What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Pearl Jam vs Nirvana (1 Viewer)

Who is the better band


  • Total voters
    141

Jayrod

Footballguy
Who is the better band?

Criteria is up to you.

@massraider seems to think I'm in the extreme minority on this one. I think it is closer than he thinks.

And no, we aren't going to include Alice in Chains or even Soundgarden. This is for serious scientific research.
 
Pearl Jam just looked cooler.

3 piece bands always looks weird and they had Dave Grohl, Kurt Cobain, and that other tall lanky goofy guy who looked way too happy against the angst they were going for.
 
woah! I just stepped into a time machine and went back to 1995.

I think Nirvana is insanely popular and would likely win this but I could see folks being "edgey" and constrain and voting PJ. I'm still voiting Nirvana.
 
Last edited:
I like both groups, but given the choice, I'd usually prefer to put on Nirvana. So Nirvana.

In fairness, I only know Pearl Jam's first few albums, but I imagine that the case for a large majority of people.
 
I like both groups, but given the choice, I'd usually prefer to put on Nirvana. So Nirvana.

In fairness, I only know Pearl Jam's first few albums, but I imagine that the case for a large majority of people.
Name more than 2 Nirvana albums.

Ten, Versus & Vitalogy are all better than any single Nirvana album.

Nirvana is the Kobe Bryant of the music world.
Just noting for the record that Pearl Jam has a much larger body of work, for an obvious reason.
 
neither needs to be better than the other, they are both equally great in my mind and each hold a special place in my heart.

edited to add: need a tie option
 
I like both groups a lot. I prefer to listen to Pearl Jam and like them better but think Nirvana were the "better" group, defined by musical and cultural impact and influence.
 
1991. I was in high school in the Pacific Northwest. Grunge hit us hard. I love Nirvana. In fact, today, I prefer old Nirvana songs over Pearl Jam ones. Having said that, put me down for Pearl Jam. To many wonderful memories. Seen them both in concert numerous times, but nothing beats the day drive to Seattle to see Eddie entertain the crown.
 
Who is the better band?

Criteria is up to you.

@massraider seems to think I'm in the extreme minority on this one. I think it is closer than he thinks.

And no, we aren't going to include Alice in Chains or even Soundgarden. This is for serious scientific research.
You're wrong imo. Nirvana is going to win. Probably by a fair amount. Maybe even rightfully so.

While there are certainly a lot of people who preferred them back in the day, they have the added "advantage" of skirting the need to mature and have to create while wealthy, entitled, and settled. Which tends to mix less well with angst-driven rock than the perceived slights of youth, drugs, alcohol, and anger. They never had a chance to grow tired to people who might not have otherwise had a preference, so people remember only their best work and remember them more fondly.

Nobody ever had to listen to KC drone on about the evils of GWB in the middle of a concert. That's not a political statement. I have friends on both sides of the aisle who found it equally annoying.

But put me in the category of people who preferred Pearl Jam even then. I :wub: Mike McCready and would listen to Eddie sing Row, Row, Row Your Boat.
 
I like both groups, but given the choice, I'd usually prefer to put on Nirvana. So Nirvana.

In fairness, I only know Pearl Jam's first few albums, but I imagine that the case for a large majority of people.
Name more than 2 Nirvana albums.

Ten, Versus & Vitalogy are all better than any single Nirvana album.

Nirvana is the Kobe Bryant of the music world.
I think No Code is even better than these. Vitology has too much b.s. on it.
 
While it's certainly possible that Nirvana would have aged poorly if Cobain hadn't have died, I don't think it's obvious enough that you can just assume that counterfactual. I liked them both back in the day, and still enjoy a lot of their stuff. I probably slightly preferred Nirvana back then. I'm not sure which side I come down on now as far as pure enjoyment of the catalogue, but I voted Nirvana because they just hit the music scene like no other band in my lifetime, and I think that has to count for something.
 
I like both groups, but given the choice, I'd usually prefer to put on Nirvana. So Nirvana.

In fairness, I only know Pearl Jam's first few albums, but I imagine that the case for a large majority of people.
Name more than 2 Nirvana albums.

Ten, Versus & Vitalogy are all better than any single Nirvana album.

