Dynasty Value Discussion Thread (7 Viewers)

[joey]

Rookie Draft is underway in a 12 tm,1 QB ppr dynasty. The owner of the 1.08 pick has put it on the block. I have the 1.12 pick and have won the league back to back seasons. Bijan, Gibbs, JNS, Richardson, Stroud,Kincaid and Young are drafted. Is it worth it to try to move up from 1.12 to 1.08? I see about 4-5 guys close in value for the remaining players.

Just saying what I would do.

If I really was wanting to draft a WR I'd move up for Addison or at a minimum be ready to move up once one of Addison or Johnston are gone so you can get one of them.

If I really needed a RB I'd probably not do a thing and assume one of Charb, Miller, Achane or Spears make it to me and if they don't it means you got some great WR value.

Summary is I'm only looking at moving up if all things being equal I'd really prefer to draft a WR.

Thanks. I was hoping a QB would fall to me, but the teams picking 4-7 love stockpiling QBs in a start 1 league.
My WRs are AJ Brown, DeVonta Smith, Amon-Ra St. Brown, Diggs, Mike Evans, Meyers, Osborn, Doubs, Pickens, JRoss.
My top RBs are Pollard, JWilson, AGibson, Damien Harris, KHerbert.
So, my need is greater there and I was leaning towards standing pat.

I’d definitely stand pat and grab a RB at 1.12, and if you have a mid-2nd-round pick, I‘d take another RB there to throw a few darts.
heck, with WRs that deep, can you trade one for an RB to a team with complimentary needs/wants?
you list Pickens all the way at the bottom of your WR list but I imagine he’d be very tradeable to a team that needs a young, upside WR. Or trade one of your top 4WRs for a proper stud RB. 2 cents

I just randomly listed my WRs, not how I rank them.
You make it sound so easy to trade a WR for a RB....but it isn't in this league lol. In the past 5 years I haven't finished lower than 3rd place. So, some of the lower teams tell me I have to really "pay big" to get a backup QB or a solid RB. An example is someone offered me Cam Akers for AJ Brown and St.Brown. I countered, but it was rejected instantly without a further counter-offer.

I didn’t mean to make it sound easy. I was just posting conversationally on a fairy tale football message board.

 

[northern exposure]

Rookie Draft is underway in a 12 tm,1 QB ppr dynasty. The owner of the 1.08 pick has put it on the block. I have the 1.12 pick and have won the league back to back seasons. Bijan, Gibbs, JNS, Richardson, Stroud,Kincaid and Young are drafted. Is it worth it to try to move up from 1.12 to 1.08? I see about 4-5 guys close in value for the remaining players.

Just saying what I would do.

If I really was wanting to draft a WR I'd move up for Addison or at a minimum be ready to move up once one of Addison or Johnston are gone so you can get one of them.

If I really needed a RB I'd probably not do a thing and assume one of Charb, Miller, Achane or Spears make it to me and if they don't it means you got some great WR value.

Summary is I'm only looking at moving up if all things being equal I'd really prefer to draft a WR.

Thanks. I was hoping a QB would fall to me, but the teams picking 4-7 love stockpiling QBs in a start 1 league.
My WRs are AJ Brown, DeVonta Smith, Amon-Ra St. Brown, Diggs, Mike Evans, Meyers, Osborn, Doubs, Pickens, JRoss.
My top RBs are Pollard, JWilson, AGibson, Damien Harris, KHerbert.
So, my need is greater there and I was leaning towards standing pat.

I’d definitely stand pat and grab a RB at 1.12, and if you have a mid-2nd-round pick, I‘d take another RB there to throw a few darts.
heck, with WRs that deep, can you trade one for an RB to a team with complimentary needs/wants?
you list Pickens all the way at the bottom of your WR list but I imagine he’d be very tradeable to a team that needs a young, upside WR. Or trade one of your top 4WRs for a proper stud RB. 2 cents

I just randomly listed my WRs, not how I rank them.
You make it sound so easy to trade a WR for a RB....but it isn't in this league lol. In the past 5 years I haven't finished lower than 3rd place. So, some of the lower teams tell me I have to really "pay big" to get a backup QB or a solid RB. An example is someone offered me Cam Akers for AJ Brown and St.Brown. I countered, but it was rejected instantly without a further counter-offer.

