RB Christian McCaffrey, SF (4 Viewers)

[Smack Tripper]

B Rob is a solid RB2 without mcaff

Guerrendo will vulture but not even worth a spot IMO

 

[dkp993]

and he doesn’t want to say too much and get in trouble

I actually agree with this. Probably because he got skewered by local radio / fans last year when he was Pollyanna about it before being declared inactive.

That said, I won’t trust anything but the game day inactives report. I’m gonna assume that everyone else is either lying or guessing.

Fair and reasonable approach considering how things have gone down there in the past

 

[Hot Sauce Guy]

Also James is as good as OUT but Guerendo is good to go so it's likely a BRob and Guerendo duo this week, and man, what a wild ride it's been the last few weeks for people who own those two.

Just added Guerendo to my stable of CMC and Brian Robinson. Finally!!! My master plan of devoting three roster spots to 49ers RBs has come to fruition!!!

In one 12 team league where I had Mixon, I picked up Pierce off waivers for $22/$500 FAAB, then drafted Woody Marks with a late 3rd round pick. Because like you, I’m a genius.

And then they got Chubb.

 

[Smack Tripper]

If B Rob has any life, I see him as full time goal line back for the foreseeable future if not ROS.

Given B Rob's trade, I'd see ironically McCaffery as Atomic Ekeler, enough production to make each other a bit useless.

 

[Hot Sauce Guy]

B Rob is a solid RB2 without mcaff

Guerrendo will vulture but not even worth a spot IMO

BRob’s been with the team for a week. Guerendo both knows, and has shown capable output in this scheme.

IMO you’re vastly misreading this scenario.

 

[Hot Sauce Guy]

Given B Rob's trade, I'd see ironically McCaffery as Atomic Ekeler, enough production to make each other a bit useless.

Once again, I do not agree with a single word of this. No offense.

 

[msudaisy26]

With 49ers playing at 4 pm on Sunday how many people are benching him becauae their players are playing early?

I am starting Pacheco at my rb1 spot now, moving CMC to my flex and hoping we have more info before Sunday games otherwise I am rolling out Pittman for my 2nd flex.

 

[Smack Tripper]

Given B Rob's trade, I'd see ironically McCaffery as Atomic Ekeler, enough production to make each other a bit useless.

Once again, I do not agree with a single word of this. No offense.

No one's asking you to, thats my opinion.

But logically, if he went to "5th gear" and this is the result, for a team with playoff aspirations, the answer is going to be to limit his touches.

You could tell me he's back in 4 weeks and they step on the gas and we know how that ends. You're looking at load management here, best case scenario.

10- 12 touches, I'd antipcate

4 rushes... 5 YPC... 20 yards

6-8 catches, maybe 7 YPC... 50 yards on a good day

TD every other game

If 14 points a game excites you out of a 1st rounder, I don't know what to tell you bud.

 

[Tin Cup]

With 49ers playing at 4 pm on Sunday how many people are benching him becauae their players are playing early?

I am starting Pacheco at my rb1 spot now, moving CMC to my flex and hoping we have more info before Sunday games otherwise I am rolling out Pittman for my 2nd flex.

I’ made the exact same decision today, subbing Pacheco in and CMC out.

 

[Smack Tripper]

B Rob is a solid RB2 without mcaff

Guerrendo will vulture but not even worth a spot IMO

BRob’s been with the team for a week. Guerendo both knows, and has shown capable output in this scheme.

IMO you’re vastly misreading this scenario.

Guerrendo made CMC look durable. He's a 3rd down back.

 

[Hot Sauce Guy]

The amount of victory lapping from people on all players is unbearable right now. It's worse than I can remember. A full slate of football can't come soon enough.

As a 49er fan, the last thing I’ll ever do about one of our best players being hurt is take a “victory lap” - I see all of this as an awful development and I am hoping beyond good reason that this issue is in fact no biggie (as CMC has said)

That said, as a 49er fan, I am also intimately aware of their lack of transparency when it comes to injured players.

But make no mistake - not a single one of my comments on this topic gives me the slightest amount of joy, nor would I consider CMC missing any amount of time a “victory” by any definition of the term.

49ers have one of the weakest schedules in football & a realistic chance at the postseason. Without CMC that hill becomes much more steep to climb.

Hopefully this is all nothing & I’ll be watching him score multiple TDs on Sunday night.

 

[Judge Smails]

Don't care what anyone says. The history of players downgraded to DNP for Friday is that they are almost always no go's on Sunday.

 

[ponchsox]

B Rob is a solid RB2 without mcaff

Guerrendo will vulture but not even worth a spot IMO

I don’t agree with this at all.

 

[Hot Sauce Guy]

Don't care what anyone says. The history of players downgraded to DNP for Friday is that they are almost always no go's on Sunday.

Unfortunately this is pretty accurate.

