krista4
Footballguy
My favorite author!!Could be one of those Murakami cats that just casually observes,talks, and has nothing to do with the milk
My favorite author!!Could be one of those Murakami cats that just casually observes,talks, and has nothing to do with the milk
1. NoCouple more random questions:
1. Did you let the fact that this is going onto a playlist effect your draft at all?
I was thinking about this as I stare at metal albums, that I don't think people will like at all, so I skipped over them.
2. Those who drafted live albums - and be honest now - what % was preferring those versions of the songs to the albums and what % was a "more bang for your buck" approach?
If there were decent full Radiohead concerts on Spotify, I would have gone that route because like I've said before - I prefer the sound of songs from KidA especially in the live form. There have been a couple live songs pop up that I thought sounded kind of bad, so that got me thinking about this as well.
No, I've just been taking the best albums. I figure some people will just have to deal with Rihanna, Robyn, Taylor Swift and a whole lot of Canadian accents... just like I have to deal with showtunes and jazz.Couple more random questions:
1. Did you let the fact that this is going onto a playlist effect your draft at all?
I've only taken one live album - The Tragically Hip, and they're undoubtedly known as a live band but I was also having a real hard time choosing what album to take so it was a bit of both.2. Those who drafted live albums - and be honest now - what % was preferring those versions of the songs to the albums and what % was a "more bang for your buck" approach?
Depeche mode - policy of truth aw, this is a good song. (Spends entire song lip synching, whistling, dancing). This is a freaking 10
 
 Oh! I'll go with TTD #2 in the 48th round here. I listened to this a couple of nights ago as a reminder of how much I'd loved it. What an incredible disappointment he's been given his talent. But this is still immeasurably good. And so so so so so sexy.48.18 - Symphony or Damn - Terence Trent D'Arby (1992)
TTD's first four albums for Columbia are all fascinating but two of them, his debut and this his third, are sensational.
He's pretty much the textbook case of an artist's ego destroying a promising career but an artist would have to have huge self-belief to take the wild swings TTD does. Or he could be crazy which is also a distinct possibility. Either way, massive talent, massive headcase, great album.
She Kissed Me
Turn the Page
Two more picks, two more TTD albums to choose from.Terence Trent D'Arby run!!!
Two more picks, two more TTD albums to choose from.
 This and the one you took were by far the best.  It's funny because you came so close to sniping me in the 48th round!
   This and the one you took were by far the best.  It's funny because you came so close to sniping me in the 48th round!(The London) Suede has been on my medium list since gimmick #2. Love the over the top emotion on their records. It's strange that this is their only record with unstreamable tracks.I'll dip into the UK/britpop pool for one more. Like Charly Bliss, I am tempted to take the debut here but I'll go for the bigger, more ambitious follow up. This checks a lot of my familiar boxes. quiet/loud dynamics, huge builds and bigger choruses,horns in the front, strings in the back, production tricks all over, a kids choir for good measure. Some Spotify issues here (8 of 12 songs are on it in Canada) hopefully what I add is playable for you.
47.09 - Suede - Dog Man Star (1994)
I listened to both of the good ones in the past week. I think Neither Fish Nor Flesh is much better than its terrible reputation but it still not as good as numbers 1 and 3.This and the one you took were by far the best. It's funny because you came so close to sniping me in the 48th round!
I should re-listen to that one. What talent.I listened to both of the good ones in the past week. I think Neither Fish Nor Flesh is much better than its terrible reputation but it still not as good as numbers 1 and 3.
OK, this was a fun exercise and a fun read.So when I took my Zeppelin live album (totally not cheating) I made sure not to pick two songs from the 50 or so Zep songs on the mix but it made me wonder if there were any "duplicate" songs in the mix - or different versions of the same song. So, having no life I went through the almost 3000 songs to pick out redundancies and deciding which was the best of the two.
(by the way, there were several duplicate "same" songs by two people putting them on the mix but from different albums versions (deluxe) - I took one off.)
All The Young Dudes - Studio version and Live both by Mott. I preferred the studio - too much talking to the audience in the live version.
The Boxer - Simon and Garfunkel vs. Paul Simon - Draw
Check Yo Self - Regular version vs. Remix - preferred the remix
Girl from the North Country - Dylan vs Dylan/Cash - Original no doubt
Hands off She's Mine - The English Beat Live vs. Studio - Both great!
Here Comes The Sun - Beatles vs. Richie Haven - maybe my favorite Beatles' song, so I was skeptical but liked the re-make, still Beatles though.
I Never Loved a Man - Aretha vs. The Commitments - wow, hard to mess with the Queen, but I think I like the remake better.
Jeep's Blues - Duke vs. Johnny Hodges - Both wonderful
L.A. Woman - Doors vs. Billy Idol - Doors
Let Down - Radiohead vs. some reggae crap. Stop ruining perfectly good song. #### on your own songs.
