What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Getcha passports ready - the middle-aged dummies are going to the British Isles! Top 31 song countdown. (2 Viewers)

Ilov80s said:
krista4 said:
Lest anyone be upset with scorchy for messing up their Bitter Sweet Symphony pick :lol: , I'll mention that The Verve actually has four different songs selected. Same with Dusty Springfield who was our other most popular choice for the Ace Award - she gets four songs as well.
Click to expand...
I will be honest, I don't think I have heard another Verve song. I am shocked there are 4. Something interesting. There are a few song guesses there that I've literally never heard of.
Click to expand...

We love The Verve in this house. My daughter warned me there would be other picks, but I just thought Bitter stood out so much that... well, I was wrong. The kid thinks Ashcroft is pure musical genius and loves his solo stuff too. I still wish she made a list.
 
krista4 said:
Pip's Invitation said:
Pip’s Invitation:

Cruel To Be Kind - Nick Lowe
(new artist)
Click to expand...
As I told Krista when I submitted my list, this is a perfect power pop song that sounds like what Alex Chilton could have done in the late '70s if he had wanted to continue making power pop, which he did not.

I remember it fondly from the car radio and the early days of MTV. It is perfectly constructed in every way -- it sounds like Paul could have written this at the height of his power in the Beatles.
Click to expand...

I agree with all of this! Nick Lowe in general is underrated, for his own work and the work he wrote and/or produced for others. I'm sure many people know of his work with Elvis Costello (especially people who are trying to be cool), but I didn't realize until this exercise that he'd produced acts as varied as The Damned, Johnny Cash, Wreckless Eric, John Hiatt, and Mavericks.
Click to expand...
Johnny Cash was also Nick's father in law. Imagine being a musician and having that guy as your wife's step dad.
 
Ilov80s said:
krista4 said:
Lest anyone be upset with scorchy for messing up their Bitter Sweet Symphony pick :lol: , I'll mention that The Verve actually has four different songs selected. Same with Dusty Springfield who was our other most popular choice for the Ace Award - she gets four songs as well.
Click to expand...
I will be honest, I don't think I have heard another Verve song. I am shocked there are 4. Something interesting. There are a few song guesses there that I've literally never heard of.
Click to expand...
They had a couple other popular songs in the 90s - The Freshmen and Reverend Girl
 
krista4 said:
Six-Point Selections:

Pip’s Invitation:

Cruel To Be Kind - Nick Lowe
(new artist)


simey:

Time Of The Season - The Zombies
(new song)



Yankee23Fan:

Starman – David Bowie
(new artist)


jwb:

Smooth Operator - Sade
(new artist)


scorchy:

The Drugs Don't Work - The Verve
(new song)



Andy Dufresne:

Atmosphere - Joy Division
(new artist)


rockaction:

Complete Control – The Clash
(duplicate – second vote)



Doug B:

Cities In Dust - Siouxsie and the Banshees
(new artist)


Chaos34:

Rain In The Summertime - The Alarm
(new artist)


Zegras11:

Here Comes The Sun - The Beatles
(new song)


Oliver Humanzee:

Suspect Device - Stiff Little Fingers
(duplicate – third vote in three days)


Mrs. Eephus:

Up The Junction – Squeeze
(new song)
Click to expand...
These are my favorites from the songs I know well. Six of them were in my top 90.
 
krista4 said:
scorchy said:
Yesterday was really an amazing bunch of songs. I always knew I was an Anglophile, but the immense chasm between this list and the American one so far (IMO, obvs) totally cements it. I was forced into the difficult decision to be way more discriminating in my round-by-round favorites post lest I end up with 2/3 of the songs from the round getting repeated on it. Also came to the realization that the wording of my categories keep me from listing songs that will be coming up among by own Top 31 (without spotlighting, of course). Oh well.
Click to expand...

I'm with you. I'm loving these selections more, and even more so I find almost all of them listenable even if they aren't my favorites, which wasn't the case in the US countdown.
Click to expand...
It's pretty much the opposite for me.