 

[dkp993]

B Rob is a solid RB2 without mcaff

Guerrendo will vulture but not even worth a spot IMO

BRob’s been with the team for a week. Guerendo both knows, and has shown capable output in this scheme.

IMO you’re vastly misreading this scenario.

I think it depends on what timeframe one is talking about. If it’s just this one week or if it’s long-term. Shanahan made it clear he brought Robinson in to be the number two back, he said those literal words. But if we’re talking about just this week due to exactly what hot sauce is saying Guerrero is probably the guy. If it turns into a long-term thing, Robinson is the asset I’d want.

 

[mrfrood]

and he doesn’t want to say too much and get in trouble

I actually agree with this. Probably because he got skewered by local radio / fans last year when he was Pollyanna about it before being declared inactive.

That said, I won’t trust anything but the game day inactives report. I’m gonna assume that everyone else is either lying or guessing.

Yeah he kept looking ever yonder to see if people were listening it seemed like.

 

[Proteus]

First time buyer.

I can't take much more of this rollercoaster.

 

[Smack Tripper]

B Rob is a solid RB2 without mcaff

Guerrendo will vulture but not even worth a spot IMO

BRob’s been with the team for a week. Guerendo both knows, and has shown capable output in this scheme.

IMO you’re vastly misreading this scenario.

I think it depends on what timeframe one is talking about. If it’s just this one week or if it’s long-term. Shanahan made it clear he brought Robinson in to be the number two back, he said those literal words. But if we’re talking about just this week due to exactly what hot sauce is saying Guerrero is probably the guy. If it turns into a long-term thing, Robinson is the asset I’d want.

i think the guy to own this week is Pearsall.

Long term, if something was going to take CMC out fully, I think I'd throw down with Jordan James.

I do think B Rob is underrated a a pass catcher so I'm rooting for him to make the most of this.

 

[Hot Sauce Guy]

First time buyer.

I can't take much more of this rollercoaster.

Fingers crossed buddy. It’s all we can do at this point is hope. I learned from Star Wars that hope is a powerful thing. Rebellions are built on hope.

 

[fantasycurse42]

Don't care what anyone says. The history of players downgraded to DNP for Friday is that they are almost always no go's on Sunday.

This is what I said on the last page.

Full, limited, dnp

That’s his week, he’s out.

 

[WhateverDavid]

B Rob is a solid RB2 without mcaff

Guerrendo will vulture but not even worth a spot IMO

BRob’s been with the team for a week. Guerendo both knows, and has shown capable output in this scheme.

IMO you’re vastly misreading this scenario.

I think it depends on what timeframe one is talking about. If it’s just this one week or if it’s long-term. Shanahan made it clear he brought Robinson in to be the number two back, he said those literal words. But if we’re talking about just this week due to exactly what hot sauce is saying Guerrero is probably the guy. If it turns into a long-term thing, Robinson is the asset I’d want.

Are we now taking Shanahan at his literal words now?

He’s probably the least trustworthy when it comes to coach speak, and I don’t see him tossing Guerendo aside because BRJ is in town. They gave up a 6th round pick for him, not exactly some large investment.

 

[Ilov80s]

First time buyer.

I can't take much more of this rollercoaster.

Not sure it’s a roller coaster so much as a freefall

 

[Hot Sauce Guy]

Are we now taking Shanahan at his literal words now?

Never have, never will.

 

[dkp993]

Are we now taking Shanahan at his literal words now?

Never have, never will.

No, but the money always speaks. They didn’t pick up his salary as charity.

 

[Scoresman]

For me it's not so much "Is he going to play Week 1 with this calf injury", it's more that we know he has an issue now and playing in a 100% full contact, full acceleration game situation can't be good for someone with his history. I have this picture in my head of him playing a few plays and limping off the field and then will be questionable the entire season.

 

[Chaka]

First time buyer.

I can't take much more of this rollercoaster.

Me too but, I'm riveted. It's like a great sitcom with the whole "will they/won't they" aspect. It's one thing when you're on the outside looking in but when you're living it, it's exhilarating. I feels like I might have a shot with Jennifer Aniston. I'll take more of that please.

 

[Faust]

Niners' Christian McCaffrey (calf) questionable for Week 1 vs. Seahawks, downplays absence as precaution

 

[irish eyes]

I almost cut BRobinson today but was outbid on a waiver claim. Now I am thankful I was outbid.

 

[Hot Sauce Guy]

I have this picture in my head of him playing a few plays and limping off the field and then will be questionable the entire season.

This is the FF killer. I said it before - in/out, black/white, that’s manageable.

Having him start & leave a game is just crushing. That ambiguity and not being able to trust him is an absolute nightmare for FF.

 

[Hot Sauce Guy]

I feels like I might have a shot with Jennifer Aniston

Oh buddy. I hate to be the one to break it to you…

 

[BespokeJort]

K Williams owner is nibbling, get me out!