I didn’t mean to make it sound easy. I was just posting conversationally on a fairy tale football message board.

No problem. I was just venting my frustrations about trying to trade in this league. Appreciate your feedback.

 

[Spookytooth]

Is my Cooks, Bateman, e Moore a second and two future thirds for 24 and 25 firsts to a receiver needy team close? It’s 12 tm ppr dynasty 1qb 27 rostered league. Thanks!

 

[smbkrypt24]

Is my Cooks, Bateman, e Moore a second and two future thirds for 24 and 25 firsts to a receiver needy team close? It’s 12 tm ppr dynasty 1qb 27 rostered league. Thanks!

No, I wouldn’t trade 2 firsts for all those players and picks.
My advice would be to go for one at a time so the total package isn’t 2 firsts for that pile. Example, Bateman and a second for a first.

 

[InDitkaWeTrust]

Rookie Draft is underway in a 12 tm,1 QB ppr dynasty. The owner of the 1.08 pick has put it on the block. I have the 1.12 pick and have won the league back to back seasons. Bijan, Gibbs, JNS, Richardson, Stroud,Kincaid and Young are drafted. Is it worth it to try to move up from 1.12 to 1.08? I see about 4-5 guys close in value for the remaining players.

I see Addison as a tier above the remainder. If you can grab him at 1.08 without losing a bunch of draft capital then go for it! If not, I'd wait to see what plays out and pick BPA. Since you've repeated, I expect you already have a pretty strong roster at most, it not all, positions.

 

[Hot Sauce Guy]

If you were a team needing to move into rebuild, what would you be looking for to sell Tyreek

I’ve seen him go for a 1st numerous times. ‘24 1st & 24 2nd in my league.

, Cooper Kupp

2023 1.04 or later.

or even AJ Brown for?

I just paid 1.03 + 1.08, which was probably a slight overpay (he’s worth 1.03 + 1.10-12) but a ‘23 1st + 24 1st is about right. Any 2 firsts should be the starting ask IMO.

 

[ghostguy123]

If you were a team needing to move into rebuild, what would you be looking for to sell Tyreek

I’ve seen him go for a 1st numerous times. ‘24 1st & 24 2nd in my league.

, Cooper Kupp

2023 1.04 or later.

or even AJ Brown for?

I just paid 1.03 + 1.08, which was probably a slight overpay (he’s worth 1.03 + 1.10-12) but a ‘23 1st + 24 1st is about right. Any 2 firsts should be the starting ask IMO.

When you call giving 3 and 8 for AJ Brown an overpay, please throw that calculator away

 

[Hot Sauce Guy]

When you call giving 3 and 8 for AJ Brown an overpay, please throw that calculator away

I’m not using a calc. I paid it. I believe it was a slight overpay.

Do you think I it was a value purchase and I should have paid more?

Or do you think it was perfect value?

Curious.

 

[foxco]

I wouldn't move Brown for 1.03 and 1.08. That's an insta reject for me.

 

[Hot Sauce Guy]

I wouldn't move Brown for 1.03 and 1.08. That's an insta reject for me.

Thank goodness. In the trade topic I was told it was a big overpay. IIRC someone suggested I overpaid by the 1.08

I thought it was a really solid purchase, myself.

 

[ghostguy123]

Oh damn it. Superflex

 

[Hot Sauce Guy]

Oh damn it. Superflex

Correct. 1.03 is Gibbs, Young, JSN, Stroud, etc.