Maggie's Farm - Dylan vs. Rage - Closer than I thought it would be, but Dylan
Me and Bobby McGee - Janis vs. Kris - Wow, both great - Draw
Ohio - CSNY vs. Young - Neil's voice gets to me - CSN in a runaway.
Poor Poo Pitiful Me - Zevon vs. Ronstadt - Love both, but Linda just knocks it out of the park - prob my favorite song sung by her.
Ready for Love - Mott vs. Bad Co. - Bad Company by a nose.
Simple Man - Lynyrd Skynyrd (Live vs. Studio) Studio but close.
Summertime - Doc & Merle Watson vs. Al Green - Both so great and so different - Draw
Things We Said Today - Beatles vs. Paul McCartney - Sort of cheating here, but I love the live older McCartney version. (disclaimer, I picked it)
Where is My Mind? - Pixies vs. Maxence Cyrin - wow, beautiful piano version of a wonderful song - Draw
Whole Lotta Love - Zeppelin vs. Dread Zeppelin - Uhg. :X
Willin' - Little Feat vs. Linda Ronstadt - See above - Linda and it's not even close.
You Ain't Goin' Nowhere - Dylan vs. The Byrds - Both great, but The Byrds did a super job - Byrds
Your Time Is Gonna Come - Zep vs. Dread Zep - :X :X
 
 @timschochet I took this in round 26 I believe. I love Wintertime and I took that one. True Fine Love also.44. Steve Miller Band Book of Dreams (1977)
“Jet Airliner”
”Jungle Love”
I really like early Steve Miller as well, the bluesy “Space Cowboy” era prior to all the hits. But their cover of Paul Pena’s “Jet Airliner” is my favorite by them and it signifies an era of my life when life was easy, between 7th and 8th grade and every summer day was spent at the beach ogling high school freshmen girls who wouldn’t give us the time of day. Seems like this song was always on the radio all summer long. The album also includes “Swingtown”, another classic.
Shoot. Sorry about that I looked but guess I missed it. Will repick.@timschochet I took this in round 26 I believe. I love Wintertime and I took that one.
I'm sure she's a great woman, but you should strongly re-evaluate your long-term plans with her.Played the shuffle hanging out with my special lady friend tonight. These are her reactions...ratings out of 10
the hives - hate to say I told you so it's fine. Not horrible not (makes awesome face) 5/10
scorpions - you give me all I need is this Cinderella? This is like a 1
crowded house - weather like you is this the Rembrandts? Kind of a goofy song. 3
Depeche mode - policy of truth aw, this is a good song. (Spends entire song lip synching, whistling, dancing). This is a freaking 10
sisters of Mercy - this corrosion i kinda like it. It sounds like a mixture of Bowie, ice House and some other band I can't think of. I can just feel the 80s. 8
paul Simon - that was your mother who is this, Paul Simon? Like a 2
david Bowie - look back in anger is it David bowie? I'd give it a 4
my bloody valentine - when do you sleep (editors note: I'm pretty sure I rated this btwn 9 and 10 the other night). I've heard of them but I don't think I've heard their music. I wouldn't change it but I wouldn't put it on either 4
jim Croce - I'll have to say I love you in a song like a 7
the damned - I feel alright it's a little too uh, it's a little crazy for me. 4
 
 Often overlooked, the Hooters' Nervous Night was a defining record not only for the band, but for 1985 itself. Filled to the brim with fun, danceable new wave-ish rock, the album is a wonderful representation of a lighthearted era. The peppy vocals of keyboardist Rob Hyman and guitarist Eric Bazilian give the band an assured, happy energy, while the sporadic use of the mandolin and melodica (a combination harmonica/keyboard) gives the group its distinctive sound. "And We Danced" and "Day by Day" became instant pop hits, but the remainder of Nervous Night is almost as strong. "All You Zombies," which refers to stories in the Bible, is the band's most powerful moment; along with "Where Do the Children Go," the track showed that the Hooters could be serious and dramatic as well as upbeat. Although the band wasn't able to maintain its momentum with subsequent records, Nervous Night remains a noteworthy contribution to mid-'80s rock and doesn't sound quite as dated as the work of some of the band's contemporaries.
Industry legend has it that this album left them so broke from advances written into the recording contract that they went into massive debt despite millions in sales and massive hits. It's held up as a "do not sign" contract in courses about the entertainment industry. :(48.38: The Hooters - Nervous Night (1985)
A big hit for these guys out of Philly, led by in-demand songwriters Rob Hyman and Eric Bazilian. Some may chalk up this album to '80s schlock, but it's a strong collection of tunes. To get a better sense of their sound, including only one of the bigger hits from the album.
All You Zombies
She Comes In Colors (good cover of the old Love song)
Interesting - didn't know the behind-the-scenes business dynamics. Hopefully Hyman and Bazilian more than made back their money with their later songwriting/producing efforts.Industry legend has it that this album left them so broke from advances written into the recording contract that they went into massive debt despite millions in sales and massive hits. It's held up as a "do not sign" contract in courses about the entertainment industry. :(
It's a fine album, though.
