QB Jameis Winston, NYG (4 Viewers)

[Capella]

Another nice game.



BTW, what's with the flopping thing? He's a big boy, he should stop with the theatrics.

Three times a lady.

Exactly! Thanks for that. You claimed I said it 5 times, Lionel.

Yes, 3 times isn't obsessive at all.

Diversion is not the best counter.

I mentioned he flopped.

Then a second flop. And not another word from me (1 post about each flop, nothing more).

And when all was said a done, a simple query about why he does this sends you into orbit (and embellishment)? Get a grip.

Orbit? I asked you when he flopped and you didn't respond. I watched the whole game and didn't see a flop nor have I seen anybody mention it anywhere else and that kind of stuff hits Twitter quick.

 

[Grahamburn]

I don't even know what he's referring to?

 

[Capella]

I don't even know what he's referring to?

 

[Old Smiley]

Thought I saw something about the WR flopping... or griping about calls or something...

 

[lod01]

Tampa Bay, where QB's go to die. Poor kid. Throwing hot potatoes all over the place.

Yup.

On pace for 3800 yards passing, 20 TDs, 14 picks ( ) and 58% completion percentage which should be quite a bit higher if he had competent receivers. Add in on pace for 230 yards rushing and 6 running TDs as well.

So 4000 total yards, 25+ touchdowns and less than a pick per game. What a loser. Bust. Dumpster fire.

Yup. This guy's the #1 overall pick and he's not any better than a 2013 3rd round pick by the name of Mike Glennon thru 8 games. 200 more yards, worse completion %, more INTs and less TDs. Glennon played against 3 division champions thru 8 games that year and a 4th 10 win team (SEA, PHI, CAR & ARI). This guy has played all weak teams except CAR and Glennon fared better against them. Bottom line, he's playing as well as Mike Glennon. No better.

On the flopping, he flops around like a fish out of water anytime someone hits him. Of course, that is a good idea if you do it on occasion. You can get a 15 yard penalty called on the D. When you do it every time, the ref's ignore it.

Oh, you got yourself a 3rd round talent with the #1 overall pick. Bravo!

 

[Faust]

Bucs' Winston continues to impress coaches and vets on field and off

 

[Capella]

Not his best game at all, but

 

[ShamrockPride]

Not his best game at all, but

Showed the clutch gene. That's good enough for me.

 

[Quez]

I wonder if we will ever get to see Jameis play with a healthy Evans, Vjax, & ASJ. That could be a beautiful thing.

 

[Faust]

Jameis Winston goes from goat to hero thanks to a Cowboys penalty

 

[cstu]

http://i.imgur.com/JMyAOyP.gif

Worse than butt fumble if there's not a penalty.

 

[jabarony]

http://i.imgur.com/JMyAOyP.gif

Worse than butt fumble if there's not a penalty.

Definitely should've lost on that embarrassing play. The Lord was on his side, though, according to him.

 

[Capella]

http://i.imgur.com/JMyAOyP.gif

Worse than butt fumble if there's not a penalty.

a qb diving for the end zone with two defenders coming at him and losing the ball is worse than the butt fumble.

You're the best.

 

[Quez]

It seems that Jameis does have some ball security issues, but that is a TD 9 times out of 10. That and the bootleg were both great calls by Dirk Koetter.

Having a large QB like Jameis really adds another dimension at the goal line. Something the Bucs have never had.

 

[Capella]

http://www.bucsnation.com/2015/11/16/9743544/watch-jameis-winstons-fiery-post-game-speech?utm_campaign=bucsnation&utm_content=chorus&utm_medium=social&utm_source=twitter

 

[zamboni]

Get this kid some receiving weapons outside of Evans that actually stay on the field, and we may be seeing something special.

 

[Grahamburn]

It seems that Jameis does have some ball security issues, but that is a TD 9 times out of 10. That and the bootleg were both great calls by Dirk Koetter.

Having a large QB like Jameis really adds another dimension at the goal line. Something the Bucs have never had.

I don't think the fumble play was a called sneak was it?

He hasn't been all that great down close in the red zone so far. It'll come.

 

[FUBAR]

how do we feel about this guy in dynasty? compare to the other young guys, carr, bridgewater, marioita, brotles.

Carr

Winston/Mariota

Bortles

Bridgewater

I can mostly get on board with this but am I delusional for thinking Bridgewater should be equal to MM/JW?

