I think the Stones's "Can't You Hear Me Knocking" and Bobby Keys changed my absolutism about the instrument within rock n' roll, as have other songs, but it's not a go-to. (Watch—I'll love the rest of your songs now that I've said this.)
Oh yeah, before guitar-driven rock n' roll and Chuck Berry, piano and sax ruled the day for rock n' roll.
Had a big influence on surf rock too. Horrifying. You don't have to see the scene to feel the horror.
It’s not all bad. I got some new threads out of it at stage 25 at least.I didn’t submit a list, or listen to any of these yet, but just from the titles so far, it uncannily describes stages of my marriage.Songs where artists let out excessive vocalizations of the “ahh,” “ooh,” “dee,” etc. variety.
I hope this exercise isn't just a bunch of frustration for you guys, but I'm enjoying the creativity in the guesses!
(We will know for sure if #1 is I Feel Free by Cream.)
Also: “exercise in frustration” is pretty apt as well.
I missed this when I wrote "narrative arc for a divorce" as a guess. Holy smoke. Sorry to hear that, Rustoleum.
It’s not all bad. I got some new threads out of it at stage 25 at least.
The Syreeta regulation: The artist must have recorded (almost) entirely under a mononym. This one has some wiggle room because my research wasn't that comprehensive. For example, Syreeta also released an early Motown single under her given name Rita Wright.
You have one like this where oddly enough someone else has a song by this artist on their list, under her recording name at the time, though it was not her given name.
Update: I'm still stumped.I don't think any new guesses came in last time.
Selections:
31. If You Tolerate This Your Children Will Be Next - Manic Street Preachers
30. Hear The Drummer Get Wicked - Chad Jackson
29. Pick Up The Pieces - Average White Band
28. Virtual Insanity – Jamiroquai
27. Another Chance - Roger Sanchez
26. Living On My Own - Freddie Mercury
25. Sharp Dressed Man - ZZ Top
24. Better Off Alone - Alice Deejay
23. Love Is The Drug - Roxy Music
Incorrect guesses:
Songs that give advice
Bands That Have Never Been in My Kitchen
Songs by artists who have headlined Glastonbury
Songs featuring the Mellotron
Fear mongering
Song titles that could be part of geometry proofs
Bands who have a member whose first or last name is a James Bond reference
Bands with family members
Songs that reference a location in another country
Songs that have nine or more words in the title
Songs that mention famous streets
Bands who had a member mysteriously disappear, get declared dead, but no body has ever been found
Songs that reference footballguys user names
Songs without a guitar
Song titles that are commands
First two words of song titles in order of lyrics from The Youngbloods’ Get Together
Songs about resilience in the face of adversity
Songs about the importance of progress
Songs to make people overthink and speculate about an imaginary theme that doesn't really exist
31 songs that MADs submitted in prior MAD rounds, but judge disqualified because the submitting MAD failed to get the long-form birth certificate of all band members before submitting
Songs NOT produced by Todd Rundgren
Artists without umlauts
Songs Sam Rockwell has danced to in a movie
Songs about navigating and adapting to a constantly changing world
Songs credited to more than one songwriter
UK top ten singles
Singles released by UK artist/bands
31 British Isles Songs That Did Not Appear in the MAD British Isles Countdown
Non-guitar driven songs
Songs in 4/4 time
Broadway shows
Songs that all charted in the same six countries:
UK
Australia
Germany
France
Ireland
Netherlands
Songs under 5 minutes
Songs where artists let out excessive vocalizations of the “ahh,” “ooh,” “dee,” etc. variety
A break up and starting over
Things that will drive a bunch of middle aged dummies who are trying to find a pattern go crazy
Stages in Rustoluem’s marriage
Guinness World Records
Songs that can qualify for other people’s themes
Songs by people with facial hair
All songs use an instrument with keys
Songs that are the narrative arc of a divorce
I believe this song would sound great on any system.
Note to @DrIanMalcolm , feel free to score songs like this and "Tonight, Tonight" as wins for Chicago. I promise you that even if Chicago takes an early lead, I have some songs near the end that will even things up.![]()
25.