There are songs that have been chosen here that I love, and I suspect many more are to come. But the depth & variety isn't anywhere close - in my opinion - to the US version of this countdown. There are a couple hundred artists I regret leaving out of the other, but I'd have strained to make 31 here and most of those wouldn't have even been in consideration for a combined list (maybe 3 or 4).

That's what keeps this rock spinning, though. I'm enjoying following along and reading everyone's stories about why they love these records - which is much more interesting to me than the records themselves.
 
My Chvrches pick was my major miss of the 31. This was the pick that caused the PM to krista after I submitted. This was the band that was brought up when my wife and I were talking about the UK artists, and she just asked "oh, what Chvrches song did you pick?" - rightly assuming that it should have been a no-brainer it was on my list. If I would have thought of them, it would have been in my top 10. In hindsight, it should be around my #8 pick instead of that one. Love them, and have seen them a few times now. Clearest Blue is the KP family's favorite by them, so that's why it made the list. The song that was the farthest up my list I felt OK with leaving off was No You Girls, so that's what got the axe to fit this one in.
 
worrierking:

There's No Way Out Of Here - David Gilmour
(new artist)
Click to expand...

I love Gilmour's self titled first solo album and anyone who likes the Gilmour-led post-Waters version of Floyd should check it out. The production gives off a great vibe and of course there is great guitar work throughout.

simey:

Time Of The Season - The Zombies
(new song)
Click to expand...

This was in my last 5 out. :heart:

Yankee23Fan:

Starman – David Bowie
(new artist)
Click to expand...

Gonna take this opportunity to post another hilarious scene from Walk Hard.
shuke:

Shouldn't Have Took More Than You Gave - Dave Mason
(new artist)
Click to expand...

I first got hooked on this song when I heard a live version on Traffic's Welcome to the Canteen. Soon thereafter I bought the Alone Together album and wore it out for the rest of high school and all of college.

scorchy:

The Drugs Don't Work - The Verve
(new song)
Click to expand...

I didn't take Bitter Sweet Symphony for the tiebreaker contest because I figured Scorchy would pull out this or one of their other songs. Of course my plan of Son of a Preacher Man didn't work either.

Zegras11:

Here Comes The Sun - The Beatles
(new song)
Click to expand...

In my top 5 of Beatles songs. My son loves it also. :heart::heart::heart::heart:

Oliver Humanzee:

Suspect Device - Stiff Little Fingers
(duplicate – third vote in three days)
Click to expand...

I figured that if I shared any picks with OH, this song was the most likely one.
 
Leroy Hoard said:
krista4 said:
Pip's Invitation said:
Pip’s Invitation:

Cruel To Be Kind - Nick Lowe
(new artist)
Click to expand...
As I told Krista when I submitted my list, this is a perfect power pop song that sounds like what Alex Chilton could have done in the late '70s if he had wanted to continue making power pop, which he did not.

I remember it fondly from the car radio and the early days of MTV. It is perfectly constructed in every way -- it sounds like Paul could have written this at the height of his power in the Beatles.
Click to expand...

I agree with all of this! Nick Lowe in general is underrated, for his own work and the work he wrote and/or produced for others. I'm sure many people know of his work with Elvis Costello (especially people who are trying to be cool), but I didn't realize until this exercise that he'd produced acts as varied as The Damned, Johnny Cash, Wreckless Eric, John Hiatt, and Mavericks.
Click to expand...
Johnny Cash was also Nick's father in law. Imagine being a musician and having that guy as your wife's step dad.
Click to expand...
On a related note, this ties into my comment about Paul Carrack's all-to-brief tenure in Squeeze. He left after a year to join a backing band for Carlene Carter -- and from there he went to Nick Lowe's Noise to Go. (And after that to Mike and the Mechanics, but you all probably knew that.)
 
