IvanKaramazov said:
Capella said:
Yes the guy was only bright enough to establish an entire universe that tens of millions enjoy, but he couldn't further a plot line for a character created. Makes sense.
I love the "Lucas is an idiot" storyline as we're all panting in anticipation to the next line in the story he created.
He was bright enough to come up with a great idea, which he then proceeded to mangle. E4 was great, and E5 (which, he didn't direct) was even better. Every movie since then has been mediocre. Given the plot of E3, the fact that it barely achieved mediocrity is a massive indictment of Lucas -- that was fantastic source material that he practically had to go out of his way to botch.
Sorry, but the critique that Lucas is more about selling toys than making good movies is spot-on. Hopefully the new trilogy will be different.
I don't think Lucas in an idiot at all. His priorities were always about making money first and foremost not about making the best movie he could.
He has justified this numerous times publicly by saying while the hard core fans may have loved Empire, it was the worst draw for all his movies.
So he prioritized money first which gave us the Teddy bears, the Pod race and other items many don't care for.
Lucas has also been very verbal that he always wanted these to be kiddie movies first.