KarmaPolice
Footballguy
Anybody take a PM? - was going to take off to the library.
				
			Oh yay.Tim, I will judge car chase and shocking scene if you need more judges.
 Guess it serves me right for making a first-round pick in a category with no judge or criteria, but I'll warn you in advance that your rankings will likely incur my great wrath.
   Guess it serves me right for making a first-round pick in a category with no judge or criteria, but I'll warn you in advance that your rankings will likely incur my great wrath.    
 Ill be around for another 25 minutes so sureAnybody take a PM? - was going to take off to the library.
Make-up pick:
3.05: Steve McQueen vs. Edward G. Robinson in the final hand of The Cincinnati Kid (Gambling Scene)
nah, no chance of that (if Tim ok's me, of course). It's a great car chase, and it benefits by being a real one, and not a CGI-fest.Oh yay.Tim, I will judge car chase and shocking scene if you need more judges.Guess it serves me right for making a first-round pick in a category with no judge or criteria, but I'll warn you in advance that your rankings will likely incur my great wrath.

I sent Tim a PM in case he missed my post, basically so I can post criteria before we get too deep. But, assuming I do it, sure to all of the above.What are you looking for on this one - as in "WTF was that?", "i can't believe that is in a movie", "i never saw that twist coming", or yes to any of the above??Tim, I will judge car chase and shocking scene if you need more judges.
 
 nah, no chance of that (if Tim ok's me, of course). It's a great car chase, and it benefits by being a real one, and not a CGI-fest.Oh yay.Tim, I will judge car chase and shocking scene if you need more judges.Guess it serves me right for making a first-round pick in a category with no judge or criteria, but I'll warn you in advance that your rankings will likely incur my great wrath.

This was the only one I had on my list2.19 "Austin Powers: International Man of Mystery" (Mike Myers) (Portrayals: Multiple Performances)
Yeah, baybee, YEAH!!!
 
 Nothing against the pick, but it speaks to the weakness of the category that Mike Myers will probably do well here.2.19 "Austin Powers: International Man of Mystery" (Mike Myers) (Portrayals: Multiple Performances)
Yeah, baybee, YEAH!!!
Agree and disagree. I find Myers' performances in the first two AP movies (not so much the third) to be extremely funny, hilarious even. However, you're absolutely right that this is a near-impossible category in degree of difficulty, with 25 picks needed.Nothing against the pick, but it speaks to the weakness of the category that Mike Myers will probably do well here.2.19 "Austin Powers: International Man of Mystery" (Mike Myers) (Portrayals: Multiple Performances)
Yeah, baybee, YEAH!!!
RIF my friendKrippling here...Hope the judge agreesThis is a great pick.2.21: Dustin Hoffman as Michael Dorsey/Dorothy Michaels in Tootsie (Dramatic Actor in a Comedic Role)
Not a valid pick IMO, but that is the judges call. We discussed yesterday (obliquely so as to not spotlight).
The actor is not playing different characters. There's no suspension of disbelief for the audience watching the same RL actor play different characters. It's known to the audience that the same actor is wearing a disguise, under the premise he couldn't get work as himself because he is too difficult to work with.
Not my call, just my opinion.
Great comment if the pick was for multiple performances, but my impression was that it was for dramatic actor in a comedic role, as noted by the drafter. No?Krippling here...Hope the judge agreesThis is a great pick.2.21: Dustin Hoffman as Michael Dorsey/Dorothy Michaels in Tootsie (Dramatic Actor in a Comedic Role)
Not a valid pick IMO, but that is the judges call. We discussed yesterday (obliquely so as to not spotlight).
The actor is not playing different characters. There's no suspension of disbelief for the audience watching the same RL actor play different characters. It's known to the audience that the same actor is wearing a disguise, under the premise he couldn't get work as himself because he is too difficult to work with.
Not my call, just my opinion.
 
 RIF my friendKrippling here...Hope the judge agreesThis is a great pick.2.21: Dustin Hoffman as Michael Dorsey/Dorothy Michaels in Tootsie (Dramatic Actor in a Comedic Role)
Not a valid pick IMO, but that is the judges call. We discussed yesterday (obliquely so as to not spotlight).
The actor is not playing different characters. There's no suspension of disbelief for the audience watching the same RL actor play different characters. It's known to the audience that the same actor is wearing a disguise, under the premise he couldn't get work as himself because he is too difficult to work with.
Not my call, just my opinion.
 