I hope so. Perhaps it was another band as I Googled it and it didn't come up, but I think I remember the story being told in my music law class for some reason and remembering that I liked the Hooters when I heard the story. I remember those videos. That was indeeed '85.Interesting - didn't know the behind-the-scenes business dynamics. Hopefully Hyman and Bazilian more than made back their money with their later songwriting/producing efforts.
I don't doubt it was them - just don't recall hearing much about it in the pre-Internet days.I hope so. Perhaps it was another band as I Googled it and it didn't come up, but I think I remember the story being told in my music law class for some reason and remembering that I liked the Hooters when I heard the story. I remember those videos. That was indeeed '85.
Huh. Maybe, maybe not.
https://www.nytimes.com/1987/07/31/business/a-long-and-winding-road-band-s-quest-for-stardom.html
Lol. I didn't see the part where it was his lady friend doing the rankings. Was surprised they were a little low.I'm sure she's a great woman, but you should strongly re-evaluate your long-term plans with her.
I didn't remember that Jeep's Blues had already been drafted with the Ellington album, or I would have picked a different song. Oh well, it's Johnny playing on both tracks, but he is in two different settings. He and Duke wrote the song.Jeep's Blues - Duke vs. Johnny Hodges - Both wonderful
I almost convinced myself to draft Violator just because of 3 songs. They're 3 perfect songs. But then I tried listening to the whole album. And I just couldn't. So I couldn't justify picking the album. Not that early anyway. But those 3 are masterpieces.Depeche mode - policy of truth aw, this is a good song. (Spends entire song lip synching, whistling, dancing). This is a freaking 10
The one Zep album I own.48.10 Led Zeppelin - How the West Was Won (1972)
You're welcome for me not picking 25 minute Dazzed for the mix.
 
 Thought about this one a couple rounds back! Another one of the bands my college roommate loved and played often. Their fourth album is really solid too.45.10 - Reel Big Fish - Turn the Radio Off (1996)
I mean, really, who doesn't love ska?
"Sell Out"
"Beer"
Totally agree. And "The Laws Have Changed" is still my favorite of theirs. "Divine Right", "Zero and One", "Testament"...so good.Alright, there's one of my top ten listened to artists that I don't have on my island yet. It's another early-00s indie rock album, because of course it is. I might stack the 8 best songs on this one against anything else in their catalog. At the same time I also considered taking one of their newer ones. Bejar and Case as full timers here and near their peak is the tie breaker.
46.32 - The New Pornographers - Electric Version (2003)
That was one that came up that I didn't like the sound of the live version and got me thinking about the question.Also, full disclosure - when I wrote about my live album picks last night I forgot about Neil Diamond. Unlike the other live albums that pick was very clearly a bang-for-buck selection. But that's also why i waited so long to pick it. The live albums I prioritized are in the rotation. I didn't consider this one until we entered the portion of the draft in which i did not prepare for in advance.
I am slow to the game on DM. One of my wife's favorite bands, but it was just in the last couple years that I sat down with a couple of their albums, and was surprised how much I liked Violator top to bottom.I almost convinced myself to draft Violator just because of 3 songs. They're 3 perfect songs. But then I tried listening to the whole album. And I just couldn't. So I couldn't justify picking the album. Not that early anyway. But those 3 are masterpieces.
I almost took that one instead. First ~10 songs are real solid but I lose a little interest on the back end, so I took this one instead. I think that one is a little less ska-y.Thought about this one a couple rounds back! Another one of the bands my college roommate loved and played often. Their fourth album is really solid too.
wu-tang was bang for the buck. probably not the best choice, but was having too much trouble deciding on one album.Couple more random questions:
2. Those who drafted live albums - and be honest now - what % was preferring those versions of the songs to the albums and what % was a "more bang for your buck" approach?
If there were decent full Radiohead concerts on Spotify, I would have gone that route because like I've said before - I prefer the sound of songs from KidA especially in the live form. There have been a couple live songs pop up that I thought sounded kind of bad, so that got me thinking about this as well.
Damn- 1 of my planned picks for the day :( Guess Ill draft my last pick first.Round 48 Scary Monsters - David Bowie (1980)
I have to have some Bowie with me, so I'll "settle" for this one. I love this record so it's not such a hardship
Scary Monsters (And Super Creeps)
Ashes to Ashes
@Hov34 had a good idea with music video draft, but that might resonate only with folks who grew up in the MTV era.I guess this is the last official day of the draft. We've covered most of the spring. Who has the next excuse for us to talk about music all summer? I assume this thread will stay pretty active with the playlist, make up picks etc... and as always I'm open to new/continuation ideas.
sorry but need some BowieDamn- 1 of my planned picks for the day :( Guess Ill draft my last pick first.
