What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

*** 2012 Official Philadelphia Eagles Post Mortem Thread *** (1 Viewer)

Please just no retreads, someone new and fresh. Looking forward to a new regime and thread. :thumbup:
There's been plenty of solid retread HC's. I have no problem with going that route just as long as it's the right guy.
I don't really see any retreads worth it. Gruden hasn't coached since 2008. Cowher even longer. That is a long time to be out of football to try and keep up with the game. Gruden still runs that QB camp or whatever so I guess he keeps up with the game but either way, he doesn't even seem to be in the running. The other thing with retreads like that, many of those guys don't seem to have the same fire they once did. Nobody really mentioned it with Andy, but when they showed older video of Andy on the sidelines and in camp, he seemed pretty fired up. Towards the end, he seemed complacent. I think that is why fans would like a new coach. They want someone to bring energy and fire to this team.
 
@JasonLaCanfora: Hearing from more sources that Chip Kelly is in fact staying at Oregon. Still nothing official from him or the school however. So we'll see

**Im a little pumped about this Gus Bradley interview.

 
@JasonLaCanfora: Hearing from more sources that Chip Kelly is in fact staying at Oregon. Still nothing official from him or the school however. So we'll see**Im a little pumped about this Gus Bradley interview.
Tell me more about Bradley....not familiar with him.
Gus Bradley has been the Seahawks DC 4 years.Ranking in yards: 24th, 27th, 9th, 4thPoints: 25th, 25th, 7th, 1st.Steady improvement.
 
Lots of reports about Chip staying in Oregon now. I already thought he was cocky and arrogant, but this makes me hate this guy even more. Backs out from Tampa last year after they agree on a deal, then gives Cleve and Philly handjobs then runs back to his flashy ducks when Nike throws more money and promises at him. The guy doesn't deserve the nfl.

 
Lots of reports about Chip staying in Oregon now. I already thought he was cocky and arrogant, but this makes me hate this guy even more. Backs out from Tampa last year after they agree on a deal, then gives Cleve and Philly handjobs then runs back to his flashy ducks when Nike throws more money and promises at him. The guy doesn't deserve the nfl.
If he does do that, gotta think it will be the last time he gets the chance.
 
@JasonLaCanfora: Hearing from more sources that Chip Kelly is in fact staying at Oregon. Still nothing official from him or the school however. So we'll see**Im a little pumped about this Gus Bradley interview.
Tell me more about Bradley....not familiar with him.
Gus Bradley has been the Seahawks DC 4 years.Ranking in yards: 24th, 27th, 9th, 4thPoints: 25th, 25th, 7th, 1st.Steady improvement.
Bradley is on my Top 5 list as well. Devil's advocate view on him is that the improvement in the Seattle D has come after Pete Carroll arrived, who is a defensive guy and who coordinated Top 10 Defenses for the Jets, 49ers and Patriots (was HC) in the 90s. Would prefer an offensive guy but Bradley is the pick of the defensive candidates pretty easily.Once concern with a defensive HC is any time their OC has a good 2-3 yr period they will likely take off for a HC position of their own, as offensive guys are in such high demand. Good defensive assistants seem to be easier to hold on to.
 
Well if Chip is out, I hope its McCoy now.

QBs win championships. Andy's ability to groom QBs has kept us competitive. I would love another coach who can work with QBs.

Wouldnt be upset with some of the other names mentioned though.

 
@GeoffMosherCSN: I can confirm Adam Schefter's report of Chip Kelly staying at Oregon. Onto the next one for the Eagles (and, no, I don'r know who that is).

 
The quality in the field has pretty much thinned out now. For whatever reason the league has been deathly silent on Greg Roman who I thought would have been a good option, got to think the entire NFL knows something I don't. Interesting to see if anything comes of that, maybe he's just riding Harbaugh's coattails, who knows?

Now looks like McCoy > Daylight > Bradley > Jay Gruden > :yucky:

Read (PFT) the Browns now will look at Marc Trestman, :shock: Talk about lowering the bar, it's like Banner got knocked back by the head cheerleader so he heads straight for the girl with the lazy eye and the back brace.