 Sorry, man. Actually, I think there are still a couple of good picks left in that cat, but not many.This was the only one I had on my list2.19 "Austin Powers: International Man of Mystery" (Mike Myers) (Portrayals: Multiple Performances)
Yeah, baybee, YEAH!!!
It sure is. I was going to take it.This is a great pick.2.21: Dustin Hoffman as Michael Dorsey/Dorothy Michaels in Tootsie (Dramatic Actor in a Comedic Role)
...
Need to flesh out the post later.
Hi. My name is Bobby, and I'm a moron. I've been addicted to idiotic behavior for my entire internet life. I first realized I had a problem....Great comment if the pick was for multiple performances, but my impression was that it was for dramatic actor in a comedic role, as noted by the drafter. No?Krippling here...Hope the judge agreesThis is a great pick.2.21: Dustin Hoffman as Michael Dorsey/Dorothy Michaels in Tootsie (Dramatic Actor in a Comedic Role)
Not a valid pick IMO, but that is the judges call. We discussed yesterday (obliquely so as to not spotlight).
The actor is not playing different characters. There's no suspension of disbelief for the audience watching the same RL actor play different characters. It's known to the audience that the same actor is wearing a disguise, under the premise he couldn't get work as himself because he is too difficult to work with.
Not my call, just my opinion.
Hi. My name is Bobby, and I'm a moron. I've been addicted to idiotic behavior for my entire internet life. I first realized I had a problem....Great comment if the pick was for multiple performances, but my impression was that it was for dramatic actor in a comedic role, as noted by the drafter. No?Krippling here...Hope the judge agreesThis is a great pick.2.21: Dustin Hoffman as Michael Dorsey/Dorothy Michaels in Tootsie (Dramatic Actor in a Comedic Role)
Not a valid pick IMO, but that is the judges call. We discussed yesterday (obliquely so as to not spotlight).
The actor is not playing different characters. There's no suspension of disbelief for the audience watching the same RL actor play different characters. It's known to the audience that the same actor is wearing a disguise, under the premise he couldn't get work as himself because he is too difficult to work with.
Not my call, just my opinion.
 Could happen to anyone (and my mentioning it means I'm about to make five worse such errors).  I probably jinxed you with the mad props yesterday for being on top of absolutely everything.
   Could happen to anyone (and my mentioning it means I'm about to make five worse such errors).  I probably jinxed you with the mad props yesterday for being on top of absolutely everything.He was awesome in this movie.3.08 Historical Portrayal- Phillip Seymour Hoffman - Capote
That should do really well. I'm a huge fan of PSH and In Cold Blood. Great pick.He was awesome in this movie.3.08 Historical Portrayal- Phillip Seymour Hoffman - Capote
BTW, you suck. You should be punting your own category.3.07 "Superman" (1978) (Superheroes)
This is the original with the late Christopher Reeve, who, in my opinion, *is* Superman, at least so far. Reeve's performance is touching and inspiring, the plot is good, and while there are certainly some flaws, and the humor and some other elements are a bit dated, this is an iconic film. Just hope the wacky judge agrees.
 
 I don't know how I forgot to put this on my shortlist. Great pick.3.08 Historical Portrayal- Phillip Seymour Hoffman - Capote
I see tish155 lurking so if Dear Leader returns with a pick, please PM me. No autoskip if I come up in the next 45 minutes or so.
Sorry to be the guy who vacillates about autoskip, but keep us on skip unless one of us posts that we're around and picking.
Thanks.
i hate youSorry guys- on my iPhone- poker scene from The Sting- gambling- will link later.Robert Shaw cheats, but Paul Newman cheats better.
Sorry guys- on my iPhone- poker scene from The Sting- gambling- will link later.Robert Shaw cheats, but Paul Newman cheats better.
 
   
   
   
   
 How in the world can BTTF2 be your favorite of the three?
Different strokes indeed...
 
 How in the world can BTTF2 be your favorite of the three?
Different strokes indeed...
There are two others?
How in the world can BTTF2 be your favorite of the three?
Different strokes indeed...
this is the jimmy Fallon, queen latifah movie rightshould be cool here per the guidance provided by the judge
3.13 Portayals best performance by child actor - Jody Foster, Taxi
Will fill in later. Regarding criteria, she was 14 at the Academy Awards (film released in 1976), but 12 at the time of filming.
this, Portman, and Linda Blair in the Exorcist were in a tier of their own for me.should be cool here per the guidance provided by the judge
3.13 Portayals best performance by child actor - Jody Foster, Taxi
Will fill in later. Regarding criteria, she was 14 at the Academy Awards (film released in 1976), but 12 at the time of filming.
Knew this wasn;t lasting much longer.3.14 Wizard of Oz - Flying Monkey Attack - Scenes that scared you as a kid
Mike Caro, the 1st wildly popular poker theorist, made his bones 30some yrs ago with a 5-page article in the original Poker Player,magazine outlining how the big hand in CK could never have happened as played.Make-up pick:
3.05: Steve McQueen vs. Edward G. Robinson in the final hand of The Cincinnati Kid (Gambling Scene)
