What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

*** 2012 Official Philadelphia Eagles Post Mortem Thread *** (1 Viewer)

Give me McCoy as HC with a Lovie Smith or Rob Ryan as DC
I'd be ecstatic if we could get Lovie as DC.
Agree, don't think it will happen, but would be truly awesome if we did. I know most aren't on the Rob Ryan train but no team he has ever been DC for has had a winning record in 9 years. His units usually rank in the 20s. Rex is brilliant, the Jets have had a Top 10 pass D for years with no pass rush talent at all. He can scheme a free rusher with only 4 or 5 coming better than anyone. Rob has good hair, not much more.
 
Give me McCoy as HC with a Lovie Smith or Rob Ryan as DC
I'd be ecstatic if we could get Lovie as DC.
I feel Lovie will get one of these openings at HC. Much like Andy, he's had success in the regular season and someone else will give him a shot.
I agree, he's a solid coach and his players play hard for him. He'd make a great duo with a good offensive mind/playcaller for the offense as his OC.
 
Give me McCoy as HC with a Lovie Smith or Rob Ryan as DC
I'd be ecstatic if we could get Lovie as DC.
I feel Lovie will get one of these openings at HC. Much like Andy, he's had success in the regular season and someone else will give him a shot.
I agree, he's a solid coach and his players play hard for him. He'd make a great duo with a good offensive mind/playcaller for the offense as his OC.
Still seems like a quick fix. Not someone who's going to miraculously become a GREAT coach and lead us to superbowls. C'mon, we all know most philly fans won't ever be happy with just pretty good and we'd hear message boards full of even more hate if we get lovie and he leads us to a few playoffs in a row without a superbowl. This team unfortunately needs to go boom or bust, because we all know if we don't win it all, it's considered a bust to most of the people who cheer for them. Gotta swing for a home run, not the safe bet, band-aid that gruden, cower, or lovie might give us. I say go young and fresh and go all in on a new guy with a new energy, but give him some experienced co ordinators if possible.
 
Personally I don't want to go out and hire a recently fired head coach, but in keeping with my earlier comments, Lovie's resume certainly begs serious consideration. His Bears defenses were always scheme proficient, and Lovie was able to plug and play lots of different pieces with great success. While his team's offensive rankings left something to be desired, that's more about Lovie having the right OC -- someone he can trust to do what he does -- in place. Also I think people underrate the difficulty in fielding a great modern offense in Chicago given the stadium conditions.

 
Personally I don't want to go out and hire a recently fired head coach, but in keeping with my earlier comments, Lovie's resume certainly begs serious consideration. His Bears defenses were always scheme proficient, and Lovie was able to plug and play lots of different pieces with great success. While his team's offensive rankings left something to be desired, that's more about Lovie having the right OC -- someone he can trust to do what he does -- in place. Also I think people underrate the difficulty in fielding a great modern offense in Chicago given the stadium conditions.
Speaking as a Bears fan...You guys could certainly do much worse than Lovie. I was disappointed to see him fired.
 
@BenVolinPBP: RT @mortreport: As expected, the Bills have hired Mike Pettine as defensive coordinator. Pettine had been with Jets previous four seasons.

 
Personally I don't want to go out and hire a recently fired head coach, but in keeping with my earlier comments, Lovie's resume certainly begs serious consideration. His Bears defenses were always scheme proficient, and Lovie was able to plug and play lots of different pieces with great success. While his team's offensive rankings left something to be desired, that's more about Lovie having the right OC -- someone he can trust to do what he does -- in place. Also I think people underrate the difficulty in fielding a great modern offense in Chicago given the stadium conditions.
Would you be OK with a Lovie (HC) and Norv (OC) combo?
 
