That's a strong, strong sprint to the finish, NV. I was going to pick With The Beatles because of this piece, actually, which I sort of referenced a while back and had krista thinking.
I don't think this is behind a paywall, and the first few paragraphs are ostensibly about The Beatles, which then turns into musings on a relationship and an awkward visit turned into a bit of sadness years later. But the first thrust of the writing is about the girl with the Beatles album. The UK version, too.
https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2020/02/17/with-the-beatles
I need to listen them as I’ve heard so many people say how good their music is. I’ve just never been able to get past the idea of the band that recorded Stacy’s Mom being a serious music act.Round 12
Fouuntains of Wayne (1996)
Welcome Interstate Managers (2003)
Sky Full of Holes (2011)
Pretty good haul though right?@Northern Voice You made too many picks.
I left the Beatles off the spreadsheet to fit the threesomes in.
- Arcade Fire
- Prince
- Neil Young
- David Bowie
- Modest Mouse
- Def Leppard
- The Tragically Hip
- The Hold Steady
- Taylor Swift
- The Killers
- The Beatles
- The New Pornographers
- Fountains of Wayne
At various times in the draft I fully expected to pick Al Green, Willie Nelson, Lucinda Williams, Joe Jackson and Emmylou Harris but never got around to them. That's in addition to the artists I draft a lot and consciously avoided this time (e.g. Talk Talk, Joan Armatrading, Mink DeVille and Prefab Sprout).
I was all set to take Willie (Red Headed Stranger and Phases and Stages) in Round 4. Then never got back to him.
Just take them for extended round 12 IMOArtists I considered but didn't draft included The Byrds, Midnight Oil, Screaming Trees, Mandrill, Joe Jackson, Ambrosia, Paul Weller, Bob Mould, Todd Rundgren, Poco, Teenage Fanclub, Indigo Girls, Ween and the legendary '70s R&B band I cryptically referred to earlier, Earth, Wind and Fire.
I like this idea. I was going to extend Round 12 because there was someone who didn't get picked yet that I thought might be. She was perfect for my late seventies/early eighties pick, but I went with the Ramones instead. I PM'd Pip with the pick a few days back, but here we go for the triad. Just for perusal's sake.Just take them for extended round 12 IMO
I think with the new draft starting early this week, this thread is going to fade away pretty quickly, do no harm in highlighting some more great combos.I like this idea. I was going to extend Round 12 because there was someone who didn't get picked yet that I thought might be.
Diana Ross is probably my least-favorite A List vocalist. Her voice is thin & tinny, even when she's singing full-throated, and she had less soul than Richard Nixon. The other Supremes - Mary Wilson and (especially) Florence Ballard - had much stronger voices. I think she's a narcissistic airhead (who somehow dated Gene Simmons, so what the hell do I know?). But Berry Gordy was smitten with Diana and he surrounded her with some of the world's greatest art. And, when done right ("You Keep Me Hanging On", "Love Child", "Love Is Like An Itching In My Heart", "I'm Gonna Make You Love Me"), her voice was used to great effect. Her upper register, when pushed by the band, could be thrilling.Diana (1980) - Diana Ross
This one has the bangers I'm looking for. "I'm Coming Out" and "Upside Down," written IIRC by the fellows in CHIC make this one a pure disco effort just as disco was passing into oblivion. But these two songs were monster hits and kept disco afloat just a bit, and also made Diana a favorite of drag queens, the transgendered, and plain old gay or bisexual people everywhere at the time. Lest anyone think I'm making too big a deal of that, Nile Rodgers got the inspiration for "I'm Coming Out" in the bathroom of a transgender bar in NYC, according to the New York Post in a recent profile.
Diana Ross is probably my least-favorite A List vocalist. Her voice is thin & tinny, even when she's singing full-throated, and she had less soul than Richard Nixon. The other Supremes - Mary Wilson and (especially) Florence Ballard - had much stronger voices. I think she's a narcissistic airhead (who somehow dated Gene Simmons, so what the hell do I know?). But Berry Gordy was smitten with Diana and he surrounded her with some of the world's greatest art. And, when done right ("You Keep Me Hanging On", "Love Child", "Love Is Like An Itching In My Heart", "I'm Gonna Make You Love Me"), her voice was used to great effect. Her upper register, when pushed by the band, could be thrilling.
