What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Game of Thrones, tv only, books don't exist, no backstory...NERDS already ruining a series that hasn't started (8 Viewers)

Well you are right, in an effort to sloppily clean up every character arc, no matter how insignificant the character is(mountain) it wouldn't surprise me to see him get some screentime.
huh. they made kind of a big deal out of the hound and mountain's backstory in the series. and each has had their own devlopment as the show has progressed that have been integral to main plot points. am I wrong here? they're minor characters in no need of resolution? anyboyd else want to chime in?

eta: and what bobcat said. and this isn't something that will take more than a couple minutes, IMO.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
huh. they made kind of a big deal out of the hound and mountain's backstory in the series. and each has had their own devlopment as the show has progressed that have been integral to main plot points. am I wrong here? they're minor characters in no need of resolution? anyboyd else want to chime in?
I think the Hound definitely is...hes a great character..And of course Arya is(duh)

But the mountain?  Not so much..In fact, really not at all.  I certainly don't want or need some epic mountain Vs hound battle...Don't care at all.  Just me man...

 
tl:dr the thread to catch up.

Ep1 - 9/10

Ep2 - 9.5/10

Ep3 - 8/10

Ep4 - 7.5/10

Another episode that could have been way better. 

No way ships can sneak up on a flying dragon, no way.  Dragon can and should be flying 1000 feet above doing surveillance.  No way the ships get close enough to hit them with giant cross-bows, lol.  So much better ways to have the dragon killed, could have lured one in during the meeting.  No way Dany takes that meeting with Ceresi AFTER they just just killed her dragon.  So stupid:

"Surrender or my dragon will burn the city down!"

"We just killed one of your dragons and it wasn't really that hard."

Major events happening backwards of logic in this episode.

 
huh. they made kind of a big deal out of the hound and mountain's backstory in the series. and each has had their own devlopment as the show has progressed that have been integral to main plot points. am I wrong here? they're minor characters in no need of resolution? anyboyd else want to chime in?
If they don't fight I am going to be highly disappointed. Hound needs to get his revenge!  That said hound is one of my favorite characters of the series, if not the favorite

 
Mountain/Hound has been brewing since S1.  If there were a battle in the field and those two found each other....noone would think twice. Given the current state of the various forces (Cersei behind her walls and The Hound not part of Jons army)  It will take a little finagling on the part of the directors/writers to put them in the same room.....but with Arya wanting to get into KL to kill Cersei...it won't be that much of a stretch. 

 
IIRC Edmure Tully is still at Riverrun. He was being run by the Freys/Lannisters, but I doubt they have much hold on him anymore. Maybe Jon pick the Tullys up as he goes south, though technically he's not related to them, and he's not King In The North (they were Stark banner men at the beginning of the show). Maybe Sansa sends them a note or something. Also they'll be passing through the neck, near Greywater Watch, which is Howland Reed's domain. Maybe Meera brings some troops?
My guess is that Sansa picks up the Tully army on her way south.

 
Mountain/Hound has been brewing since S1.  If there were a battle in the field and those two found each other....noone would think twice. Given the current state of the various forces (Cersei behind her walls and The Hound not part of Jons army)  It will take a little finagling on the part of the directors/writers to put them in the same room.....but with Arya wanting to get into KL to kill Cersei...it won't be that much of a stretch. 
I don't think it will be part of the larger battle- I think arya and the hound walk right into KL prior to any large scale thing and go find the fight.

eta: exactly what the post above points out...

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Mountain/Hound has been brewing since S1.  If there were a battle in the field and those two found each other....noone would think twice. Given the current state of the various forces (Cersei behind her walls and The Hound not part of Jons army)  It will take a little finagling on the part of the directors/writers to put them in the same room.....but with Arya wanting to get into KL to kill Cersei...it won't be that much of a stretch. 
They actually started fighting at one of the festivals, and Baratheon told them to cut the ####.

 
Ok why didn't Cersei just execute all of them, especially Tyrion.  She promises Bronn a kingdom to go and kill Tyrion and then when she has the opportunity with dozens of archers on him, she doesn't do it.  They also could have used the spears/arrows on Danerys.  

Also, I know there were catapults and stuff but why couldn't Drogon come straight down onto Cersei,  kill all of them in that spot and then just take off?  Especially after Miss Andy was killed.  End the whole thing there.  
You must have been kicked off the "Season-8-Six-Episodes" committee.