Who? – B.B. King
What? – B.B. King
Where? – NJPAC
When? – 1998
Why? – King was a very old man when I saw him (sitting one row ahead of Newark Mayor, Sharpe James) in Newark. His storytelling and jokes alone were worth the admission price, but while he had some trouble moving around and played sitting down on a stool for 95% of the set, he showed he could still play Lucille and make her sound pretty.
#, Please # 24
Song: 1999
Artist: Prince
Year: 1982
My roommate David had a theory about "1999" circa 1984 or 85. He posited that whenever the song came on at a party, it was time to leave and go somewhere else. This was back in the days when we had multiple options on a given night. It sort of worked because it was the period of Prince's peak popularity.
I got a text from him last week saying he's defending his doctoral dissertation at the end of this month. I don't think it's about his "1999" theory but it's still an incredible accomplishment for a guy who's been a heroin user for many of the 40 years we've known each other.
This is another band that I can’t find too much about. This song was by far their biggest hit. They were another one of the bands formed in the wake of the Nigerian civil war. The African Music Library has this summary of them:
Wrinkars Experience was a Nigerian afro-funk band formed in Lagos in 1970. Led by guitarist and singer Dannie Ian Mbaezue, they consisted of a multi-ethnic group of Nigerian, Cameroonian, and Ghanaian musicians. Wrinkars Experience's music blended traditional Nigerian rhythms with funk, soul, and jazz. They released their debut album, "Fuel for Love," in 1970. The album was successful, and it helped to make them one of the most popular bands in Nigeria. The band also released other successful albums, including "Money to Burn" (1972), "Soundway" (1973), and "Ballad of a Sad Young Woman" (1974). Wrinkars Experience disbanded in 1977, but their music continues to be influential today. The band is considered one of the pioneers of Afro-funk music, inspiring generations of Nigerian and African musicians.
Not all rain songs are depressing, musically at least.
seeing as how I just finished a book by Saul Bellow."Rain King" is a single by the rock band Counting Crows. It was released as the band's fourth single (and third single from their debut album). The title is a reference to Saul Bellow's Henderson the Rain King. "Rain King" peaked at number 66 on the US Billboard Hot 100 Airplay chart, number 18 in Canada, and number four in Iceland. In April 2022, American Songwriter ranked the song at number eight on their list of "The Top 10 Counting Crows Songs".
I like all of the lyrics, but especially the YEAHHHHHHHH at the end.Adam Duritz said, about this song: "I read this book in college when I was at Berkeley called Henderson, the Rain King. And the main character in the book was kind of this big, open-wound of a person, Eugene Henderson, he just sort of bled all over everyone around him. For better or for worse, full of joy, full of sorrow, he just made a mess of everything.
I keep going back to my breakup and moving on guess - can't see anything else at all.Update: I'm still stumped.I don't think any new guesses came in last time.