 
Reuben Frank is :lmao:

Reuben Frank ‏@RoobCSN

Chip Kelly has announced he will interview for two NFL head coaching openings next year before returning to Oregon.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Well if Chip is out, I hope its McCoy now.

QBs win championships. Andy's ability to groom QBs has kept us competitive. I would love another coach who can work with QBs.

Wouldnt be upset with some of the other names mentioned though.
IMO its McCoy or bust. None of the other guys WOW me.
 
Its not often you get to hire the Coach of the Year as your new head coach.

Is Bruce Arians age enough to keep him out of serious consideration?

 
In Vegas this weekend, the other FBG staffers understandably peppered me with questions about who I wanted the Eagles to hire. And I kept telling them...the guy Lurie feels is the best answer. Not to be flip, but fans (ourselves included) have shown a stunning inability to effectively vet hires as they're made. People laughed at the Packers for Mike McCarthy. When the Saints hired Payton everyone pointed out that he lost his play-calling duties on two different teams. Named assistants like Rod Marinelli, Eric Mangini and Josh McDaniels were praised by many, and we know how they worked out.

When Reid was hired, we were all baffled. Even die hard NFL fans didn't know who Reid was, and the idea of hiring Brett Favre's QB coach -- a guy that had never been an OC or play-caller, seemed laughable.

I have confidence that Lurie understands what skills are required to be a successful head coach in Philly. That could mean McCoy. That could me Bradley. Or maybe it means Arians or someone we're not even talking about. I won't be overly excited or dismayed at whoever we hire. I'll reserve judgment until we see what kind of staff they put together and what they do on game day in 2013.

 
In Vegas this weekend, the other FBG staffers understandably peppered me with questions about who I wanted the Eagles to hire. And I kept telling them...the guy Lurie feels is the best answer. Not to be flip, but fans (ourselves included) have shown a stunning inability to effectively vet hires as they're made. People laughed at the Packers for Mike McCarthy. When the Saints hired Payton everyone pointed out that he lost his play-calling duties on two different teams. Named assistants like Rod Marinelli, Eric Mangini and Josh McDaniels were praised by many, and we know how they worked out. When Reid was hired, we were all baffled. Even die hard NFL fans didn't know who Reid was, and the idea of hiring Brett Favre's QB coach -- a guy that had never been an OC or play-caller, seemed laughable. I have confidence that Lurie understands what skills are required to be a successful head coach in Philly. That could mean McCoy. That could me Bradley. Or maybe it means Arians or someone we're not even talking about. I won't be overly excited or dismayed at whoever we hire. I'll reserve judgment until we see what kind of staff they put together and what they do on game day in 2013.
:goodposting: :goodposting:
 
In Vegas this weekend, the other FBG staffers understandably peppered me with questions about who I wanted the Eagles to hire. And I kept telling them...the guy Lurie feels is the best answer. Not to be flip, but fans (ourselves included) have shown a stunning inability to effectively vet hires as they're made. People laughed at the Packers for Mike McCarthy. When the Saints hired Payton everyone pointed out that he lost his play-calling duties on two different teams. Named assistants like Rod Marinelli, Eric Mangini and Josh McDaniels were praised by many, and we know how they worked out.

When Reid was hired, we were all baffled. Even die hard NFL fans didn't know who Reid was, and the idea of hiring Brett Favre's QB coach -- a guy that had never been an OC or play-caller, seemed laughable.

I have confidence that Lurie understands what skills are required to be a successful head coach in Philly. That could mean McCoy. That could me Bradley. Or maybe it means Arians or someone we're not even talking about. I won't be overly excited or dismayed at whoever we hire. I'll reserve judgment until we see what kind of staff they put together and what they do on game day in 2013.
Thats not what we do in philly! :angry:
 
The quality in the field has pretty much thinned out now. For whatever reason the league has been deathly silent on Greg Roman who I thought would have been a good option, got to think the entire NFL knows something I don't. Interesting to see if anything comes of that, maybe he's just riding Harbaugh's coattails, who knows?Now looks like McCoy > Daylight > Bradley > Jay Gruden > :yucky: Read (PFT) the Browns now will look at Marc Trestman, :shock: Talk about lowering the bar, it's like Banner got knocked back by the head cheerleader so he heads straight for the girl with the lazy eye and the back brace.
I think I read somewhere that Greg Roman doesn't do as much as you might think. Jim Harbaugh calls a lot of stuff and the RB and WR coaches are very involved in the gameplanning and stuff like that.
 