 
Oh, for what it's worth I'm actually okay with Dany's descent into madness because I think it's been understandably accelerated by her finally being close to the throne, her losing half her armies+, Jorah dying, Tyrion erring, and her having some real competition for the throne (Jon and/or Sansa).  But, I would agree that prior season Danaerys was probably one of if not the most kind-hearted characters on the show.  I mean, hell, even cool-head Ned beheaded the deserting Crow whereas Dany did not always kill a character when she probably could have justified doing so. 
Dany has killed people that deserve it, but did it in a way that Jon certainly wouldn’t approve of (burned the witch in season 1, locked 2 people in a vault in Qarth). She crucified en masse hundreds of Meereen nobles. She fed a couple others to her dragons. She burned alive the Dothraki khals. And that’s before we get to the Rickon thing. Most if not all of these people had it coming, but she’s always had a very ruthless edge to her, and now she’s feeling vulnerable and isolated. If the show had given itself a couple more seasons, they could have slow played her shift in behavior a little more gracefully, but it’s not coming totally out of left field either. 

 
I have a minute to jump in here...

1. I loved this episode. Since I've only caught live episodes since last year and missed last week when it happened, seeing Rhaegal get shot down was my first real shock out of the blue.  Sure it wasn't on the same level as the Red Wedding, but I don't care; it was a shock to me.

2. I don't see Arya killing the Mountain.  In his weird condition, I think he needs to be killed in close quarters, and she's less set up for close combat than the Viper was. She won't be able to dance around him and wear him down like that, and if she gets close, she would have to be too close for to long to hurt him, which would give him a chance to grab her and squeeze her head like a grape.

3. Was sad to see Tormund go back north of the wall, but it made sense; once a Wildling, always a Wildling.

4. Varys and Tyrion were great in their scenes together.  I think they made it clear between them that when things go sideways, even though they have different opinions on what should happen, they still respect each other regardless of what happens.  May sound lame, but in the midst of so much squabbling, civilized, respectful discourse is a welcome sight.

5. The writing of the show and the story arcs, dialog, etc, is way beyond anything I could ever do on my best day of writing, but I still feel I need to point out that I want to better feel the justification from Dany wanting to 'break the wheel' to the Iron Throne being her destiny. Would have liked a little more vacillating between the two, but instead she seemed to put her altruism aside without looking back.

6. When did Tyrion and Sansa get divorced? Did her marrying Ramsey Bolton automatically negate it?

7. Missandei saying Dracaris as her last word was fitting but I didn't like it. Too much of a parallel to real life, specifically during the protests in Ferguson, when Michael Brown's stepfather was trying to incite a riot. Tread lightly here; I don't want this thread exiled to the politics forum.

8. If Euron puts 2 and 2 together about Cersei's pregnancy, I don't think he'll care; in fact, I think it gives him leverage over her. And I'm still waiting for a Spanish Armada type naval victory for Yara over Euron's fleet.

 
No way ships can sneak up on a flying dragon, no way.  Dragon can and should be flying 1000 feet above doing surveillance.  No way the ships get close enough to hit them with giant cross-bows, lol.  So much better ways to have the dragon killed, could have lured one in during the meeting.  No way Dany takes that meeting with Ceresi AFTER they just just killed her dragon.
I brought it up earlier but comments get buried in this thread fast. My thought is if Jon had been riding Rhaegal maybe because he has a warriors sense about him but with Dany, she looked to just be enjoying the moment and joyriding. Look at her at the mark on this video, she's happy, content and feels safe. I feel like a seasoned fighter might have had a more military approach to Dragonstone before you go off joyriding. Especially if you watch from the beginning. The dragons almost had to pass close to or right by Euron's fleet. They were certainly high enough to see them. As they fly toward Dragonstone, they turn left and head back out to sea where Raeghal then becomes a pincushion.

https://youtu.be/V_v6VINwkEk?t=22

Remember cersei explicitedly said....keep the city gates open....so they are allowing everyone in.....arya n hound should slip in easily
Arya I could see, she's small, can dress like almost any street urchin she chooses and go in easily. The Hound I have my doubts about. He's one of the most recognizable people in the 7 Kingdoms and he's kinda huge but I know in the interest of time, he too will walk in unapproached.

 
Anyone think Vary’s is clueing in Euron and still working with Cersei? He was the guy informing Jorah to kill Dany when they were across the narrow sea. Or, at least he was the chain in the message link. His birds haven’t been talked about in some time so is he still working that communication?

 
2.  They really really really need to explain Bran better. He's such an important character, and I was actually on board with his trek north, but it's so hard not to be frustrated with the minimal information were given about him couple with the incredible lack of utility he appears to give everybody.  I was really hoping we'd get an episode dominated by his visions or him basically going all storyteller on everybody to fill in some plot holes. But instead we're basically given he knows everything + doesn't do anything + nobody thinks to ask him about the best course of action. 
I would bet that we never see Bran again.  

 
This is another place where I feel like I can see the writers' strings moving. Dragon air power is an unmatched weapon in that place and time. Three dragons are almost undefeatable. So they give one dragon to NK, that evens things out and brings down the wall which has magic protective runes.

And now they take one more out. Presto technology is invented, large scale manufacturing happens, and 50-100, 200? of these dragon and boat missiles are ready and loaded on ships and the red keep. Wow. They own the sea and the air all of a sudden.

Because otherwise 3 dragons, and they just mow down the dead and obliterate the pirate navy and the castle surrenders. Not good for storyboarding is it.
Looking back, it seems clear the writers started with the premise that Dany and Cersei needed to be evenly matched by the end, and worked backwards from there to find ways to knock Dany’s forces down a few pegs. 

 
Looking back, it seems clear the writers started with the premise that Dany and Cersei needed to be evenly matched by the end, and worked backwards from there to find ways to knock Dany’s forces down a few pegs. 
I think you and me had this conversation perhaps in the offseason somewhere.  I said it would make more sense for Dany to just deal with Cersi first then the NK, but was reminded that as it stood her army was gigantic and would be a mismatch.  

 
Man they really butchered that episode.  Sheesh.  How disappointing to have the dragon die like that.  Maybe they just didn't see a whole ####### fleet in the water. 
Agreed. I guess they had to demonstrate that those ballistas can actually do the job, and thus are a check on the last dragon, but if the goal was just to off one more, they should have just let Viseryon die in the previous episode at the hands of the undead.

 
Oh, for what it's worth I'm actually okay with Dany's descent into madness because I think it's been understandably accelerated by her finally being close to the throne, her losing half her armies+, Jorah dying, Tyrion erring, and her having some real competition for the throne (Jon and/or Sansa).  But, I would agree that prior season Danaerys was probably one of if not the most kind-hearted characters on the show.  I mean, hell, even cool-head Ned beheaded the deserting Crow whereas Dany did not always kill a character when she probably could have justified doing so. 
This is not how I’ve viewed Dany at all. 

 
Anyone think Vary’s is clueing in Euron and still working with Cersei? He was the guy informing Jorah to kill Dany when they were across the narrow sea. Or, at least he was the chain in the message link. His birds haven’t been talked about in some time so is he still working that communication?
I think that's the easy leap of faith right now. Varys has said over and over and even in the last episode, he is for the realm so while he is in Dany's camp right now I don't think he would have any regrets doing what he thinks would be right for the realm. He's also voiced his concerns about Dany's state of mind so everything points toward that except...the person he is championing, Jon, wouldn't benefit from any of this. Losing the last dragon would be devastating to their cause barring some last minute savior army showing up (Second Sons, Dorne, etc).

Could Varys still be employed by Cersei? I'm sure it's a possibility but I don't read Varys that way, again pointing back to he wants to do right by the realm, not a particular individual. It will be very easy to make a case against him should the writers decide to take the easy way out and have him turned into a kabob. I just don't like the idea of it. Varys has been manipulating story lines throughout the series for what he percieves is the good of the realm. It would seem out of character to me if his allegiances where with Cersei at this point.

 
This is not how I’ve viewed Dany at all. 
How'd you view her? 

(I'm not trying to be flippant here as I recognize that there is genuinely different ways to view her - I always viewed her as having a pretty big heart). 

 
Dany has killed people that deserve it, but did it in a way that Jon certainly wouldn’t approve of (burned the witch in season 1, locked 2 people in a vault in Qarth). She crucified en masse hundreds of Meereen nobles. She fed a couple others to her dragons. She burned alive the Dothraki khals. And that’s before we get to the Rickon thing. Most if not all of these people had it coming, but she’s always had a very ruthless edge to her, and now she’s feeling vulnerable and isolated. If the show had given itself a couple more seasons, they could have slow played her shift in behavior a little more gracefully, but it’s not coming totally out of left field either. 
Dickon

 
Anyone think Vary’s is clueing in Euron and still working with Cersei? He was the guy informing Jorah to kill Dany when they were across the narrow sea. Or, at least he was the chain in the message link. His birds haven’t been talked about in some time so is he still working that communication?
No. Varys does what's best for the realm above all. He has been true to that the entire series, doing what he can to make the 7 Kingdoms good for the people. He would not be helping Cersei in anyway shape or form unless we are getting the 180 degree heel turn.

 
Oh, for what it's worth I'm actually okay with Dany's descent into madness because I think it's been understandably accelerated by her finally being close to the throne, her losing half her armies+, Jorah dying, Tyrion erring, and her having some real competition for the throne (Jon and/or Sansa).  But, I would agree that prior season Danaerys was probably one of if not the most kind-hearted characters on the show.  I mean, hell, even cool-head Ned beheaded the deserting Crow whereas Dany did not always kill a character when she probably could have justified doing so. 
This is not how I’ve viewed Dany at all. 
didn't she crucify the slavers? 

I do think she was one of the more "just" characters- whose goals were always about trying to make the world better by ruling in a more "just" way than the wheel she'd seen in operation that discounted the non-important/rich people of the kingdom. 

early on this or last season she talked her entire life being about getting to be the queen- and it was based on heredity and morals. now that she's close, she's realizing that not only is she not the true heir apparent, she's also not the most moral. this is what's messing with her and causing her to have some internal conflicts. I don't think she really believes it's right for John to step down and not say anything. but if he doesn't, her whole life's m.o. has been for naught, so she's still holding on. 

 
How'd you view her? 

(I'm not trying to be flippant here as I recognize that there is genuinely different ways to view her - I always viewed her as having a pretty big heart). 
I view her as having an insatiable appetite for power and that the good deeds she has done have all been because she sees them as opportunities to seize more power. Very curious how they will handle her relationship with Jon at the end. 

 
Oh, for what it's worth I'm actually okay with Dany's descent into madness because I think it's been understandably accelerated by her finally being close to the throne, her losing half her armies+, Jorah dying, Tyrion erring, and her having some real competition for the throne (Jon and/or Sansa).  But, I would agree that prior season Danaerys was probably one of if not the most kind-hearted characters on the show.  I mean, hell, even cool-head Ned beheaded the deserting Crow whereas Dany did not always kill a character when she probably could have justified doing so. 
Girl's got a point. World class strategic move and all round act of coolness granting Gendry his lordship and it's forgotten 10 minutes later.

 
I don't know though - what if it was a guy?

- Dude gets run over, is stuck in a corner despite saving the damned planet, hell yes he's going right at Cersei, dragons a'blazing. Go right at Cersei, get in first, go in strong. What is so mad about this?

 
Lol, I gotta say, like Dany said - Oh, ok buddy the two blooming people who just happen to know this continent changing secret and they just happen to be your brother and your bestest friend? - Not really mad.

I guess destroying innocent civilians is cruel and genocidal but then how exactly is this supposed to work? Starve them slowly instead like Tyrion proposed?

 
I don't think she's done a full heel turn yet. They're building up to a crisis point for her at which she'll have to make a decision, probably with some tragic consequences either way, about who she really is and what she's really about. This episode she's still trying to have her cake and eat it too with Jon, being a just ruler and being sole monarch, etc. Her hand is going to be forced, then we'll see what kind of character she has.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
I don't think she's done a full heel turn yet. They're building up to a crisis point for her at which she'll have to make a decision, probably with some tragic consequences either way, about who she really is and what she's really about. This episode she's still trying to have her cake and eat it too with Jon, being a just ruler and being sole monarch, etc. Her hand is going to be forced, then we'll see what kind of character she has.
which way do you think she'll go?

 
which way do you think she'll go?
I'm leaning toward her "doing the right thing" for the people in the end. I'm figuring either her or Jon don't live through whatever comes next, maybe both, as a result. I'm leaning toward Jon eating it, with Dany being pregnant with his kid (somehow the prophecy about how she can't get pregnant until all that crazy stuff happening being fulfilled) and giving birth to the next heir.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
I'm leaning toward her "doing the right thing" for the people in the end. I'm figuring either her or Jon don't live through whatever comes next, maybe both, as a result. I'm leaning toward Jon eating it, with Dany being pregnant with his kid (somehow the prophecy about how she can't get pregnant until all that crazy stuff happening being fulfilled).
WRONG

 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top