What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Dynasty Value Discussion Thread (14 Viewers)

Different regime and they had Gibbs . Pasted an article in this very thread detailing how Eagles stole other players for cheap that panned out. But yes, we can agree that we disagree on Swift.
Sure Holmes didn;t draft Swift but that was supposedly one of the best players he inherited and he's quite cheap. They just flat out don't want him on the team. Watching every Lions game and Hard Knocks, I get why. He is *soft.

*relatively speaking of course
 
Different regime and they had Gibbs . Pasted an article in this very thread detailing how Eagles stole other players for cheap that panned out. But yes, we can agree that we disagree on Swift.
Sure Holmes didn;t draft Swift but that was supposedly one of the best players he inherited and he's quite cheap. They just flat out don't want him on the team. Watching every Lions game and Hard Knocks, I get why. He is *soft.

*relatively speaking of course
I agree they won't him and to that I say, so? They won't be the first team that is wrong.

And I'll disagree he's soft, how would you even know?
 
And I'll disagree he's soft, how would you even know?
The comment about being hurt Vs injured wasn’t exactly flattering.
Said this in the Swift thread and I"ll say it again here.

Is Duce Staley a doctor? How does he know what Swift is dealing with?

I asked this question as well. Everytime I mention that Swift has played in 80% of his games and has averaged close to 15 fantasy points a game people run to say "well he was not ok in a lot of those games". The question is which is it? Was he playing through injuries or not? People seem to want to have it both ways with him.
 
Not to most. If anyone truly makes a habit of selling future 1sts 2 years out for a current year late second that is a terrible strategy.
No, I’m asking the question, not making a statement.

anyway, I’m on the fence. I could probably get Miles Sanders for a 2025 2nd.

I just feel like I need more depth at RB.
My question is why you feel you need to make this trade in May? Does your league count OTA/training camp/pre-season stats? Seems like you’re looking to win the sexy roster award.
A future 1st is still a first. I’d be shocked if you couldn’t move it in-season when situations are more clarified.
 
My question is why you feel you need to make this trade in May? Does your league count OTA/training camp/pre-season stats? Seems like you’re looking to win the sexy roster award.
A future 1st is still a first. I’d be shocked if you couldn’t move it in-season when situations are more clarified.
Has nothing to do with “sexy roster” - what a ridiculous presumption.

There are several reasons I like trading in May/June. It’s early, and it’s before hype builds on players. Last year Swift was an early 3rd round pick until late august when he moved into the late 2nd and then by a week before the season he was getting picked at the 12-13 turn.

Similarly as news develops of how the Eagles intend on using Swift, his value could also build. Or any other player.

Call it a time-tested style where I like getting trades done earlier because I tend to get better value.

In this specific case, it’s a new owner who took over a team about a week ago, and they’re loaded at RB. I know my league well enough to know that the early bird gets the worm, and new owners tend to want to move assets to put their own stamp on a team.

Which means if I’m going to be able to capitalize on that situation, the sooner the better. Because I also know my leaguemates will be trying to make deals with the new guy as well.

Context matters. Thanks for asking.
 
Last edited:
What are your thoughts about his role in PHI?
The opportunity is in front of him to be the lead member of a RBBC, putting up solid RB2 numbers with upside while being put in a position to rehab his value heading into free agency.

If he falters he could flame out to a point he's not got a role with a team that gives you much confidence.

He controls his destiny, huge year for him.
I think imma float the offer tomorrow.

Man - I spent 2.5 years trying to deal him away in one league, finally did, and going back in at a discount in a different league feels dirty.

It’s such a gamble. But hey

lol
@rockaction @barackdhouse @Dez @Birdie048

Your thoughts? Pay a 2025 1st for Swift or nah?

No one else in my league is selling RB! Someone talk me onto or off of the ledge!

I guess I have Mattison as my RB4, but at the moment it doesn’t exactly inspire confidence. :oldunsure:

Same dude has Jamaal Williams (28) Cam
Akers (🤢), McKinnon, & Foreman available.

Not sure I want to invest in any of those dudes.
That’s the definition of boom or bust trade. If swift hits and you think you can win I’d be tempted. It’s a big IF though. Also consider where that pick might be. If you have aging assets like cook, jones , Henry 25’ could be a rough year for ya and turn into a very high pick. It all comes down to if you can win for me. I wouldn’t bet on swift having a lot of touches on the year and staying healthy.
 