 

[steelcityman]

Hyatt, Reed, Izzy A? Problem is I have Doubs, so I dont need another WR2/3. Is Hyatt the man, can be be? I have Breece, so maybe Izzy makes the most sense, get that talent just in case Hall has career issues(hope not). I know Carter is there too. I've been back and forth on this pick for a couple hours. IDK what to do. Any advice?

 

[Wigglytuff's Gruff]

Hyatt, Reed, Izzy A? Problem is I have Doubs, so I dont need another WR2/3. Is Hyatt the man, can be be? I have Breece, so maybe Izzy makes the most sense, get that talent just in case Hall has career issues(hope not). I know Carter is there too. I've been back and forth on this pick for a couple hours. IDK what to do. Any advice?

Draft whoever has the most upside, not someone who currently profiles to be a long term backup.

 

[Hot Sauce Guy]

Hyatt, Reed, Izzy A? Problem is I have Doubs, so I dont need another WR2/3. Is Hyatt the man, can be be? I have Breece, so maybe Izzy makes the most sense, get that talent just in case Hall has career issues(hope not). I know Carter is there too. I've been back and forth on this pick for a couple hours. IDK what to do. Any advice?

Draft whoever has the most upside, not someone who currently profiles to be a long term backup.

Agree with this.

 

[steelcityman]

Its all a guess, but backup is Izzy. Reed seems to be WR2 at best if he beats out Doubs, I think Watson is that good. So that would leave Hyatt.

 

[acarey50]

Rookie Draft is underway in a 12 tm,1 QB ppr dynasty. The owner of the 1.08 pick has put it on the block. I have the 1.12 pick and have won the league back to back seasons. Bijan, Gibbs, JNS, Richardson, Stroud,Kincaid and Young are drafted. Is it worth it to try to move up from 1.12 to 1.08? I see about 4-5 guys close in value for the remaining players.

Just saying what I would do.

If I really was wanting to draft a WR I'd move up for Addison or at a minimum be ready to move up once one of Addison or Johnston are gone so you can get one of them.

If I really needed a RB I'd probably not do a thing and assume one of Charb, Miller, Achane or Spears make it to me and if they don't it means you got some great WR value.

Summary is I'm only looking at moving up if all things being equal I'd really prefer to draft a WR.

Thanks. I was hoping a QB would fall to me, but the teams picking 4-7 love stockpiling QBs in a start 1 league.
My WRs are AJ Brown, DeVonta Smith, Amon-Ra St. Brown, Diggs, Mike Evans, Meyers, Osborn, Doubs, Pickens, JRoss.
My top RBs are Pollard, JWilson, AGibson, Damien Harris, KHerbert.
So, my need is greater there and I was leaning towards standing pat.

I’d definitely stand pat and grab a RB at 1.12, and if you have a mid-2nd-round pick, I‘d take another RB there to throw a few darts.
heck, with WRs that deep, can you trade one for an RB to a team with complimentary needs/wants?
you list Pickens all the way at the bottom of your WR list but I imagine he’d be very tradeable to a team that needs a young, upside WR. Or trade one of your top 4WRs for a proper stud RB. 2 cents

I just randomly listed my WRs, not how I rank them.
You make it sound so easy to trade a WR for a RB....but it isn't in this league lol. In the past 5 years I haven't finished lower than 3rd place. So, some of the lower teams tell me I have to really "pay big" to get a backup QB or a solid RB. An example is someone offered me Cam Akers for AJ Brown and St.Brown. I countered, but it was rejected instantly without a further counter-offer.

I'd suggest that it is exactly this approach from your opponents that has allowed you to stay top 3 all these years.

 

[northern exposure]

Rookie Draft is underway in a 12 tm,1 QB ppr dynasty. The owner of the 1.08 pick has put it on the block. I have the 1.12 pick and have won the league back to back seasons. Bijan, Gibbs, JNS, Richardson, Stroud,Kincaid and Young are drafted. Is it worth it to try to move up from 1.12 to 1.08? I see about 4-5 guys close in value for the remaining players.

