Is it blasphemy to say I’m not convinced Zimm is obviously better than Ream? I mean, I think he’s better but it’s close for me. And it’s not like Ream was bad in his most recent USMNT appearances.
ETA - to be clear - my issue is with Long, not Zimmerman.
For the most part, our entire central defender pool is average to mediocre and the differences between them is on the margins. I don't think there is a meaningful difference between CCV/Zimmerman pairing and a Ream/EPB pairing. I think you could scream to the high heavens that Brooks/Miazga is our best option and I really wouldn't argue with you. The single most important factor in this is getting a pairing that is comfortable with each other and the guys around them.
Unfortunately, Berhalter has selected Long who imo is a step below all the rest to pair with Zimmerman. And he's ride or die with it because he refused to give anyone else a fair shot since Robinson went down.
To be fair, it's pretty normal that coaches settle on their roster by now and we'll just have to wait for the next cycle (and coach) to see some guys. I think guys like Ream, Miazga, Tolkin, Djordje, Vasquez, Cohen, and Paredes may all be in our best 26 right now but have zero shot at getting called. This group (sans Ream) along with Pomykal, Williamson, Slonina, Zendejas, Ledezma, Sonora, and Koleosho will hopefully get called into the first post-world cup window.