As for this album, it's really good. It's a Chic record with Ross as the singer (same with Sister Sledge's records). Diana doesn't do anything here that's transcendent , but Nile Rodgers got her to ride the grooves like a cowboy busting a bronco. The intro to "I'm Coming Out" is one of my favorites in all of pop music.
And now is the time for my semi-annual rant about how underrated & misunderstood Chic is.
They got labeled as "disco" because that's what we do - try to shove everything into compartments. I guess because they were black and used strings sometimes? Anyway, to me, they were much more in line with the New Wave bands like the Cars & Blondie - which makes a kind of sense, since the guys in Chic were playing punkish heavy metal before they hit big - than they were with acts like Cerrone or Silver Convention.
Chic's music was minimalist in the extreme. Scratch guitar, thundering drums, monotone vocals, with the bass the only thing providing melody - that's about it. Rodgers would add strings, but they weren't baroque - they slashed like a switchblade, a hit-and-run attack. The lyrics he wrote weren't all that clever, though they always seemed really cynical to me - which could get tiring if you care about messages in your music (I mostly don't). The playing on Chic's songs are amazing.
Thompson's metalloid drumming, Rodgers laying down Napalm cover with his guitar, scything strings, on-the-beat vocals that sound like drums. But Bernard Edwards was the real star. If he's not the most influential bass player of the last 1/4 of the 20th century (& beyond), he's in the top 2 or 3. When not getting his licks straight ripped off cough: Queen :cough, he was imitated so much that folks had to use OTHER instruments just to mask their thievery ("When Doves Cry").
For better or worse, I'd estimate that about 25% of what we think of as "80s music" is because of Chic (skinny tie bands, unemotive vocals, overproduced minimalism). Which also makes sense since Rodgers produced about 9 million records for other popular acts during the decade.
Chic is one of the few great bands I can think of that got less ornate as they went on. In the end, it was all rhythm for Rodgers. Just like the punks and hip-hoppers.
@rockaction digging into the playlist and first early impressions are
- I need to listen to more Everly Brothers, I dug every song from them
- I am jealous of the EB and S+G picks, I couldn't find anything with such nice harmonies and that's miss by me
- The cosmic shift from the EB to Daft Punk is pretty intense, woke me right up
- Goes without saying but The VU rule. How excited are you for the big doc coming out on them?
@rockaction digging into the playlist and first early impressions are
- I need to listen to more Everly Brothers, I dug every song from them
- I am jealous of the EB and S+G picks, I couldn't find anything with such nice harmonies and that's miss by me
- The cosmic shift from the EB to Daft Punk is pretty intense, woke me right up
- Goes without saying but The VU rule. How excited are you for the big doc coming out on them?
Diana's solo records are nothing if not lush and beautiful - they still sound good today (especially "Theme From Mahogany"). And she's a good singer; just not among my favorites. She's more like an actor fitting herself into songs - I never really believe she means what she sings. That's not all her fault, though. Berry Gordy was Viktor Frankenstein and he built his perfect woman/singer/performer. I think he thought he'd have a multimedia Barbra Streisand-like career for Ross.Well, I'm happy to have you comment. I looked at Chic for records because I think so highly of your thoughts of them. I gave them a listen, and will repeat that.
I kind of agree about Diana -- I'm not going to lionize her, but I'm less about the register and pitch than the act. I'm not a huge fan of people that step out as solo artists from a former popular group, though I understand the impulse. I'd go into a long thing about the diva-esque mannerisms and the musical material suffering as a result when people go for that, but I'll save that for a rainy day.
