Sorry, you're crazy. Obviously the Colts line is better than Miami. But to ssay Edge cannot carry a team is nuts. Believe it or not, Miami does have weapons on offense to take some pressure off of Edge.
Besides, that isn't what I am arguing here.
Would Ronnie Brown have a better chance at producing in Miami then Edge??
With Edge, you know what you're getting. With Ronnie Brown, you're getting...
I think we may be missing the point here. Would Miami be better with edge? Sure. Is he a good fit here? No. Edge is a great back with a lot of talent and for a team that needs him, he will be a special player. However, he is not what Miami needs now. Miami needs room to manuver in the salary cap and for the next few years, they need draft picks. Edge doesn't give them salary flexibility, and he definitely will not give them cap space. As I said, if we rewind a year in terms of the RW fiasco and have wanny and speilman running the show with edge for surtain or a number 1 or whatever, then this is a no brainer. However, this years' dolphins ain't last years' dolphins. Championship aspirations are on hold at the moment. A solid foundation is what we are builing now. With edge in the fold, McMichael is bye bye next year and so are some other players on D just to get to the cap, forget about spending. Miami is setting things up for cap room in 2 years and edge's contract demands would preclude that.
Edge in Arizona is fine with me. He ain't gonna be a fin.
Edit to add: I called the "edge not a phin" thing last year right after the RW fiasco. If he was willing to sign a friendly contract for his hometown team, maybe, but this is full priced edge we are talking about.