I've had the Pixel XL for about a week now and thought I'd weigh in with opinions in cases other were considering. After reading many, many reviews I came down to the Google Pixel and the Samsung S8. The S8 had the edge on hardware (full use of screen/no dead space, water proof, etc). The Pixel is one step down hardware wise IMO but is pure android OS and gets immediate updates. The margin on these two was so razor thin I finally decided to just get whichever I could get cheaper on eBay and that was the Pixel XL at $425. I was wary of buying a used phone on eBay but if your careful and pick a user with good rating it's better then getting new from the vendor IMO (I basically paid half price). The phone is in pristine condition. Not a blemish or nick anywhere.
The phone is extremely snappy and responsive which is exactly what I had read and expected. Don't like the dead space on the bottom of the phone but I knew that was the case so not really a knock. The camera is top notch with a 12.3 MB in the rear and a 8.0 MB in front. My old phone was a 4 MB so this is quite a step up. I no longer feel like I have a phone that can take a picture in a pinch but that I have a real camera that happens to function in other capacities. Aesthetics are kind of meh with the two tone look in back but it will have a screen protector on it so doesn't really matter. The speaker is on the bottom and depending on how you hold your phone it could cover the speaker. Why they don't put the speakers on the front of the phone is beyond me. The buttons are all well placed (i.e. power, volume and fingerprint scanner) and easy to access. With pictures and contacts backed up to my Google account setup was a breeze.
Bottom line is that if money weren't an issue I likely would have opted for the S8. Since money was a consideration I couldn't be more pleased with the Google Pixel as a solid second choice.
- Pros: Software and camera
- Cons: Doesn't use full screen, not waterproof, speaker on bottom