I see Addison as a tier above the remainder. If you can grab him at 1.08 without losing a bunch of draft capital then go for it! If not, I'd wait to see what plays out and pick BPA. Since you've repeated, I expect you already have a pretty strong roster at most, it not all, positions.

Thanks all for the input. I stood pat because the asking price for 1.08 was too high imo. He ended up using the pick on Will Anderson. The next picks were Addison and Q Johnson. So, now I wait to see who goes at 1.11 and see who falls to me.

 

[InDitkaWeTrust]

Would Burrow for Jefferson/Carr be ok in the SF world?

I think its probably fair'ish. In my opinion, you need at least one stud QB to compete. I think its probably a bad move for a contending team to try to get by with Carr/Goff/Ridder.

True though hard to say without knowing what level of upgrade JJ is to the WR room. It's a totally even deal so I don't know if anyone wins or loses the deal.

Wr room is mediocre. G Wilson, Hollywood, Ridley, Gabe Davis, Lockett, D Parker, and Allen Robinson.

that seems pretty decent to me...

High variance WR room. Lots of players with fun upside but Hollywood has no QB, Ridley hasn't played in like 2 years, Gabe Davis puts up a lot of duds, Locket is getting old and got some major draft competition.

Ended up keeping Burrow (for now) and traded for some help in the WR room. Rhamondre, 3.09 and 24 3rd for Jeudy and Thielen. Neither are WR1 guys, but I'd expect both to contribute a good bit. With any luck, G Wilson will roll on as my WR1 and I can shuttle hollywood, Thielen, Jeudy and Ridley as my WR2 and WR3. Appreciate the board's help thinking this one through.

 

[Gally]

Ended up keeping Burrow (for now) and traded for some help in the WR room. Rhamondre, 3.09 and 24 3rd for Jeudy and Thielen.

I think that is selling low on Rhamondre but understand why you did it.

 

[Ilov80s]

Would Burrow for Jefferson/Carr be ok in the SF world?

I think its probably fair'ish. In my opinion, you need at least one stud QB to compete. I think its probably a bad move for a contending team to try to get by with Carr/Goff/Ridder.

True though hard to say without knowing what level of upgrade JJ is to the WR room. It's a totally even deal so I don't know if anyone wins or loses the deal.

Wr room is mediocre. G Wilson, Hollywood, Ridley, Gabe Davis, Lockett, D Parker, and Allen Robinson.

that seems pretty decent to me...

High variance WR room. Lots of players with fun upside but Hollywood has no QB, Ridley hasn't played in like 2 years, Gabe Davis puts up a lot of duds, Locket is getting old and got some major draft competition.

Ended up keeping Burrow (for now) and traded for some help in the WR room. Rhamondre, 3.09 and 24 3rd for Jeudy and Thielen. Neither are WR1 guys, but I'd expect both to contribute a good bit. With any luck, G Wilson will roll on as my WR1 and I can shuttle hollywood, Thielen, Jeudy and Ridley as my WR2 and WR3. Appreciate the board's help thinking this one through.

I agree it's a slight undersell on Stevenson but I do think Jeudy is a good player. Thielen is dust though. Doubt you get much from him but a spot flex start a couple times this year.

 

[Mitchie]

Would Burrow for Jefferson/Carr be ok in the SF world?

I think its probably fair'ish. In my opinion, you need at least one stud QB to compete. I think its probably a bad move for a contending team to try to get by with Carr/Goff/Ridder.

True though hard to say without knowing what level of upgrade JJ is to the WR room. It's a totally even deal so I don't know if anyone wins or loses the deal.

Wr room is mediocre. G Wilson, Hollywood, Ridley, Gabe Davis, Lockett, D Parker, and Allen Robinson.

that seems pretty decent to me...

High variance WR room. Lots of players with fun upside but Hollywood has no QB, Ridley hasn't played in like 2 years, Gabe Davis puts up a lot of duds, Locket is getting old and got some major draft competition.

