EBF
Footballguy
I actually traded up to take Hill ahead of Williams in our rookie draft, but I like what Williams has shown in the preseason. Very nice burst of speed and he's a load to bring down. He's not a juker, but can cut a little bit. He looks like a guy who's going to do some good things in the NFL. A lot of the concerns I had about him before the draft still linger. He's going to get banged up and he's never going to be a great pass catcher, but his NFL career is only four games old and he has already ripped of some pretty good runs, most of which can be seen here:
http://www.nfl.com/videos/new-york-giants/0ap3000000381027/NFL-NOW-Rookie-Watch-Andre-Williams
I don't hate Hill, but he has no special athletic qualities and has looked pretty ordinary in the preseason so far. He also has a more obstructed path to becoming a universally coveted FF asset, as Bernard isn't going anywhere. I still thought it was a close call. Ultimately, I just liked what I was seeing from Williams more. When you make a pick that you regret, it's better to admit your mistake early than to hold onto a guy while opportunities to make moves are dissolving. Likewise, if you see a guy flashing good talent and you think he's going to be pretty good then you should act on that as soon as possible because if you're right then his price will only rise the longer you wait.
http://www.nfl.com/videos/new-york-giants/0ap3000000381027/NFL-NOW-Rookie-Watch-Andre-Williams
I don't hate Hill, but he has no special athletic qualities and has looked pretty ordinary in the preseason so far. He also has a more obstructed path to becoming a universally coveted FF asset, as Bernard isn't going anywhere. I still thought it was a close call. Ultimately, I just liked what I was seeing from Williams more. When you make a pick that you regret, it's better to admit your mistake early than to hold onto a guy while opportunities to make moves are dissolving. Likewise, if you see a guy flashing good talent and you think he's going to be pretty good then you should act on that as soon as possible because if you're right then his price will only rise the longer you wait.
I have both in one league where I have good depth at WR but could use a stud in a league where we start 6 WR/RB. I'd consider making this deal but would likely keep Martin and Cobb. Seems fair to give two top 15 players at their positions for a top 4 at his. Depends on lineups though.