 

[Quez]

Wow, that post game speech even got Mike Glenon pumped.

 

[lod01]

Keeping pace with 3rd round pick Mike Glennon...just less TDs and more INTs....and a lower completion %.

 

[fatness]

Keeping pace with 3rd round pick Mike Glennon...just less TDs and more INTs....and a lower completion %.

You're slowly losing this battle.

 

[Capella]

Keeping pace with 3rd round pick Mike Glennon...just less TDs and more INTs....and a lower completion %.

 

[Bronco Billy]

Keeping pace with 3rd round pick Mike Glennon...just less TDs and more INTs....and a lower completion %.

You're slowly losing this battle.

He'll never figure that out, or admit it if he did.

When you look at other prolific QBs who started very early in their careers and ended up putting up historic numbers, Winston compared pretty favorably. Look at Manning, Favre, Brady, and Elway 9 starts in and you see the following:

Winston has more passing yds and easily a much better ypa than all of them. Only Favre and Brady had better comp. % and more TDs than INTs - and Winston has as many passing TDs as Favre did with only 1 more INT. Winston has more total TDs than any of them.

Now I'm not going to make an assertion that Winston will join their elite company after his career - I'm smart enough to know it is way too early to make any inference like that. But it does give a rational person some perspective when jumping to conclusions about young QBs. Imagine what lod would have been saying about each of them at this point in their career.

All the more reason to simply ignore him.

 

[cstu]

Keeping pace with 3rd round pick Mike Glennon...just less TDs and more INTs....and a lower completion %.

Rk 		        Age 	Year 	Lg 	Tm 	G 	W 	L 	T 	Cmp 	Att 	Cmp% 	Yds 	TD 	Int 	Rate 	Y/A 	AY/A14 	Mike Glennon 	24 	2014 	NFL 	TAM 	6 	1 	5 	0 	117 	203 	57.64 	1417 	10 	6 	83.3 	6.98 	6.6416 	Jameis Winston 	21 	2015 	NFL 	TAM 	9 	4 	5 	0 	164 	285 	57.54 	2159 	10 	9 	80.1 	7.58 	6.86

 

[cstu]

Now I'm not going to make an assertion that Winston will join their elite company after his career - I'm smart enough to know it is way too early to make any inference like that. But it does give a rational person some perspective when jumping to conclusions about young QBs. Imagine what lod would have been saying about each of them at this point in their career.

I disagree with comparing him to elite QB's because there many who started out like him and busted (including Glennon) but agree that it's too early to tell.

 

[Grahamburn]

I was an advocate for Glennon in the past and didn't understand why they didn't give him the opportunity to start last year. That being said, anyone objectively paying attention here can see that Jameis Winston is 10 times the quarterback Mike Glennon is.

 

[lod01]

It's not looking good is it? Long ways to go though. I'll take joy at a minimum of seeing the #####ing in here that it's always someone else's fault...its almost as if you are Winston. That is a victory in itself. So far to date we have 'It's Lovie's fault and the D's fault' and last week it was that 'Mike Evans is the worst' and now it's 'all the receivers are awful'. I predicted this. You will also blame the O-line eventually, the running game as well. Bottom line is he is a ham & egger at best. Took 5 years to make people understand that David Carr sucked as they used the same technique of blame that you use. It does look like this guy will be around for a while....to bad for Tampa.

Capella, on 13 Sept 2015 - 5:20

Lovie is way way way worse than Jameis anyhow. Is Winston playing defense?

God Evans is awful.

Another great game that won't look as good because of his awful receivers

 

[lod01]

Now I'm not going to make an assertion that Winston will join their elite company after his career - I'm smart enough to know it is way too early to make any inference like that. But it does give a rational person some perspective when jumping to conclusions about young QBs. Imagine what lod would have been saying about each of them at this point in their career.

I disagree with comparing him to elite QB's because there many who started out like him and busted (including Glennon) but agree that it's too early to tell.

No idea if Glennon is NFL starting material, I have doubts myself, but he has never been given a fair chance. He put up a 19-9 TD-INT ratio and was benched in favor of a journeyman hack. Talk about no receivers. All he had was Vincent Jackson.

 

[Capella]

Evans was awful last week. He had the most drops in a game in 10 years. That's not an excuse, that's a fact.

The defense was awful when I wrote that. They gave up 35 points in week one at home to a rookie. Again, that's not an excuse, that is also a fact.