Personally I don't want to go out and hire a recently fired head coach, but in keeping with my earlier comments, Lovie's resume certainly begs serious consideration. His Bears defenses were always scheme proficient, and Lovie was able to plug and play lots of different pieces with great success. While his team's offensive rankings left something to be desired, that's more about Lovie having the right OC -- someone he can trust to do what he does -- in place. Also I think people underrate the difficulty in fielding a great modern offense in Chicago given the stadium conditions.
Would you be OK with a Lovie (HC) and Norv (OC) combo?
Hmmmmmmmmm, I'm pretty tired of the Norv show. If I thought our squad was a veteran coach away from really competing, I might justify it, but I think we're looking at a possible blow up and rebuild mode so I would rather a younger mind who MAY turn out great.
 
I've been thinking a lot about what our expectations should be for this team and, I think we have to assume we're looking at two or three lean years.A lot of people think our offensive line magically gets fixed by Jason Peters return, but let's remember that a 320 pound lineman tearing his Achilles is a lot different than a 225 pound receiver. Peters could be 400+ pounds at this point, and his rehab and return to 100% in terms of fitness and conditioning have to be in serious question. While I certainly hope he regains his former level, we have to presume he never does. That leaves us with an offensive line full of questions.Meanwhile two of the other premier positions -- QB and CB -- are also major question marks. I'm not a Foles believer. To be clear, I think he could start for a season or two if need be, but I don't see him as ever becoming a plus QB that elevates the team into a serious offensive power. At CB we have two corners that ranked worse than many team's dime defenders according to PFF metrics. Nnamdi HAS to go, and DRC is hardly a playoff caliber CB1. :unsure:

 
I've been thinking a lot about what our expectations should be for this team and, I think we have to assume we're looking at two or three lean years.A lot of people think our offensive line magically gets fixed by Jason Peters return, but let's remember that a 320 pound lineman tearing his Achilles is a lot different than a 225 pound receiver. Peters could be 400+ pounds at this point, and his rehab and return to 100% in terms of fitness and conditioning have to be in serious question. While I certainly hope he regains his former level, we have to presume he never does. That leaves us with an offensive line full of questions.Meanwhile two of the other premier positions -- QB and CB -- are also major question marks. I'm not a Foles believer. To be clear, I think he could start for a season or two if need be, but I don't see him as ever becoming a plus QB that elevates the team into a serious offensive power. At CB we have two corners that ranked worse than many team's dime defenders according to PFF metrics. Nnamdi HAS to go, and DRC is hardly a playoff caliber CB1. :unsure:
I agree. I don't think we can expect a quick fix and return to greatness. The Eagles have 3 teams to climb over in their own division and one of them appears to have a premier QB for the next several years. The talent cupboard is certainly bare. I'm looking for someone to come in and reverse the downward trend they've been in for years and show promise and improvement. If it takes a few years, I'm fine with it as long as the trend is upward.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
'Amused to Death said:
'Jason Wood said:
I've been thinking a lot about what our expectations should be for this team and, I think we have to assume we're looking at two or three lean years.

A lot of people think our offensive line magically gets fixed by Jason Peters return, but let's remember that a 320 pound lineman tearing his Achilles is a lot different than a 225 pound receiver. Peters could be 400+ pounds at this point, and his rehab and return to 100% in terms of fitness and conditioning have to be in serious question. While I certainly hope he regains his former level, we have to presume he never does. That leaves us with an offensive line full of questions.

Meanwhile two of the other premier positions -- QB and CB -- are also major question marks. I'm not a Foles believer. To be clear, I think he could start for a season or two if need be, but I don't see him as ever becoming a plus QB that elevates the team into a serious offensive power. At CB we have two corners that ranked worse than many team's dime defenders according to PFF metrics. Nnamdi HAS to go, and DRC is hardly a playoff caliber CB1.

:unsure:
I agree. I don't think we can expect a quick fix and return to greatness. The Eagles have 3 teams to climb over in their own division and one of them appears to have a premier QB for the next several years. The talent cupboard is certainly bare. I'm looking for someone to come in and reverse the downward trend they've been in for years and show promise and improvement. If it takes a few years, I'm fine with it as long as the trend is upward.
We'll see how long Eli has left. :unsure: RGIII has Vick written all over him. Better QB but still not a premier QB. As far as CB's, many have thought that a lot of their failures have been b/c of the wide 9/safety play. I admit their play wasn't very good but it almost seemed like they stopped caring more than anything else. I think DRC provides the most upside but I would certainly keep at least one and possibly both and expect them to rebound. I also like the Hughes kid and have heard pretty good things. And Boykin while not an outside corner plays one of the most important positions in the new NFL.

