This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!
There’s a lot of carries that went to Johnson, Coleman Perrine and others so Carter doesn’t necessarily have to lose work just because Hall is there now. With that said a lot of Carter’s bigger games came with Coleman out and Johnson in the doghouse so while he may end up with a similar workload it may get spread out different. The Jets will still run a RBBC with Hall leading the way.
I agree that Carter will still get work, but last year it seems like he had to share mainly because Saleh & Co. did not view him as a workhorse. Pretty much the one knock on him even coming out of college.
No, maybe I wasn’t clear. I think Hall will be the leader of the backfield but Carter will get a series or two a half. I don’t see Carter as the main back and I wouldn’t want to rely on him as a starter in fantasy but he could be will be a decent depth guy with a decent floor and will occasionally touch the ceiling.
I wouldn't take anything less than a 2nd. If the Hall owner isn't interested I would be fine with keeping Carter. I'm doing a startup dynasty mock draft and Hall was taken 1.11. He's already being valued like he's a proven high end starting RB. He has the talent to be that, but he hasn't actually playing yet so at this point in time it seems like Carter's value is as low as it's going to be. If Hall doesn't play like he's the next Jonathan Taylor, Carter's value will go up. If he does play like expected, then Carter's value will stay where it is now IMO.
A little less and I'm probably more bullish on Carter's role then most and forecast him in the 35-40% type of playing time range. However hoping for anything tangibly more while Hall is healthy seems like a pipe dream.
agreed. I have Carter in one league and have been looking to offer him to the team that drafted Hall, and I never officially send the offer cuz I expect the Hall owner will only spend a 3rd, and the upside of Carter with a Hall injury would make Carters value go up. So Carter seems like nothing but a hold at this point to me.
I'm offering him up for a 2023 2nd. If no takers I'll just hold. No way would I take a 3rd or some crap like that. I hold the right to change my mind this time next year
In this class? Fair starting point, but I wouldn't take it. I would not trade a '23 #2 for Carter, but I also wouldn't have spent an mid '21 #2 on him in the first place.
Oh, I get it. I wasn't picking him before the mid 2nd last year, which meant I wasn't getting him. I think you have to be exceptionally high on the talent (Freeman comes to mind) to pick a rb with that draft capital before then. I wasn't enthralled with Carter the talent.You misspelled “late ‘21 1st”
I think there should only be 2 RB's going in round 1. I won't comment on round 2 because I only play IDP dyno's, but in that format I didn't consider picking any RB until rd 3.
Breece has been fleeced.
I would say that may not be the case after the next joint practice or preseason game
I’m with you. Was very hopeful after last season and then the Hall pick happened. Was only holding him as injury insurance to sell in a trade if Hall went down. But I’d love for this to be true thst he has some real world value even with a healthy Hall. Carter owners collectively cross their fingers.
Me too, double kick to the nuts. We didn't even get to enjoy one week of Carter being the guy
Should thank Joe Douglas for thinking of fantasy owners by doing this trade today rather than in a few days after many would have blown most, if not all, of their FAAB.
Great insight. People who used FAAB on Carter should feel better??? He was out touched 15 to 13 in the Robinson's 1st game!. Do these geniuses get paid for this ridiculous information.
Carter played well and scored. I doubt people bidding on him were expecting him to be some kind workhorse. He’s always going to be out of a split backfield. I think he’s better than Robinson and will be the more productive player rest of season.
I am definitely not certain but it’s my hunch at least. We shall see.
Yes - White was a big time check down Charlie last year.
My only regret is I have only 1 copy of the Jets D to start today