Ended up keeping Burrow (for now) and traded for some help in the WR room. Rhamondre, 3.09 and 24 3rd for Jeudy and Thielen. Neither are WR1 guys, but I'd expect both to contribute a good bit. With any luck, G Wilson will roll on as my WR1 and I can shuttle hollywood, Thielen, Jeudy and Ridley as my WR2 and WR3. Appreciate the board's help thinking this one through.

Do not like

 

[Jayded]

I’ve never specifically targeted an IDP player as the core trade element from recollection, so I’m curious.

What does Will Anderson’s value look like? Appears to be IDP rookie 1.1, but what’ll it take me to pry him away? I have young defenders and the owner already said at least a hybrid (LB/DL) but curious how different really age or draft compensation might factor in.

 

[Gally]

I’ve never specifically targeted an IDP player as the core trade element from recollection, so I’m curious.

What does Will Anderson’s value look like? Appears to be IDP rookie 1.1, but what’ll it take me to pry him away? I have young defenders and the owner already said at least a hybrid (LB/DL) but curious how different really age or draft compensation might factor in.

This is going to depend on the platform you are using and scoring system. The platform is important because over this off season there was a big shift to true position where many OLB's got reclassified as DE. This has somewhat saturated the position as there are a lot more startable assets at DE now. More than ever before so getting a premier DE isn't as important as it use to be.

As for scoring importance, this goes to big play (4+ pts for sack vs 1 pt per tackle) vs tackle heavy (1 pt per sack vs 1 pt per tackle) vs balanced (2-3 pts per sack vs 1 pt per tackle). DE's are devalued in balanced and tackle heavy formats. So if that is the case then Anderson will not have much value.

Another factor is where do IDP players score in relation to the offensive players and do you have enough IDP starters to make them meaningful. If you start one or two IDP's vs 8 or 10 offensive players then IDP is an afterthought and I wouldn't give up really anything for any iDP players. There will be plenty on waivers to get you by that spending capital on them is ony hurtful.

I am in a rookie draft right now (9 offensive starters & 9 defensive starters). Large rosters (50-60 players). However, the IDP side doesn't score nearly as well as offense. Out of the top 50 scorers from last year there are 8 IDP players and the highest one is #25. In addition of those 8, six were LB's with 1 DE and 1 S. In that draft Will Anderson was the 2nd IDP player taken at pick 2.06. The first was Jack Campbell at 1.09.

All that background to say, where does the first IDP player typically come off your board in your league? If it's pick 2.06 then the price should be about what a typical mid second round pick would go for.

 

[Jayded]

I’ve never specifically targeted an IDP player as the core trade element from recollection, so I’m curious.

What does Will Anderson’s value look like? Appears to be IDP rookie 1.1, but what’ll it take me to pry him away? I have young defenders and the owner already said at least a hybrid (LB/DL) but curious how different really age or draft compensation might factor in.

This is going to depend on the platform you are using and scoring system. The platform is important because over this off season there was a big shift to true position where many OLB's got reclassified as DE. This has somewhat saturated the position as there are a lot more startable assets at DE now. More than ever before so getting a premier DE isn't as important as it use to be.

As for scoring importance, this goes to big play (4+ pts for sack vs 1 pt per tackle) vs tackle heavy (1 pt per sack vs 1 pt per tackle) vs balanced (2-3 pts per sack vs 1 pt per tackle). DE's are devalued in balanced and tackle heavy formats. So if that is the case then Anderson will not have much value.

Another factor is where do IDP players score in relation to the offensive players and do you have enough IDP starters to make them meaningful. If you start one or two IDP's vs 8 or 10 offensive players then IDP is an afterthought and I wouldn't give up really anything for any iDP players. There will be plenty on waivers to get you by that spending capital on them is ony hurtful.

