This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!
AJG pretty easily for me. All three guys are decent but not something I am trading a top 6WR for
I like it for you. Probably sold a little early on Marshall but you got a solid young WR for PPR and an upside guy in Williams. Ertz >> Fleener for me
This is a better deal for the guy dealing Calvin. Still Hopkins may not be the guy I would want in that deal but I would think about it
Nope but I had very little receiver depth after my top 3. Brown, DT, and Marshall. I was also very sketchy at tight end with Eifert and Gates. Plus I believe in the theory of selling too early rather then to late. He is a free agent next year.
I like McCown as a sleeper but Carr or Garrapolo will be there at the pick and be worth more, let alone the RB/WR.
You didn't have any RBs or WRs because you traded them all away. So what if you don't have a great QB? That was your worst problem and it's not a bad one at all. Now you have all sorts of problems with that roster.
the Roddy white deal wasn't mine. I had Maclin, Julio, and Jeffrey along with maybe givens and/or the raiders WR as depth. Did not think that was enough to compete with the top teams in the league. I was likely starting a raider WR, givens or Finley at flex and that's during non bye weeksThe Roddy white deal wasn't meMoveToSkypager said:
I would take the 3.12 over Richardson. The 1.12 is insane.
About the right price to take a shot on TRich. I would probably keep the pick but I can see a contender thinking TRich helps (or might help) more than 1.12
Why??
In theory, yes, but league context from the OP indicated otherwise. I also would have traded Fitz if I owned his team.
It's MAY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
And what finish in the bottom 4 or 5 instead of last? And let's be honest Fitz isn't winning me many games. My top 3 WR/RB were Fred Jackson, Steve Smith and Fitz. That's 33, 35 and 31. In a non-PPR that can start 3 RBs it's not a good spot to be in. Being average or below average isn't going to me anywhere. If I get something that can help my team going forward it's better than not getting anything and having them retire soon.
2.01 isn't going to "win you many game" either. Few players do. I get that your team is bad and old, but that doesn't seem like a good excuse to undersell him. Right now is not a good time to sell Fitzgerald. Rookie fever is at its apex and interest in veterans is at its lowest.
What could happen to improve Fitz's situation? Outside of AZ trading up for a QB probably not much and even then he has a rookie QB.
I was offered a future 1st and 2 future 2nds and passed.....maybe I am crazy and think he can turn it around.....the 3.12 ? Come on now.
1- other peoples players could get hurt or any of 100 other things to make people need a WR more than they do now
Then why insist on selling low? If you are well aware that the season doesnt start for like 4 months, why sell low??
In a rebuild??? That is a ridiculously amazing return for Bush. Considering he knew he was about to rebuild, and he pretty much controls how bad his team will be for that pick (and he is definitely gonna trade all his guys), that is a top 3 pick 100%.
I think the point he was making is Fitz is unlikely to retire before the season.
Like you said, ridiculous return when you put it in context. Is it your deal, by any chance?
Nope. I AM in a huge rebuild though, so me and that guy are gonna "fight" for the #1 pick now, lol. I was trying to trade for that pick after he dealt Fitzgerald and I knew he was going to do a total rebuild.
PLus so many things can happen before week 1. Someone else could pull some kind of 3 for 1 deal for a stud and create a need for a WR, and boom, you get a mid-ish 1st or a future 1st that looks halfway decent. Someone could get hurt/traded/arrested and create a need for someone.
