I’m mostly over the penalty at this point. I think the ref had brain lock and assumed that, since 70 had been eligible before, he was again. That’s a huge and unforgivable screwup. But once they announced 70, I’m not sure what they could have done to make it right. To not call the penalty would have been unfair to Dallas. And yes, maybe they would have sniffed the play out if they had known Decker was eligible
This is my take as well. Allen see’s 70 and he’s reported a bunch already. 68 was not aggressive enough getting recognized.
To mitigate this risk, you only send 68 over.
Play stupid games, win stupid prizes.
I believe this is why they explained it to the refs pregame
It still provides 0 strategic value sending 3 guys over. The ref still has to tell Dallas who reported LOL.
I honestly wish Allen got it right and we got to see the real play unfold with Dallas knowing 68 was eligible.
I think it’s a dumb call on so many levels imo.
Dallas was on 70 and actively pointing and they prepped for this very play we learned from Cowboys D players post game.
This. It’s crazy that people aren’t also able to see this situation from the perspective of the Dallas D. The refs told them #70 was eligible. Why would they even bother to watch #68? Of course he was wide open. Basic common sense.
Did the refs botch this? Absolutely.
Did the Lions deserve better from the refs? Absolutely.
Would the play have worked as planned if Dallas knew #68 was eligible. No way to know for sure — I consider it unlikely.
Should Detroit have been penalized on the play? Nope. Refs hosed it and should have corrected the error by replaying it - no penalty - simply a do over. That was the only fair outcome once the screw up happened.
That the refs doubled down on their stupidity by penalizing the Lions makes it even worse IMO.
But again, Lions fans who say “68 was wide open and caught the conversion, we got robbed” are willfully missing this from the Cowboys viewpoint (which is fine by me; as a Packer fan I hate the Cowboys).