I am in a rookie draft right now (9 offensive starters & 9 defensive starters). Large rosters (50-60 players). However, the IDP side doesn't score nearly as well as offense. Out of the top 50 scorers from last year there are 8 IDP players and the highest one is #25. In addition of those 8, six were LB's with 1 DE and 1 S. In that draft Will Anderson was the 2nd IDP player taken at pick 2.06. The first was Jack Campbell at 1.09.

All that background to say, where does the first IDP player typically come off your board in your league? If it's pick 2.06 then the price should be about what a typical mid second round pick would go for.

Thanks for the thoughts. My league is pretty crazy. We start 11 offense, 11 defense and its devy as well. Five offense and defense are flex, so LBs or hybrids are especially valuable because it’s like getting a tackler advantage into the DL position.

I’ve come close to winning a few years partly because of depth at LB/hybrid. My team is aging so trying to get young and I’m a Texans fan, so might as well grab our guy and have fun cheering him on for two reasons.

I have Reddick (DL2 last year) and Landry as core starters at DL so trying to figure out how much more it’ll take to make an offer. He naturally comes into question as Reddick is 28 and Landry is 26, but Anderson is the traditional rookie conjecture. Could be dominant for years or a dud. Not sure how much he values either yet but want to make a strong offer so he doesn’t get scared off.

 

[Hot Sauce Guy]

I’ve never specifically targeted an IDP player as the core trade element from recollection, so I’m curious.

What does Will Anderson’s value look like? Appears to be IDP rookie 1.1, but what’ll it take me to pry him away? I have young defenders and the owner already said at least a hybrid (LB/DL) but curious how different really age or draft compensation might factor in.

I dealt Pittman for Kwity Paye+Mooney late last season.

Maybe relevant, depending whether you believe Anderson is similar to, below, or above Paye (who I see as a top 12 IDP DE)

 

[Hot Sauce Guy]

I am in a rookie draft right now (9 offensive starters & 9 defensive starters). Large rosters (50-60 players). However, the IDP side doesn't score nearly as well as offense. Out of the top 50 scorers from last year there are 8 IDP players and the highest one is #25. In addition of those 8, six were LB's with 1 DE and 1 S. In that draft Will Anderson was the 2nd IDP player taken at pick 2.06. The first was Jack Campbell at 1.09.

Yeah, good points throughout. My dynasty IDP is performance scoring, so elite DEs wildly outscore many offensive positions.

 

[northern exposure]

What is the value of Joe Mixon in terms of a 2024 rookie draft pick(s)?
12 team ppr SF dynasty league. The owner has put him on the block with a 2024 2nd as the asking price. My pick will probably be in the 2.03 -2.06 range. With the uncertainty surrounding Mixon that asking price seems too high. Thoughts?

 

[rockaction]

What is the value of Joe Mixon in terms of a 2024 rookie draft pick(s)?
12 team ppr SF dynasty league. The owner has put him on the block with a 2024 2nd as the asking price. My pick will probably be in the 2.03 -2.06 range. With the uncertainty surrounding Mixon that asking price seems too high. Thoughts?

I'd actually say that's about right. You're assuming the risk with Mixon. I personally don't like his chances of being starting RB when all is said and done, but 2.03-2.06 in a non-IDP league seems about right.

I just checked a calc and 2.03 is actually low for Mixon according to KTC.

Dynasty Dominator has it as too low, also.

My personal thing is I'd stay away from Mixon, but the price is reasonable.

 

[northern exposure]

What is the value of Joe Mixon in terms of a 2024 rookie draft pick(s)?
12 team ppr SF dynasty league. The owner has put him on the block with a 2024 2nd as the asking price. My pick will probably be in the 2.03 -2.06 range. With the uncertainty surrounding Mixon that asking price seems too high. Thoughts?

I'd actually say that's about right. You're assuming the risk with Mixon. I personally don't like his chances of being starting RB when all is said and done, but 2.03-2.06 in a non-IDP league seems about right.

I just checked a calc and 2.03 is actually low for Mixon according to KTC.