Uruk-Hai said:
krista4 said:
scorchy said:
Yesterday was really an amazing bunch of songs. I always knew I was an Anglophile, but the immense chasm between this list and the American one so far (IMO, obvs) totally cements it. I was forced into the difficult decision to be way more discriminating in my round-by-round favorites post lest I end up with 2/3 of the songs from the round getting repeated on it. Also came to the realization that the wording of my categories keep me from listing songs that will be coming up among by own Top 31 (without spotlighting, of course). Oh well.
Click to expand...

I'm with you. I'm loving these selections more, and even more so I find almost all of them listenable even if they aren't my favorites, which wasn't the case in the US countdown.
Click to expand...
It's pretty much the opposite for me.

There are songs that have been chosen here that I love, and I suspect many more are to come. But the depth & variety isn't anywhere close - in my opinion - to the US version of this countdown. There are a couple hundred artists I regret leaving out of the other, but I'd have strained to make 31 here and most of those wouldn't have even been in consideration for a combined list (maybe 3 or 4).

That's what keeps this rock spinning, though. I'm enjoying following along and reading everyone's stories about why they love these records - which is much more interesting to me than the records themselves.
Click to expand...
Also because you're a jerkface. :laugh:
 
krista4 said:
worrierking:

There's No Way Out Of Here - David Gilmour
(new artist)
Click to expand...

This was the biggest surprise on the list for me. Nice! Since I went down the Floyd hole last night and this was discussed, here's some background. It's usually attributed to David, but it's a cover. He discovered a folk rock band in 77-78 and a brilliant teenage singer and decided to produce records for both. Unicorn was the band's name and Gilmour liked this one so much he told them he was gonna take a swing at it. His vocals, his guitar, soaring Floyd-like female back up singers. He killed it. Despite the success of Animals, Wish, and Dark the guys were financially desperate having been duped by their financial management. They weren't getting along much or working together. Unicorn flopped. David's solo album flopped. The teenager's debut was a big hit helping David out financially. The rise of punk and the teenager's debut, according to Gilmour, both contributed to the flop of his first solo effort.

Around this time Roger got the guys together and explained what he'd been working on. His little dream of an autobiographical concept album, a film, and a tour where they would play behind a wall. The others had nothing better going so they went to work. And whew, did Roger and David go the extra mile to make it all happen. Anyway the teenager Gilmour discovered was Kathy Bush, but they decided to call her Kate.
 
Pip's Invitation said:
Uruk-Hai said:
krista4 said:
scorchy said:
Yesterday was really an amazing bunch of songs. I always knew I was an Anglophile, but the immense chasm between this list and the American one so far (IMO, obvs) totally cements it. I was forced into the difficult decision to be way more discriminating in my round-by-round favorites post lest I end up with 2/3 of the songs from the round getting repeated on it. Also came to the realization that the wording of my categories keep me from listing songs that will be coming up among by own Top 31 (without spotlighting, of course). Oh well.
Click to expand...

I'm with you. I'm loving these selections more, and even more so I find almost all of them listenable even if they aren't my favorites, which wasn't the case in the US countdown.
Click to expand...
It's pretty much the opposite for me.

There are songs that have been chosen here that I love, and I suspect many more are to come. But the depth & variety isn't anywhere close - in my opinion - to the US version of this countdown. There are a couple hundred artists I regret leaving out of the other, but I'd have strained to make 31 here and most of those wouldn't have even been in consideration for a combined list (maybe 3 or 4).

That's what keeps this rock spinning, though. I'm enjoying following along and reading everyone's stories about why they love these records - which is much more interesting to me than the records themselves.
Click to expand...
Also because you're a jerkface. :laugh:
Click to expand...
That's a given, Pip. I thought everyone filtered my comments through that lens. I know I would.
 
