Between him and Judkins with situation being the tiebreaker. I think. Today, anyway.
Yeah, right. I might vacillate myself. I think Henderson's breakaway and long speed are too tempting. When there are yards there for the taking in the NFL, you want somebody that can take them and house it. Judkins has plenty of speed to be effective in the NFL, but he doesn't strike me as having the speed to pull away from DBs and take it to the house. Henderson will get you an extra forty yards and six points for the housing of the run, Judkins only an extra twenty-five and nothing extra for points because he got tackled.
Now, that doesn't mean Henderson is anything to speak of between the tackles, and Judkins might wind up the better back and scoring more points because of that, but I don't honestly know if that's the case, and all things constant, I'm a sucker for the breakaway speed and catching the football in our full PPR league. Just my thought process.