"Don't worry Wilson, I'll do all the paddling. You just hang on."...Chuck Noland, from Castaway
I liked both movies but have to give the emotional edge to ID4. I can get fired up about kicking some space alien butt in a stolen space ship and fending off extinction. I can't get fired up over a guy who can't kill himself the way he wanted to and, in the end, had the key to his rescue in his hands the whole time and didn't use it. ID4 characters used every resource and then some and even made up some stuff. Noland didn't open the box and get off the island before he went crazy.