But the songs that Nile Rodgers wrote, mixed with the Supremes, mixed with the two songs from Diana Ross in '76 put this squarely in contention (note it fell out of the rounds) for my little corner of the draft. The love for certain aspects of this pick with me is undeniable, and I thought it brought something my other artists didn't have to the game.
I think I'm also a modern consumer unlike somebody that may have appreciated this career arc in the seventies. While I grew up with Hartford radio, I grew up with a station that played groups like the Spinners, Diana Ross, et. al, and disco. It was not afraid of it. It was a good station as far as pop stations go, and I really almost won a thousand dollar prize once until they heard my voice, figured out I was six years old, and said I was the ninth instead of tenth caller or some lame excuse a child will never forget.
But back to the station. It played the Theme from Mahogany, Upside Down, and I'm Coming Out, and I remember all those songs. That said, I really remember Notorious B.I.G. and Puff Daddy and Ma$e sampling it to great effect, and the Nile Rodgers hook becomes the hook of a lifetime on that record. So I can relate to what you're talking about when you're talking about Chic. So many rappers sample or have sampled Chic. It's absolutely perfect music to sample.
Anyway, those are my quick thoughts to yours. Thanks for commenting.
I half-expected to see Love Battery here because of Between The Eyes and Dayglo straddling the '89/'91-2 line perfectly. I almost picked Mudhoney's Mudhoney and Every Good Boy Deserves Fudge for the '89/'91 grunge split. It just didn't make the cut, but it was one of the last ones on the cutting room floor.Artists I considered but didn't draft included The Byrds, Midnight Oil, Screaming Trees, Mandrill, Joe Jackson, Ambrosia, Paul Weller, Bob Mould, Todd Rundgren, Poco, Teenage Fanclub, Indigo Girls, Ween and the legendary '70s R&B band I cryptically referred to earlier, Earth, Wind and Fire.
I tried to get Summer into the mix for late '70s early '80s because her '70s material is so strong, in my estimation, but I didn't like her '80s material enough. The one with Musical Youth came closest to being selected.Diana's solo records are nothing if not lush and beautiful - they still sound good today (especially "Theme From Mahogany"). And she's a good singer; just not among my favorites. She's more like an actor fitting herself into songs - I never really believe she means what she sings. That's not all her fault, though. Berry Gordy was Viktor Frankenstein and he built his perfect woman/singer/performer. I think he thought he'd have a multimedia Barbra Streisand-like career for Ross.
I was 14 when the Porn Trifecta of 1976's Ross' "Love Hangover", Andrea True's "More, More, More", and Donna Summer's "Love To Love You" happened. Everyone knew True's record was a joke, and I thought Summer's was too. Turned out, she was the best singer by far of the 3.
Round 12
Tomorrow The Green Grass - The Jayhawks (1995)
Rainy Day Music - The Jayhawks (2003)
Xoxo - The Jayhawks (2020)
The Between the Eyes single came out in '89, but the album was '91. Dayglo was '92.I half-expected to see Love Battery here because of Between The Eyes and Dayglo straddling the '89/'91-2 line perfectly.
The Between the Eyes single came out in '89, but the album was '91. Dayglo was '92.
They had two albums in the 95-99 frame but they weren't as good as the first three.
I like Ross as a Supreme and solo. I've always liked her voice.Well, I'm happy to have you comment. I looked at Chic for records because I think so highly of your thoughts of them. I gave them a listen, and will repeat that.
I kind of agree about Diana -- I'm not going to lionize her, but I'm less about the register and pitch than the act. I'm not a huge fan of people that step out as solo artists from a former popular group, though I understand the impulse. I'd go into a long thing about the diva-esque mannerisms and the musical material suffering as a result when people go for that, but I'll save that for a rainy day.
I like Ross as a Supreme and solo. I've always liked her voice.