I have a guy inquiring on Dj Moore. I am not really sure where how to value him. He doesn’t have a 1st or 2nd this year. He has two thirds and all of his 24’ picks plus an extra third. Moore is my wr 3 atm. Pickens Palmer pierce follow. Thoughts?
 
What are your thoughts about his role in PHI?
The opportunity is in front of him to be the lead member of a RBBC, putting up solid RB2 numbers with upside while being put in a position to rehab his value heading into free agency.

If he falters he could flame out to a point he's not got a role with a team that gives you much confidence.

He controls his destiny, huge year for him.
I think imma float the offer tomorrow.

Man - I spent 2.5 years trying to deal him away in one league, finally did, and going back in at a discount in a different league feels dirty.

It’s such a gamble. But hey

lol
@rockaction @barackdhouse @Dez @Birdie048

Your thoughts? Pay a 2025 1st for Swift or nah?

No one else in my league is selling RB! Someone talk me onto or off of the ledge!

I guess I have Mattison as my RB4, but at the moment it doesn’t exactly inspire confidence. :oldunsure:

Same dude has Jamaal Williams (28) Cam
Akers (🤢), McKinnon, & Foreman available.

Not sure I want to invest in any of those dudes.
That’s the definition of boom or bust trade. If swift hits and you think you can win I’d be tempted. It’s a big IF though. Also consider where that pick might be. If you have aging assets like cook, jones , Henry 25’ could be a rough year for ya and turn into a very high pick. It all comes down to if you can win for me. I wouldn’t bet on swift having a lot of touches on the year and staying healthy.
After my complete tear down/rebuild my average age is 23.3 years old.

So yeah, an aging roster is not a risk - that was the impetus of my rebuild. . :)
 
I have a guy inquiring on Dj Moore. I am not really sure where how to value him. He doesn’t have a 1st or 2nd this year. He has two thirds and all of his 24’ picks plus an extra third. Moore is my wr 3 atm. Pickens Palmer pierce follow. Thoughts?
I sniffed around him and the shareholder in my league wanted a late 2023 late 1st. Like 1.10

I’d try to extract the 2024 1st for him.
 
What are your thoughts about his role in PHI?
The opportunity is in front of him to be the lead member of a RBBC, putting up solid RB2 numbers with upside while being put in a position to rehab his value heading into free agency.

If he falters he could flame out to a point he's not got a role with a team that gives you much confidence.

He controls his destiny, huge year for him.
I think imma float the offer tomorrow.

Man - I spent 2.5 years trying to deal him away in one league, finally did, and going back in at a discount in a different league feels dirty.

It’s such a gamble. But hey

lol
@rockaction @barackdhouse @Dez @Birdie048

Your thoughts? Pay a 2025 1st for Swift or nah?

No one else in my league is selling RB! Someone talk me onto or off of the ledge!

I guess I have Mattison as my RB4, but at the moment it doesn’t exactly inspire confidence. :oldunsure:

Same dude has Jamaal Williams (28) Cam
Akers (🤢), McKinnon, & Foreman available.

Not sure I want to invest in any of those dudes.
That’s the definition of boom or bust trade. If swift hits and you think you can win I’d be tempted. It’s a big IF though. Also consider where that pick might be. If you have aging assets like cook, jones , Henry 25’ could be a rough year for ya and turn into a very high pick. It all comes down to if you can win for me. I wouldn’t bet on swift having a lot of touches on the year and staying healthy.
After my complete year down/rebuild my average age is 23.3 years old.

So yeah, an aging roster is not a risk - that was the impetus of my rebuild. . :)
Who else do you have at rb. Sorry if already here somewhere. I did look lol
 
What are your thoughts about his role in PHI?
The opportunity is in front of him to be the lead member of a RBBC, putting up solid RB2 numbers with upside while being put in a position to rehab his value heading into free agency.

If he falters he could flame out to a point he's not got a role with a team that gives you much confidence.

He controls his destiny, huge year for him.
I think imma float the offer tomorrow.

Man - I spent 2.5 years trying to deal him away in one league, finally did, and going back in at a discount in a different league feels dirty.

It’s such a gamble. But hey

lol
@rockaction @barackdhouse @Dez @Birdie048

Your thoughts? Pay a 2025 1st for Swift or nah?

No one else in my league is selling RB! Someone talk me onto or off of the ledge!