As far as the overall talent, I think it is somewhere between the ones who think the cupboard is bare and the others who think the Eagles are just a player or two away. The Eagles appear to be an average to possibly slightly above average NFL team talent wise. Now the QB position, they are probably in the bottom 1/3rd. Teams who are as bad or worse at QB include Ten, Jac, Cle., KC, OAK, ARI, BUF seem pretty obvious and I'd add in NYJ and MIN. So I think that is one of the things that holds them back. But the rest of the offense has shown its explosiveness and defensively, they seem to have pieces, just missing putting them together.

And recent years has shown what happens when you put in one of these up and coming coaches with a team. Seattle, SF, Minnesota in recent years have seen coaches take relatively average rosters (at least based on their record) into playoff teams. I'm not saying the Eagles are as talented as Seattle or SF but I think some of their talent gets overrated just like any team who wins a lot. Carrol took over for a 5-11 team, Harbaugh for a 6-10 team and turned them around in a few years, both without what I would call stud QB's.

As far as the OL. I haven't read too much into Peter's recovery after the Eagles sucked but there was talk he could make it back for the playoffs or at least the SB if need be so I assume his recovery was on pace and he must've been doing something to justify that hope. And it seems like when freaks of nature like Peters get injured, they can get back from the injury easier than when an average player gets injured and I think worst case is that Peters is an average to slightly below average tackle. And sure the rest of the line was built in some respect to Mudd but I find it hard to believe 2 PB snubs in Kelce and Mathis won't be able to adjust. Heck, we had King Dunlap in there running Mudd's system (granted it wasn't very good but that seems to be more King than system), I feel that Mathis and Kelce can run a different system.

 
Jon Gruden was just sighted at the Diner by my house here in Manayunk (Philadelphia)...FYI.. :yes:
hmmmm isnt there one at the movie complex on main st? or was it one of the main st placesedit: manayunk diner is the only diner i can think of since Bob's Diner is in roxborough
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Mort and Schefter say he's already interviewed with them and there's mutual interest. I do not have the same interest. And my opinion is just as important. Right?

 
Article on philly.com that eagles are targeting Brian Kelly. I guess if you can't get one Kelly....
I'm. ND fan and I'm not sure how to take thisThe infatuation with the college guys is worrying me a bit. I don't mind them looking at Kelly and the mutual interest thing isn't as big a deal as ESPN makes it seem. If a college guy wants to come to the NFL then there would be obvious mutual interest if interviewed by the team.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
@Jeff_McLane: @mortreport did have some more detail on #Eagles interest in Kelly. Said 2 sides met after champ game/plan to meet when he returns from trip

 
'Jason Wood said:
I've been thinking a lot about what our expectations should be for this team and, I think we have to assume we're looking at two or three lean years.A lot of people think our offensive line magically gets fixed by Jason Peters return, but let's remember that a 320 pound lineman tearing his Achilles is a lot different than a 225 pound receiver. Peters could be 400+ pounds at this point, and his rehab and return to 100% in terms of fitness and conditioning have to be in serious question. While I certainly hope he regains his former level, we have to presume he never does. That leaves us with an offensive line full of questions.Meanwhile two of the other premier positions -- QB and CB -- are also major question marks. I'm not a Foles believer. To be clear, I think he could start for a season or two if need be, but I don't see him as ever becoming a plus QB that elevates the team into a serious offensive power. At CB we have two corners that ranked worse than many team's dime defenders according to PFF metrics. Nnamdi HAS to go, and DRC is hardly a playoff caliber CB1. :unsure:
Interesting thread. 9 months ago you all agreed that you had the close to the perfect draft and were killing the off season signings. Most were predicting between 8 to 10 wins. Now it's 2 to 3 lean years. Knock, knock...your team was better than Minny of 2011. You have more talent than Minny of 2012. You exclude QB for the equation and I take your roster over Wash heads up. We're not talking da raiders here so cheer up.
 