In Vegas this weekend, the other FBG staffers understandably peppered me with questions about who I wanted the Eagles to hire. And I kept telling them...the guy Lurie feels is the best answer. Not to be flip, but fans (ourselves included) have shown a stunning inability to effectively vet hires as they're made. People laughed at the Packers for Mike McCarthy. When the Saints hired Payton everyone pointed out that he lost his play-calling duties on two different teams. Named assistants like Rod Marinelli, Eric Mangini and Josh McDaniels were praised by many, and we know how they worked out.

When Reid was hired, we were all baffled. Even die hard NFL fans didn't know who Reid was, and the idea of hiring Brett Favre's QB coach -- a guy that had never been an OC or play-caller, seemed laughable.

I have confidence that Lurie understands what skills are required to be a successful head coach in Philly. That could mean McCoy. That could me Bradley. Or maybe it means Arians or someone we're not even talking about. I won't be overly excited or dismayed at whoever we hire. I'll reserve judgment until we see what kind of staff they put together and what they do on game day in 2013.
Thats not what we do in philly! :angry:
:lmao: :lmao:
 
Well if Chip is out, I hope its McCoy now.

QBs win championships. Andy's ability to groom QBs has kept us competitive. I would love another coach who can work with QBs.

Wouldnt be upset with some of the other names mentioned though.
IMO its McCoy or bust. None of the other guys WOW me.
mehh,

Not all that impressed with McCoy. Not really sure what exactly he's done with Peyton and he coached the Panthers? Delhomme and that offense?

Sorry, not buying how he is a hot candidate unless I'm missing something on his resume.

I'm still in the Jay Gruden camp. He's getting more out of Dalton than he should. And I see no way that Lurie goes with a defensive guy as the HC

 
In Vegas this weekend, the other FBG staffers understandably peppered me with questions about who I wanted the Eagles to hire. And I kept telling them...the guy Lurie feels is the best answer. Not to be flip, but fans (ourselves included) have shown a stunning inability to effectively vet hires as they're made. People laughed at the Packers for Mike McCarthy. When the Saints hired Payton everyone pointed out that he lost his play-calling duties on two different teams. Named assistants like Rod Marinelli, Eric Mangini and Josh McDaniels were praised by many, and we know how they worked out.

When Reid was hired, we were all baffled. Even die hard NFL fans didn't know who Reid was, and the idea of hiring Brett Favre's QB coach -- a guy that had never been an OC or play-caller, seemed laughable.

I have confidence that Lurie understands what skills are required to be a successful head coach in Philly. That could mean McCoy. That could me Bradley. Or maybe it means Arians or someone we're not even talking about. I won't be overly excited or dismayed at whoever we hire. I'll reserve judgment until we see what kind of staff they put together and what they do on game day in 2013.
:goodposting: More on the bolded. When the Packers were looking for a head coach the hot name was Brad Childress. Green Bay was rumored to interview him but Minnesota hired him before they had a chance. Many GB fans were upset that Green Bay didn't act more quickly and they lost their chance. They were even more upset with Thompson hired a no-name in McCarthy. Who the heck was he? I'm happy with how that turned out. It's not always the hot sexy name that turns out to be the next great coach.

 
Well if Chip is out, I hope its McCoy now.

QBs win championships. Andy's ability to groom QBs has kept us competitive. I would love another coach who can work with QBs.

Wouldnt be upset with some of the other names mentioned though.
IMO its McCoy or bust. None of the other guys WOW me.
mehh,

Not all that impressed with McCoy. Not really sure what exactly he's done with Peyton and he coached the Panthers? Delhomme and that offense?