I guess I have Mattison as my RB4, but at the moment it doesn’t exactly inspire confidence. :oldunsure:

Same dude has Jamaal Williams (28) Cam
Akers (🤢), McKinnon, & Foreman available.

Not sure I want to invest in any of those dudes.
That’s the definition of boom or bust trade. If swift hits and you think you can win I’d be tempted. It’s a big IF though. Also consider where that pick might be. If you have aging assets like cook, jones , Henry 25’ could be a rough year for ya and turn into a very high pick. It all comes down to if you can win for me. I wouldn’t bet on swift having a lot of touches on the year and staying healthy.
After my complete year down/rebuild my average age is 23.3 years old.

So yeah, an aging roster is not a risk - that was the impetus of my rebuild. . :)
Who else do you have at rb. Sorry if already here somewhere. I did look lol
No worries.

Currently I have ETN & AJD. I’m about to draft Bijan. Very solid WR corps, 2 good QBs & Pitts at TE.

also I expect my pick to be late 1st, to your earlier Q.
 
Thinking about the ETN ceiling talk and IDK, maybe we shouldn't even say stuff like that. Cooper Kupp was considered the definition of a high floor, low ceiling player after a few years of his career and then he went prime Jerry Rice mode for 1.5 seasons. It does of course take the right confluence of circumstances but once we know a player is good, I don' think we can be very sure about who has a high end ceiling and who doesn't.
I'm not selling him. But when I look at his gamelogs, and his competition for targets, I am not happy with his targets.
 
What are your thoughts about his role in PHI?
The opportunity is in front of him to be the lead member of a RBBC, putting up solid RB2 numbers with upside while being put in a position to rehab his value heading into free agency.

If he falters he could flame out to a point he's not got a role with a team that gives you much confidence.

He controls his destiny, huge year for him.
I think imma float the offer tomorrow.

Man - I spent 2.5 years trying to deal him away in one league, finally did, and going back in at a discount in a different league feels dirty.

It’s such a gamble. But hey

lol
@rockaction @barackdhouse @Dez @Birdie048

Your thoughts? Pay a 2025 1st for Swift or nah?

No one else in my league is selling RB! Someone talk me onto or off of the ledge!

I guess I have Mattison as my RB4, but at the moment it doesn’t exactly inspire confidence. :oldunsure:

Same dude has Jamaal Williams (28) Cam
Akers (🤢), McKinnon, & Foreman available.

Not sure I want to invest in any of those dudes.
That’s the definition of boom or bust trade. If swift hits and you think you can win I’d be tempted. It’s a big IF though. Also consider where that pick might be. If you have aging assets like cook, jones , Henry 25’ could be a rough year for ya and turn into a very high pick. It all comes down to if you can win for me. I wouldn’t bet on swift having a lot of touches on the year and staying healthy.
After my complete year down/rebuild my average age is 23.3 years old.

So yeah, an aging roster is not a risk - that was the impetus of my rebuild. . :)
Who else do you have at rb. Sorry if already here somewhere. I did look lol
No worries.

Currently I have ETN & AJD. I’m about to draft Bijan. Very solid WR corps, 2 good QBs & Pitts at TE.

also I expect my pick to be late 1st, to your earlier Q.
Any chance of landing bigsby? Honestly. Aaron jones might be a better target for you. There’s going to be some skepticism with him not having Rodgers and he’s gettin up there. Jmo. I think I’d be looking at other options. Etn and bijon are a niiiice combo. Start 2 rb?
 
Any chance of landing bigsby? Honestly. Aaron jones might be a better target for you. There’s going to be some skepticism with him not having Rodgers and he’s gettin up there. Jmo. I think I’d be looking at other options. Etn and bijon are a niiiice combo. Start 2 rb?
No. I only have picks 1.01, 1.02, and a few 5ths.

Start 10, no K, no D/ST. 2-5 RB, 2-6 WR, 1-2 TE, 1 QB, 1 SF.
 
Any chance of landing bigsby? Honestly. Aaron jones might be a better target for you. There’s going to be some skepticism with him not having Rodgers and he’s gettin up there. Jmo. I think I’d be looking at other options. Etn and bijon are a niiiice combo. Start 2 rb?
No. I only have picks 1.01, 1.02, and a few 5ths.

