What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Mike McCarthy will be a flop as Packers HC (1 Viewer)

McCarthy is a great coach. He lost a game it happens. He did not fail to read the fake kick he did not miss read the hail mary on 2 pt conversion he did not fumble the onside kick why should he be fired because Packers fans are upset they lost? Those same fans would be complaining if he didnt kick the field goals and got stopped each time.
Some of Belichick's "genius" isn't brilliant schemes it's drilling the small things into his players. Like when your job is to block on an onside kick you don't jump in front of the teams best wr who is waiting to catch the ball. Guarantee an idiot like that is cut immediately.

Hard to give the packers a lot of credit for getting the lead because seattle really just handed it to them. No way you should ever lose a game when the other team turns it over 5 times.
I agree with this. You get him enthused for HIS part in the play.

The other thing is on the fake fg, the guy that ignored his assignment had been ignoring his assignment all year. Seattle's coaches sniffed it out.

A lot of times I'll follow games on the NFL game center website. It's just a graphic representation of what's happening, but it can be instructive. So many times GB's special teams would do bad things You'd watch the little graphic and it was like, "Really? You let them out to the forty on the kickoff AGAIN?"

Now, the ST guy is gone, but that it took this loss to make that happen isn't good. Good coaches rigorously self scout. I worry that there's a middlin' IQ situation with GB's coaches. And Rogers hides it again and again.

I like GB and I worry.

 
Making big changes because of one game is also dumb, so I suspect this is something McCarthy has considered before.

I wonder if this might improve GB's early-season performance. It seems like every year, McCarthy starts the season slowly in part by trying too many dumb things.

 
Making big changes because of one game is also dumb, so I suspect this is something McCarthy has considered before.

I wonder if this might improve GB's early-season performance. It seems like every year, McCarthy starts the season slowly in part by trying too many dumb things.
I'm sure this is 99% media hype and very little actual change. The Packers are inherently conservative due to their ownership and management structure, which has served them well. McCarthy is widely acknowledge as one of the best play-calling coaches alive, for good reason. When Rodgers was healthy, the offense was unstoppable this season.

 
Making big changes because of one game is also dumb, so I suspect this is something McCarthy has considered before.

I wonder if this might improve GB's early-season performance. It seems like every year, McCarthy starts the season slowly in part by trying too many dumb things.
I'm sure this is 99% media hype and very little actual change. The Packers are inherently conservative due to their ownership and management structure, which has served them well. McCarthy is widely acknowledge as one of the best play-calling coaches alive, for good reason. When Rodgers was healthy, the offense was unstoppable this season.
Except on the road where players around Rodgers would crumble at times. I think the #1 point in the season where you saw that stupidity was in the Bills game when Nelson dropped the long pass that likely goes for a TD.

I have supported McCarthy and Thompson from the start and won't be stopping anytime soon. Do I think they could do things differently? Sure but not so much so that the organization should look to remove them from the team.

I personally thought at mid-season we had the Super Bowl in the bag and were the best team in the NFL only to be reinforced by the Patriots game where our offense did pretty much anything they wanted except score in the red zone. Our biggest need in the offseason does not come down to coaching but down to getting a TE (Rodgers could be the man in his 2nd year) to a level that they can be trusted in the Red Zone to help punch the ball in when inside the 10 which they fell short on one to many times this season. I also believe they could use an upgrade at LB/CB but that is really secondary need.

 
I don't think giving up play calling duties means he gives up making the decision to go or kick. That rotoworld blurb is a bit off IMO.
sounds like hes giving up the part that hes actually relatively competent at while continuing to hamstring his team by idiotic 4th down calls.

at first i felt sorry for rodgers, but ultimately, its his own damn fault. if he wants to win and be the best, then he should force management to replace mccarthy or at least overrule him on the field and keep his offense on the field for proper 4th downs and 2p t conversions and also audible to better plays.