Hawks64 said:
krista4 said:
Six-Point Selections:

Pip’s Invitation:

Cruel To Be Kind - Nick Lowe
(new artist)


New Binky the Doormat:

Conquistador - Procol Harum
(new song)


worrierking:

There's No Way Out Of Here - David Gilmour
(new artist)


titusbramble:

Take Me Out – Franz Ferdinand
(duplicate – third vote)


simey:

Time Of The Season - The Zombies
(new song)


Just Win Baby:

Nothing Compares 2 U - Sinead O’Connor
(new artist)


Don Quixote:

Rolling In The Deep - Adele
(new song)


MAC_32:

Last Train Home - Lostprophets
(new artist)


timschochet:

Leather Jacket - Mick Taylor
(new artist)


Yankee23Fan:

Starman – David Bowie
(new artist)


Hawks64:

Mistreated – Deep Purple
(new song)


jwb:

Smooth Operator - Sade
(new artist)


DrIanMalcolm:

Steppin' Out - Joe Jackson
(new song)


Dr. Octopus:

Someone Saved My Life Tonight - Elton John
(duplicate – second vote)


KarmaPolice:

Clearest Blue - CHVRCHES
(new artist)


shuke:

Shouldn't Have Took More Than You Gave - Dave Mason
(new artist)


Manster:

Sails - Elephant Tree
(new artist)


scorchy:

The Drugs Don't Work - The Verve
(new song)


Sullie:

Something About You - Level 42
(new artist)


Andy Dufresne:

Atmosphere - Joy Division
(new artist)


Mister CIA:

Time Has Told Me - Nick Drake
(new song)


Mrs. Rannous:

Dance Hall Days - Wang Chung
(new artist)


higgins:

See The World - Gomez
(new song)


The Dreaded Marco:

Dark Entries – Bauhaus
(new song)


simsarge:

Let Me Be There - Olivia Newton-John
(new song)


Mt. Man:

(Forever) Live And Die - Orchestral Manoeuvres In the Dark
(new artist)


landrys hat:

I'll Get Along - Michael Kiwanuka
(new artist)


Westerberg:

Good Fortune - PJ Harvey
(new artist)


Eephus:

Stay With Me – Faces
(new song)


rockaction:

Complete Control – The Clash
(duplicate – second vote)


falguy:

White Flag – Dido
(new artist)


Hov34:

Valerie – Mark Ronson ft. Amy Winehouse
(duplicate – second vote)


zamboni:

Day Is Done - Nick Drake
(new song)


Doug B:

Cities In Dust - Siouxsie and the Banshees
(new artist)


Ilov80s:

Latch – Disclosure feat. Sam Smith
(both new artists)


Val Rannous:

Uprising - Muse
(new song, but see below)


Chaos34:

Rain In The Summertime - The Alarm
(new artist)


Chaz McNulty:

Always On My Mind – Pet Shop Boys
(new song)


Zegras11:

Here Comes The Sun - The Beatles
(new song)


AAABatteries:

Uprising – Muse
(duplicate – second vote today!)


Oliver Humanzee:

Suspect Device - Stiff Little Fingers
(duplicate – third vote in three days)


Mrs. Eephus:

Up The Junction – Squeeze
(new song)


ditkaburgers:

Dirty Harry – Gorillaz
(new artist)


cosjobs:

Driftin' – The Invaders
(new artist)


krista4:

Outdoor Miner – Wire
(new artist)
Click to expand...
Double tres list.
And we had a first today, I couldn't find two songs! Sorry @MAC_32 and @cosjobs Spotify did not have either of your picks. :kicksrock:


ETA Apologies, but I will be heading out for the day so I won't be able to get Docs songs on the list till later tonight or tomorrow.
Click to expand...
My link
 
Uruk-Hai said:
Pip's Invitation said:
Uruk-Hai said:
krista4 said:
scorchy said:
Yesterday was really an amazing bunch of songs. I always knew I was an Anglophile, but the immense chasm between this list and the American one so far (IMO, obvs) totally cements it. I was forced into the difficult decision to be way more discriminating in my round-by-round favorites post lest I end up with 2/3 of the songs from the round getting repeated on it. Also came to the realization that the wording of my categories keep me from listing songs that will be coming up among by own Top 31 (without spotlighting, of course). Oh well.
Click to expand...