Nirvana is the Kobe Bryant of the music world.
I think No Code is even better than these. Vitology has too much b.s. on it.
But Vitalogy has your soundtrack for when you call the exterminator!
 
I am not an Uber fan of either band, but Pearl Jam has placed 69 different songs on global charts. Nirvana had 18. Different strokes for different folks, but I voted PJ.

Clearly, I never was a huge fan of Nirvana, as I once ended a conversation with Dave Grohl (before Nirvana hit it big) by telling him not to quit his day job because I didn’t think they’d make it in the music business.

I guess that’s not as bad as a woman I know that used to date and live with Eddie Vedder, who dumped him because he wasn’t contributing anything to their bills (and laughed at him when he said he was joining a band as their singer).
 
I am not an Uber fan of either band, but Pearl Jam has placed 69 different songs on global charts. Nirvana had 18. Different strokes for different folks, but I voted PJ.

Clearly, I never was a huge fan of Nirvana, as I once ended a conversation with Dave Grohl (before Nirvana hit it big) by telling him not to quit his day job because I didn’t think they’d make it in the music business.

I guess that’s not as bad as a woman I know that used to date and live with Eddie Vedder, who dumped him because he wasn’t contributing anything to their bills (and laughed at him when he said he was joining a band as their singer).
Wow, so much going on in these three lines.
 
Pearl Jam would have never been the wealthy careerists they've become if is wasn't for Nirvana breaking big before them.
 
Ten, Versus & Vitalogy are all better than any single Nirvana album.
I voted Pearl Jam due to their longevity and their touring prowess (famous for live shows), and I love all those records - but Nevermind is a better and more important album by a considerable amount (imo of course).
 
It's Nirvana for me... PJs songs tend to blend after their first album. Lots of good stuff, but nothing pops out for me. nirvana's all hits me more distinctly.

But this is like Pie or Cake.

It's both, not one or the other.
 
My friend also directed that Rusted Root video. Mght be her only video. And somehow seems related.

Eta... Hmm- it must be a different video by one of those bands from that era.
 
Last edited:
High School 1995, you were either team PJ or team Nirvana. Now that 1995 is considered classic rock, I tend to turn them both off on the radio fairly quickly. Voted PJ because my favorite song of theirs is better then my favorite song of Nirvana imo. Also, Smells like Teen Spirit is trash.
 
It's who I think is the better band, yeah? If it's my criteria, I don't care about longevity. It's rock music, not encyclopedia sales.

Nirvana had a lot of moments. Moments I remember.
Smells Like Teen Spirit was a phenomenon, and ended hair metal. One song, a few grungy guys in flannel, and in like a week, spandex and leopard print looked really silly. There have been few musical movements since then, and they were the catalyst. This matters *to me* a little on which is better.
I caught a little of the self-important Bono thing from Eddie, and I don't love that in my rock n roll. If you do bring it, you better be Joe Strummer. In general, I love Pearl Jam, and I love Eddie, they all seem to be great guys. Not as edgy as Nirvana, which I always would gravitate towards.
Unplugged in New York after his death, I mean....probably listened to this album more than the others because it was easier to listen to when just hanging out. That was a huge moment, one of MTV's last cool moments.

I was in Germany in 1996, and this bar played Smells Like Teen Spirit, and all these German kids started singing along. They didn't know the words, no one knew the words, and they were still screaming along, making phonteic gibberish sounds. It was so cool/funny.
 
somehow I don't feel like longevity or catalog size should matter much in a who is better. Quality over quantity and none of you think ZZ top is the band ever.
 
High School 1995, you were either team PJ or team Nirvana. Now that 1995 is considered classic rock, I tend to turn them both off on the radio fairly quickly. Voted PJ because my favorite song of theirs is better then my favorite song of Nirvana imo. Also, Smells like Teen Spirit is trash.
95? Nevermind dropped in 91 and was awesome
 
I’ll give a slight nod to Pearl Jam but I don’t have a strong preference either way

Pearl Jam probably has more good songs but I think Nirvana has a better Top 5 / Top 10

I’ve also never seen either live so I can’t factor that in
 
Clearly, I never was a huge fan of Nirvana, as I once ended a conversation with Dave Grohl (before Nirvana hit it big) by telling him not to quit his day job because I didn’t think they’d make it in the music business.