 
I don't think giving up play calling duties means he gives up making the decision to go or kick. That rotoworld blurb is a bit off IMO.
sounds like hes giving up the part that hes actually relatively competent at while continuing to hamstring his team by idiotic 4th down calls.

at first i felt sorry for rodgers, but ultimately, its his own damn fault. if he wants to win and be the best, then he should force management to replace mccarthy or at least overrule him on the field and keep his offense on the field for proper 4th downs and 2p t conversions and also audible to better plays.
:lmao:

 
I don't think giving up play calling duties means he gives up making the decision to go or kick. That rotoworld blurb is a bit off IMO.
sounds like hes giving up the part that hes actually relatively competent at while continuing to hamstring his team by idiotic 4th down calls.

at first i felt sorry for rodgers, but ultimately, its his own damn fault. if he wants to win and be the best, then he should force management to replace mccarthy or at least overrule him on the field and keep his offense on the field for proper 4th downs and 2p t conversions and also audible to better plays.
And I thought claiming TE is the #1 priority was a bad post.

Yes...Rodgers should force the team to replace the coach that mentored him and that puts him in a top offense year in and year out.

oof...

 
http://www.jsonline.com/blogs/sports/291302651.html

Packers reportedly adding veteran OL coach Mike SolariGreen Bay — Former San Francisco 49ers offensive line coach Mike Solari, who has coached in the NFL since 1987, including two years with the Kansas City Chiefs when Mike McCarthy was quarterbacks coach there, is reportedly joining the Packers coaching staff.

Fox Sports' Alex Marvez reported that Solari, who was Jim Harbaugh's line coach from 2010-'14, had taken a job with the Packers. Media reports had indicated that Solari was still under contract and that the 49ers had to give permission for him to interview.

Solari is a veteran coach who led an extremely tough and talented offensive line for a 49ers team that beat the Packers three times in a two-year span, including two playoff victories.

McCarthy has been in the market for an assistant to offensive line coach James Campen since Steve Marshall left to become offensive line coach with the New York Jets in January. Solari, who turned 60 last month, interviewed in Buffalo where he could have joined former 49ers offensive coordinator Greg Roman.

Solari spent two years coaching special teams in Dallas in 1987 and '88, but it seems unlikely he would be hired to fill the spot Shawn Slocum held before being fired or filling the spot assistant Ron Zook held assuming Zook is promoted to special teams coach.

Solari would add a lot of experience to the staff and could be part of the structure McCarthy is creating to help him transfer play-calling duties and possibly spread the game-planning assignments around. The line had its best year under Campen and would return all five starters if free agent right tackle Bryan Bulaga is re-signed.

McCarthy is apparently handing play-calling duties over to Tom Clements, although the Packers have made no announcements yet.

Before coaching in San Francisco, Solari succeeded Tom Lovat as Mike Holmgren's offensive line coach in Seattle ('08-'09). He was in Kansas City for 11 years before that, first as line coach ('97-'05) and then as offensive coordinator ('06-'07). McCarthy was quarterbacks coach with the Chiefs from '95-'98.

Solari began his coaching career at the University of Pittsburgh, where he was offensive coordinator in 1986. (McCarthy joined the Pitt staff three years later). He left to coach special teams and be the assistant offensive line coach with the Cowboys, where he stayed for two years.

He coached offensive lines for the Cardinals ('89) and the University of Alabama ('90-'91) before spending five years coaching tight ends for the 49ers.

The list of coaches Solari has worked under includes Marty Schottenheimer, **** Vermeil, Herman Edwards, George Seifert, Gene Stallings and Tom Landry.
 
The 2011 season, when they were 15-1 and lost that opening round playoff game to the NYG at home, that was ridiculous. (Yes I know the Giants won it all but that game was just being outcoached).

http://www.pro-football-reference.com/boxscores/201201150gnb.htm
I have no problem with a fan looking at a game like this one and saying McCarthy and his assistants failed. When you lose by 17 at home as a double-digit favorite, there is no question the head coach takes the blame for it. I do have a problem with armchair joe-six-pack fans (as I am) questioning a gameplan or individual play calls. We have no knowledge whatsoever what goes into a play called in a given situation.

 
That was definitely one of the worst 15-1 teams ever based on the defense, though.

So when the offense turned it over a bunch in the playoffs, yeah, game over.

 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top