I'm with you. I'm loving these selections more, and even more so I find almost all of them listenable even if they aren't my favorites, which wasn't the case in the US countdown.
Click to expand...
It's pretty much the opposite for me.

There are songs that have been chosen here that I love, and I suspect many more are to come. But the depth & variety isn't anywhere close - in my opinion - to the US version of this countdown. There are a couple hundred artists I regret leaving out of the other, but I'd have strained to make 31 here and most of those wouldn't have even been in consideration for a combined list (maybe 3 or 4).

That's what keeps this rock spinning, though. I'm enjoying following along and reading everyone's stories about why they love these records - which is much more interesting to me than the records themselves.
Click to expand...
Also because you're a jerkface. :laugh:
Click to expand...
That's a given, Pip. I thought everyone filtered my comments through that lens. I know I would.
Click to expand...
I know. I was just memeing back to Krista's comment on page 1.
 
Chaos34 said:
krista4 said:
worrierking:

There's No Way Out Of Here - David Gilmour
(new artist)
Click to expand...

This was the biggest surprise on the list for me. Nice! Since I went down the Floyd hole last night and this was discussed, here's some background. It's usually attributed to David, but it's a cover. He discovered a folk rock band in 77-78 and a brilliant teenage singer and decided to produce records for both. Unicorn was the band's name and Gilmour liked this one so much he told them he was gonna take a swing at it. His vocals, his guitar, soaring Floyd-like female back up singers. He killed it. Despite the success of Animals, Wish, and Dark the guys were financially desperate having been duped by their financial management. They weren't getting along much or working together. Unicorn flopped. David's solo album flopped. The teenager's debut was a big hit helping David out financially. The rise of punk and the teenager's debut, according to Gilmour, both contributed to the flop of his first solo effort.

Around this time Roger got the guys together and explained what he'd been working on. His little dream of an autobiographical concept album, a film, and a tour where they would play behind a wall. The others had nothing better going so they went to work. And whew, did Roger and David go the extra mile to make it all happen. Anyway the teenager Gilmour discovered was Kathy Bush, but they decided to call her Kate.
Click to expand...
Up until 4-5 years ago I thought this was a Monster Magnet song and 1 of my favs by them. They also do a decent cover of Venus In Furs on the same album(Monolithic Baby!)
 
Known-to-me favorites from the six-pointers, AKA a touchdown when Brett Maher attempts the extra point, excluding my own pick and Suspect Device which is known to be on my list:

Rolling in the Deep -- Adele (Don Quixote)
Valerie -- Mark Ronson ft. Amy Winehouse (Hov34)
Time of the Season -- The Zombies (Simey)
Here Comes the Sun -- The Beatles (Zegras11)
Take Me Out -- Franz Ferdinand (Titusbramble)
Shouldn't Have Took More Than You Gave -- Dave Mason (Shuke)
Stay With Me -- Faces (Eephus)
Smooth Operator -- Sade (jwb)
There's No Way Out of Here -- David Gilmour (Worrierking)
Steppin' Out -- Joe Jackson (DrIanMalcolm)
Good Fortune -- PJ Harvey (Westerberg)
Starman -- David Bowie (Yankee23Fan)
Conquistador -- Procol Harum (Binky)
Something About You -- Level 42 (Sullie)
 
Last edited:
krista4 said:
titusbramble said:
It kind of sucks seeing a failure of reactions to your pick when it's been chosen twice already, but at the same time Take Me Out is a banger
Click to expand...

Yeah, a lot of people are going to face this. A large number of songs got 5+ votes, so by the time the people who really loved the song come up, they could be played out, so to speak.

I do love "Take Me Out"!
Click to expand...

Also, I saw Franz Ferdinand in Chicago when they were on the tour supporting this album, and they were a fantastic live show. One of the best I saw during that time period, and I saw a squillion shows a year back then.
 
titusbramble said:
It kind of sucks seeing a failure of reactions to your pick when it's been chosen twice already, but at the same time Take Me Out is a banger
Click to expand...
I marked your pick wrong on my master list -- my post is edited now.

