This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!
Edit to add: In the past some of his rumors pan out and some don't FWIW.
Giving away the farm yet again for yet another a career backup type QB? Nope I dont see it happening.Broncos get a QB that can't start for CLE.... for Marshall. Yep, I see that happening.
Since we live in a world with poor grammar, it's hard to tell exactly what the deal is here. It's possible the Giants WR and draft pick would go to Denver. I doubt Cleveland would get Marshall, a NYG WR, and a draft pick for Edwards.Broncos get a QB that can't start for CLE.... for Marshall. Yep, I see that happening.
I don't want Marshall on my team, and I'm only a fan.This isn't fantasy, it's real life. Think Mangini wants that kind of player on his team? He got rid of Winslow and Winslow was 30x the pro that Marshall is.Denver would be lucky to get Anderson for him at this point. The guy gives cancer cancer. Plus, he's an arrest away from a large suspension.Broncos get a QB that can't start for CLE.... for Marshall. Yep, I see that happening.
Yeah, I think I must have misunderstood. Getting just Anderson was goofy.
It sure doesn't read that clear but this is what I make of it
enver gets: Anderson, Giants unnamed WR + Giants unnamed pickCleveland gets: MarshallGiants get: Edwards
That's the way I read it too.Funny how in both this scenario and the other 3-team trade rumor that the Broncos are obtaining a QB. (Leinart in the other)It sure doesn't read that clear but this is what I make of it
Cleveland gets: Marshall
Giants get: Edwards
Orton and Simms are both currently injured. Anderson would be an acceptable backup to Orton if hes healthy and they need a warm body to start if hes not able to go the first couple of weeks. This doesn't make much sense for the Browns at all. Trading Braylon for Marshall straight up does them no good. Its at best a push for them and probably a downgrade.
Because not only is Orton hurt but he sucks. Just got up and heard this rumor myself. Additionally, Denver has confirmed that they have been in talks with several teams in an attempt to trade Marshall.
thats nothing. Josh McDaniels already skipped to step 36, run off your franchise QB.
Hows about the highest paid QB in the league instead of Carr.
Its funny how even with Carr's horrendous OL in HOU, he and Eli have almost identical career QB ratings.
Are you sitting down? Ok, ready? Their top QB's are Kyle Orton and Chris Simms.
This is a nice analysis from a Jets fan who has had to deal with Herm Edwards, Eric Mangini and Mike Tannenbaum so he knows all about organizations that have seen failure from the top down . It remains to be seen how good a coach Rex Ryan is. Last time the Patriots saw him he was calling a panicked time out to help preserve their record 16 game winning streak. We know he talks a good game; let's see if he can coach one.Oh, and how did that Pennington for Favre transition work out last year; fail-check, fail-check, etc., etc.......TLEF316 said:thats nothing. Josh McDaniels already skipped to step 36, run off your franchise QB.JuSt CuZ said:TLEF316 said:
neither Mangini or McDaniels are affiliated with the Patriots anymore. Hell, neither one of them held a significant role with team for an extended period of time. I understand your desire to defend members of the Belicek coaching tree, but i think any rational person would admit that both guys badly miscalculated how you can act as a first time head coach. Belicek is a tremendous coach who has earned the right to do whatever the hell he wants when it comes to BS injury reports, organizational control, ect. He's won, so he's earned it. No question about it. The other 2 havent, which is why they both come off like D-Bags. McDaniels has turned the Broncos from one of the NFL's model franchises into a total punch line in only a few months. An Tannenbaum is far from a failure. The Favre move was a semi-disaster (although they were 8-3 at one point last year) and Gholston is still very much up in the air. But other than that, his drafting has been outstanding and the FA's he's brought in have done what we've expected. And if you seriously thought the Jets were going to get to the promised land with Pennington, you dont know football, regardless of what team you're a fan of.This is a nice analysis from a Jets fan who has had to deal with Herm Edwards, Eric Mangini and Mike Tannenbaum so he knows all about organizations that have seen failure from the top down . It remains to be seen how good a coach Rex Ryan is. Last time the Patriots saw him he was calling a panicked time out to help preserve their record 16 game winning streak. We know he talks a good game; let's see if he can coach one.Oh, and how did that Pennington for Favre transition work out last year; fail-check, fail-check, etc., etc.......TLEF316 said:thats nothing. Josh McDaniels already skipped to step 36, run off your franchise QB.JuSt CuZ said:TLEF316 said:
You're ruining a good speculation thread with facts and reason; please stop.
Thought reporting messages and rumors is what this is about, discussion on possiblities!No one has said he has signed with anybody, just the rumors there hearing!
Check on that with Plaxico when he gets out of prison.
Aside from the fact that NFL trades are difficult, and three-way trades involving stars even more so, that's the reason why this makes no sense.
Plaxico was producing for the Giants. Playing hurt and everything.Ummm...how do you square "Shoots self in leg with unregistered handgun" with "has that magic kind of locker room that turns head cases into solid players"? Isn't that the kind of thing that the magic locker room is supposed to prevent?Plaxico was producing for the Giants. Playing hurt and everything.
He got Plaxico to be a team player who was a team leader on the field and gave his all and played through some pretty bad leg injuries and showed up big for the Giants just about every week. He was worlds away from the "Plexiglass" of the Steelers days.Turned out he was still a ####### off the fields but Coughlin got him to play tough for the team each and every week.Ummm...how do you square "Shoots self in leg with unregistered handgun" with "has that magic kind of locker room that turns head cases into solid players"? Isn't that the kind of thing that the magic locker room is supposed to prevent?Plaxico was producing for the Giants. Playing hurt and everything.
Plaxico was still a solid on-field player for the Giants at the time of the incident. That crime did not happen on the field -- IOW, it was a different thing that sulking on the sidelines, quitting at practice, developing alligator arms, half-acing routes, etc.I think it would be a mistake for the Giants (or any team) to re-visit Plaxico's situation every time they evaluate players in the future. There aren't enough talented AND stand-up guys like Peyton Manning and Warrick Dunn to go around. Teams have to dip into the knucklehead pool from time to time.
OK, so Plaxico was a standout on-field performer.He still manged to completely screw himself and the team over by that rather ill-advised trip to the night club. That is in no way Coughlin's or the team's fault...but it is rather difficult for me to believe that the awesome Giants' team atmosphere is going get Marshall all of a sudden on the straight and narrow.Now prior to this off-season, Brandon Marshall was the same way as Burress. GREAT on-field producer, million-dollar football talent, but ten cents worth of common sense. "Slipping" on McDonald's bags, rampant accusations of beating on his girlfriend, court appearances...It is not just a matter of stopping him from goofing off during practice. Seriously, I think the Broncos are totally boned here. No one is going to give anywhere close to fair value for him, and how much can you trust him to play? Only team I see with a chance of taming Marshall is the Cowboys. They could assign the same crack security force that was on Pacman Jones last year...
