Ted Mullins
Footballguy
I'm thinking there's something to this as well. Not because a running QB *can't* be a good passing QB, but it seems like a lot of them are able to rely on their running ability to the point where they can use their speed so that they don't have to work on going through their reads in a messy pocket. I still think the ability to run is a tremendous asset, you just need it to be one part of the arsenal, not the main thing. I am not sure I'd classify Winston as one of these guys though, he doesn't run a ton and supposedly he was able to run a more complex offense in his first start than Manuel did as a senior - he seems like he has a ton of potential.I am becoming very leery of NFL QB's with extreme running ability that propel them to do great things in college. Reasons:
-Their mental side of the game tends to be less developed because they have been successful relying on their running ability.
-Their running ability doesn't put them above other players nearly as much in the NFL as it did in college.
-They don't learn how to move in the pocket, because they are used to using their legs to start running rather than buy more time in the pocket
-Because of these first three, they have their first exposure to failure. Most of these QB's with great running ability have never had to overcome failure before the NFL and they don't know what to do.
Examples: Vick, Young, Tebow
Still Pending: Newton, Griffin, Manziel
On Deck: Winston
Right now, Griffin seems to be stuggling with failing for the first time in his life. We will see how he overcomes it.
In the NFL, you can't be a one trick pony because teams adjust and take that trick away from you. It's the QB's that can then adjust their game that are successful.
I think Robert clearly has a ton to work on but it really seems like Gruden is pretty much saying this guy can work in my system or GTFO. He's giving him some easy passes presumably with the intent of building his confidence up, but it doesn't seem like he's doing a lot to integrate the things that worked for Robert previously as a passer. When he goes out there and looks terrible it's easy to compare him to Tebow, but Robert threw the ball a lot with plenty of shots downfield while he was at Baylor, and Robert's rookie year was tailored to what works for him and his passing was plenty good.
I saw a tweet that was actually about Chip Kelly's offense/QBs that could make a lot of sense here - it doesn't matter if someone's a "system qb" if the offense works and is sustainable in the NFL. Not saying go back to Kyle Shanahan's offense, but maybe at least try to mesh Gruden's offense with what's worked previously for Robert and see if that helps. Right now that doesn't seem like it's going to happen though, and it makes me think that if Robert is going to succeed it'll be elsewhere.
as the curiosity of seeing carnage on the side of the road/tracks is just too compelling to turn away from...