Dynasty Dominator has it as too low, also.

My personal thing is I'd stay away from Mixon, but the price is reasonable.

Should have provided more details about the league I guess. It is a Zealots league, so there are IDP on the roster.

 

[rockaction]

Should have provided more details about the league I guess. It is a Zealots league, so there are IDP on the roster.

Ah, okay. I actually thought it might be. But there's still really only one or two guys that would bump him down, then -- those guys being Anderson and Campbell. And the QBs should go higher in Zealots than other 1QB leagues, so that's a consideration, too.

I still think the 2.03-2.06 makes sense and is worth the price, but you also wouldn't catch me paying it, if that makes any sense.

 

[steelcityman]

Just finished my picks for rookie/FA draft:

Flowers in 1st
Mayer and Hyatt in 2nd
Z Evans in 3rd
Jordan Love in 4th
Puka Nacua in 5th
Michael Wilson in 6th

I need WR options, I think I got 4 more now, we'll see about the last 2 in camps. Needed TE depth, and think I got a good one. And I like the upside of Love as a QB2(Herbert is my QB1). Evans, just kind of a dart throw, if he shows signs of being something in LA, I will hold onto him, otherwise, I can probably trade or cut him to get down to roster size before week 1.

 

[finfansteve]

Lamar or Herbert in a keeper league?

 

[steelcityman]

I'd probably go big with Lamar, big scores, but big risk, even with new contract. He has WRs now, but also brings with him an injury risk. Seems every year there are 3-4 QBs entering the NFL who can be elite, so you can reload if Lamar's leg falls off.

 

[3quinox825]

Dynasty Superflex

Aj brown for the 1.07, 2,06 terry mnclauren and a 24 2nd?

 

[Hot Sauce Guy]

Lamar or Herbert in a keeper league?

I like Herbert. I don’t entirely trust LJax’s career longevity. He seems like a player whose value could deteriorate as the hits add up, and Father Time spares no man. Pocket passers tend to have longer careers.

 

[Hot Sauce Guy]

Dynasty Superflex

Aj brown for the 1.07, 2,06 terry mnclauren and a 24 2nd?

You’re getting or giving AJB here?

If buying it seems like a bargain. 1.07 is ok, TMC is 28 in September, and the 2nd doesn’t move the needle.

AJB is the best player in the deal. I paid 1.03 + 1.08 & have no regrets.

If selling, it’s not enough return, IMO.

 

[titusbramble]

It reads like two seconds which makes it closer, if the first was 1.06 I'd probably take the package

 

[League Champion]

Dynasty Superflex

Aj brown for the 1.07, 2,06 terry mnclauren and a 24 2nd?

Not if you're competing now. 1.07 is kind of no man's land. There's nothing close to AJ Brown sitting there. Unless you're in the middle of team building, I'd say no.

 

[Gally]

Lamar or Herbert in a keeper league?

What is the scoring (6 pt all TD's or varied for passing vs rushing TD's)?

If it's 6 pts for all TD's then its Herbert easily. If it's not, then its closer and depends on how long you can keep him and what your risk acceptance is.

 

[wlwiles]

Joined a new SF league this offseason, having our startup draft later this summer. Any good resources or tips as to how to evaluate startup picks vs. future rookie picks? Already getting some trade offers (i.e. startup 6th for future rookie 2nd) type offers and just haven't done a startup in so long, I end up looking at overall dynasty rankings to get an idea of who is ranked in the 60-70th range to be equivalent to a startup 6th, but I feel like that's missing the point...

 

[Hot Sauce Guy]

Joined a new SF league this offseason, having our startup draft later this summer. Any good resources or tips as to how to evaluate startup picks vs. future rookie picks? Already getting some trade offers (i.e. startup 6th for future rookie 2nd) type offers and just haven't done a startup in so long, I end up looking at overall dynasty rankings to get an idea of who is ranked in the 60-70th range to be equivalent to a startup 6th, but I feel like that's missing the point...