Start 10, no K, no D/ST. 2-5 RB, 2-6 WR, 1-2 TE, 1 QB, 1 SF.
That’s a LOT of starting options. I’d take bijon and gibbs and not worry about rb for along time.
 
I have gibbs at 2 in any format as the other half of tier one with bijon. I feel Richardson has unmatched upside at qb so I completely get it. Wish ya luck man.
yeah, RB have shorter careers and in superflex I need to take the swing for the fences that ARich represents.

I like Gibbs. No way I take anything but ARich at 2.
 
I have gibbs at 2 in any format as the other half of tier one with bijon. I feel Richardson has unmatched upside at qb so I completely get it. Wish ya luck man.
yeah, RB have shorter careers and in superflex I need to take the swing for the fences that ARich represents.

I like Gibbs. No way I take anything but ARich at 2.
Bijan/ARich in SuperFlex is :chef’skiss:
 
What's Ja'Marr Chase worth in PPR SF? Guy with 1.03 is sniffing around. FBG trade chart says roughly 1.03 and a late 2nd. I looked at recent trades on DTC's trade wire and by their numbers people have been letting him go way too cheap recently.
 
What's Ja'Marr Chase worth in PPR SF? Guy with 1.03 is sniffing around. FBG trade chart says roughly 1.03 and a late 2nd. I looked at recent trades on DTC's trade wire and by their numbers people have been letting him go way too cheap recently.
That would be way too cheap. Multiple 1sts, IMO

1.03 + 2024 1st would maybe start the discussion if I had Chase. I’d probably want more.
 
What's Ja'Marr Chase worth in PPR SF? Guy with 1.03 is sniffing around. FBG trade chart says roughly 1.03 and a late 2nd. I looked at recent trades on DTC's trade wire and by their numbers people have been letting him go way too cheap recently.
That would be way too cheap. Multiple 1sts, IMO

1.03 + 2024 1st would maybe start the discussion if I had Chase. I’d probably want more.
Thought about asking for 1.03 and 1.12 this year. I also have 1.09 so I could reload some with those
 
What's Ja'Marr Chase worth in PPR SF? Guy with 1.03 is sniffing around. FBG trade chart says roughly 1.03 and a late 2nd. I looked at recent trades on DTC's trade wire and by their numbers people have been letting him go way too cheap recently.
That would be way too cheap. Multiple 1sts, IMO

1.03 + 2024 1st would maybe start the discussion if I had Chase. I’d probably want more.
Thought about asking for 1.03 and 1.12 this year. I also have 1.09 so I could reload some with those
Are you really needing QB help? Again this is light.
 
What's Ja'Marr Chase worth in PPR SF? Guy with 1.03 is sniffing around. FBG trade chart says roughly 1.03 and a late 2nd. I looked at recent trades on DTC's trade wire and by their numbers people have been letting him go way too cheap recently.
That would be way too cheap. Multiple 1sts, IMO

1.03 + 2024 1st would maybe start the discussion if I had Chase. I’d probably want more.
Thought about asking for 1.03 and 1.12 this year. I also have 1.09 so I could reload some with those
Still way way too light for Chase.

I’m shocked the trade value chart is this off - supply & demand, Chase is a top dynasty asset & top tier WR.

Don’t sell him for 1.03 & a late 1st. That’s crazy talk. As the seller you’re in the position of power, trading from strength. Be a bully. Ask for the world.
 
What's Ja'Marr Chase worth in PPR SF? Guy with 1.03 is sniffing around. FBG trade chart says roughly 1.03 and a late 2nd. I looked at recent trades on DTC's trade wire and by their numbers people have been letting him go way too cheap recently.
That would be way too cheap. Multiple 1sts, IMO

1.03 + 2024 1st would maybe start the discussion if I had Chase. I’d probably want more.
Thought about asking for 1.03 and 1.12 this year. I also have 1.09 so I could reload some with those
Still way way too light for Chase.

I’m shocked the trade value chart is this off - supply & demand, Chase is a top dynasty asset & top tier WR.

Don’t sell him for 1.03 & a late 1st. That’s crazy talk. As the seller you’re in the position of power, trading from strength. Be a bully. Ask for the world.
People who trade players like Chase are probably picking toward the top of the draft every year. At some point you have to say, you know what? I'm keeping players like that. I know no player is untradeable in certain situations, but you build on players like that.
 