Sorry, not buying how he is a hot candidate unless I'm missing something on his resume.

I'm still in the Jay Gruden camp. He's getting more out of Dalton than he should. And I see no way that Lurie goes with a defensive guy as the HC
McCoy was QB coach of the Panthers under Fox. Got a lot out of Delhomme considering he really was pretty marginal ability wise, but had consistent success and a Pro Bowl spot one year. Became Denver OC in 2009 (under McDaniels) and got 2 3500 yard passing seasons out of Kyle Orton where his QB rating was 10 points higher than either before or after those 2 years under McCoy. In 2011 changed the offense mid season after the switch to Tebow @ QB, and was able to win a playoff game with a guy who simply is not an NFL passer.

Admittedly you wouldn't expect anything less than what's being done this year with Manning, but I like McCoy for what he's done before this year. He's a coach who will get the most out of the talent that the team has, and has shown he can do that with different players and different teams.

Gruden is not a bad option as well, but doesn't have the same track record. McCoy has shown he can replicate his success, Gruden hasn't yet, but still might in the future.

 
More on the bolded. When the Packers were looking for a head coach the hot name was Brad Childress. Green Bay was rumored to interview him but Minnesota hired him before they had a chance. Many GB fans were upset that Green Bay didn't act more quickly and they lost their chance. They were even more upset with Thompson hired a no-name in McCarthy. Who the heck was he? I'm happy with how that turned out. It's not always the hot sexy name that turns out to be the next great coach.
True, Ted Thompson is quietly one of the best GMs in the league. Aaron Rogers was his first draft choice. :homerun:I'd trade Howie straight up for TT
 
In Vegas this weekend, the other FBG staffers understandably peppered me with questions about who I wanted the Eagles to hire. And I kept telling them...the guy Lurie feels is the best answer. Not to be flip, but fans (ourselves included) have shown a stunning inability to effectively vet hires as they're made. People laughed at the Packers for Mike McCarthy. When the Saints hired Payton everyone pointed out that he lost his play-calling duties on two different teams. Named assistants like Rod Marinelli, Eric Mangini and Josh McDaniels were praised by many, and we know how they worked out. When Reid was hired, we were all baffled. Even die hard NFL fans didn't know who Reid was, and the idea of hiring Brett Favre's QB coach -- a guy that had never been an OC or play-caller, seemed laughable. I have confidence that Lurie understands what skills are required to be a successful head coach in Philly. That could mean McCoy. That could me Bradley. Or maybe it means Arians or someone we're not even talking about. I won't be overly excited or dismayed at whoever we hire. I'll reserve judgment until we see what kind of staff they put together and what they do on game day in 2013.
Very good post, Jason. This is where I stand too. But I don't want Bradley. He seems like the type of guy who's message wears thin real fast. A Mike singletary or Rex Ryan type to be loud and curse but with no substance. Those types make good DCs but terrible head coaches.
 
Well if Chip is out, I hope its McCoy now.

QBs win championships. Andy's ability to groom QBs has kept us competitive. I would love another coach who can work with QBs.

Wouldnt be upset with some of the other names mentioned though.
IMO its McCoy or bust. None of the other guys WOW me.
mehh,

Not all that impressed with McCoy. Not really sure what exactly he's done with Peyton and he coached the Panthers? Delhomme and that offense?

Sorry, not buying how he is a hot candidate unless I'm missing something on his resume.

I'm still in the Jay Gruden camp. He's getting more out of Dalton than he should. And I see no way that Lurie goes with a defensive guy as the HC
I'd rather McCoy over Gruden. Gruden will have to live in his brothers shadow in this town because he'll always be the Gruden we didn't want for some people in the media who will never let that go. I too was skeptical on McCoy. I thought he was just a guy there holding the playsheet while Peyton does his thing. I think he's more than that though. He's a guy who adapts his scheme to the QB and players he has. He played to Delhomme's strengths and got him to a pro bowl level for a couple years. He got Tebow in a system to promote his strengths. He knew enough this year to be able to let Peyton do his thing and Peyton has given him a glowing endorsement. To me, this is the only guy I want out there now.