Selections:
31. If You Tolerate This Your Children Will Be Next - Manic Street Preachers
30. Hear The Drummer Get Wicked - Chad Jackson
29. Pick Up The Pieces - Average White Band
28. Virtual Insanity – Jamiroquai
27. Another Chance - Roger Sanchez
26. Living On My Own - Freddie Mercury
25. Sharp Dressed Man - ZZ Top
24. Better Off Alone - Alice Deejay
23. Love Is The Drug - Roxy Music
Incorrect guesses:
Songs that give advice
Bands That Have Never Been in My Kitchen
Songs by artists who have headlined Glastonbury
Songs featuring the Mellotron
Fear mongering
Song titles that could be part of geometry proofs
Bands who have a member whose first or last name is a James Bond reference
Bands with family members
Songs that reference a location in another country
Songs that have nine or more words in the title
Songs that mention famous streets
Bands who had a member mysteriously disappear, get declared dead, but no body has ever been found
Songs that reference footballguys user names
Songs without a guitar
Song titles that are commands
First two words of song titles in order of lyrics from The Youngbloods’ Get Together
Songs about resilience in the face of adversity
Songs about the importance of progress
Songs to make people overthink and speculate about an imaginary theme that doesn't really exist
31 songs that MADs submitted in prior MAD rounds, but judge disqualified because the submitting MAD failed to get the long-form birth certificate of all band members before submitting
Songs NOT produced by Todd Rundgren
Artists without umlauts
Songs Sam Rockwell has danced to in a movie
Songs about navigating and adapting to a constantly changing world
Songs credited to more than one songwriter
UK top ten singles
Singles released by UK artist/bands
31 British Isles Songs That Did Not Appear in the MAD British Isles Countdown
Non-guitar driven songs
Songs in 4/4 time
Broadway shows
Songs that all charted in the same six countries:
UK
Australia
Germany
France
Ireland
Netherlands
Songs under 5 minutes
Songs where artists let out excessive vocalizations of the “ahh,” “ooh,” “dee,” etc. variety
A break up and starting over
Things that will drive a bunch of middle aged dummies who are trying to find a pattern go crazy
Stages in Rustoluem’s marriage
Guinness World Records
Songs that can qualify for other people’s themes
Songs by people with facial hair
All songs use an instrument with keys
Songs that are the narrative arc of a divorce
Addiction?I don't think any new guesses came in last time.
Selections:
31. If You Tolerate This Your Children Will Be Next - Manic Street Preachers
30. Hear The Drummer Get Wicked - Chad Jackson
29. Pick Up The Pieces - Average White Band
28. Virtual Insanity – Jamiroquai
27. Another Chance - Roger Sanchez
26. Living On My Own - Freddie Mercury
25. Sharp Dressed Man - ZZ Top
24. Better Off Alone - Alice Deejay
23. Love Is The Drug - Roxy Music
My 23 wasn't one I had in regular rotation or even knew about- came up in my research for this.
clap clap clap... good answer! good answer! [/family feud]Addiction?I don't think any new guesses came in last time.
Selections:
31. If You Tolerate This Your Children Will Be Next - Manic Street Preachers
30. Hear The Drummer Get Wicked - Chad Jackson
29. Pick Up The Pieces - Average White Band
28. Virtual Insanity – Jamiroquai
27. Another Chance - Roger Sanchez
26. Living On My Own - Freddie Mercury
25. Sharp Dressed Man - ZZ Top
24. Better Off Alone - Alice Deejay
23. Love Is The Drug - Roxy Music
Summary: Duh! Guns N' Roses is an American hard rock band formed in Los Angeles, California, in 1985, as the result of a merger between local bands L.A. Guns and Hollywood Rose. Their album, Appetite for Destruction is the highest-selling debut of all time in the United States and is often credited with the shift from hair metal to more edgy sound.#23 songs
Yambag – Metal songs from 1988-1992 that became the gateway into the world of music for a young Yambag
You Could Be Mine - Guns N' Roses
I remember first hearing this when the video came out back in 1983. The sound was pretty mind blowing at the time, even for a metalhead like me - particularly Geoff Tate's range.
One of my favorite intros.Summary: Duh! Guns N' Roses is an American hard rock band formed in Los Angeles, California, in 1985, as the result of a merger between local bands L.A. Guns and Hollywood Rose. Their album, Appetite for Destruction is the highest-selling debut of all time in the United States and is often credited with the shift from hair metal to more edgy sound.#23 songs
Yambag – Metal songs from 1988-1992 that became the gateway into the world of music for a young Yambag
You Could Be Mine - Guns N' Roses
Times Seen Live in Concert: 1 = 1992 (with Metallica). I had tickets to see them a few years ago, but after seeing a YT video of Axl trying to sing November Rain, I sold them.
Personal Connection: No list from this timeframe can exist without some GN’R. In fact, according to my friend, Appetite for Destruction was the first cassette tape he ever bought and one of the first band shirts we each owned. Unfortunately, that album was released in 1987 so I could not pick a song from it. While I now prefer other songs from the Use Your Illusion albums, I went with one of the big guns as our school (like many others) used it when introducing football lineups before games.
