Just finished watching the Machete order (4-5-1-2-3-6) of Star Wars. This was actually my first watch of any Star Wars movie in quite a while. Thoughts:
1. Phantom Menace is useless. It is not in the Machete order because it adds NOTHING to the trilogy. Movie is 99% filler.
2. Attack of the Clones was actually not bad. Still 5th best of the 6, but the gap isn't as striking. Hayden Christensen wasn't the issue here, it was the lousy writing, dialogue, and lack of direction he got. I get what he was going for, but he was handcuffed.
3. Revenge of the Sith probably beats Return of the Jedi for me. Story stayed focused and it was as dark and grim as it needed to be. It was also nice to see how Anakin became Vader following his reveal at Empire. More later.
4. A New Hope is still great and I don't find the difference between it and the prequels as jarring, though the stuff Lucas added in later helps.
5. Empire Strikes Back is the best Star Wars movie. Perfect blend of action, character development and cinematography. Only hitch is 3PO was especially annoying in this movie, though I still cheer when he blows up in Cloud City.
6. In this watch, Return actually dipped below Revenge for me, and I watched the two back to back. A lot of bloat that didn't add much, but still enjoyable. But the big thing is I had a lot more sympathy for Vader having just watched the prequels right before. I no longer saw him as the big bad guy, but rather the conflicted father he was. I almost got up and cheered when he chucked the Emperor down the shaft.
Order of preference: 5, 4, 3, 6, 2, BIG GAP, 1.