 
Well if Chip is out, I hope its McCoy now.

QBs win championships. Andy's ability to groom QBs has kept us competitive. I would love another coach who can work with QBs.

Wouldnt be upset with some of the other names mentioned though.
IMO its McCoy or bust. None of the other guys WOW me.
mehh,

Not all that impressed with McCoy. Not really sure what exactly he's done with Peyton and he coached the Panthers? Delhomme and that offense?

Sorry, not buying how he is a hot candidate unless I'm missing something on his resume.

I'm still in the Jay Gruden camp. He's getting more out of Dalton than he should. And I see no way that Lurie goes with a defensive guy as the HC
McCoy was QB coach of the Panthers under Fox. Got a lot out of Delhomme considering he really was pretty marginal ability wise, but had consistent success and a Pro Bowl spot one year. Became Denver OC in 2009 (under McDaniels) and got 2 3500 yard passing seasons out of Kyle Orton where his QB rating was 10 points higher than either before or after those 2 years under McCoy. In 2011 changed the offense mid season after the switch to Tebow @ QB, and was able to win a playoff game with a guy who simply is not an NFL passer.

Admittedly you wouldn't expect anything less than what's being done this year with Manning, but I like McCoy for what he's done before this year. He's a coach who will get the most out of the talent that the team has, and has shown he can do that with different players and different teams.

Gruden is not a bad option as well, but doesn't have the same track record. McCoy has shown he can replicate his success, Gruden hasn't yet, but still might in the future.
ThanksDidn't know he was there under McDaniel as well. I guess if he can may Delhomme, Orton and Tebow look like real QBs he would be OK with Foles :unsure:

 
Wasn't enamored before. Definitely not now. We can get ra ra guys in any round. We need a stud at #4.
Is it safe to say stay away from the ND players in the draft this year?
I think that is more of an indication how strong Bama is. Te'o will take a tumble. Eifert played well and probably cemented his 1st round spot but Walter football only had those 2 mocked in the first 3 rounds so I don't exactly think there were a ton of NFL prospects for this year to begin with.
 
Wasn't enamored before. Definitely not now. We can get ra ra guys in any round. We need a stud at #4.
Is it safe to say stay away from the ND players in the draft this year?
I think that is more of an indication how strong Bama is. Te'o will take a tumble. Eifert played well and probably cemented his 1st round spot but Walter football only had those 2 mocked in the first 3 rounds so I don't exactly think there were a ton of NFL prospects for this year to begin with.
More of a joke because I know Mel Kiper is going to slopper all over them like he did Claussen that one year. They have some nice prospects though.
 
Well if Chip is out, I hope its McCoy now.

QBs win championships. Andy's ability to groom QBs has kept us competitive. I would love another coach who can work with QBs.

Wouldnt be upset with some of the other names mentioned though.
IMO its McCoy or bust. None of the other guys WOW me.
mehh,

Not all that impressed with McCoy. Not really sure what exactly he's done with Peyton and he coached the Panthers? Delhomme and that offense?

Sorry, not buying how he is a hot candidate unless I'm missing something on his resume.

I'm still in the Jay Gruden camp. He's getting more out of Dalton than he should. And I see no way that Lurie goes with a defensive guy as the HC
I'd rather McCoy over Gruden. Gruden will have to live in his brothers shadow in this town because he'll always be the Gruden we didn't want for some people in the media who will never let that go. I too was skeptical on McCoy. I thought he was just a guy there holding the playsheet while Peyton does his thing. I think he's more than that though. He's a guy who adapts his scheme to the QB and players he has. He played to Delhomme's strengths and got him to a pro bowl level for a couple years. He got Tebow in a system to promote his strengths. He knew enough this year to be able to let Peyton do his thing and Peyton has given him a glowing endorsement. To me, this is the only guy I want out there now.
AT the top of my board, but Jason's right....I trust Lurie with this one, and won't lose it if he hires someone I've never heard of.
 
I think the pick is going to be Joeckel but I don't know how I will react if it's Teo. He may have just had a bad game last night but from I saw I was not impressed at all.