Other songs to consider: If I had used Appetite for Destruction, I would have gone with It’s So Easy. Something about that one and its rawness hit me big time when I was young.
Mt. Man – Number, Please
1979 – The Smashing Pumpkins
Ilov80s - One song from each of the 31 best albums of 1984
Rock Box - Run-DMC
I have an even worse excuse for not seeing Junior Wells -- my cousin was his guitarist for the last 5 years of his life or so. I missed when they came to Philadelphia and figured I'd get another chance.
Note to @DrIanMalcolm , feel free to score songs like this and "Tonight, Tonight" as wins for Chicago. I promise you that even if Chicago takes an early lead, I have some songs near the end that will even things up.![]()
Ha, I've gotten a bit behind @krista4 - but I'll get at it shortly!
25.
Who? – B.B. King
What? – B.B. King
Where? – NJPAC
When? – 1998
Why? – King was a very old man when I saw him (sitting one row ahead of Newark Mayor, Sharpe James) in Newark. His storytelling and jokes alone were worth the admission price, but while he had some trouble moving around and played sitting down on a stool for 95% of the set, he showed he could still play Lucille and make her sound pretty.
@Dr. Octopus -- this warms my heart that you were able to see him. I saw Otis Rush in the late 1990s when he was only in his early 60s, and he already seemed quite old; he ended up living another 20 years. I also remember when Junior Wells died, and lamenting not having gotten to see him in my lifetime. Made a point of trying to see a number of these folks as they got older.
#, Please # 24
Song: 1999
Artist: Prince
Year: 1982
My roommate David had a theory about "1999" circa 1984 or 85. He posited that whenever the song came on at a party, it was time to leave and go somewhere else. This was back in the days when we had multiple options on a given night. It sort of worked because it was the period of Prince's peak popularity.
I got a text from him last week saying he's defending his doctoral dissertation at the end of this month. I don't think it's about his "1999" theory but it's still an incredible accomplishment for a guy who's been a heroin user for many of the 40 years we've known each other.
I gotta throw a flag on this one, @Eephus ... this warrants a hell of a lot more detail here.
25s and 24s were't particularly great for my tastes.
Ruth Underwood is a national treasure.My 23 wasn't one I had in regular rotation or even knew about- came up in my research for this.
Marimba gets featured here- early and throughout. incorporated as an equal part of the ensemble which feels more like a jazz tune in it's format to me. everybody gets a solo, including the Marimba (Ruth Underwood) who even gets a shout out from the band to close the song "On Ruth, on Ruth, that's Ruth!". this isn't some band wonk who went out and picked up a mallet instrument for S&Gs for a song or two- she is a legit, 4 plus mallet percussion pro.
this is a weird, wacky and wonderful song (stoner dude who worked at my childhood record shop would call these kind of tunes/albums playing over the in-store speaker the 3 dubs... I remember Miles Davis aghartha being the first one he said that about)
I really like this song but it's so embarrassing for me to be caught singing along with the lyrics
Another great one. The bolded had meWorld’s Worst Superheroes #23
Just a Girl
Artist - No Doubt (1995)
Strengths - Frequently underestimated; filled with hidden rage at the patriarchy that won’t let her have any rights; with the bat of an eye, she can have guys like Moustache Man, Dirty White Boy, and especially The Exploding Boy do her bidding (Mr. Tambourine Man seems to be immune)
Weaknesses - Shopping (amiright fellas?); monthly bouts with cramps, hot flashes, and hormonal imbalance; deciding what to eat for dinner; 90-Day Fiancé marathons; the word Moist
There Goes My Hero
Situation - You’re in the finals of the team pie-eating contest at the county fair. Your normal partner, Bubba the Belly, is sidelined with a severe case of gout and you need a new partner.
Town Mayor: “Ladies and gentlemen, welcome to the 2025 Team Pie-Eating Contest!!! On this side of the stage, our five-time defending champions - Lardass Hogan and Big Brother Biff!!”
Crowd: [cheering]. “Lardass, Lardass, Lardass!”