Jameis is right now playing with Evans (usually quite good) and three...not one, not two, but THREE undrafted receivers. That is also not an excuse, but a fact.

You're the only one making excuses and laughable comparisons. I have been very out front when he has played poorly.

 

[cstu]

Evans was awful last week. He had the most drops in a game in 10 years. That's not an excuse, that's a fact.

The defense was awful when I wrote that. They gave up 35 points in week one at home to a rookie. Again, that's not an excuse, that is also a fact.

Jameis is right now playing with Evans (usually quite good) and three...not one, not two, but THREE undrafted receivers. That is also not an excuse, but a fact.

You're the only one making excuses and laughable comparisons. I have been very out front when he has played poorly.

His numbers so far are very similar to Leftwich, whose receivers were a 34 year old Jimmy Smith, Troy Edwards, and Kyle Brady. Nothing even close to Evans.

 

[Quez]

It takes a lot of effort to troll as hard as lode01. The rants are one thing, but going back and finding post, then quoting then all. That is the extra effort that blurs the line between troll & mentally unstable.

He even makes cstu seem mild.

 

[Capella]

Evans was awful last week. He had the most drops in a game in 10 years. That's not an excuse, that's a fact.

The defense was awful when I wrote that. They gave up 35 points in week one at home to a rookie. Again, that's not an excuse, that is also a fact.

Jameis is right now playing with Evans (usually quite good) and three...not one, not two, but THREE undrafted receivers. That is also not an excuse, but a fact.

You're the only one making excuses and laughable comparisons. I have been very out front when he has played poorly.

His numbers so far are very similar to Leftwich, whose receivers were a 34 year old Jimmy Smith, Troy Edwards, and Kyle Brady. Nothing even close to Evans.

Winston is a averaging a full yard per attempt more than Byron did. That's really significant even if you wish to pretend it's not.

Winston is also averaging 50 yards more per game.

Byron also had 16 total touchdowns for the year. Jameis already has 14.

Byron had a qb rating of 73 and Jameis is at 80.

Byron also had a int % of 3.8 to 3.2 for Jameis. Also Jameis gets 13.2 yards per catch to 11.8 for Byron.

So no they're not like each other at all. Would you like to nominate another talk, black qb for me to compare? Or we good for now?

 

[Grahamburn]

I know it sounds a little silly, but can we quit with the "numbers" comparisons? What Jameis did in his first 9 games statistically compared to "insert average QB here to fit my argument" is pretty pointless. Mike Glennon won 5 games in 19 starts. How many of his statistics were accumulated during blowouts? How many of those blowouts were because Glennon couldn't convert on third down? I've never seen so many gutless 5 yard check downs on 3rd and 12 as I did when Mike Glennon was starting for the Bucs.

Watch the games. Jameis continuously attacks the defense. He's throwing 15 yard strikes on 3rd and 12. He's finding open receivers when it matters. When the game is on the line. And now he has a game winning comeback drive under his belt too.

 

[Capella]

Btw, Jameis is 10th in the league in YPA. Mike Glennon's rookie YPA would have him at 32, or 5 spots above where he was in 2013.

 

[Capella]

I know it sounds a little silly, but can we quit with the "numbers" comparisons? What Jameis did in his first 9 games statistically compared to "insert average QB here to fit my argument" is pretty pointless. Mike Glennon won 5 games in 19 starts. How many of his statistics were accumulated during blowouts? How many of those blowouts were because Glennon couldn't convert on third down? I've never seen so many gutless 5 yard check downs on 3rd and 12 as I did when Mike Glennon was starting for the Bucs.

Watch the games. Jameis continuously attacks the defense. He's throwing 15 yard strikes on 3rd and 12. He's finding open receivers when it matters. When the game is on the line. And now he has a game winning comeback drive under his belt too.

My favorite is the randomly inserted "he is similar to ________" guy who has nothing in common with him at all. How did he land on Byron Leftwich? His rookie season was like 12 years ago. So weird.

 

[Grahamburn]

Leftwich did start 3 games for the Bucs in 2009.

 

[Capella]

yea Winston has been ok but his stats are no better than Mike Tomzcaks first 9 games in 1988

 

[fatness]

I'm seeing a difference in Glennon's W/L record and Winston's W/L record in those stats.

Since someone thinks the numbers are important, there are the ones that matter.