Kyren or Kyle lmao

 

[Hot Sauce Guy]

K Williams owner is nibbling, get me out!

Kyren or Kyle lmao

Oh yeah, that matters.

 

[BespokeJort]

K Williams owner is nibbling, get me out!

Kyren or Kyle lmao

Oh yeah, that matters.

Like I smash accept for kyren; wouldn’t sell him for Kyle but I’m not sure the actual (dynasty) value at this point isn’t closer there

 

[Hot Sauce Guy]

K Williams owner is nibbling, get me out!

Kyren or Kyle lmao

Oh yeah, that matters.

Like I smash accept for kyren; wouldn’t sell him for Kyle but I’m not sure the actual value at this point isn’t closer there

Unless and until we know CMC is out that would be a massive overreaction.

Kyren is a smash accept.

 

[BespokeJort]

K Williams owner is nibbling, get me out!

Kyren or Kyle lmao

Oh yeah, that matters.

Like I smash accept for kyren; wouldn’t sell him for Kyle but I’m not sure the actual value at this point isn’t closer there

Unless and until we know CMC is out that would be a massive overreaction.

Kyren is a smash accept.

TBC I’m not saying he’s worth Kyle, I’m saying I probably smash accept for kyren as a mccaffrey owner more enthusiastically than I smash accept for mccaffrey as a Kyle owner

Edit: Kyle went in the 2nd in most leagues afaik, a 2nd was at the low end of the realistic market for him at various points last year, again the value isn’t on par but it’s not as ludicrous as it sounds imo. His value went back up based on relatively little

 

[irish eyes]

How is there confusion between Kyren & Kyle. What am I missing.

 

[King of the Jungle]

Also Grant Cohen is entertaining to watch as a Seattle fan because he has a negative bent look on the 9ers - which is why his assessment of CMC of being a shell of himself is to be taken with a grain of salt.

I am shocked every time I watch a video of that guy that he does not sport a black eye.

 

[rockaction]

First time buyer.

I can't take much more of this rollercoaster.

Not sure it’s a roller coaster so much as a freefall

I think this is the most apt thing that could have been said..

 

[Chaka]

I feels like I might have a shot with Jennifer Aniston

Oh buddy. I hate to be the one to break it to you…

YOU'RE NOT HER SUPERVISOR!!!!

 

[Proteus]

Everything is awful. Quit.

 

[Hot Sauce Guy]

Everything is awful. Quit.

I don’t have CMC. I do have Worthy everywhere. And AJB last night in a few leagues, too.

Just an awful start to the season.

 

[Hot Sauce Guy]

My lone Mahomes share is nodding sagely.

My lone Butker share is disgusted.

 

[Jacob's Ladder]

49ers paying for a RB when all they do is let KS run them into the dirt was about the dumbest trade/move this decade outside of the two terrible QB trades in Denver/Cleveland.

 

[Uncle Leo]

49ers paying for a RB when all they do is let KS run them into the dirt was about the dumbest trade/move this decade outside of the two terrible QB trades in Denver/Cleveland.

“The San Francisco 49ers made the kind of decision that could set a franchise back for years when they traded three first-round picks to draft Trey Lance third overall in 2021”

 

[Jacob's Ladder]

49ers paying for a RB when all they do is let KS run them into the dirt was about the dumbest trade/move this decade outside of the two terrible QB trades in Denver/Cleveland.

“The San Francisco 49ers made the kind of decision that could set a franchise back for years when they traded three first-round picks to draft Trey Lance third overall in 2021”

Yikes, not sure how that one slipped my mind. Brock Purdy really bailed 'em out huh?

 

[travdogg]

49ers paying for a RB when all they do is let KS run them into the dirt was about the dumbest trade/move this decade outside of the two terrible QB trades in Denver/Cleveland.

I mean, Philly did the same thing and just won a Super Bowl. CMC's 2 healthy years were NFC Championship game, and Super Bowl loss that could have gone either way.

 

[sushinsky4tsar]

K Williams owner is nibbling, get me out!

Also have a bite from the Kyren owner in my league.

The trouble is he wants to pay in Roschon Johnson and Tyjae Spears.

 

[cdclopper]

Ya'll are 100% being trolled by Shanny. I'm going to laugh my *** off.

 

[KellysHeroes]

He was a solid avoid. Especially at his 1st round price tag. GL everyone

 

[Buckna]

Are we now taking Shanahan at his literal words now?

Never have, never will.

No, but the money always speaks. They didn’t pick up his salary as charity.

Wash had to take on a 3rd of his salary as part of the trade. BRob's base is only $2.125M and non-guaranteed, hardly a sizeable commitment. Doesn't mean they don't see him as that #2 RB, but I'd be more confident in your reasoning had they not required Wash to take a chunk of his contract when 49ers have the 3rd most cap space in the league going into the regular season. Granted, they do need to save some $ for next year but BRob is a FA next year too.