Mayor: “And on this side, our challengers - [insert your name here] and special surprise guest teammate . . . “
You: [removes blindfold]. “Take this pink ribbon off my eyes! Why am I wearing this thing anyway? Ok, who’s my partner anyway? Oh great, it’s Just a Girl.”
Just a Girl: [gives a bow]. “Aw, little old me.”
You: “What took you so long? We’ve been waiting for a half hour?”
JAG: “Sorry, I would’ve been here yesterday, but they won’t let me drive late at night.”
You: “Hope you’re ready for some pie.”
JAG: “I’m not that hungry. I’ll just have some of yours.”
You:
Mayor: “On your mark, get set, eat!!”
You: [eats like crazy, on your third pie you look over and see Just a Girl has barely touched her first]. “Hey, aren’t you going to eat?”
JAG: [looking sick]. “Sorry, I just can’t eat any more. I’ve had it up to here!”
Just a Girl turns and vomits all over Lardass Hogan.
Lardass, now covered in purple blueberry goo, starts a thunderous rumbling in his massive belly.
The rest is history.
Recommended listening: Poor and Humble was a good listen and taps into a more traditional reggae feel. I've been liking some of the albums that I was drawn to because of the weird cover art like Scientist Rids the World of the Evil Curse of the Intergalactic Vampire and Lost in Space. If I read my research correctly, there is a possibility of cross over with @titusbramble, as some of his tracks were on GTA3?
So I have Hedley on my list and I REALLY struggled with my conscience on whether to include them. They have many great songs and were destined to really take off until their lead singer/songwriter got into some, shall we say, legal troubles. That was it for them and him. IN an effort to separate the music from the person I ended up including it but still think that maybe I shouldn't have. If you are unaware and interested, here's his wiki page
Oh, k-jah is basically that whole album?Recommended listening: Poor and Humble was a good listen and taps into a more traditional reggae feel. I've been liking some of the albums that I was drawn to because of the weird cover art like Scientist Rids the World of the Evil Curse of the Intergalactic Vampire and Lost in Space. If I read my research correctly, there is a possibility of cross over with @titusbramble, as some of his tracks were on GTA3?
Given the entirety of one station is entirely from a single Scientist album, it's a fair bet you might be right
The Syreeta regulation: The artist must have recorded (almost) entirely under a mononym. This one has some wiggle room because my research wasn't that comprehensive. For example, Syreeta also released an early Motown single under her given name Rita Wright.
You have one like this where oddly enough someone else has a song by this artist on their list, under her recording name at the time, though it was not her given name.
![]()
The Syreeta regulation: The artist must have recorded (almost) entirely under a mononym. This one has some wiggle room because my research wasn't that comprehensive. For example, Syreeta also released an early Motown single under her given name Rita Wright.
You have one like this where oddly enough someone else has a song by this artist on their list, under her recording name at the time, though it was not her given name.
![]()
I'm so confused
We’ve reached the epitome of excellent soundtracks with GotG. We’ll stay here for a few songs but really this could be the entire playlist. And there are playlists for those interested.-OZ- - song / music moments from the Marvel cinematic universe
Hooked On A Feeling - Blue Swede, Björn Skifs
I gotta throw a flag on this one, @Eephus ... this warrants a hell of a lot more detail here.
There are actually two versions, the one credited to Walsh that appeared on the Warriors soundtrack, and the one credited to the Eagles that appeared on The Long Run. They are similar but have slight differences, most notably that the backing vocals on the latter are obviously Henley, Frey and Schmit.#25: In the City
Artist: Joe Walsh (I used to say "The Eagles," but @Pip's Invitation likes to remind me that this is really a Joe Walsh tune with the Eagles doing backing vocals. And I prefer this, because as Jeff Lebowski says, "I hate the f***ing Eagles, man.")
Reservoir Dogs. One of my roommates in college had the soundtrack. He cranked it for Hooked On A Feeling. My favorite on the soundtrack is Fool for Love. The woman singing it (and she wrote it) is Sam Shepard's sister, Sandy Rogers..
Also used in another favorite movie - can anyone guess that movie?![]()