Of course those saying Winston's no better than Glennon will say it's always someone else's fault. It's Glennon's receivers, or Glennon's coach, or Glennon's defense. Eventually they'll blame Glennon's O-line and his running game. It'll take years until they figure out that Glennon's "a guy" and Winston's becoming a good QB, much to Tampa's good fortune.

 

[Andrew]

Keeping pace with 3rd round pick Mike Glennon...just less TDs and more INTs....and a lower completion %.

Rk Age Year Lg Tm G W L T Cmp Att Cmp% Yds TD Int Rate Y/A AY/A14 Mike Glennon 24 2014 NFL TAM 6 1 5 0 117 203 57.64 1417 10 6 83.3 6.98 6.6416 Jameis Winston 21 2015 NFL TAM 9 4 5 0 164 285 57.54 2159 10 9 80.1 7.58 6.86

2014 was Glennon's second year. His rookie year, he had a 6.27 y/a.

 

[jurb26]

He had a few of those rookie mental lapses this week, but again was impressive for the most part. Evans is killing him. That guy has been terrible this year.

The post game speech.... Damn. It's easy to see why teammates love him.

 

[Bronco Billy]

yea Winston has been ok but his stats are no better than Mike Tomzcaks first 9 games in 1988

Please refrain from using white QBs as points of comparison. TIA

 

[Soulfly3]

Evans is killing him. That guy has been terrible this year.

averaging 83 yds per game (more than megatron, cooper, hurns, hilton, sanders etc). was hurt to start the season. and is 22.

Evans aint killing nobody, he's pretty spectacular. admittedly, the drops last week were brutal. dropped ONE this week

 

[Capella]

Evans is killing him. That guy has been terrible this year.

averaging 83 yds per game (more than megatron, cooper, hurns, hilton, sanders etc). was hurt to start the season. and is 22.

Evans aint killing nobody, he's pretty spectacular. admittedly, the drops last week were brutal. dropped ONE this week

He did drop one this week, but boy it was a third and 14 that was right on the money.

 

[jurb26]

Evans is killing him. That guy has been terrible this year.

averaging 83 yds per game (more than megatron, cooper, hurns, hilton, sanders etc). was hurt to start the season. and is 22.

Evans aint killing nobody, he's pretty spectacular. admittedly, the drops last week were brutal. dropped ONE this week

He did drop one this week, but boy it was a third and 14 that was right on the money.

He's also getting almost no separation on his deep routes (most of the time) and is constantly getting forced too close to the edge and not giving his QB hardly any margin for error on deep balls, particularly the deep sideline throws. Winston keeps forcing it to him, though. Mainly because his other weapons are hurt.

 

[Soulfly3]

Evans is killing him. That guy has been terrible this year.

averaging 83 yds per game (more than megatron, cooper, hurns, hilton, sanders etc). was hurt to start the season. and is 22.

Evans aint killing nobody, he's pretty spectacular. admittedly, the drops last week were brutal. dropped ONE this week

He did drop one this week, but boy it was a third and 14 that was right on the money.

He's also getting almost no separation on his deep routes (most of the time) and is constantly getting forced too close to the edge and not giving his QB hardly any margin for error on deep balls, particularly the deep sideline throws. Winston keeps forcing it to him, though. Mainly because his other weapons are hurt.

again, likely to do with health/hamstrings

 

[jabarony]

He had a few of those rookie mental lapses this week, but again was impressive for the most part. Evans is killing him. That guy has been terrible this year.

The post game speech.... Damn. It's easy to see why teammates love him.

This one?

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZiJ4-ZFcRPA&feature=youtube_gdata_player

 

[jurb26]

He had a few of those rookie mental lapses this week, but again was impressive for the most part. Evans is killing him. That guy has been terrible this year.

The post game speech.... Damn. It's easy to see why teammates love him.

This one?http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZiJ4-ZFcRPA&feature=youtube_gdata_player

That's a funny one. I blasted him for it years ago and of course people thought I was being over critical.BTW here is the speech I'm referring too.

http://youtu.be/wiqLwrpbxkw

 

[Frostillicus]

Just another Spurgeon Wynn.

 

[Capella]

@VeteranScout: Some of the incompletions and one of 2 INTs Jameis threw on Sunday for some perspective. #Bucs https://t.co/8kXV1OjatD

 

[LOCO]

i hate mike evans