Welcome to Our Forums. Once you've registered and logged in, you're primed to talk football, among other topics, with the sharpest and most experienced fantasy players on the internet.
Hit me up.
Howard Cosell
You people SUCK. I can't believe this came up again. I should make you pick one, but then some weisenheimers are likely to pick each one separately. You can have 'em all.mphtrilogy said:
I'd have to see which one you are talking about to answer that. This is oddly arcane.
Not sure why it was an issue to begin with. IMO a precedent was set with something like Planet Earth. If each of those episodes is a narrative as a whole about life on Earth, not sure how each of these about a specific group of people isn't.
I updated the spreadsheet with your name and took out higgins.
He was a professional baseball player - but not sure he would need to be an athlete for that category.
I'm going to do a search in the thread for those who signed up to be judges and will update the sheet. I'm assuming we will have a lot of openings so if you are following along and want to be a judge please reply and @ me or Acer. I'm volunteering you Acer
so that didn't work out well - either the search function is broken or folks used different words than "judge" and "judging" in their posts.
I think the Documentary category has gotten more scrutiny than all other categories combined. I just don't see why in a television draft, documentary series that were on television wouldn't be allowed. Just an outsider's observations - not a big deal of course.
There is no beef with Up. Docs just seem to be the category with the most problems.
why volunteer to judge? Whats the beef with Up?
haha, ok, then
I am judging Comedy - 1971 to 1990 and Comedy - 1991 to 2020.
My apologies but I'm not re-reading 66 pages. If you volunteered to be a judge and still want to can you just re-post it?
There is no issue.
There were a few others like Wild Kingdom that I didn't understand either. That's a documentary series.
Still not a documentary anything. Saying, "This is a lion. It lives in Africa." does not make something a documentary. (I loved Wild Kingdom, by the way.) Just like a movie that just shows a concert is not a doc. There's no point of view, context, or anything of the filmmaker in it. It's just a record. There's no added content (except for the fun of watching Jim wrestle an alligator.) It's basically an encyclopedia with moving pictures.
Wanna watch documentaries? It's sooooo fun.If anyone wants to be part of a 3-judge panel, let me know I am happy to team up. I don't want to judge any categories solo though... prefer the dollar cost averaging approach
Its been awhile since I've seen them. Can you remind me what the pov, narrative arc, perspective of the filmmaker, etc is for Planet Earth?
Nope. I had no idea.
I volunteered to do Sci Fi (Doc Oc dropped out of that one, even though he's still listed)
My apologies but I'm not re-reading 66 pages. If you volunteered to be a judge and still want to can you just re-post it?