I’d always rather be the guy giving the 6th for the 2nd.

 

[zaner75]

Joined a new SF league this offseason, having our startup draft later this summer. Any good resources or tips as to how to evaluate startup picks vs. future rookie picks? Already getting some trade offers (i.e. startup 6th for future rookie 2nd) type offers and just haven't done a startup in so long, I end up looking at overall dynasty rankings to get an idea of who is ranked in the 60-70th range to be equivalent to a startup 6th, but I feel like that's missing the point...

There’s plenty of mock startups to look at that will help gain a general sense of where players go. Find a trusted/reliable site and go to their YouTube channel. A lot of channels/resources are generally in consensus. Future first is typically in the 5-7 range. KTC has a startup mode so you can get a sense of how pick values compare.
Are rookies included or will rookie picks be drafted? I find with rookies included, the players go a bit later than where the corresponding rookie pick would go. Best of luck and have fun!

 

[Dez]

I have gibbs at 2 in any format as the other half of tier one with bijon. I feel Richardson has unmatched upside at qb so I completely get it. Wish ya luck man.

yeah, RB have shorter careers and in superflex I need to take the swing for the fences that ARich represents.

I like Gibbs. No way I take anything but ARich at 2.

Hope those who passed up Chase to grab Lance in Superflex have recovered. I sure can't imagine having done that but I am sure plenty seen Lance as the next big thing like they see AR now. Lucky for me I don't play SF so I couldn't have thought about making that horrendous mistake of passing up Chase for Lance.

 

[Hot Sauce Guy]

Hope those who passed up Chase to grab Lance in Superflex have recovered. I sure can't imagine having done that but I am sure plenty seen Lance as the next big thing like they see AR now. Lucky for me I don't play SF so I couldn't have thought about making that horrendous mistake of passing up Chase for Lance.

Fortunately, Lance isn’t on the board this year.

For that matter there isn’t a Chase either.

 

[Hot Sauce Guy]

What would you be comfortable paying for a 31 y/o McKinnon in a 12 team PPR, start 10, no K, no D/ST SF league?

 

[JohnnyU]

What would you be comfortable paying for a 31 y/o McKinnon in a 12 team PPR, start 10, no K, no D/ST SF league?

What would you be comfortable paying for a 31 y/o McKinnon in a 12 team PPR, start 10, no K, no D/ST SF league?

$1 in blind bid money.

 

[Hot Sauce Guy]

What would you be comfortable paying for a 31 y/o McKinnon in a 12 team PPR, start 10, no K, no D/ST SF league?

What would you be comfortable paying for a 31 y/o McKinnon in a 12 team PPR, start 10, no K, no D/ST SF league?

$1 in blind bid money.

The post so nice you quoted it twice?

Cmon - $1? He’s got enough PPR juice to be a BYE week filler.

Was considering throwing a 5th at him, but not sure the owner will go for that.

 

[zaner75]

What would you be comfortable paying for a 31 y/o McKinnon in a 12 team PPR, start 10, no K, no D/ST SF league?

Future 3rd. You're paying hoping for spot starts. I saw somewhere that Pacheco had 0 red-zone or 3rd down targets. Don't know if that's accurate but McKinnon's role doesn't seem much different for this upcoming season.

 

[Hot Sauce Guy]

What would you be comfortable paying for a 31 y/o McKinnon in a 12 team PPR, start 10, no K, no D/ST SF league?

Future 3rd. You're paying hoping for spot starts. I saw somewhere that Pacheco had 0 red-zone or 3rd down targets. Don't know if that's accurate but McKinnon's role doesn't seem much different for this upcoming season.

I was thinking between a late 3rd & early 4th

He’s a 1-year rental/spot start guy

And yeah - same thought on his usage, though Pacheco got a little more love down the stretch in receiving.

I’m still not ruling out KC as a potential Cook landing spot when the dust settles.