I may give these a whirl later this morning. I love what I know of the Jayhawks (mostly 'Blue') but have never done a deeper dive.Round 12
Tomorrow The Green Grass - The Jayhawks (1995)
Rainy Day Music - The Jayhawks (2003)
Xoxo - The Jayhawks (2020)
Blue
I'd Run Away
All The Right Reasons
Don't Let The World Get In Your Way
This Forgotten Town
Living In A Bubble
I’ve always been - and still am - an alt-country guy so they’ve been in my rotation for a long while. I actually liked ending this draft being able to spread albums out from the mid nineties to 2020. That latest album is very good - you’d like it I think because there’s a strong pop element in it as well.I may give these a whirl later this morning. I love what I know of the Jayhawks (mostly 'Blue') but have never done a deeper dive.
I would guess the album had a limited pressing and then was reissued after Dayglo came out. I got Dayglo first and then found Between the Eyes shortly thereafter.Cool beans. I wonder what Sub Pop did. One is listed as SP69, the other SP131 or so. Sounds like an album got shelved or something.
I forgot to mention them too. Plenty of '70s stuff to work with (Abandoned Luncheonette is the best) plus Voices and Private Eyes.Hall and Oates
I know you were responding to Uruk regarding her voice. I do love disco. "Love Hangover" starts out slow and sexy, and then glides right into disco. In the Genrepalooza thread, Studio 54 is in my top 5 of the playlists. Diana has never had a strong voice like Donna Summer, but it's nice and distinct. She has a lot of charisma too. Do you remember her concert in Central Park in the early 80s during the rain storm?Yeah, I do too, simey. I'm not sure about the technicalities of her voice is all. I wouldn't have really considered these if I didn't like her Supremes and solo stuff, either -- this was definitely a "I really like these" albums. But you're probably attuned to that.
I thought there would be good discussion about them if I presented them as viable entries. I like hearing what you guys think about what I'm listening to. I seriously have "Love Hangover" in my head right now. Love the beginning and the turn into disco. But I know you like disco, too, so...
Donna Summer rules.I was 14 when the Porn Trifecta of 1976's Ross' "Love Hangover", Andrea True's "More, More, More", and Donna Summer's "Love To Love You" happened. Everyone knew True's record was a joke, and I thought Summer's was too. Turned out, she was the best singer by far of the 3.
I honestly don't remember either having a Central Park album, but I don't doubt it. I just can't remember it. I know there's one by Donna Summer on Spotify that looks like it's live and raining, but it's in Costa Mesa, CA. Diana, on the other hand, draws sort of a blank for me. I was really young even for Diana in 1980. I wouldn't have followed her career but for the hits. I was still listening to pop radio at that age (about six or seven at that time).I know you were responding to Uruk regarding her voice. I do love disco. "Love Hangover" starts out slow and sexy, and then glides right into disco. In the Genrepalooza thread, Studio 54 is in my top 5 of the playlists. Diana has never had a strong voice like Donna Summer, but it's nice and distinct. She has a lot of charisma too. Do you remember her concert in Central Park in the early 80s during the rain storm?
I’m not sure if an album was released but I think the concert was broadcast on HBO.I honestly don't remember either having a Central Park album, but I don't doubt it. I just can't remember it. I know there's one by Donna Summer on Spotify that looks like it's live and raining, but it's in Costa Mesa, CA. Diana, on the other hand, draws sort of a blank for me. I was really young even for Diana in 1980. I wouldn't have followed her career but for the hits. I was still listening to pop radio at that age (about six or seven at that time).
It was televised on a cable station, and a huge storm came through. There were hundreds of thousands of people there. She was told to get off the stage, and she wouldn't. She sang for over thirty minutes in a torrential downpour with 50 mph winds. They finally made her get off the stage when the lightning got bad. It was a benefit concert, and she came back the next day to perform the concert again. It's one of the most legendary concerts due to the circumstances, and her determination that the show must go on.I honestly don't remember either having a Central Park album, but I don't doubt it. I just can't remember it. I know there's one by Donna Summer on Spotify that looks like it's live and raining, but it's in Costa Mesa, CA. Diana, on the other hand, draws sort of a blank for me. I was really young even for Diana in 1980. I wouldn't have followed her career but for the hits. I was still listening to pop radio at that age (about six or seven at that time).