I guess that’s not as bad as a woman I know that used to date and live with Eddie Vedder, who dumped him because he wasn’t contributing anything to their bills (and laughed at him when he said he was joining a band as their singer).
Wow, so much going on in these three lines.
Here are more Nirvana details. Back in the day (college and just after), a friend of a friend had a nightclub that hosted live bands. In exchange for free snacks and drinks, I would help out as their sound engineer if I was around and would help bands with equipment set up, breakdown, and sound checks. Most bands were local bands or wannabees, and few amounted to much of anything. However, there were some other acts I remember that went on to bigger things: Spin Doctors, Smashing Pumpkins, Live, and the Mighty Mighty Boss Tones.

On Thursday 1991-09-26 in New Haven (2 days after Nevermind was released), Nirvana played there (right before they exploded almost overnight). It was the first week of the Nevermind tour. No one really knew them. The Smells Like Teen Spirit video would debut on MTV that weekend. They had a following on the West Coast, but hardly anyone had ever heard of them on the East Coast. I was a college DJ, and I had never played them.

I was already there when they arrived in a station wagon late that afternoon from a gig in Providence. I did the usual set up and sound check stuff and got to hang out with the 3 band members and Courtney Love (pre- and post-show). Kurt and Courtney were busy being into each other, and she tried shocking people by suggesting all the things she wanted to do to Kurt (they had just started dating). I remember Krist was pretty quiet and kept to himself. That left Grohl as the one left over to talk to and accessible to hang out with. So we sat at the bar drinking and shooting the breeze. He told me his backstory (I am a couple years older) and went over different bands that we were into. He was a pretty cool guy.

The problem was, to me, Nirvana just seemed to be loud to be loud and used heavy distortion just because they could. Remember, at that time, grunge wasn't a thing yet. Dance, R&B, boy bands, and pop rock were all popular then, and the popular acts were Bryan Adams, R.E.M., Damn Yankees, and big hair / glam metal. Nirvana was nowhere near those. From the moment they started their soundcheck, I wasn't a big fan. I'm not anti-noisy bands . . . they just didn't sound all that musical to me. (Plus I didn't know any of their songs.) By the end of the night, we all had a bit too much to drink (and in Kurt's case, who knows what else), but as the band was getting ready to leave, I mentioned to Dave that it was cool hanging out, but just in case, don't quit the day job in case the music thing didn't work out. I may have been wrong on that one, but at least I didn't just father a newborn.

I wish I knew who they were, had been a big fan, and was into them when this all went down. But to me, they were just a bunch of scrubs hanging out at a seedy club just like all the other bands and guys I met at the same club. I remember my friends at the time asking what I had done that weekend (we all counted Thursday as part of the weekend). I distinctly remember telling them I hung out at the bar with some band I never heard off called Urbana. That's how little I knew them and little attention I paid them during their set. It's a great story now, but live as it happened, it really wasn't that special or exciting.
 
My friend also directed that Rusted Root video. Mght be her only video. And somehow seems related.

Eta... Hmm- it must be a different video by one of those bands from that era.
Spin Doctors?
Lol .. might as well be.

One of my college classmates managed Blues Traveller early on, so we saw a lot of them and Spin Doctors.

My ex-wife dated the Spin Doctor’s manager. Apparently she stole him from one of her friends causing a riff.

Blues Traveler, God Street Wine, Spin Doctors, Rusted Root, and a few others all played that Wetlands, Nightengales, McGoverns jam band circuit.
 
PJ by a country mile for me, but I think Screaming Trees put out two albums better than anything Nirvana. Nirvana broke first but they are pretty far down on my list of favorite grunge bands.
 
Who is the better band?

Criteria is up to you.

@massraider seems to think I'm in the extreme minority on this one. I think it is closer than he thinks.

And no, we aren't going to include Alice in Chains or even Soundgarden. This is for serious scientific research.
Soundgarden or Stone Temple Pilots is the answer for me.

For your purposes, easily Nirvana.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top