 
I think the pick is going to be Joeckel but I don't know how I will react if it's Teo. He may have just had a bad game last night but from I saw I was not impressed at all.
I've watched him every game for 2 years and he's legit. ND was the #1 team in the country and not one person looked good for them...that speaks more to Alabama then anything.I still want a 3-4 and Jarvis Jones the most but I'd be happy with Joeckel as well.
 
I think the pick is going to be Joeckel but I don't know how I will react if it's Teo. He may have just had a bad game last night but from I saw I was not impressed at all.
I've watched him every game for 2 years and he's legit. ND was the #1 team in the country and not one person looked good for them...that speaks more to Alabama then anything.I still want a 3-4 and Jarvis Jones the most but I'd be happy with Joeckel as well.
Would be absolutely giddy if Jones dropped to them but unless there is some shifting between the combine and the draft (which is a very good chance) I don't see him dropping to 4.
 
I think the pick is going to be Joeckel but I don't know how I will react if it's Teo. He may have just had a bad game last night but from I saw I was not impressed at all.
I've watched him every game for 2 years and he's legit. ND was the #1 team in the country and not one person looked good for them...that speaks more to Alabama then anything.I still want a 3-4 and Jarvis Jones the most but I'd be happy with Joeckel as well.
Would be absolutely giddy if Jones dropped to them but unless there is some shifting between the combine and the draft (which is a very good chance) I don't see him dropping to 4.
I think we'll have a decent shot if/ when a QB launches into the top 3. That seems to always happen and the 3 teams that pick ahead of us are all QB starved at the moment.
 
I think the pick is going to be Joeckel but I don't know how I will react if it's Teo. He may have just had a bad game last night but from I saw I was not impressed at all.
I've watched him every game for 2 years and he's legit. ND was the #1 team in the country and not one person looked good for them...that speaks more to Alabama then anything.I still want a 3-4 and Jarvis Jones the most but I'd be happy with Joeckel as well.
Would be absolutely giddy if Jones dropped to them but unless there is some shifting between the combine and the draft (which is a very good chance) I don't see him dropping to 4.
I think we'll have a decent shot if/ when a QB launches into the top 3. That seems to always happen and the 3 teams that pick ahead of us are all QB starved at the moment.
You guys aren't scared of Jones' medical red flag? It's a pretty major one and could be a career shortener.
 
I think the pick is going to be Joeckel but I don't know how I will react if it's Teo. He may have just had a bad game last night but from I saw I was not impressed at all.
I've watched him every game for 2 years and he's legit. ND was the #1 team in the country and not one person looked good for them...that speaks more to Alabama then anything.I still want a 3-4 and Jarvis Jones the most but I'd be happy with Joeckel as well.
Would be absolutely giddy if Jones dropped to them but unless there is some shifting between the combine and the draft (which is a very good chance) I don't see him dropping to 4.
I think we'll have a decent shot if/ when a QB launches into the top 3. That seems to always happen and the 3 teams that pick ahead of us are all QB starved at the moment.
You guys aren't scared of Jones' medical red flag? It's a pretty major one and could be a career shortener.
I'm fine with it. That was in his freshman year and he looked amazing this year. I really want a 3-4 D hereHere's a write-up ESPN did after be declared.
 
I have no reason to think this other than personal opinion, but I think we're going to go OT with the 4th pick.
Even if Joeckel isnt availible? Him not being there really worries me.
If he's not there then no way we take OT at 4. The drop off is simply too big. However with Andy Reid picking at #1, I wouldn't be surprised if he took him there.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I have no reason to think this other than personal opinion, but I think we're going to go OT with the 4th pick.
Even if Joeckel isnt availible? Him not being there really worries me.
If he's not there then no way we take OT at 4. The drop off is simply too big.
That's not necessarily true. After workouts you could have 4 OT's gone in the top 15JoeckelJake Matthews- Texas A&MEric Fisher-Central Michigan Taylor Lewan- MichiganIf that's the position they want then there should be one worth taking if Joeckel is gone.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top