laid plans and all...Although it may help your championship aspirations this year, I like the other side quite a bit.Trade last week:Team A gives up:Frank GoreMike ThomasPittsburghTeam B gives up
RhymesMcJuice
Footballguy
Woah, I thought it was Wallace.
The Captain
Footballguy
Will take some heat for this one.
Gave Tampa Mike + 2012 2nd & 3rd rd pick
Received Eric Decker
Non-PPR dynasty
Gave Tampa Mike + 2012 2nd & 3rd rd pick
Received Eric Decker
Non-PPR dynasty
jeter23
Footballguy
Wow, like this a lot for your team.
Which is his team? I like the team getting Smith.
Last edited by a moderator:
Wasn't my trade. I like Team A's side too, but B desperately needs a WR #3 and Little/Young haven't produced like that yet, Torrey seems to be a bit more along.
I actually corrected myself in the edit-- I prefer Torrey Smith to either of the three WRs, and I generally follow the "whoever got the best player wins" rule in dynasty trades.
BallsySmurf
Footballguy
What's your opinion on this trade I just pulled the trigger on:
I gave
Vincent Jackson
Benjarvis Green-Ellis
2013 2nd round pick
I get
Dez Bryant
2012 3rd round pick
I'm 3-6, in rebuild mode. Team I traded with is 7-2 with a chance to win it. Thoughts?
I gave
Vincent Jackson
Benjarvis Green-Ellis
2013 2nd round pick
I get
Dez Bryant
2012 3rd round pick
I'm 3-6, in rebuild mode. Team I traded with is 7-2 with a chance to win it. Thoughts?
Dez
Footballguy
This year in my start upTampa Mike was a 2nd round pick and Smith was a 11th round pick1 guy is in his early 20s the other in his early 30sI get Tampa Mike has not been good this year and Steve Smith has been great but I could never get this deal in the 1 league I have Steve Smith.At the start of the year you would have been lucky to get a 2nd for Smith and Williams would have needed muliple 1sts.
jeter23
Footballguy
Good move Smurf!
The Captain
Footballguy
What a difference 9 weeks and a new QB makes. Smith is the #3 wr in our league and I have a nice combination of youth and veterans at wr. This deal was made with one goal: pair Welker and Smith together and make a run at the title.'Dez said:
RhymesMcJuice
Footballguy
Not if you aren't in the playoff hunt. As good as Smith is he's 33 next year and there's no telling when the wheels finally fall off.
James Daulton
Footballguy
Brandon Marshall for 2012 #1 (no higher than #7)
buck56
Footballguy
16 team dynasty league, PPR starts next season
gave: Stewart,Mattews,Harvin,Mason Foster,2012 1st rounder(most likely 3-6),2012 2nd(11-16).
got: CJ3,Ringer,McCoy,Titus Young,Kelvin Sheperd,J.J.Watts,2013 4th rounder(early).
I have AJ,Holmes,Dez,Crabtree,Bowe,and Edwards at WR already and Bishop,Lauranits,Washington,Timmons,Hawthorne,Bowman,and Beason at LB, so it seemed like a good trade for me.
Hoping CJ3 comes around, seems like a buy low on him?
gave: Stewart,Mattews,Harvin,Mason Foster,2012 1st rounder(most likely 3-6),2012 2nd(11-16).
got: CJ3,Ringer,McCoy,Titus Young,Kelvin Sheperd,J.J.Watts,2013 4th rounder(early).
I have AJ,Holmes,Dez,Crabtree,Bowe,and Edwards at WR already and Bishop,Lauranits,Washington,Timmons,Hawthorne,Bowman,and Beason at LB, so it seemed like a good trade for me.
Hoping CJ3 comes around, seems like a buy low on him?
dickey moe
Fingerpicker
Dez
Footballguy
Last year during my start up I gave up my 2011 1st (ended up being pick 12) plus a 3rd and a 4th round start up picks just for Marshall.Talk about value falling out of the sky for a guy only traded for a mid 1st.No way I sell him for that.
The Comedian
Footballguy
I don't know why you keep comparing trades here to trades in your league in completely different situations. You made a really bad trade, no reason it should be used a measuring stick.
Instinctive
Footballguy
It's HenryMuto man. That's. How. It. Works.
James Daulton
Footballguy
The pick could well end being #10 or #11. Very tempting...
dickey moe
Fingerpicker
Marshall is a Top 10 WR in my PPR league and a proven talent. Not sure I'd trade him away for a lower 1st Round pick.
petenice15
Footballguy
I actually think Greg Little is a better long term prospect. He needs to obviously become more polished, but he's an animal when he has the ball in his hands. For this year, sure Smith seems to have more value, long term Little is a #1 and Young is a good bye week fill in on a potent offense.'jonboltz said:
