Game Thread - Wildcard - Carolina V NY Giants (1 Viewer)

[Keys Myaths]

And here come the homer arguments about the refs.GDB the smiley in these threads.

 

[jeff_eaglz]

Question: What is the punt returner counting before the ball is snapped for the punt? Is he making sure his team only has 11 guys on the field or checking the other team?

Yes. that's his job.

 

[Grace Under Pressure]

No challenge on the Goings fumble?

 

[snogger]

No challenge on the Goings fumble?

Down by contact can not be challanged.

 

[wilked]

No challenge on the Goings fumble?

down by contact, unchallengable

 

[Grace Under Pressure]

Ah, DBC rule.

 

[jeff_eaglz]

fumble, Carolina gets another break

Shockey's non-fumble benefitted Carolina?

 

[Green and Gold]

McFly!

 

[Ghost Rider]

Another blown call.

Sure on Super Slow Motion it's easy to tell that was a fumble.

Dang Refs need to adjust their Superman Googles so they can slow down the play as it happens.

I understand that it is a lot easier to tell on a replay when you can carefully watch the play, but that ball was coming out way before his knee hit the ground and the replay showed a ref looking right at the play. To miss that is bad.

 

[wilked]

fumble, Carolina gets another break

Shockey's non-fumble benefitted Carolina?

Are you an idiot? How could that have benefitted Carolina?

 

[jeff_eaglz]

No challenge on the Goings fumble?

down by contact, unchallengable

The top rule I'd like to see something done about - this "down by contact" is weak.Not sure what the change I suggest is, but something should be done. And 'letting the play continue' and saying a challenge can fix an injustice - also weak. Lost timeouts and challenges can haunt you.

 

[FairWarning]

Bears will spank either of these teams next week.

 

[Grace Under Pressure]

Giants need to get Tiki working on this drive. Any score here would be key, get some momentum and get the crowd back involved.

 

[wilked]

No challenge on the Goings fumble?

down by contact, unchallengable

The top rule I'd like to see something done about - this "down by contact" is weak.Not sure what the change I suggest is, but something should be done. And 'letting the play continue' and saying a challenge can fix an injustice - also weak. Lost timeouts and challenges can haunt you.

Be sure to get back to us when you have some idea on how to fix it

 

[snogger]

NICE THROW Manning..

 

[Ghost Rider]

fumble, Carolina gets another break

Shockey's non-fumble benefitted Carolina?

Are you an idiot? How could that have benefitted Carolina?

That was a rhetorical question, homer. The obvious point is that it is laughable for you to get mad about that play not going in the Giants favor when on their previous possession, the same thing happened on Shockey's catch.BTW, nice throw, Eli.

 

[cowboyz]

was peppers hoping for a lateral? wtf he just stood there

 

[Keys Myaths]

Who was complaining that the loss of players on the Giants *defense* was the reason they were losing?The offense blows.

 

[Grace Under Pressure]

Terrible throw across the field like that.

 

[Johnny Ice]

Good 'ol Eli.

 

[NorvilleBarnes]

LOL @ Aikman: "Not sure what Eli was tryin to accomplish . . "

 

[jeff_eaglz]

That sound you hear is the air coming out of 80,000 Giants fans in the Meadowlands.If Carolina gets 7 here, game over.

 

[snogger]

TD Smith!!!!

 

[gman8343]

oh well

 

[bostonfred]

Riding the bull!

 

[NorvilleBarnes]

Well that was quick.

 

[Genester]

That Steve Smith guy doesn't suck!

 

[Johnny Ice]

Steve Smith AGAIN!!!

 

[Green and Gold]

Someone should tell Manning to stop watching game tape of Brunell.

 

[Keys Myaths]

That sound you hear is the air coming out of 80,000 Giants fans in the Meadowlands.

If Carolina gets 7 here, game over.

There's 6.And how many times do the Panthers need to run the Smith play before teams finally plan for it?

 

[Badm]

Steve Smith is amazing...understatement.

 

[jeff_eaglz]

That sound you hear is the air coming out of 80,000 Giants fans in the Meadowlands.

If Carolina gets 7 here, game over.

Um, like that.

 

[RAPTURE]

Eli Manning is no Tom Brady!Rapture

 

[wilked]

fumble, Carolina gets another break

Shockey's non-fumble benefitted Carolina?

Are you an idiot? How could that have benefitted Carolina?

The obvious point is that it is laughable for you to get mad about that play

Who was mad? Not me...

 

[Ghost Rider]

Steve Smith is a man among boys. On this day, the role of the boys are being played by the New York Giants defense.

 

[snogger]

Early shot taken here.IF the Panthers hold on to win and play like this next week.. Hello NFC Championship game.

 

[Keys Myaths]

Eli Manning is no Tom Brady!

Rapture

Rapture=Master of the Obvious.KEYS

 

[Grace Under Pressure]

Steve Smith. That Carolina D is gonna pin their ears back now. Giants in serious trouble here.

 

[cowboyz]

No challenge on the Goings fumble?

down by contact, unchallengable

The top rule I'd like to see something done about - this "down by contact" is weak.Not sure what the change I suggest is, but something should be done. And 'letting the play continue' and saying a challenge can fix an injustice - also weak. Lost timeouts and challenges can haunt you.

Be sure to get back to us when you have some idea on how to fix it

i think they could change possession without allowing a return on those plays.

 

[Badm]

Early shot taken here.

IF the Panthers hold on to win and play like this next week..

Hello NFC Championship game.

Ummmmm.....NOT!!!!This ain't the Bears D.

 

[jeff_eaglz]

So I give this thread about 30 minutes more of this before it becomes the CHI/CAR thread.....By the way - Carolina will be about 4 point dog in Chicago. Not saying it is right, just what it would be.Chicago would only be a 2 pt fav over NY.

 

[NorvilleBarnes]

Come on NY - make a game of it at least!

 

[msommer]

Bears dosn't seem to have much offence but they have a bit more D than NYG does today

 

[MeVsMaradona]

Good 'ol Eli.

Brunell had 40 and a pick right? hes what 15 years older then eli?

 

[bostonfred]

Maybe Eli does have a little bit of his big brother in him.

 

[Badm]

Who was complaining that the loss of players on the Giants *defense* was the reason they were losing?

The offense blows.

Ya got me there. They are playing very poorly. :X

 

[jeff_eaglz]

No challenge on the Goings fumble?

down by contact, unchallengable

The top rule I'd like to see something done about - this "down by contact" is weak.Not sure what the change I suggest is, but something should be done. And 'letting the play continue' and saying a challenge can fix an injustice - also weak. Lost timeouts and challenges can haunt you.

Be sure to get back to us when you have some idea on how to fix it

Should we start a poll?Wilked contributes something or the Giants score..... which happens first?

 

[Johnny Ice]

Good 'ol Eli.

Brunell had 40 and a pick right? hes what 15 years older then eli?

Keep your head up and focus on your dog fight.

 

[Ghost Rider]

Should we start a poll?

Wilked contributes something or the Giants score..... which happens first?

The latter.

 

[Genester]

Maybe Eli does have a little bit of his big brother in him.

Here, I helped highlight the key part of that statement.