The first FF album and Take Me Out in particular was a huge deal among my friends during my Lost Years. It's one of the best examples of danceable rock we've ever seen.
 
Uruk-Hai said:
krista4 said:
scorchy said:
Yesterday was really an amazing bunch of songs. I always knew I was an Anglophile, but the immense chasm between this list and the American one so far (IMO, obvs) totally cements it. I was forced into the difficult decision to be way more discriminating in my round-by-round favorites post lest I end up with 2/3 of the songs from the round getting repeated on it. Also came to the realization that the wording of my categories keep me from listing songs that will be coming up among by own Top 31 (without spotlighting, of course). Oh well.
Click to expand...

I'm with you. I'm loving these selections more, and even more so I find almost all of them listenable even if they aren't my favorites, which wasn't the case in the US countdown.
Click to expand...
It's pretty much the opposite for me.

There are songs that have been chosen here that I love, and I suspect many more are to come. But the depth & variety isn't anywhere close - in my opinion - to the US version of this countdown. There are a couple hundred artists I regret leaving out of the other, but I'd have strained to make 31 here and most of those wouldn't have even been in consideration for a combined list (maybe 3 or 4).

That's what keeps this rock spinning, though. I'm enjoying following along and reading everyone's stories about why they love these records - which is much more interesting to me than the records themselves.
Click to expand...

I would agree with this, and it's obvious over the first few rounds and was solidified when Krista confirmed how many fewer artists there were drafted here vs. the US lists despite having several more participants. Both countdowns are great, but my lean with these is more wanting to be introduced to a lot of new artists vs. a lot of songs from fewer newer artists.
 
Maybe I'm misremembering the first few rounds, but did we have an equivalent of something like the same George Michael song being taken 3 times or the same Stiff Little Fingers songs 3 times?
 
krista4 said:
Sleaford Mods
Click to expand...

Last night, while trying to sleep, I was playing a semi-conscious game with El Floppo about homeless guys yelling at me and how that related to this thread's point total. It went over and over in my head. Fizzy!

Honestly don't know why that happened. Yes, Flop loves Sleaford Mods.

Other things:

"Take Me Out" is an awesome track that deserves a meritorious affirmative nod every time it's been posted.

"Outdoor Miner" is a fantastic track, and one I considered.

There's another one there I'm forgetting that I saw and loved. TK.

I opined about "Complete Control" the other day. Suffice it to say that it's the Clash's declaration of independence from every pressure but their own to be the best rock and roll band in the world. That's how they (naively) saw it, anyway.
 
Last edited:
KarmaPolice said:
Uruk-Hai said:
krista4 said:
scorchy said:
Yesterday was really an amazing bunch of songs. I always knew I was an Anglophile, but the immense chasm between this list and the American one so far (IMO, obvs) totally cements it. I was forced into the difficult decision to be way more discriminating in my round-by-round favorites post lest I end up with 2/3 of the songs from the round getting repeated on it. Also came to the realization that the wording of my categories keep me from listing songs that will be coming up among by own Top 31 (without spotlighting, of course). Oh well.
Click to expand...

I'm with you. I'm loving these selections more, and even more so I find almost all of them listenable even if they aren't my favorites, which wasn't the case in the US countdown.
Click to expand...
It's pretty much the opposite for me.

There are songs that have been chosen here that I love, and I suspect many more are to come. But the depth & variety isn't anywhere close - in my opinion - to the US version of this countdown. There are a couple hundred artists I regret leaving out of the other, but I'd have strained to make 31 here and most of those wouldn't have even been in consideration for a combined list (maybe 3 or 4).

That's what keeps this rock spinning, though. I'm enjoying following along and reading everyone's stories about why they love these records - which is much more interesting to me than the records themselves.
Click to expand...