What's Ja'Marr Chase worth in PPR SF? Guy with 1.03 is sniffing around. FBG trade chart says roughly 1.03 and a late 2nd. I looked at recent trades on DTC's trade wire and by their numbers people have been letting him go way too cheap recently.
That would be way too cheap. Multiple 1sts, IMO

1.03 + 2024 1st would maybe start the discussion if I had Chase. I’d probably want more.
Thought about asking for 1.03 and 1.12 this year. I also have 1.09 so I could reload some with those
Still way way too light for Chase.

I’m shocked the trade value chart is this off - supply & demand, Chase is a top dynasty asset & top tier WR.

Don’t sell him for 1.03 & a late 1st. That’s crazy talk. As the seller you’re in the position of power, trading from strength. Be a bully. Ask for the world.
People who trade players like Chase are probably picking toward the top of the draft every year. At some point you have to say, you know what? I'm keeping players like that. I know no player is untradeable in certain situations, but you build on players like that.
agree entirely. If you’re lucky enough to finally get one of the top 5 uber-stud dynasty players, build AROUND that player instead of dealing them off for more “value”.
 
Sitting at 1.11 in ffpc SF bestball draft. I need a second qb bad to pair with Hurts. I also need rb depth behind CMC and Conner. I have some offers on the table.

A) Stay put and draft Levis or Achane
B) Trade for 2024 1st (1.08 this year could definitely be higher).
C) Trade for two 2023 2nds
D) Something else
 
What's Ja'Marr Chase worth in PPR SF? Guy with 1.03 is sniffing around. FBG trade chart says roughly 1.03 and a late 2nd. I looked at recent trades on DTC's trade wire and by their numbers people have been letting him go way too cheap recently.
That would be way too cheap. Multiple 1sts, IMO

1.03 + 2024 1st would maybe start the discussion if I had Chase. I’d probably want more.
Thought about asking for 1.03 and 1.12 this year. I also have 1.09 so I could reload some with those
Still way way too light for Chase.

I’m shocked the trade value chart is this off - supply & demand, Chase is a top dynasty asset & top tier WR.

Don’t sell him for 1.03 & a late 1st. That’s crazy talk. As the seller you’re in the position of power, trading from strength. Be a bully. Ask for the world.
People who trade players like Chase are probably picking toward the top of the draft every year. At some point you have to say, you know what? I'm keeping players like that. I know no player is untradeable in certain situations, but you build on players like that.
agree entirely. If you’re lucky enough to finally get one of the top 5 uber-stud dynasty players, build AROUND that player instead of dealing them off for more “value”.
I’ll pile on. I was lucky enough to have Chase in both of my leagues. The one that is a SuperFlex I traded him as part of a package that brought back CMC and Fields, as I needed another QB. I don’t believe that you trade guys like Jefferson or Chase unless you’re bringing back a proven stud in return along with other pieces. What good are draft picks in this situation? The hope that you might hit the lottery and a player that you pick ends up being one of their caliber or that perhaps the multiple picks may end up being players that are of their worth when combined, at best? There’s also the chance that the picks fizzle out completely, of course. Not worth that chance.
 
agree entirely. If you’re lucky enough to finally get one of the top 5 uber-stud dynasty players, build AROUND that player instead of dealing them off for more “value”.
Agree, but within reason. If you can beat up a team for multiple 1sts, especially early 2024, then it might be worth it, but it has to be a true godfather offer or like @JohnnyU said, just build around them.

But if you can flip Chase for MH Jr + 2 other 1sts, sure - do that. Outside of that, there’s just no point.
 
I don’t believe that you trade guys like Jefferson or Chase unless you’re bringing back a proven stud in return along with other pieces.
Right - like, if you know you’re getting 2024 1.01 or 1.02, plus multiple other 1sts, or 2023 1.0Bijan + multiple other picks/players, go for it.

Otherwise you’re giving up a top 5 dynasty asset for “what’s behind door #2” which is just an automatic losing proposition.
 
agree entirely. If you’re lucky enough to finally get one of the top 5 uber-stud dynasty players, build AROUND that player instead of dealing them off for more “value”.
Agree, but within reason. If you can beat up a team for multiple 1sts, especially early 2024, then it might be worth it, but it has to be a true godfather offer or like @JohnnyU said, just build around them.

But if you can flip Chase for MH Jr + 2 other 1sts, sure - do that. Outside of that, there’s just no point.
What about Cee Dee Lamb and a mid 1st and a late 1st? I wouldn’t.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top