Edge Defenders: Jason Pierre-Paul (NYG) and Brandon Graham (PHI)No DeMarcus Ware in this team, with JPP having a year that deserved more plaudits than it got. Sure, his pressure numbers were down, but his work in the run game propelled him to the third-highest grade of all 4-3 defensive ends. Who was ahead of him? Well Graham for one, with the Eagle making the most of his limited time to be a pass rushing menace. Playing time kept him out of many end of year teams, but not this one.
Graham over Ware? Yes, Graham looked good in the games he got at the end, but this is silly. If Graham does pan out, though, it will be huge. Maybe a resurgence for Cole? (who?)And a ringing endorsement here:
In the middle, Ryans wasn’t quite able to maintain his strong level of play, but who else were we going to go with?
Suprised not to see Kerrigan on the team. He looked good when I saw him.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
'Please See Mine said:
'unckeyherb said:
Jon Gruden was just sighted at the Diner by my house here in Manayunk (Philadelphia)...FYI.. :yes:
hmmmm isnt there one at the movie complex on main st? or was it one of the main st placesedit: manayunk diner is the only diner i can think of since Bob's Diner is in roxborough
Manayunk Diner. It's crap-Someone should have told him to go to Bob's.
Old Eagle Tavern, FTW.
hah, that joint is 4 blocks from my house. For whatever reason whenever I walk my bulldog by he tries like hell to go inside.
 
'Please See Mine said:
'unckeyherb said:
Jon Gruden was just sighted at the Diner by my house here in Manayunk (Philadelphia)...FYI.. :yes:
hmmmm isnt there one at the movie complex on main st? or was it one of the main st placesedit: manayunk diner is the only diner i can think of since Bob's Diner is in roxborough
Manayunk Diner. It's crap-Someone should have told him to go to Bob's.
Old Eagle Tavern, FTW.
hah, that joint is 4 blocks from my house. For whatever reason whenever I walk my bulldog by he tries like hell to go inside.
There are always dogs in there whenever I go in, so that may have something to do with it . . . or he likes great beer.
 
Owner of Old Eagle has his dog in there alot i think, thats why your dog wants to go in. Bobs Diner kinda sucks anymore, was alot better a few years ago. Did I just hear that Reid made Doug Pederson his OC?

 
Please just no retreads, someone new and fresh. Looking forward to a new regime and thread. :thumbup:
I think people hear the word retread and think failure butI think sometimes the HC wasn't ready, didnt have the right Qb or had a bad GM. In the 14 years under Reid there have been 7 SB's won by so called retreads so I dont like writing anyone off. Im not in love with the guys out there but I think Del Rio got a bad wrap because he had an awful GM and no Qb which kills every young HC. I also like Lovie I think he was cursed with a bad GM and he has been awful at picking an OC which is his fault but maybe Howie can help find an OC just dont keep Marty.
Fair points. But I want to learn with a new guy, learn about him and be excited about what an unkown might bring. I don't want what I seen in Chicago for 9 years, or in San Diego for 8 years, or in Jacksonville for 4 years. Not saying they're all terrible and won't succeed somehwere else, i just want something new that I haven't seen before.
With that said I would still take a Lovie (HC)-- Norv (OC) combo.
Not sure why many want Lovie Smith. Lovie Smith is the defensive version of Andy Reid. Good coach, knows one side of the ball well, but is not the best in game manager. I'm just not sure the best coach for post Andy Reid is to bring in a coach with similar pros and cons.
 
How would you take to this combo?@pdomo: Talked to Monte Kiffin. Said he's definitely interested in returning to NFL for 2013 season. He and Gus Bradley coached together in TB.

