hauser42
Footballguy
Is this tool still posting this garbage? Gross.Take a look at their records and only difference is the Super Bowl. Mike Sherman with a Super Bowl has a loosing playoff record when you take away his one year super bowl run. He has a great regular season record has he has beaten up one of the bottom two divisions in the NFL since he has been in the league. Look into the numbers before you post, I took the time before last year and was amazed how close they really are.Pipes said:Agreed...horrible take.Calling him Sherman with a Super Bowl run is still one of the dumbest possible things to post.
2013: McCarthy gave big letters promise for running game to be better - Got lacy the next year and have been fantastic.
2014: McCarthy gave big letters for defense to be better - defense was top 10 unit for the 2nd half of the season (and crushed Seattle in Seattle; loss was due to special teams, not the defense).
2015: McCarthy gave big letters promise for special teams to be better - jury is still out but week 1 was very promising... fantastic tackling, easily recovered onside kick, and long returns.
McCarthy: 69.5% regular season, 54% (7-6) postseason record
Sherman: 59.4% regular season, 33% (2-4) postseason record
Belichick, regarded as one of the best coaches in the league, has a 66% win rate, lower than McCarthy.
His coaching themes are rotating assistants every couple years so they get the perspective of various units (i.e., Edgar Bennett going from special teams coach, to RB coach, to WR coach, to offensive coordinator). In addition, Philbin is now a head coach and Clements will be a head coach somewhere in a few years, so he already has a solid coaching tree (which is the best compliment you can give a coach).
On what planet are those two remotely comparable?
I feel bad for you that you can't appreciate what a wonderful job McCarthy has done coaching this team. There are 32 teams in this league and you can't win the Super Bowl every year. McCarthy would not last a week without a head coaching job if the Packers were to let him go.
Philbin was here as the line coach before McCarthy showed up, he as much as Sherman's tree as he is McCarthy.Is this tool still posting this garbage? Gross.Take a look at their records and only difference is the Super Bowl. Mike Sherman with a Super Bowl has a loosing playoff record when you take away his one year super bowl run. He has a great regular season record has he has beaten up one of the bottom two divisions in the NFL since he has been in the league. Look into the numbers before you post, I took the time before last year and was amazed how close they really are.Pipes said:Agreed...horrible take.Calling him Sherman with a Super Bowl run is still one of the dumbest possible things to post.
2013: McCarthy gave big letters promise for running game to be better - Got lacy the next year and have been fantastic.
2014: McCarthy gave big letters for defense to be better - defense was top 10 unit for the 2nd half of the season (and crushed Seattle in Seattle; loss was due to special teams, not the defense).
2015: McCarthy gave big letters promise for special teams to be better - jury is still out but week 1 was very promising... fantastic tackling, easily recovered onside kick, and long returns.
McCarthy: 69.5% regular season, 54% (7-6) postseason record
Sherman: 59.4% regular season, 33% (2-4) postseason record
Belichick, regarded as one of the best coaches in the league, has a 66% win rate, lower than McCarthy.
His coaching themes are rotating assistants every couple years so they get the perspective of various units (i.e., Edgar Bennett going from special teams coach, to RB coach, to WR coach, to offensive coordinator). In addition, Philbin is now a head coach and Clements will be a head coach somewhere in a few years, so he already has a solid coaching tree (which is the best compliment you can give a coach).
On what planet are those two remotely comparable?
I feel bad for you that you can't appreciate what a wonderful job McCarthy has done coaching this team. There are 32 teams in this league and you can't win the Super Bowl every year. McCarthy would not last a week without a head coaching job if the Packers were to let him go.
I don't see the high regard for McCarthy. He has blown two great chances at a Super Bowl by being out coached. 15-1 during the regular season and he blows it in the first game in the playoffs at home. Last year he takes the foot of the pedal and plays not to loose in the NFC Championship. His loyalty to a poor special teams coach finally cost the team a game also in the NFC Championship.
Before Sherman and McCarthy teams dreaded coming to Green Bay during the playoffs. Since the have been coaching the Packers home playoff record is 4-5 (Sherman 1-2, McCarthy 3-3). Home field advantage is huge in the playoffs but our last two coaches have squandered it.
McCarthy is a good coach but he is not this top end guy that everyone sees. The numbers prove that he is not an elite coach.
 
	 
 
		 
 
		 
 
		 
 
		 
 
		 
 
		 
 
		 
 
		 
  
 
		 
 
		 
 
		 
 
		 
 
		 
 
		 
 
		 
 
		 
 
		 
	 
 
		 
 
		 
 
		