I would agree with this, and it's obvious over the first few rounds and was solidified when Krista confirmed how many fewer artists there were drafted here vs. the US lists despite having several more participants. Both countdowns are great, but my lean with these is more wanting to be introduced to a lot of new artists vs. a lot of songs from fewer newer artists.
Click to expand...

how about new songs from bands you know?
 
krista4 said:
krista4 said:
titusbramble said:
It kind of sucks seeing a failure of reactions to your pick when it's been chosen twice already, but at the same time Take Me Out is a banger
Click to expand...

Yeah, a lot of people are going to face this. A large number of songs got 5+ votes, so by the time the people who really loved the song come up, they could be played out, so to speak.

I do love "Take Me Out"!
Click to expand...

Also, I saw Franz Ferdinand in Chicago when they were on the tour supporting this album, and they were a fantastic live show. One of the best I saw during that time period, and I saw a squillion shows a year back then.
Click to expand...
The time I saw them live was first on during one of the NME tours in 2004 behind the Von Bondies, the Rapture (both ineligible hence naming, House of Jealous Lovers by the latter is incredible) and eligible Welsh band who were headlining but who were terrible, literally half the crowd had left within three songs of their set, myself included
 
A bit more balanced today on whether I knew the songs or not today. As all things should be? Regardless, always some tough choices to prevent me from talking about half the list!

#26s
Recognized by title alone: 19
Sounded familiar: 5
Knew from this countdown: 2
Didn't know: 15

Selected Favorites:
Time of the Season (simey)
Steppin’ Out (DrIanMalcolm)
Something About You (Sullie)
Stay With Me (Eephus)

Some songs I didn't know that I ended up liking:
Shouldn’t Have Took More Than You Gave (shuke)
Time Has Told Me (Mister CIA) - Really, props to both Nick Drake selections, but I preferred this one on first listen.
See The World (higgins)
Rain In the Summertime (Chaos34)
 
New Binky the Doormat said:
KarmaPolice said:
Uruk-Hai said:
krista4 said:
scorchy said:
Yesterday was really an amazing bunch of songs. I always knew I was an Anglophile, but the immense chasm between this list and the American one so far (IMO, obvs) totally cements it. I was forced into the difficult decision to be way more discriminating in my round-by-round favorites post lest I end up with 2/3 of the songs from the round getting repeated on it. Also came to the realization that the wording of my categories keep me from listing songs that will be coming up among by own Top 31 (without spotlighting, of course). Oh well.
Click to expand...

I'm with you. I'm loving these selections more, and even more so I find almost all of them listenable even if they aren't my favorites, which wasn't the case in the US countdown.
Click to expand...
It's pretty much the opposite for me.

There are songs that have been chosen here that I love, and I suspect many more are to come. But the depth & variety isn't anywhere close - in my opinion - to the US version of this countdown. There are a couple hundred artists I regret leaving out of the other, but I'd have strained to make 31 here and most of those wouldn't have even been in consideration for a combined list (maybe 3 or 4).

That's what keeps this rock spinning, though. I'm enjoying following along and reading everyone's stories about why they love these records - which is much more interesting to me than the records themselves.
Click to expand...

I would agree with this, and it's obvious over the first few rounds and was solidified when Krista confirmed how many fewer artists there were drafted here vs. the US lists despite having several more participants. Both countdowns are great, but my lean with these is more wanting to be introduced to a lot of new artists vs. a lot of songs from fewer newer artists.
Click to expand...

how about new songs from bands you know?
Click to expand...
There's been some, like a couple Deep Purple tracks. That's cool too, but like I said, my slight preference is new artists that I get introduced to.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

Tau837
Middle Aged Dummies Music Countdowns
Replies
15
Views
986
Dr. Octopus
Dr. Octopus
Zegras11
Middle Aged Dummies - Artist - Round 5 - #1's have been posted. Link in OP.
57 58 59
Replies
3K
Views
216K
Zegras11
Zegras11
krista4
Middle-aged Dummies are back and bursting at the "themes" to get going! Full theme ahead!
101 102 103
Replies
5K
Views
112K
higgins
higgins

Users who are viewing this thread

Total: 1 (members: 0, guests: 1)
Back
Top