 
Cowboys looking at Kiffin for DC.If I heard correctly on 97.5 a few minutes ago, thought thu said Lovie was in town for second interview, and are planning on meeting again with Brian Kelly. Sounds like those two are the front runners :mellow:

 
Cowboys looking at Kiffin for DC.If I heard correctly on 97.5 a few minutes ago, thought thu said Lovie was in town for second interview, and are planning on meeting again with Brian Kelly. Sounds like those two are the front runners :mellow:
Lovie in town today for his first interview. The Kelly "interview" was only a meeting about interviewing him when he's back from vacation.
 
Cowboys looking at Kiffin for DC.If I heard correctly on 97.5 a few minutes ago, thought thu said Lovie was in town for second interview, and are planning on meeting again with Brian Kelly. Sounds like those two are the front runners :mellow:
Lovie in town today for his first interview. The Kelly "interview" was only a meeting about interviewing him when he's back from vacation.
Oh I'm all screwed up. I thought they had already interviewed Lovie earlier in the week or over the weekend. Thanks for clarifying both.
 
I've been thinking a lot about what our expectations should be for this team and, I think we have to assume we're looking at two or three lean years.A lot of people think our offensive line magically gets fixed by Jason Peters return, but let's remember that a 320 pound lineman tearing his Achilles is a lot different than a 225 pound receiver. Peters could be 400+ pounds at this point, and his rehab and return to 100% in terms of fitness and conditioning have to be in serious question. While I certainly hope he regains his former level, we have to presume he never does. That leaves us with an offensive line full of questions.Meanwhile two of the other premier positions -- QB and CB -- are also major question marks. I'm not a Foles believer. To be clear, I think he could start for a season or two if need be, but I don't see him as ever becoming a plus QB that elevates the team into a serious offensive power. At CB we have two corners that ranked worse than many team's dime defenders according to PFF metrics. Nnamdi HAS to go, and DRC is hardly a playoff caliber CB1. :unsure:
I agree. I don't think we can expect a quick fix and return to greatness. The Eagles have 3 teams to climb over in their own division and one of them appears to have a premier QB for the next several years. The talent cupboard is certainly bare. I'm looking for someone to come in and reverse the downward trend they've been in for years and show promise and improvement. If it takes a few years, I'm fine with it as long as the trend is upward.
I hope you don't mean RG3 because with his injury his career is very much in question.
 
Ugh, this offseason is already dragging on. Dammit, I need some Eagles football.
Flyers Hockey Jan 19.
screw the nhl they did this #### one too many times. I dont get Kelly from ND either, where did he come from?
I'll come back to the NHL but I'm going to be very bitter about it. But I digress. Don't understand Kelly at all. I liked Chip b/c he brought a revolutionary offense with success behind him. This not so much with Brian. I was willing to gamble on Chip's system without any NFL background but not Brian. I'll be upset if he gets the nod. I can at least understand Lovie. Wouldn't love the hire but most of the best hires I don't seem to love. But assuming he can bring Marinelli or someone who along with him can spearhead the defense and hopefully he learned from his failures from an offensive standpoint and get the right guy.
 
Ugh, this offseason is already dragging on. Dammit, I need some Eagles football.
Flyers Hockey Jan 19.
screw the nhl they did this #### one too many times. I dont get Kelly from ND either, where did he come from?
I'll come back to the NHL but I'm going to be very bitter about it. But I digress. Don't understand Kelly at all. I liked Chip b/c he brought a revolutionary offense with success behind him. This not so much with Brian. I was willing to gamble on Chip's system without any NFL background but not Brian. I'll be upset if he gets the nod. I can at least understand Lovie. Wouldn't love the hire but most of the best hires I don't seem to love. But assuming he can bring Marinelli or someone who along with him can spearhead the defense and hopefully he learned from his failures from an offensive standpoint and get the right guy.
Brian Kelly has had good success on every team he has coached. He seems to be a good all around coach as he is not an devoted to just one side of the ball. Both his offense and defense improved every year. I like him more than chip Kelly. Not trying to say he's a perfect hire, but I would rather have him than most of these others being looked at. I still really like bradley from sea and would take him over kelly
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top