This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!
Gene Bremel is the best
Are the cheatsheets in the paid section Dodds' rankings or averages of all the staff? Is there a way to print a cheatsheet of just Dodds' rankings?
Question seconded, he was an excellent addition to staff, with his dynasty focus. Especially since he didn't disappear from the forum.
Would love to see Waldman's WAR stats. Writes gazillions of pages but his rankings can't be any better than a garden variety Yahoo analyst, if not worse. This year in particular with Wilson QB1, Kelce > Eifert, Franklin and Ware over Michaels, Hopkins WR5...just abysmal.
Waldman almost lapped the expert field last year in QB draft accuracy so i wouldn't be too dismissive.
Based on him nailing Russell Wilson. Everything else was pretty on par, IIRC. Otherwise, prepare to overdraft Ryan Lindley, Bilal Powell, Russell Wilson, Franklin, Kelce, Patterson, etc. based on his analyses.Waldman almost lapped the expert field last year in QB draft accuracy so i wouldn't be too dismissive.
Plus, his Barry White voice is dreamy!Waldman almost lapped the expert field last year in QB draft accuracy so i wouldn't be too dismissive.
I wouldn't go as far to say that I trust him but Wimer deserves props for being one of the only experts on the internet who doesn't have virtually identical rankings as everyone else. Going from site to site to site, aside from a few minor tweaks it's like they all basically have the same list. Wimer loves to rate the wr's and te's high and even though I don't agree a lot of the time at least he just isn't moving a few people up a slot here and there from the master list that everyone else seems to work off.
Thanks, I appreciate it. After a wonderful 10 year run I am no longer on staff but still post often.
He is so against the grain I actually filter him out of the rankings a lot to see what the mainstream group-think is for my sell/buy analysis. Does that make him good or bad?
I like writers who are not afraid to take a stand. Jason Whitlock for example rubs a lot of people the wrong way myself included at times yet I can't stop reading him. JT has a system and it usually involves not gambling too much early on but when he does decide to pull the trigger and reach or take a guy with question marks, it usually is for a guy who has the ability to win a league if he hits, and he usually does it at points in the draft where if it doesn't hit, no big deal because you have a solid foundation. That formula which is not unique, serves him well and I think makes for a good trusted opinion and rankings. He buys the meat vs the sizzle, and I appreciate that. I think that's why his rankings are different than many others.Ariakis said:
I think he gets respect, but unfortunately this poll only allows for one vote. I wish it could be "your top 3 guys" or something like that - Dodds and Henry kill it year after year. I hated this poll because we could only vote for one. Since I'm an IDP guy I had to use mine on an IDP staff member. For offense I would have gone Dodds or Henry.
