I see your thought process and reasoning. Here is mine.
ok, Ross is not into retreads. Guys who were HC somewhere else isn’t really his style. Good bad or indifferent. Not saying I agree because I think someone like Petersen is a good match here (more so than harbaugh who has never coached a qb he didn’t think he was better than).
now let’s look at McDaniel vs the other OC we have hired to be coaches. Philbin may or may not have been a real OC, but something we have learned from the Green Bay coaching tree is those guys (philbin, McCarthy) etc seem to not be very good. Adam gase had manning and from what I heard around town a pretty big bar tab (if you know what I mean).
mcdaniel has been on every good coaching staff the past 16 years. Shanahan in Denver, kubiak in Houston, shanny again in Washington, the falcons under Quinn (other shanny was his OC) and then Kyle S in San Fran. He did have a stint as a college rb coach for a year and a year in Cleveland but that’s a hell of a coaching tree resume.
finally: this from Pierre garçon (remember is career fantasy year in Washington? His wr coach was McDaniel)
Garçon endorses McDaniel as next coach for Miami.
again I’m not saying he is my first choice (I’d list them personally as Petersen, daboll, McDaniel, Quinn, the ghost of Jim harbaugh, mike Shula, tony sopranos son, steve spurrier, and finally me) but he graduated from Yale and went right into coaching. His running game is ridiculous and he (and shanny) are doing all this with likely the worst qb in the playoffs that didn’t retire after his last game